| Changeset |
No. |
Date |
Contributor |
Comment |
|
| 49441534 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 49152139, 49181573, 49182030, 49182513, 49182642, 49182774, 49183572, 49185168, 49191155, 49191221, 49191231, 49191246, 49191252, 49196299, 49200091, 49294947, 49361532, 49361703. |
|
| 48576715 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 48524671, 48524685, 48524692, 48524836, 48524849, 48524860, 48524865, 48524889, 48524916, 48524933, 48524986, 48525001, 48525055, 48525059, 48525064, 48525144, 48525169, 48525237, 48525288, 48525357, 48525386, 48525715, 48525732, 48525737, ... |
|
| 48477734 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 45535595, 45535776, 45535875, 45536046, 45536059, 45536086, 45536179, 45536299, 45536325, 45536352. |
|
| 48420321 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 47949780, 47949827, 47949874, 47949959, 47950158, 47950198, 47950249, 47950476, 47950508, 47950670, 47950751, 47950853, 47950888. |
|
| 48417098 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 47598204, 47598587, 47599829, 47601891, 47605931, 47606691, 47640232, 47640329, 47642411, 47642715, 47642742, 47668994, 47669279, 47669373, 47670454, 47671813, 47672129, 47672228, 47672246, 47672274, 47678105, 47799361, 47799398, 47799441, ... |
|
| 48354795 | SomeoneElse | This follows on from https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/48258464 - see the comment there. |
|
| 48258464 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 47946345, 47947047, 47947482, 47978416, 47980692, 48002126. |
|
| 47952690 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 47429266, 47429309, 47429326, 47429349, 47429404, 47429457, 47429461. |
|
| 47562672 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 47408490, 47408506, 47408631, 47408658, 47408723, 47408907, 47408946, 47408974, 47409221, 47409251, 47409300, 47409418, 47409740, 47409770, 47410030, 47410097, 47410408, 47432811, 47439259, 47439325, 47439342, 47439427, 47439480, 47439530, ... |
|
| 38247099 | RicoZ | The reverted changeset clearly had some errors but I think many of the objects are in fact cave_entrances. |
| SomeoneElse | @RicoZ Indeed, and local mappers will I'm sure pick those up over time.The solution to "some cave entrances are incorrectly mapped as caves" is not to change ALL caves to cave entrances - that's just differently wrong.By their very nature (being underground and not visible on aeria... |
| RicoZ | Thanks, I have started http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/natural%3Dcave and am looking at those places now |
| zstadler | Currently, there is "cave" is not an approved tag. .I find is strange that the most appropriate approved tag "natural=cave_entrance" was replaced by an tag that was proposed at the time of the change..As a result of this change, applicable caves have disappeared from maps... |
|
| 46943778 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42725792, 46937137. |
|
| 46943595 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46790855, 46923347, 46923395. |
|
| 46943272 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46801542, 46923435, 46937153, 46938159, 46938613. |
|
| 46502451 | ButterflyOfFire_ | Thank you :) |
|
| 46773378 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46771249, 46771267. |
|
| 46773203 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46770858, 46770866. |
|
| 46772870 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46770106, 46770116, 46770139, 46770151, 46770157. |
|
| 46772125 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46768552, 46768648, 46768858, 46768873, 46768966, 46769130, 46769166, 46769186, 46770228, 46770239. |
|
| 46705947 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46704602, 46704644, 46705427, 46705428, 46705431. |
|
| 46674968 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46670151, 46670152, 46670155, 46671211, 46671214, 46671215, 46671227, 46671228, 46671229, 46671406, 46671408, 46671410, 46671484, 46671486, 46671487, 46671507, 46671509, 46671510, 46671598, 46671600, 46671604, 46671610, 46671613, 46671614, ... |
|
| 46653048 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46621971, 46622007, 46641032, 46641323, 46641329, 46641336, 46641381, 46641392, 46641399, 46641427, 46641451, 46641456, 46641459, 46641466, 46641486, 46641501, 46641504, 46641543, 46641553, 46641558, 46641575, 46641583, 46641613, 46641628, ... |
|
| 46564594 | SomeoneElse | This reverts some further edits which depended on Google-derived data reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/46564425 . |
|
| 46564425 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 28460887, 28460921, 28460962, 28461111, 28996784, 29095770, 29095784, 29095822, 29096032, 29202533, 29202618, 29202714, 29202772, 29203049, 29203123, 29203646, 29203861, 29203957, 29204005, 29204042, 29204073, 29204101, 29204113, 29249016, ... |
|
| 46391955 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43476437, 43477049, 44946646. |
| SomeoneElse | Edits that depended on this data were reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/46392158 . http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/46392950 and the next two changesets are patching up some gaps in NY9A (actually present before these changes) and I've asked someone who edited the M12 bus rou... |
|
| 46392158 | SomeoneElse | This is tidying up some data that depending on Google-derived data reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/46391955 . |
|
| 46375354 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46339328, 46357356, 46357630, 46357669, 46357685, 46357754, 46357782, 46357802, 46357831, 46357878, 46357890, 46357955, 46357977, 46357985, 46358006, 46358016, 46358021, 46358024, 46369625, 46369678, 46374058, 46374086, 46374551, 46374611. |
|
| 46332241 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43325504, 43351908, 43362794, 43366169, 43368072, 43368081, 43368098, 43368128, 43368167, 43369110, 43545100, 43545294, 43545405, 43545549, 43548511. |
|
| 46204825 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44965175, 44965389, 44965478, 44965600, 45004296, 45005826, 45030077, 45030136, 45030191, 45030201, 45030228, 45030279, 45030325, 45030498, 45030528, 45030597, 45030694, 45031401, 45031427, 45031438, 45031502, 45031588, 45031623, 45031865, ... |
|
| 46202925 | SomeoneElse | Changeset comment here should have been "Reverting some more things in erroneous revert https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/46189471 - see there for more details." |
|
| 46189471 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 46194682 where the changeset comment is: Undoing revert carried out in error - my apologies |
|
| 46194682 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 46189471. |
|
| 46178656 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 45914144, 45914294, 45914333, 45914358, 45914500, 45914565, 45914981, 45915104, 45915253, 45915299, 45915473, 45915577, 45915797, 45915920, 45916255, 45916443, 45917867, 45918292, 45944402, 45944711, 45944898, 45945626, 45945773, 45945911, ... |
| SomeoneElse | The changeset comment above is incorrect - this is unrelated to Google. It is instead a revert of a number of plant-based mechanical edits. See https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45974439 and other changesets by author of that for details of the problems with the edits that led to them bein... |
|
| 46131853 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43072547, 43072651, 43072824, 43072929, 43079333, 43079595, 43079782, 43079956, 43080436, 43080482, 43080801, 43325742, 43325980. |
|
| 46116908 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43847279, 43847386, 43847423. |
|
| 46087845 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43760406, 43761363, 43761605, 43943649, 43959354, 44061111, 44063294. |
|
| 46056517 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 46037891, 46038307, 46038519, 46038766, 46038927, 46038961, 46038969, 46039052, 46039098, 46039159, 46039214, 46039253, 46039313, 46039346, 46039397, 46039452, 46039497, 46039533, 46039582, 46039792, 46039898, 46039944, 46039996, 46042417. |
|
| 46030207 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41639571. |
|
| 46021360 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41657369. |
|
| 46019640 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41651966. |
|
| 46016965 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41651699. |
|
| 46001770 | SomeoneElse | This is a follow-up to http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45996374 . It reverts the remaining edits made in changeset 41640199, not reverted by the previous attempts. |
|
| 46005666 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41651394. |
|
| 46003785 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41640775. |
|
| 45996374 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41640199. |
|
| 45908850 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 42577584. |
|
| 45907040 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 41551998, 41552560, 42419061, 42419249, 42419795, 42419936, 42419957, 42420694, 42420735, 42421209, 42537519, 42537681, 42538497, 42538554, 42539736, 42911791, 43269667. |
|
| 45778053 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 42690485. |
|
| 45607656 | Teiron | Hey, I haven't originaly made this changes but I don't agree with opinion that they were Google Maps traced. First of all most of objects reverted were varius forms of landuse which were not that similar to Google's (especialy becouse their are approximate). All in all they seemed to be made wit... |
| SomeoneElse | Hi Teiron,The changeset source for http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/42721909 is "Geoportal 2: Ortofotomapa (zdjęcia lotnicze),googlemaps". I explained the problem on there and said "If you have any questions please email the Data Working Group on data@osmfoundation.org "... |
| Teiron | Would that be possible for me to go through those changes, discern which violates Google's ToS and re-add not copied parts?Some of those were realy valuable. |
| SomeoneElse | Where we have been able to have the conversation with the author of the changeset we have sometimes been able to do investigation on a sub-changeset level, but in this case I'd be tempted to just remap based on allowable data sources - it'll probably be quicker than going through the previous edits ... |
|
| 45697904 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 37146922, 37151504, 37152766, 37152833, 37166563, 37174054, 37851769, 41044418, 41045414, 44008335, 44012914, 44033409, 44033428, 44033474. |
|
| 45607481 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42495476, 42496198, 42496301, 42496733, 42502164, 42502651, 42721909, 42722064, 42901600, 42901714. |
|
| 45360825 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 41456185, 41487032, 41487085, 41487112, 41487173, 41487251, 41636400, 41644090, 41644452, 41645202, 41645515, 41645823, 41877738, 41878456, 44042511, 44665248, 44665529, 44665958, 44675849, 44675979, 44676505, 44686640, 44687470, 44689928, ... |
|
| 45276509 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 44225033. |
|
| 45132953 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43715721, 43716022. |
|
| 45120166 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 44164620. |
|
| 45119996 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 44453711. |
|
| 45064832 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42501715, 42501887, 44495757. |
|
| 45037169 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 40651812, 40660626, 40661524, 40703886, 40750627, 40759272, 41083328, 41083350, 41083365, 41478761, 42836655, 43129879, 43456996, 43611434, 44827765. |
|
| 44771579 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 35884028, 35884310, 35884405, 35884576, 35884639, 35884695, 35922493, 35922551, 35922628, 35922748, 35926754, 35926902, 35927040, 35927132, 35927238, 35927597, 35927666, 35927680, 35927725, 35944330, 35944416, 35944523, 35944608, 35967598, ... |
|
| 44681670 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 37093541, 37093584, 37093604, 37093650, 37093673. |
|
| 44672785 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42003749, 42004155, 42004959, 42006148, 42038452, 42151018, 42151589, 42151857, 42151975, 42152430, 42152929, 42158211, 42158784, 42159135, 42159604, 42159892, 42160342, 42160484, 42160663, 42160888, 42161043, 42161241, 42161296, 42173465, ... |
|
| 44672506 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44092019, 44092114, 44092184, 44092207. |
|
| 44672115 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 44166037. |
|
| 44671830 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44252997, 44272450, 44274108. |
|
| 44650611 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 41479648, 41479762, 41481239, 41502691, 41502746, 41502814, 41502829, 41502843, 41502917, 41502958, 41502995, 41503020, 41503039, 41524371, 41524441, 41524454, 41524526, 41524625, 42623197, 42623305, 42624008, 42629378, 42629503, 42629746, ... |
|
| 44626504 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44624806, 44624915. |
|
| 44597273 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44109532, 44110148, 44110948, 44111707, 44112146, 44112634, 44113031, 44113615, 44113935, 44114396, 44115198, 44116109, 44117025, 44118024, 44128051, 44151379, 44151653, 44152051, 44152493, 44180749, 44181323, 44182069, 44284387, 44394565, ... |
|
| 44497876 | SomeoneElse | Force-reverting some further objects based on google.cn sourced data in Taiwan |
| Supaplex | WOW, a big changeset. I thought I already revert some edit. So I miss something. |
| SomeoneElse | Hi Supaplex,To get the list I downloaded all the changesets from the user concerned, searched for all those that used google.cn imagery and reverted those. I then looked at all the reversions that failed because of subsequent edits and force-reverted those. In changesets such as this one. It wa... |
|
| 44502050 | SomeoneElse | And force-deleting the remaining objects based on google.cn sourced data in China |
|
| 44501113 | SomeoneElse | Force-reverting the remaining objects based on google.cn sourced data in China |
|
| 44496385 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 44074239, 44056401, 44054140, 44053119, 44073798, 44072483, 44056170, 44051828, 44056824, 44054669, 44073627, 44072594, 44071688, 44056743, 44054556, 44052835, 44055155, 44074120, 44074456, 44071744, 44053644, 44073491, 44072809, 44053737, ... |
|
| 44409366 | SomeoneElse | Force-reverting some further objects based on google.cn sourced data in China |
| SomeoneElse_Revert | Force-reverting some further objects based on google.cn sourced data in China |
| 中鲁潍昌 | Please give me a list of deleted data in order to restore the Bing map. Thank you 请给我一个删除数据的列表，以便在bing地图上恢复。谢谢。 |
| SomeoneElse | As mentioned by email, the list of changesets can be seen in the comment added to http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44403770 . |
|
| 44410866 | SomeoneElse_Revert | Force-reverting some further objects based on google.cn sourced data in China |
|
| 44403770 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43419344, 42621067, 43417527, 41770580, 43867399, 43667547, 41342598, 43578869, 42981518, 42586719, 41706568, 41469476, 43819431, 41138852, 43920440, 42073707, 44032513, 43789679, 43488194, 42407204, 42170562, 41665358, 42344209, 42746623, ... |
|
| 44396421 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43419344, 42621067, 43417527, 41770580, 43867399, 43667547, 41342598, 43578869, 42981518, 42586719, 41706568, 41469476, 43819431, 41138852, 43920440, 42073707, 44032513, 43789679, 43488194, 42407204, 42170562, 41665358, 42344209, 42746623, ... |
|
| 44243311 | aseerel4c26 | just for reference - this is about https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/43414281 |
|
| 43902702 | SomeoneElse | See also note is http://www.openstreetmap.org/note/793696 . |
|
| 37479067 | skyper | Da ist wohl einiges schief gelaufen.Habe hier etliche duplicate nodes zB https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3765790696 |
|
| 42452795 | SomeoneElse | Changeset discussion comment (to previous changing user) written to http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/42450861 in English and auto-translated French. |
|
| 42353289 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42289201, 42288073. |
|
| 42346185 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 42289201, 42288073. |
|
| 42308186 | SomeoneElse | See https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/42263645 and https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/52108/reverting-a-very-large-changeset for the context of this. |
| jc86035 | Thanks :) |
|
| 42210235 | saintam1 | Hi Andy,I think http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4379940990 was probably valid. The hostel has a website, the location matches: http://www.10coins-hostel.eu/location.htmI'll put the node back on if that's OK with you.Cheers |
| SomeoneElse | Yes - please do put it back if it looks valid. |
|
| 41967657 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40953903. |
|
| 41891270 | SomeoneElse | Previous blocks (on both sides) and . https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2016-September/054885.html said very clearly not to carry out edit wars. The DWG does not endorse either side of this argument and will revert mass edits in either direction.Please continue the discussion on ... |
|
| 41730738 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41683384. |
|
| 41726215 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41606969. |
| Adib Yz | Thanks. |
|
| 41725831 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41606532. |
|
| 41723435 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41606532. |
|
| 41718622 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41606250. |
|
| 41722297 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41606250. |
|
| 41718334 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41452536. |
| SomeoneElse | Er - no it doesn't. It actually reverts 41452536 (which was a smaller changeset by the same user with the same issue). |
|
| 41714811 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 41449985. |
|
| 41192016 | SomeoneElse | In each case here I've tried to keep any other changes made in the last 10 months. If I've missed any, my apologies (there were > 300 to review!).There may well be examples where the discussion on https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/34479372 doesn't apply, i.e. a tree really _should_ be ta... |
|
| 37478950 | MKnight | was hat es mit diesem revert genau auf sich? Siehe zusammenhängend damit: http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/41115387 |
| MKnight | what about this revert? see http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/41115387 in combination of that |
| SomeoneElse | @MKnight Thanks - I've separately been in discussion with botdidier2020 about lack of explanation in changeset comments, and have sent them a must-read message http://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/995 (which they have just read). Hopefully they'll use more meaningful comments in the future.Re... |
|
| 40980474 | razor74 | Thats because maps.me didnt extract data from server before edit. It only uploads data. In fact Map.me users edit "in blind" and they didn't see what it is in the database... |
| ff5722 | Maps.me downloaded maps are up to a 2 months or so behind OSM data, that is, if the users keeps his/her downloaded maps up to date from maps.meUsers can't add any POIs that are not rendered by Maps.me. |
|
| 40802340 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40195731. |
|
| 40792543 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40066399. |
|
| 40783949 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40065268. |
|
| 40776283 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40064728. |
|
| 40774507 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40064280. |
|
| 40764460 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40053210. |
|
| 40760865 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40052929. |
|
| 40760167 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset . |
|
| 40756978 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40052639. |
|
| 40752516 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40052416. |
|
| 40751297 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 40052314, 40052307, 40052313, 40052185, 40052308. |
|
| 40726151 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40051946. |
|
| 40701250 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40051763. |
|
| 40701240 | SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changeset 40051763. |
|
| 37716171 | EzekielT | Redland City's website (which I thought, at the time, was an allowed source, before I knew) says that it's a city, but now you've explained why we can't source from such places, as OSM has its own rule on what's a "city". I did not know that then. Sorry. |
| EzekielT | "What the place describes itself as is essentially irrelevant in OSM terms. If local OSM mappers think that it deserves to be a city, then it does. Previous to your edit, it's actually spent time in OSM as both town and city. It's original "city" status seems to have come directly fro... |
| EzekielT | Same applies here, right? |
| EzekielT | "There are a couple of reasons why we can't use wikipedia as a source. One is that wikipedia is cc-by-sa licensed, and that licence is incompatible with OSM.The other is that what OSM calls a "city" is described on http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:place%3Dcity . Wikipedia es... |
| EzekielT | See comment on http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37716055 - the same applies here. |
| EzekielT | I did not know all of that at the time. Sorry. |
|
| 37716185 | EzekielT | I was sourcing from Wikipedia, which I thought was allowed at the time. It says that Capalaba West's no more. Sorry. |
|
| 37479041 | Meillo | It would be great to get some background information about this revert and the original changeset. Is there a message on a mailing list? I'm curious to understand what went on. |
| SomeoneElse | Hi,The "background discussion" started off on https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37476283 . What happened was that while merging some nodes, some detail was lost. The author of that changeset contacted the DWG asking for it and a number of other similar changesets to be reverted s... |
| Meillo | A bit late, but anyhow: Thanks for the explanation. :-) |
|
| 37716055 | EzekielT | The Wikipedia page says it is a city. Source:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unalaska,_Alaska. |
| EzekielT | The Wikipedia page says it is a city. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unalaska,_Alaska. |
| SomeoneElse | There are a couple of reasons why we can't use wikipedia as a source. One is that wikipedia is cc-by-sa licensed, and that licence is incompatible with OSM.The other is that what OSM calls a "city" is described on http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:place%3Dcity . Wikipedia essent... |
| EzekielT | Oh sorry... I never thought of that... I will discuss with the community from now on. |
|
| 37716484 | EzekielT | The reason why I put it as a motorway is because it has some characteristics of a motorway, but I think I was wrong. Source: https://www.google.ca/maps/place/Davis+Station,+Antarctica/@-68.5763842,77.9678537,526m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0xb1f366cd8ba7809d:0xc0e41055c81a02e0?hl=en. |
| SomeoneElse | As described in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37716429 we can't use Google as a source.However, if someone really had built a motorway within Antarctica I think we might have heard about it on the news - it was therefore safe to assume that this changeset suggesting there was a motorway... |
| EzekielT | Sorry... I did not know that we can't use Google and Wikipedia as sources... I will do as you ask and try to follow the guidelines and rules closer. I want you to know I'm trying to help and not cause any problems for anyone. And again, I am not a vandal :(. I will make a note so that someone can ad... |
|
| 37716624 | EzekielT | There was a note saying that it has been claimed as the "Kingdom of North Sudan". Source: http://www.openstreetmap.org/note/352737. |
| SomeoneElse | You can't take what someone has written in a note as something that you can add straight to OpenStreetMap - you have to ask yourself what is the likelihood that what is written is correct.In the case of Bir Tawil, it's been widely discussed inside OSM and outside for a very long time. Only last... |
| EzekielT | Oh okay. So they have to control the land to be added as a country to OSM. |
|
| 37717265 | EzekielT | On Google Street View it does not look like a shop at all... Source: https://www.google.ca/maps/place/Howard+Rd,+Dingley+Village+VIC+3172,+Australia/@-37.9821505,145.1214054,3a,75y,53.58h,84.01t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sZdc_taUY2At0LaYpPE3rTA!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo3.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DZdc_taUY2At0LaYpPE... |
| SomeoneElse | Again, as previously noted on http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37716429 , we cannot use Google Streetview as a source. |
| EzekielT | Oh okay, I did not know that when I deleted it... |
|
| 37716429 | EzekielT | My source was this: https://www.google.ca/maps/place/66%C2%B033'00.0%22S+93%C2%B001'00.0%22E/@-66.554696,93.0000906,1147m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0x0:0x0?hl=en |
| EzekielT | My source was this: https://www.google.ca/maps/place/66%C2%B033'00.0%22S+93%C2%B001'00.0%22E/@-66.554696,93.0000906,1147m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0x0:0x0?hl=en. Maybe the road is not a primary road... |
| SomeoneElse | To clarify, we can't use Google as a source. It is against their terms and conditions and against OSM's terms. |
| EzekielT | Oh okay. |
|
| 37716206 | EzekielT | Logan City's website refers to it as a city... Source: http://www.logan.qld.gov.au/about-logan/living-in-logan/statistics-and-facts. Should we revert it to "City" status? |
| SomeoneElse | See comment on http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37716055 - the same applies here.What the place describes itself as is essentially irrelevant in OSM terms. If local OSM mappers think that it deserves to be a city, then it does. Previous to your edit, it's actually spent time in OSM as bo... |
|
| 37717323 | EzekielT | Ubirr is not a locality... Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubirr. And I am not a vandal. |
| SomeoneElse | As has been mentioned elsewhere, we can't use wikipedia as a source because its licence (cc-by-sa) is incompatible with OSM.However what that article actually says is "... is known for its rock art." and "It consists of a group of rock outcrops" - i.e. it's a place where ther... |
|
| 37716731 | EzekielT | A note was here saying that the land has been claimed by the Kingdom of North Sudan. Source: http://www.openstreetmap.org/note/352737. |
| SomeoneElse | See comment on http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/37716624 |
|
| 36075031 | SomeoneElse | Actually, a web search finds a similarly-named company on the same street name on an industrial estate in Gateshead . It might actually just be a cockup rather than a conspiracy :) |
|
| 35900884 | SomeoneElse | test changeset discussion comment (please ignore) |
|
| 35171192 | SomeoneElse | Added to OHM in http://www.openhistoricalmap.org/changeset/1901 |
|
| 32085096 | SomeoneElse | For info I didn't add a comment on the changeset that caused this problem because (a) my tourist Spanish would struggle and (b) I didn't want to scare a user off by commenting negatively on their first edit. |
|
| 30706979 | SomeoneElse | (continuing from changeset comment) I'm familiar with quite a few places on this list and at first glance _none_ of them appears to have a genuine Russian name. Some (e.g. Great Dunmow, Swadlincote) are little more than villages.If there's a need to make up Russian names as a data source for so... |
| Peter Mead | I do not see a valid reason why this was reverted.Although you have a constant opposition to these changes there were several people in support when discussed on talk-gb IRC last week. |
| Wynndale | Why don’t you write an article for the Daily Express explaining how you’re a knight in shining armour gallantly holding back against Russian in OSM? |
|
| 29592162 | Bryce C Nesbitt | This changeset damaged the mapping effort of another mapper. There's a lot of good mapping here such as mlountain=yes to natural=peak. |
| Bryce C Nesbitt | (http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3121407760) |
| Bryce C Nesbitt | Each node was individually examined, with the relevant typo not just fixed, but the entire node evaluated for good modern tagging standards. |
| SomeoneElse | No-one's going to complain about changing a typing error such as "mlountain=yes" (and of course a message on the original changeset http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/25971751 explaining the problem would have been nice too).It's also entirely possible that UK canal boaters might e... |
| Bryce C Nesbitt | If you have a problem with a particular node such as #273021554, please consider reverting that node, or contacting the person who made the change first.amenity=pumpout was changed as it was the only use of that key worldwide, not for any other reason. Perhaps I should have tagged that to an ol... |
|
| 29174882 | SomeoneElse | A large series of deletions was reported near Beachy Head (see http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=488700#p488700 and https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2015-March/017130.html ). |
| SomeoneElse | I added a comment to the changeset discussion at http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/29087502 - see there for further details. |
|
| 27073661 | SomeoneElse | (for completeness) note added as http://www.openstreetmap.org/note/277305 |