Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-03-03 10:59:05 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
22017-03-04 20:54:58 UTCposchon I seems to be, I was to fast. Please give me the feedback over PN. What did I do wrong?
Poschon
32017-03-04 20:58:50 UTCposchon For the start:

The basis for the import was http://dati.emilia-romagna.it/dataset/numerazione-civica-del-territorio-comunale--50f328b0/resource/fa3d040e-d4ea-4cdd-85c7-a83294fbeab0

The licenc for all imported adresses is Creative Commons - CC0 1.0
42017-03-04 21:14:16 UTCposchon Check the datas:
I compared all the adresses between present in the openstreet and in the SET. After the import I checked all the adresses over http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/ and corrected all doubel house numbers
52017-03-04 21:18:08 UTCposchon But now I see some of my adaptations of double house numbers are not present on official release. Positive think is: The server has all the corrections
62017-03-04 21:22:39 UTCposchon I prepared all the import to correct it. Every one can filter all house numbers for "Information = info". I have also the imported file on my computer and could send it to every one.
72017-03-05 14:03:41 UTCdieterdreist Hello Poschon, thank you for replying. The most important critique from the mailing list is that you didn't follow the import guidelines and didn't contact the local community, otherwise you would have learnt that there was already an established structure and guidelines for importing this data: ht...
82017-03-05 14:08:33 UTCdieterdreist also you should use a dedicated account for imports, especially if you are uploading a lot of stuff like you did.
92017-03-05 21:44:26 UTCposchon Hallo Martin,

I see.

I will the same: A great map for the world.

Are you in the community "Emilia Romagna"?

At the moment all my try to change something on the map is not visible. It seems that my account works partially.

About the doubles address:
At the moment over osmose you will ...
102017-03-06 16:55:36 UTCdieterdreist Hello Poschon, there is still some discussion on the italian ML as you might have seen. I have told them that you are wiling to solve the few duplicates and that I have the impression you have understood now that there are import guidelines that have to be respected. Although the data doesn't requir...
112017-03-06 21:00:01 UTCposchon Hallo Martin,
Grazie for this feedback.
I did not get your formulation "Although the data doesn't require legally attribution (cc0) it would still have made sense to provide it (so others can see where the data came from)."

What is exactly the requirement in this case about source?

Source ...
122017-03-06 21:19:25 UTCposchon I stay in Modena for more as one year. I have big interest to increase the status of OSM in Modena.
132017-03-06 21:22:59 UTCposchon Sorry I miss understand you last comment.
142017-03-06 21:25:37 UTCposchon Then I will wait for the feedback. I follow the discussion in ML, but it is quite difficult to understand. The google translate help me a little.
152017-03-09 18:50:42 UTCposchon I see the first feedback about the quality:

1.\tSome days ago I talked about invisible addresses. I mean the wrong format --> 2/A. At the moment there are 51 addresses with wrong format. There is no problem to solve it.

2.\tNot existing houses: I can not imagen that one responsible/person for ...
162017-03-15 11:05:45 UTCdieterdreist Hello Poschon, there have only been neutral or positive reactions regarding the import (a revert will likely not happen). You can go on with fixing the few duplicates (my preferences would be in doubt to favor the non-import version of the duplicates). Thank you,
Martin
172017-03-15 11:08:24 UTCdieterdreist btw: why are you sure 2/A is the wrong format? It is a common housenumber scheme in italy. If search doesn't find this, we might have to improve the search.
182017-03-15 22:11:22 UTCposchon Hello Martin,

Grazie for the feedback. I will follow the unwritten low in case of duplicates to delete the imported address. At the next time I will search more deeply for a community. My big mistake is: I looked just for Modena. The wiki side for Regio Emilia does not include the word Modena.
...
192017-03-16 01:15:32 UTCdieterdreist the shortcomings of the search should be reported to Nominatim (the geocoding software on osm.org). Contacting the local community about the import: best way is probably to ask on the national mailing list, they can refer to a regional mailing list (if there is). There is also an international maili...
202017-03-16 08:58:07 UTCRegina Phalange Sorry for being late. I'm not much happy about this changeset, as I've seen the source in the past and I wasn't very amused about the quality. The house numbers are very often misplaced around the buildings, or even in the near buildings. If the general feeling is neutral though, I'm not going to in...
212017-03-17 10:47:36 UTCdieterdreist I think there is likely not a rule or if there is, it is not enforced, you can find different kind of 3/A, 3/a, 3a, 3A and there also are very frequent uses of the slash to make a list, e.g. 3/5/7 (for the house numbers 3 and 5 and 7) and there also are variants like 3/2 (which has to be read simila...
222017-03-18 12:54:56 UTCposchon ciao,

the format for the numbers is important. I agree with you. Today I did a small walk around Modena. I saw just the Format without ”/”.

Here are some pictures from plates and in upper left corner the position of this plate on the map:
https://owncloud.weberhost.de/pu...
232017-03-19 11:41:38 UTCRegina Phalange Ok I'm really sorry because you are totally right about the plates. However the "/" format is default when you talk about addresses, as you can see here https://www.paginegialle.it/serramenti-infissi-klimainfissi-modena , http://www.immobiliaredonatello.it/it/contatti.html and (not Modena though) ht...
12017-03-03 11:04:07 UTCConstable Sir, apart from the fact that "addapt" dont seem to make any sense, could you be so kind to start using proper changeset comments?
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Your actual changeset comments means almost nothing.
Thanks
12017-03-03 11:00:10 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 11:00:05 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:59:47 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:59:17 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:59:11 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:58:55 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:58:47 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:48:56 UTCConstable Sir, did you see this https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/911451 ?
22017-03-03 10:58:06 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment. See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12017-03-03 10:57:44 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment.
12017-03-03 10:57:37 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment.
12017-03-03 10:57:33 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment.
12017-03-03 10:57:24 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment.
12017-03-03 10:56:00 UTCConstable sir, could you please explain why you deleted the "addr:city=Modena" tag from those bus stops and at the same time you added the "addr:country=IT" to a supermarket?
thanks
12017-03-03 10:53:35 UTCdieterdreist This should be reverted ASAP. Undiscussed import. Wrong source in changeset comment.
22017-03-03 10:54:21 UTCdieterdreist See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2017-March/057524.html
12016-12-18 09:10:07 UTCLvdT Der Name "delle Assi" wurde italianisiert. Der örtliche name ist "delle Asse"; man kann z.B. den name der nahen Gasse ansehen.
12015-07-04 11:32:35 UTCNakaner Welche Dienste von Geoportal.de hast du für diesen Changeset verwendet?
22015-07-16 21:05:59 UTCNakaner Bitte beantworte meine Anfrage, sonst gehe ich vom Schlimmsten aus.
32015-07-21 09:09:06 UTCposchon Bei diesem Set habe ich als Quellen ehe Bing und das was ich gesehen habe genutzt.
Geoportal habe ich default Eintrag in JOSM stehen. Da die Seite zusätzliches Bildmaterial liefert.
12015-07-04 11:33:58 UTCNakaner Dir ist klar, dass dieser Changeset über kurz oder lang revertiert werden wird? Oder kannst du eine schriftliche Nutzungserlaubnis für geoportal.de vorweisen?
12014-12-04 18:05:04 UTCnaoliv One more thing: you have changed a valid wikipedia key and included some unnecessary alternatives for the same article in Fernando de Noronha relation.
22014-12-04 18:17:39 UTCposchon You mean this? -> wikipedia:de Fernando de Noronha
32014-12-04 18:20:23 UTCnaoliv You have changed "wikipedia = pt:Fernando de Noronha" (that is the primary langague) to "wikipedia:pt = Fernando de Noronha".
And yes, you have also included "wikipedia:de" and "wikipedia:ru" (since they point to the same article but in a different language, they are unneeded)
42014-12-04 18:21:43 UTCnaoliv Can I fix this?
52014-12-04 21:20:19 UTCposchon you have right about pt:. The wikipedia links for other languages are important for the tourist like me.
I was used the wikipedia for traveling inside Brasil. It helps to enjoy the country ;-)
62014-12-04 21:21:28 UTCposchon On the page: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:wikipedia

You could read:
.....In these circumstances use the format wikipedia:lang=page title for the secondary languages......
72014-12-04 23:49:50 UTCnaoliv It's only valid when the secondary language doesn't match/point to the same article :-)
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:wikipedia#Secondary_languages
"One example where it is appropriate to provide additional explicit links to articles in secondary languages is where the subject is included...
12014-12-04 18:02:15 UTCnaoliv poschon, you have removed some names from some objects. For example: http://osm.mapki.com/history/way.php?id=11304037

Is there a reason for this?
21 changeset(s) created by poschon have been discussed with a total of 53 comment(s)