Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-04-21 14:15:02 UTCcarciofo Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap! Thanks for your contributions in Boca! Just a quick note to let you know that the "backyard ponds" are actually private swimming pools, so a more appropriate tag would be leisure=swimming_pool along with access=private :) You may also find the "straigh...
12017-03-24 20:33:01 UTCsergioablanco Ésta edición está apareciendo en el Mapa Base, está afectando la cartografía que lo consume.
22017-04-16 10:40:27 UTCcarciofo Cordial saludo marcodena, la etiqueta bus_guideway es válida para el Transmilenio. Véase http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dbus_guideway: "Do not use this on normal paved roadways that are designated for buses only. One correct tagging for those is highway=service, a...
32017-04-16 10:41:47 UTCcarciofo perdón, la etiqueta **no** es válida
12017-04-16 09:01:02 UTCcarciofo Hi & welcome to OSM! Thanks for your very detailed contributions! Just wanted to welcome you and invite you to visit the wiki page (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org) where you can find additional information about tags. More specifically, the mapping of turning lanes as individual ways is discourag...
12017-04-15 18:25:35 UTCcarciofo Hi there, just thought I'd mention that perhaps covered=yes would be a better tag for roads which pass through a roof structures without walls on all sides (such as the ones in front of the cruise terminals). This is specially true if you'll be doing large scale imports. Cheers & happy mapping
12017-04-13 14:41:54 UTCcarciofo Hi, I'm not really sure why you've decided to re-align the whole of A1A in Miami-Dade to the outer lane? The convention is to align to the road's centerline. For such widespread changes, please consider discussing your idea with the rest of the community via the mailing list before endeavoring into ...
12017-03-13 14:16:28 UTCcarciofo Hi there and welcome to OSM! Thanks for your additions to Delray Beach. Please make sure to connect sidewalks to the road network at crossings so that they can be used for routing :) Happy mapping!
12017-03-05 16:20:19 UTCcarciofo Hi there, thanks for your update of the I-4 @ Maitland Blvd exit. I noticed that you deleted the NB exit ramp towards the west. Couple of things: 1) there are two 90B exits now since the old exit is still tagged. 2) Since the ramp is still visible on the current imagery, I'd suggest using the approp...
22017-03-05 20:59:20 UTCJeopardyTempest Oye, made a bunch of changes yesterday, and of all the ones to falter on. I optedto copy the exit point to speed/ensure the new point had the same information, but forgot to delete the old.

Reading through key:construction, construction:minor sounds more valid for the exit (and all of the inters...
32017-03-06 17:33:28 UTCcarciofo No problem at all! It was just a small detail really, nothing to worry about. The important thing is that what you mapped matched reality, and at the end of the day that's all that matters.

Thanks for removing the tags from the duplicate exit node. I went ahead and reverted the deletion of the r...
42017-03-06 19:27:44 UTCJeopardyTempest Cheers :-) I still use Potlatch, so things like reversions are more challenging. Yeah, I know we've got a few places prepared with the new layouts using the construction details... and I've spent far too long looking at that PDF trying to work out exact details of it all. Hadn't realized you were...
12017-02-24 18:05:44 UTCcarciofo Hi there Davvan, thanks for your contributions! When mapping parking isles, it would be great if the roads didn't backtrack existing roads as it comes up in data quality checks as an overlapping road (which is considered an error). Feel free to get in touch if you have any questions! Happy mapping!
12017-02-24 17:29:12 UTCcarciofo Hi lazy5, thanks for your contributions in and around Amelia Earhart Park. It look as if you may have forgotten to check for overlapping roads & trails as some of the paths overlap existing features. Uploading unchecked GPX tracks is discouraged, so just make sure you check them next time before...
12017-02-21 17:08:33 UTCcarciofo Hi, regarding your changes to Collins Avenue, can you let us know what the basis is for moving the way off the centerline yet again after it had been fixed from your earlier changesets? As a convention, roads are mapped on the centerline. You haven't used any placement tags, either, so I'd appreciat...
22017-02-21 17:16:46 UTCcarciofo Also, road priority changes need a source, but you have left no comment on your changeset either. Leaving meaningful comments helps other mappers with verifiability (see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Verifiability). Thanks again. If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to get in touch ...
12017-02-21 16:50:09 UTCcarciofo Hi, I'm not sure why you disconnected all footways from the cul-de-sacs near the beach? Without a connection to the road network, no walking directions can be provided...
12017-01-06 14:53:05 UTCcarciofo Hi & thanks for your upload. In future, please take care to check beforehand if roads don't already exist before uploading GPX tracks in order to avoid duplicated/overlapping roads. Thanks.
12016-12-16 14:53:47 UTCcarciofo Hi & thanks for your edit! Regarding Bill Dr & West Anoka Ln, is it possible to cross by foot? If so, could you please connect them with a highway=footway (or path as appropriate); if not, please add noexit=yes to the terminal node of W Anoka Ln in order to avoid data quality tools marking t...
12016-12-03 12:54:54 UTCcarciofo Hi, I've reverted your changes to road priorities as they were correct prior to your edits. For cross-referencing, I didn't received a response to my question regarding the source for these changes which I posted to your changeset 42052810. The wiki is a great place to get information about tags in ...
12016-11-26 10:01:18 UTCcarciofo Hi, thanks for your edit. Might I ask according to whom, or to what source, are the road priorities incorrect? Thanks.
12016-11-24 10:42:51 UTCcarciofo Hi abel801, thanks for your contribution. Way 354595007 (http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/354595007) showed up in data quality since no junction nodes were created for the ways it intersects along the way. Could you be so kind and create intersection nodes with the existing road network for this way...
12016-11-23 12:42:26 UTCcarciofo Hi Davvan, unfortunately I've had to remove once again the lanes you mapped as individual ways in Plant City, FL, despite my comments in your previous changesets (e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/34004745). Please note that individual lanes are not mapped as separate ways in OSM; rather,...
12016-11-15 10:01:18 UTCMKnight Öffnungszeit am Atrium ist falsch, ich habe sie wieder gelöscht.
22016-11-15 19:59:01 UTCcarciofo As you know, edits in OSM should be verifiable (see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Verifiability). Your statement that they are "wrong" is unsubstantiated; my edit, however is verifiable through the mall's official website. You did not add the allegedly "correct" hours but si...
32016-11-15 23:12:36 UTCMKnight The building (!) isn't closed after 20:00, the right OH are on the most POIs in the building (like http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3276496356).

For "verifiing" example: http://www.weimar-atrium.de/store/herkules/ is open Th-Fr up to 22:00. At the top of the page you can see, that POIs...
42016-11-16 18:59:02 UTCcarciofo Thanks for the info & feedback. The issue here is that the building and the mall features have been conflated into a single feature, and since we can't have different opening hour tags for the same feature I've split the feature into building and mall to better represent the data since –I'...
52016-11-16 19:18:51 UTCscai With the new shop=mall node (https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4504849799) it is completely unclear for which objects and/or building parts these opening hours apply.
62016-11-16 20:29:49 UTCMKnight its not better now. the building and the mall (is the same) have no closing time. the shops (most already tagged) have it.
72016-11-17 13:10:11 UTCcarciofo @scai the opening hours of the mall are reflected in the mall feature, and the opening hours for the building are in the building feature. There was no data before, so I'm not sure how this can more confusing compared to no data?
@MKnight I was under the impression based on your original comment th...
82016-11-17 15:42:22 UTCscai It is unclear which shops belong to the "mall feature". Therefore the opening hours on the "mall feature" are pretty useless in my opinion.
92016-11-17 16:22:01 UTCcarciofo @scai I imagine you are referring to the scenario where the mall is mapped as a node instead of the building tagged as mall. Even in the latter case, we're still left with the absence of a tag which can be interpreted to mean that the data is missing.
12016-10-23 20:08:01 UTCcarciofo Carlos,
Bienvenido a OSM y gracias por sus contribuciones. Desafortunadamente las ediciones han aparecido en las herramientas de calidad de datos principalmente porque se mapearon rutas de bus como carreteras/calles una sobre la otra. Esto debe hacerse mediante una relación de transporte p&u...
12016-10-14 13:46:38 UTCcarciofo Bienvenidos a OpenStreetMap. Fue cambiada la categorización del nodo "Sede Familias en Acción" a un centro comunitario, ya que había sido etiquetado erroneamente como una ciudad. Si esta etiqueta no es correcta para este nodo, los invitamos a visitar la página w...
12016-10-10 17:08:11 UTCcarciofo Hi, regarding your dual carriageway split on Nat'l Hwy 25, please note that your edits came up as issues/errors in data quality since you neglected to properly connect intersecting roads. The relation for the National Highway was not updated either. Kindly make sure all intersecting roads connect pr...
12016-10-07 12:31:58 UTCcarciofo Hi Joshua, thanks for your contributions! Just wanted to let you know that your changes popped up on data quality tools mostly because the pedestrian crosswalks you added do not intersect the highways they cross. This is a problem because the intersection node also needs to be tagged as a crossing f...
12016-10-03 14:41:31 UTCcarciofo Bienvenido a OpenStreetMap. El nombre que le está asignando a los objetos no es válido. Toda la información que entre a OSM debe ser real y verificable. Para mayor información, visite la página wiki de la etiqueta de nombre http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Nom...
12016-09-22 21:20:19 UTCcarciofo Welcome to OSM. Regarding the dual carriage split you made on Carrera 65, please note that data quality tools picked up a number of errors from Calle 102 northward, as these streets were left unconnected. The carriageway itself was alse left with no name. Kindly fix and clean up this changeset. Than...
12016-07-13 13:07:44 UTCcarciofo Bienvenido(a) a OSM. Gracias por tus contribuciones. Te invito a que visites la wiki donde encontrarás más información acerca del significado de las etiquetas. La vía que etiquetaste como trunk ya existía. En OSM hay una política de representar dentro de lo ...
12016-06-08 19:28:59 UTCcarciofo Hola cris, veo que revertiste algunos cambios de prioridad de carreteras en la carretera Viterbo-Apía. En este caso, alguien se tomó la molestia de escribir una nota indicando que este tramo hace parte de una ruta nacional, y por lo tanto es una vía primaria. Si no estas de acue...
12016-05-26 19:58:18 UTCcarciofo Hola Juan Sebastián, bienvenido a Open Street Map! Gracias por tus contribuciones. Te invito a revisar la Wiki en wiki.openstreetmap.org, donde encuentras información acerca de las etiquetas usadas en el mapa. Si tienes alguna duda, también puedes buscar ayuda en help.openstreet...
12016-05-26 17:56:50 UTCcarciofo Please note that your edit has been considered vandalism. If you were trying to add a business, please find help via the different channels available (see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Get_help).
12016-03-15 11:08:10 UTCcarciofo Hola, gracias por tu contribución! Al añadir ciclorutas, por favor asegúrate de crear intersecciones con la red vial, ya que sin ellas están desconectadas y los motores de rutas no las tomarán en cuenta para crear rutas. Igualmente, para ciclovias contiguas a calle...
12016-03-03 10:38:12 UTCcarciofo Thank you for your contribution. When creating parking isles, please create individual roads for each isle instead of using the same object to overlap the service roads, as overlapping roads are raised as a data quality error.
12016-03-03 10:28:14 UTCcarciofo Thank you for your contribution. When creating parking isles, please create individual roads for each isle instead of using the same object to overlap the service roads, as overlapping roads are raised as a data quality error.
12016-03-03 10:08:10 UTCcarciofo Thank you for your contribution. You have drawn roads which overlap on themselves; this is raised as a data quality error as roads should not overlap. Please create individual roads for each segment instead of using the same road to go back and backtrack onto itself. Also, there are no intersection ...
12016-02-11 14:48:21 UTCcarciofo Cordial saludo Felipe Andrés. Por favor asegúrese en el futuro de chequear primero que los objetos que está añadiendo no existen ya, especialmente si está subiendo tracks de GPS. Adicionalmente, separe y cree intersecciones con las demás calles, de lo contra...
12016-02-11 14:43:28 UTCcarciofo Cordial saludo. Por favor asegúrese de crear un nodo de intersección entre ciclorutas y la red vial, de lo contrario no se podrá rutear por ellas. Adicionalmente las intersecciones sin nodo son consideradas como erros por las diferentes herramientas de control de caldad de OSM. ...
12016-02-10 07:49:21 UTCGerdP Hi there!
I've noticed the tag highway=demolished:residential which is only used here. I think you should better use demolished:highway=residential.
22016-02-11 08:28:59 UTCcarciofo Thanks for the heads up, GerdP! My intention was to apply the prefix to the key instead of the value, but I probably clicked the wrong field in JOSM and started typing without noticing. I've applied a fix and committed it in changeset 37141121. Cheers.
32016-02-11 08:53:35 UTCGerdP OK, thanks for the feedback :-)
12016-02-09 14:26:34 UTCcarciofo Please note that Taft Street is *not* a dual carriageway as it has no physical separator. In addition, when splitting dual carriageways, ensure that you have connected intersecting roads to both one-ways and set oneway=yes on both directions. That was not done here.
22016-09-26 16:25:42 UTCsamely Hey, carciofo.
You are completely right, not all Taft Street is a dual carriage. So thank you for fixing the segment which has no physical separation and sharing the way this should be mapped.
12015-11-29 18:41:09 UTCcarciofo Cordial saludo y gracias por su contribución. Por favor recuerde que los nombres deben ser entrados sin abreviaciones (Calle 102A y no Cll 102a).
12015-11-29 18:26:31 UTCcarciofo Please be more careful when splitting dual carriageways. All ways connecting to SW 100th Ave south of Griffin Rd were left unconnected
12015-11-29 18:21:21 UTCcarciofo Please be more careful when splitting dual carriageways, Golden Shoe Road northbound and southbound at SW 29th Place were left unconnected
12015-11-06 18:06:12 UTCcarciofo Hola, bienvenido/a a OSM. La categoría highway=trunk se usa para vías de doble calzada. La carretera entre Caldas y Angelópolis es una carretera regional, por lo tanto la etiqueta trunk no le corresponde. Para mayor información puedes consultar la Guía para mapear ...
12015-10-25 14:17:58 UTCcarciofo Again, please be more careful and thorough when splitting dual carriageways. You've left both sides of North Park road as northbound only! Also, attributes like traffic lights at intersections must be propagated to the new/split road, and the lanes attribute must be adjusted (i.e. split).
22015-10-29 13:49:46 UTCediyes Hello carciofo, thank you for noticing this error and correct it. I'm going to be more careful about this in the future.
Do let me know if there's anything else I could improve on, thanks again.
Edith.
12015-10-25 14:07:23 UTCcarciofo Please be more careful and thorough when splitting dual carriageways. NW 56th Ave north- and south-bound segments were left unconnected, the entire undivided stretch between Sunrise Blvd and NW 19th St was left as one way, and many intersections were not extended to both directions. Thanks.
22015-10-26 14:20:29 UTCsamely Hey there, thanks for your feedback. I saw you've already fixed them. I will keep your recommendation in mind . Thanks again.
12015-10-17 16:01:47 UTCcarciofo Hi, regarding the tags highway=turning_circle and highway=turning_loop in this commit, please note the difference: turning_loop has a non-transversable island, while turning_loop has no non-transversable island. It seems you've got these two mixed up since they were applied here opposite to their me...
22015-10-17 16:03:11 UTCcarciofo Oops, that should read of course: "while turning_circle has no non-transversable island". See http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway=turning_circle and http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dturning_loop
32015-10-31 11:05:36 UTCSeandebasti thx for commiting, I realized this problem too, because other mappers did add the wrong tag. I thought I did it right here, do you have a specific area here?
12015-10-07 21:05:19 UTCcarciofo Hi there, regarding your changes in Plant City, FL, where you added separate ways for each lane (Alexander St & SR 39, for example). Please note a road should be mapped as a single way with attributes to denote that it has several lanes. You can use the lanes=* tag along with turn:lanes to map i...
12015-10-05 13:37:48 UTCcarciofo Please be more careful next time with unfinished dual carriageways. You left a long segment of Lyons Road with oneway=yes without a corresponding way in the opposite direction.
22015-10-31 11:17:40 UTCSeandebasti which one exactly, did you fix it? would be nice if you can point it when you commit something . because i dont see what you mean if you do not point it. thx
32015-10-31 11:30:34 UTCSeandebasti and actually did you know that the carriageways are abandoned, so please fix it the right way
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relations/Proposed/Dual_carriageways
12015-09-27 21:01:34 UTCcarciofo Hi, as I mentioned before, roads which back-track on themselves keep coming up in data quality tools as overlapping. Please draw roads as single segments with other roads intersecting them, as opposed to having the same road backtrack and go in a different direction. If you have any questions, pleas...
12015-09-24 16:19:57 UTCcarciofo Cordial saludo. Quisiera confirmar que los cambios a los nodos de la Ruta 45 en la glorieta con la Ruta 40 en los que añade decenas de traffic_calming=bump son correctos? No conozco el area, pero me parece extraño que hubiera tantos policias acostados consecutivamente. De ser un error,...
22015-09-24 20:41:51 UTCjuanda097 Lo podéis apreciar en una foto de la zona y no están pintados en el asfalto son reales http://www.mapillary.com/map/im/EzDw9fjcO6US0cJ6Tco-bg/photo
32015-09-24 20:45:07 UTCjuanda097 además te dejo una guía de mapeo que dejaron en la comunidad, yo tengo que quitar el RN de las carreteras y autopistas que edité.

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia
42015-09-25 16:45:32 UTCcarciofo Gracias por las fotos, juanda097. La verdad no alcanzo a apreciar en ellas rieleve en el asfalto para categorizarlo como un "bump", pero si usted conoce el área eso es lo importante. En caso de no tener relieve, los categorizaría entonces como traffic_calming=rumble_strip. Gr...
12015-09-18 09:34:03 UTCcarciofo Hola Iván, la etiqueta highway=motorway no aplica a vías en Colombia (véase http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia#Etiquetas_de_rutas_en_Colombia). Estas vías tienen una definición específica restringida en OSM y bajo esa defini...
12015-09-07 10:58:04 UTCmueschel Hi carciofo,
with this changeset you introduced the misspelled key "destinaton:lanes" (missing 'i') on several ways. Could you check / correct for that? As another remark, all these tags contain only ref numbers of roads - these are usually tagged as "destination:ref:lanes" inst...
22015-09-07 12:21:38 UTCcarciofo Hi Jan,
Thanks for the heads up! I've corrected the spelling on the key on the instances of destinaton:lanes returned by overpass turbo. As far as your remark is concerned, I didn't used destination:ref:lanes as the ref value on the destination roads does not match, e.g. I-595 East/West (which is w...
carciofo has contributed to 49 changeset discussions(s) with a total of 76 comment(s)