Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-10-10 20:39:59 UTCPierZen Bonjour Yan, à mon avis tu as mal interprété la clé motorway_link. On l'utilise seulement pour les bretelles qui communiquent entre une autoroute et les chemins avoisinants. Le boulevard au bas de l'autoroute ne devrait pas être classé avec la clé moto...
12017-10-07 14:02:13 UTCPierZen url image ? Je constate que non aligné sur Bing et aimerait comparer par exemple way=13044361, immeuble nettement plus petit que ce que l'on voit sur Bing.
12017-03-21 23:05:11 UTCPierZen Autoroute de l'acier
Voies temporaires lors de travaux routiers ne doivent pas etre ajoutées comme bretelles d'autoroute.

Road maintenance temporary lines should not be added as motorway links.
22017-03-22 06:52:36 UTCandreis_telenav Hello. Could you please give me the exact id of the way?
32017-03-22 12:48:58 UTCPierZen I refer to the crossing segments that you added in the middle of the motorway.
See
http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45855730#map=18/45.39577/-73.46574
42017-03-24 06:39:59 UTCandreis_telenav Done. See changeset 47115681.
52017-09-15 14:17:19 UTCdega @andreis_telenav
The following ways:
472613767: part of "Avenue Jacques-Martin"
13470677: part of "Avenue de la Belle-Dame"
472613765: "Rue du Cuivré-des-Marais"
472613760: "Rue du Satyre-des-Prés"
472613763: "Rue du Cuivr&e...
62017-09-15 15:47:05 UTCPierZen @andreis_telenav both Road maintenance temporary lines and these planned roads stopped by Environment Canada for species protection suggest that you use historical navigation data. Is this exact? If so, how do you validate with the reality in the field?
12017-09-08 22:37:18 UTCPierZen #correction of #maproulette #multipolygon damage - for Natural=wood relation 1141323, you modified outer way=73959226, adding a natural=water + source=Canvec ?? creating a triangular lake, a few km long where there is not. I Corrected, removing the natural=water.
12017-07-23 02:00:01 UTCPierZen Les chemins délimitant les frontières sont habituellement tracés à partir de données d'arpentage. Il ne faut pas modifier la géométrie de ces chemins à partir d'images aériennes.
12017-04-18 15:56:13 UTCPierZen Vous avez créé plusieurs doublons de la relation Route Verte. Ceci a causé par la suite plusieurs problèmes d'édition.

Venez en discuter sur la liste Talk-ca https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca
22017-04-18 16:25:38 UTCAlouette955 De plus je semble remarquer que vous changez des cycleway=lane pour des cycleway=track pour satisfaire un calculateur de trajet.

Je vous réfère aux meilleures pratiques d'OSM ... ne mappez pas pour le rendu, on doit mapper la vérité et non en fonction d'un outil de re...
32017-04-18 16:48:24 UTCPierZen En examinant plus en détail, je constate que vous avez effacé la relation originale 416115.

Pour conserver l'historique des éditions OSM, nous prévoyons rétablir cette relation originale et effacer les nouvelles relations que vous avez créé. Les mo...
12017-04-18 15:59:53 UTCPierZen Vous avez créé plusieurs doublons de la relation Route Verte. Ceci a causé par la suite plusieurs problèmes d'édition.

Venez en discuter sur la liste Talk-ca https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca
12017-03-31 14:52:39 UTCPierZen Relation : 7114883 a enlever. Inutile, croisement d'une rue à sens unique.
22017-04-04 12:30:51 UTCiuliah_telenav C'est vrai, relation:7114883 est une croisement d'une rue à sens unique mais le signe "only_straight_on" est visible sur OSC et il interdit par défaut "u_turn" dans le Rue des Équinoxes. N'est pas correct?
32017-04-04 13:20:53 UTCPierZen il interdit par défaut "u_turn"
C'est votre interprétation. Aucune indication.
42017-04-05 08:44:32 UTCiuliah_telenav Ce que je voulais dire, c'est que si un signe only_straight_on est là, cela ne veut pas dire qu'il interdit seulement d'aller à gauche ou à droite, mais aussi de faire un u_turn, et donc le signe n'est pas complètement inutile. Est-ce une faux interprétation? Pourq...
12017-03-31 14:48:04 UTCPierZen Relation : 6852463 a enlever - Intersection - deux sens uniques et aucun panneau d'interdiction u-turn
22017-04-04 07:19:17 UTCmihaii_telenav Hi PierZen,
Thanks for your message. From what I understand (my French is really bad) you're saying that relation #6852463 should be deleted, right? Please correct me if I'm wrong.
I have added that turn restriction based on Montreal local data with turn restrictions. In that file, at that interse...
32017-04-04 13:05:35 UTCPierZen highway 464050186 is both direction. The two other ways at the intersection are oneway. Coming from highway 464050186, there are simply two oneway signs at the intersection. The No u-turn is your interpretation.
42017-04-05 07:16:38 UTCmihaii_telenav Thanks for your input! In my opinion if there's a sign saying that you can only go straight at an intersection, all other maneuvers are prohibited. That was my logic behind the edit. Please let me know if you consider that I should remove that restriction.

Thanks,
Mihai
12017-03-21 22:59:57 UTCPierZen Voies temporaires lors de travaux routiers ne doivent pas etre ajoutées comme bretelles d'autoroute.

Road maintenance temporary lines should not be added as motorway links.
22017-03-22 06:52:34 UTCandreis_telenav Hello. Could you please give me the exact id of the way?
32017-03-22 12:48:03 UTCPierZen I refer to the crossing segments that you added in the middle of the motorway.
See
http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45856834#map=18/45.45092/-73.41792
42017-03-24 06:40:02 UTCandreis_telenav Done. See changeset 47115716.
12017-03-21 20:27:57 UTCPierZen Voies temporaires lors de construction ne doivent pas etre ajoutées comme bretelles d'autoroute, encore moins a double sens

Construction temporary lines should not be added as motorway linkds, and surely not with highway=no
22017-03-22 06:52:32 UTCandreis_telenav Hello. Could you please give me the exact id of the way?
32017-03-22 12:45:46 UTCPierZen I refer to the crossing segments that you added in the middle of the motorway.
See http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45855967#map=19/45.41808/-73.45171
42017-03-24 06:40:04 UTCandreis_telenav Done. See changeset 47115938.
12017-03-21 23:03:54 UTCPierZen Voies temporaires lors de travaux routiers ne doivent pas etre ajoutées comme bretelles d'autoroute.

Road maintenance temporary lines should not be added as motorway links.
22017-03-21 23:20:28 UTCdannykath Hi PierZen, i will revert my changeset ,thanks for your comment! https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/47054005
12017-03-21 22:47:50 UTCPierZen access = yes,moped=no ??
12017-03-21 22:17:49 UTCPierZen Autoroute de l'acier
Voies temporaires lors de travaux d'entretien. Elles ne doivent pas etre ajoutées comme bretelles d'autoroute.

Road Construction temporary lines should not be added as motorway links.
12017-03-13 22:26:50 UTCPierZen Svp faire un revert. Risque Exercice Maproulette sans connaissance terrain. Vous avez brisé connexion a cette intersection. Outils de navigation routieres ne peuvent plus traverser l'intersection à partir du chemin de Rue Costa-Rica.

Please revert. The risk of Maproulette exercise w...
12017-03-13 22:25:07 UTCPierZen Svp faire un revert. Risque Exercice Maproulette sans connaissance terrain. Vous avez brisé connexion a cette intersection. Outils de navigation routieres ne peuvent plus traverser l'intersection à partir du chemin du Ruisseau-Desnoyers.

Please revert. The risk of Maproulette exerci...
12017-03-13 22:19:26 UTCPierZen Svp faire un revert. Risque Exercice Maproulette sans connaissance terrain. Vous avez brisé connexion a cette intersection. Outils de navigation routieres ne peuvent plus traverser l'intersection à partir du chemin Saint-André pour se rendre sur section sud de la route 104.

P...
22017-03-13 22:22:56 UTCKevo Hi PierZen - I'll take a look at this changeset and the other changeset you commented on tonight.

Sorry about that
32017-03-14 00:19:40 UTCKevo I believe I fixed all of the problems, PierZen. I did it manually rather than reverting, which can cause other problems.
Please tell me if you find any other problems I created and I'll be glad to fix them.
My apologies, have a good night.
12017-03-13 22:10:38 UTCPierZen Svp faire un revert. Risque Exercice Maproulette sans connaissance terrain. Vous avez brisé connexion a cette intersection. Outils de navigation routieres ne peuvent pplus traverser l'intersection à partir de la rue de l'Atre pour se rendre sur section nord de la route.

Please rever...
12016-10-30 12:40:15 UTCmueschel Hi,
looking at the building you added here: It would be very helpful to stick with normal tags. E.g. all the opening_hour tags can not be understood by any software - they can be combined to one normal opening_hours tag.
'Personne de contact' is better written as contact:name or contact:person
'...
22016-10-30 13:27:47 UTCPierZen Hi Jan,
Thanks to spot this.
These tags have been added by the Potentiel 3.0 Field team that organized a UAV mission in this village. They took the time to add POI We are a team to support them at distance. This opening_hours does not look pertinent. I will remove.
12016-10-14 19:50:57 UTCSOSM Please explain why you are removing existing valid data, for example http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/68587894/history instead of simply improving geometries (if needed at all).
22016-10-15 02:12:58 UTCRps333 I have tired very hard to keep all the existing data when adding the new geometries. If I removed some data by mistake, I will be happy to do a local survey to confirm the data.
32016-10-15 13:00:58 UTCLogicalViolinist Original data was probably from NRCan v6.0(which is acient and innacurate in building footprints). Data footprints being added are traced on 30cm imagery and correctly positionned. Copying attributes to new geometry and deleting the old is quicker and more effecient than trying to align old geometry...
42016-10-15 14:15:34 UTCmaxerickson In the above example, the "building:levels" tag was not copied over to the new building.

Procedurally, it looks like there were 2166 existing buildings deleted in one changeset and new buildings uploaded in another. Where could one look to find documentation of how information from the ...
52016-10-15 15:40:09 UTCLogicalViolinist This is part of a project involving statistics canada. Documentation can be found here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WikiProject_Canada#Crowdsourcing_buildings_with_Statistics_Canada
62016-10-15 17:50:11 UTCSimonPoole Nothing against statistics canada, but they have to follow OSM rules just like everybody else.
72016-10-17 21:03:28 UTCRps333 This is part of the Stats Canada Open data project. And has been discussed on Talk:ca It has received OSM Ottawa community approval. OSM Ottawa has been planning on adding the build for 3 months now. We have a dedicated Task sever. FYI, every building I added, I have tried to confirm with Bing imag...
82016-10-17 21:26:56 UTCPierZen There might be improvements to the process like using JOSM Replace Geometry functionality.

Such discussion should benefit to all canadian osm contributors. Please come and discuss this on the Talk-ca discussion list.
92016-10-17 21:39:48 UTCNakaner Hi Rps333,

as you might know, all imports have to comply with the Import Guidelines. Neither "It has received OSM Ottawa community approval." nor a discussion on Talk-ca mailing list is sufficient. You are currently violating almost all sections of the guideline although although you kn...
102016-10-17 22:19:47 UTCRps333 I have never heard of the Replace Geometry. Thanks, I should have used that.
112016-10-20 13:59:12 UTCmikelmaron @Nakaner, you have some things to learn about the OpenStreetMap community. We do not have police, officially sanctioned or self appointed, who monitor imports for "compliance". If there is an issue, then certainly, there is room to be specific and helpful to address any problems. Sorry, bu...
122016-10-20 15:07:42 UTCLogicalViolinist @mikelmaron while I do agree with you, it's easy to police people into obeying Guildelines(which by definition should be a suggested coarse of action instead of a hardset rule book that if you don't obey you get reverted) to a T when you work with someone from the DWG:
From:
https://wiki.openstree...
132016-10-20 15:26:32 UTCNakaner @LogicalViolinist I did not looked at all your edits of the last 18 months. I just asked myself: "Well Gatineau has all addresses on the map. What's the source of them?" And the answer was: "It's changeset 33248922 from LogicalViolinist."

I do have a job at Geofabrik. But as y...
142016-10-20 15:37:01 UTCLogicalViolinist I did say roughly. I did not use google translate. Mein Deutsch ist nicht so gut. Side job still qualifies as a job. It means you probably know woodpeck personally in real life (judging that geofabrik is not that big of a company)
152016-10-20 15:48:38 UTCottawa_data I do agree that @Nakaner has been actively looking for reasons to revert commits from OSM community members in Canada. Thanks to these reverts, we now have a blank map again.
162016-10-20 17:34:21 UTCSOSM @mikelmaron the complaints about the import originate with local mappers that found that their data was needlessly being deleted/replaced without any substantial previous discussion. As nakaner has pointed out, the people involved were very well aware of what the guidelines say from previous discuss...
172016-10-20 17:37:58 UTCSimonPoole Upps, the previous comment was from me, and is obviously not an opinion of SOSM.
182016-10-22 15:03:15 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 43067946 where the changeset comment is: revert un-discussed building import in Ottawa
12016-08-29 15:16:25 UTCPierZen Zooming-in with Bing, we see that these are service roads inside the mine and not railways. Way 436205830 is partly used by cars going to the parking at the entrance of the mine. Other ways are used by overweight trucks inside the open mine.
12016-06-20 14:17:14 UTCPierZen Where did you took your infos before mapping? This look like more like spamming. Please only add features that exist to OpenStreetMap.

I cannot comment for the club near Liverpool.

But I have knowledge of the area where you have added an ambassy on the border of the Richelieu River ie node 42...
22016-06-20 14:44:31 UTCPierZen Sorry, wrong position with my navigator.

But can you confirm that there is a Rachel ?? embassy or consulate in Manchester, UK. Wich country do you refer to?
32016-06-20 15:42:35 UTCSzabolcs Nyikó Sorry, not sure what's happening.
I only added the Kitesurfing school in Rhyl, North Wales.
No idea how the embassy got linked to my account.
42016-06-20 16:42:25 UTCtrigpoint The edit has gone a little wrong, the kite surfing school tag has been added to an existing monument that isn't right.
Does it have a building somewhere?
52016-06-21 11:45:08 UTCtrigpoint I am reverting this change, please add the kitesurfing school in its correct location.

Thanks
12016-05-16 16:17:50 UTCPierZen Nous avons une discussion sur la liste de discussion talk-ca pour régler les problèmes d'affichage sur le Lac-des-deux-Montagnes.

Tes modifications au polygone de la rivière Rigaud sont partielles. Avant de faire d'autres modifications, viens discuter.

https://lists.openst...
12016-04-18 00:25:47 UTCJojo4u Hello PierZen, the school in Atahualpa is duplicated now. I don't think the school has this big area, are you sure?
area: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/410981472
node: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3115590629
22016-04-18 00:45:40 UTCPierZen Thanks Joj4u,

You are right. I revised the polygon surrounding the school to a smaller size align on a wall around the school. The buildings for this school were traced by other contributors. I removed the duplicates inside the boundary of the school. But you will find more duplicates in the nei...
12016-01-18 21:17:49 UTCPierZen Longueuil a une population de plus de 100,000 personnes et répond donc au critère place=city. Sur quel critère avez-vous modifié cette classification?
22016-01-18 22:22:25 UTCGizmot Use the place=city tag to identify the largest settlement or settlements within a territory, including national, state and provincial capitals, and other major conurbations.
Smaller charter cities should normally be tagged using place=town to avoid these places being promoted too highly in gazettee...
12015-10-11 10:14:14 UTCGerdP Google earth shows this
junction much closer to the city
22015-10-12 13:20:36 UTCPierZen Seul le nom a été modifié dans le Groupe de modifications 32683546. Vous n'indiquez pas à quel carrefour vous vous référez. À noter, nous utilison l'imagerie Bing pour cartographier OpenStreetMap. Certains carrefours giratoires ont été a...
32015-10-12 14:38:01 UTCGerdP yes, sorry, I did not notice that this changeset has such a large bbox,
and I don't remember the exact place anymore nor how I got there :-(
42015-10-12 14:39:22 UTCGerdP the part was in an area where Bing shows
no hires pictures, so I tried to find it in
Google earth. I think that is allowed?
52015-10-12 17:18:47 UTCPierZen On peut compare, Mais attention, la licence propriétaire de l'imagerie Google ne nous permet pas de l'utiliser pour tracer sur OpenStreetMap.
62015-10-12 17:31:12 UTCGerdP okay, up to now I just use it to confirm what I found in Bing images. If I see a road name
sign or a house number in StreetView, is it allowed to use that info?
72015-10-12 18:19:08 UTCPierZen Non, la licence n'est pas compatible. Il faut trouver d'autres sources. Dans JOSM / Preferences / WMS-TMS, il est possible d'ajouter la couche Routes Geobase. Elle nous donne les noms de rue au Canada.
82015-10-15 09:09:01 UTCGerdP sorry, forgot to thank you for that hint reg. Geobase
12015-02-28 19:32:07 UTCPierZen Modifications systématiques aux règles sans d'abord en discuter avec la communauté. SVP venir discuter sur https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca
12015-02-28 19:31:15 UTCPierZen Modifications systématiques aux règles sans d'abord en discuter avec la communauté. SVP venir discuter sur https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca
12015-01-06 16:22:09 UTCneuhausr Hi, it looks like you did a large import of data and haven't included OSM tags, just the attributes that were with the data. It also seems likely this didn't go through the Mechanical Edit Process outlined here: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Mechanical_Edit_Policy I look forward to your reply....
22015-01-06 17:07:56 UTCPierZen Manipulation error while browsing this file adding manually some lines. This is anyway very imprecise data. Deleting it.
32015-01-06 19:15:52 UTCSomeoneElse For info - this has been reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/27962131 .
PierZen has contributed to 29 changeset discussions(s) with a total of 84 comment(s)