Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-12-12 09:54:35 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map contribution. Can you please provide more information about this ATM? Its in an unlikely location.
22017-12-13 21:55:22 UTCtonyf1 No reply to changeset comment. Deleted ATM.
12017-12-09 22:47:11 UTCtonyf1 Hi. How sure are you that there is a park here? From the LPI satellite it appears to be part (there's more in the shadow to the right) of a green coloured roof.
22017-12-12 05:35:10 UTCtonyf1 No reply to changeset comment. Deleted park.
12017-12-11 02:04:34 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map edits. The original mapping of the paths 4 years ago, name=Unknown, was wrong. Thanks for wanting to do something about it. Its OK for things not to have names, many paths do not have a name. If the paths do not have official names, eg they have no named signposts, then its b...
12017-12-09 23:37:34 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for the new info. Duplicate caravan park node, I transfered new tags to older one and deleted newer
12017-12-09 23:19:01 UTCtonyf1 Removed reservoir tag from backyard swimming pool, tag as leisure=swimming_pool Changeset #54498662
12017-12-09 23:06:17 UTCtonyf1 Deleted beach and stream with Changeset #54498408. Satellite shows car park.
12017-12-09 23:02:47 UTCtonyf1 Deleted beach and stream with Changeset #54498408. Satellite shows car park.
12017-12-08 23:35:09 UTCtonyf1 This edit looks like map greffiti. Spells 'Lilli'. not evident in sat image. Deleted.
12017-12-08 04:49:10 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions. A small point though, can you please leave more detailed changeset descriptions rather than just 'change'
12017-12-04 00:36:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. You have changed relation 7125879, which extends 2km south of your new subdivision road all the way to the Peter Murrel State Reserve from natural=wood to landuse=residential. Is this what you intended?
22017-12-07 01:18:15 UTCWarin61 Hi,
I have changed this back to trees .. that is what is observable in bing. Newton3 .. you need to say what you are using for this change - it could be 'local knowledge' - that is very good and will trump any satellite imagery! However the relation, as ronyf1, says covers some areas that are desig...
32017-12-07 02:25:51 UTCtonyf1 Thanks Warin61
42017-12-10 23:28:49 UTCWarin61 Hi,
I have separated the relation into 2 relations. The northern one could be a residential development Relation: 7798537. I have left it as trees, but it could be come landuse=brownfield with things are being built then landuse=residential .. but it needs local input to be certain.
Over to you ...
12017-12-04 00:10:48 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map contribution. You have placed a guest house in the middle of the road. It would be better if you moved it to its exact location and entered its name. Thanks.
22017-12-06 23:46:27 UTCtonyf1 No reply to my changeset comment. This guest house can not be in its correct location, has no identifying information and from its location is more likely to be a hotel or hostel. On balance I have decided to delete it.
12017-12-02 01:01:21 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map contributions. This area looks like a bad match to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure=park. From the satellite photo it looks like its half the front yard of the house to the south and half the nature strip?
22017-12-05 07:09:58 UTCtonyf1 Deleted by user CloCkWeRX
12017-11-24 22:41:55 UTCtonyf1 Hola. Este es un duplicado de una panadería que creó hace 6 meses. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/49342035
Hi. This is a duplicate of a bakery you created 6 months ago. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/49342035
22017-12-02 02:28:23 UTCtonyf1 Deleted the newer as duplicate, copied capitalisation and hours to the older node. The newer node was 30m south of the older node, I don't know which location was more accurate.
12017-12-01 02:01:10 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions. I suggest railway=rail be replaced with railway=proposed
22017-12-02 01:47:51 UTCtonyf1 The proposed railway was deleted by user MapAnalyser465
12017-12-01 01:50:19 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for your edit. I did some tweaks in Changeset #54221236
12017-12-01 00:51:06 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You can square up buildings with the ID right button menu. Can you please pause your edits while you read and reply to your changeset comments.
12017-11-30 01:48:28 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You tagged a bank named House. Is this your house? OSM is not the place for marking private data if that is what you have done. If not, my apologies. Either way a bank is not usually called house?
22017-11-30 23:57:56 UTCtonyf1 No reply so deleted Bank named House with Changeset #54219712
12017-11-27 04:42:53 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You tagged a tourism apartment named House. Is this your house? OSM is not the place for marking private data if that is what you have done. If not, my apologies. A tourism apartment should fit this definition "A holiday or vacation apartment is a furnished apartment or flat with cooking an...
22017-11-30 23:55:00 UTCtonyf1 No reply so deleted House with Changeset #54219656
12017-11-30 23:14:54 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions, Its important though to use more descriptive changeset descriptions than 'change'. You should aim to say what you changed, why you changed it and how you knew it was right. Another user has identified issues with your changes, changeset descriptions help us differ...
12017-11-30 23:01:05 UTCtonyf1 Hi, 2 months ago you placed a castle named home here, I am assuming that the apartment named Home is similarly personal information and not suitable for OSM. I have deleted it.
12017-11-25 02:18:25 UTCtonyf1 Hi. This bench is in an unlikely location and does not show on the satellite images. Is it really there?
22017-11-30 01:43:16 UTCtonyf1 No reply. Deleted Changeset #54193141
12017-11-24 22:34:51 UTCtonyf1 Hola. ¿Hay un fire_hydrant aquí? No hay nada en la imagen de satélite.
Hi. Is there a fire_hydrant here? There is nothing in the satellite image.
22017-11-27 20:40:56 UTCtonyf1 No reply, deleted Changeset #54132293
12017-11-26 00:49:24 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions. For guidance how to tag an area as a shooting range see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:shooting
12017-11-21 06:40:11 UTCtonyf1 Hi. That's a lot of deletions. Where did Coles and Myer move to? What happened?
22017-11-21 21:12:05 UTCCD123 they did not move i deleted them
32017-11-22 02:24:54 UTCnevw Can you tell us why you deleted them, CD123?
Was it an accidental deletion?
42017-11-23 04:42:31 UTCtonyf1 Hi CD123. I assume your deletions were either an accident or you didn't realise you were editing the public map. On this basis I have reverted your edits with Changeset #54016899
12017-11-23 00:34:57 UTCtonyf1 su edición accidentalmente eliminada Santa Rosa highway= etiqueta
Your edit accidentally deleted Santa Rosa highway= tag.. Was residential, I reinstated as unknown
12017-11-21 05:32:45 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Assuming that this is an office, it would be better tagged
office=insurance
name=SEQ Life Brokers
rather than at the moment
insurance=SEQ Life Brokers
because maps know how to render offices but not insurances
12017-11-18 22:27:32 UTCtonyf1 ¿Hay un camping aquí? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Tag:tourism%3Dcamp_site
Is there a campground here? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag%3Atourism%3Dcamp_site
22017-11-21 05:22:32 UTCtonyf1 Sin respuesta. Eliminado.
No reply. Deleted.Changeset #53966431
12017-11-20 05:55:14 UTCtonyf1 Responda a los comentarios por favor, no hay nada en la foto de satélite, nada en las imágenes Mapillary a nivel de calle. Parece que solo hay un parque..
Please reply to comments, there is nothing in the satellite photo, nothing in Mapillary street level images. It looks like there i...
22017-11-21 05:14:27 UTCtonyf1 Deleted changeset #53966347
12017-11-19 22:49:59 UTCtonyf1 Hola. Gracias celisab por sus contribuciones recientes a OSM cerca de Rio Salado. Hay algunos problemas con tus ediciones recientes.
(1) Se desaconseja el uso de mayúsculas de bloque.
(2) El nombre es solo el nombre http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Nombres#Nombre_es_s.C3.B3lo_el_nombre...
12017-11-17 05:40:54 UTCtonyf1 Hola. ¿Hay una tienda aquí? Es un parque?
Hi. Is there a shop here? It is a park?
22017-11-19 21:56:34 UTCtonyf1 Sorry. No reply to comment, nothing in satellite photo, nothing in Mapillary street level images. It looks like there is just a park. Deleting a photography store.
12017-11-17 23:04:19 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have created a hotel at 234 Victoria Street. Does it have a name, phone, email or website? Is it actually a hotel?
22017-11-18 03:47:35 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I've looked a bit deeper. Is it possible that you have entered the wrong street number or put it in the wrong place on the map? Its between a bakery at 255 and a pizza bar at 312 so number 234 seems out of place in the numbering.
32017-11-18 22:14:04 UTCtonyf1 Hi. There is a hotel at number 304 which seems a good match, Morgans Boutique Hotel http://www.morganshotel.com.au
12017-11-16 02:32:06 UTCtonyf1 Hola. ¿Por qué has eliminado estos árboles? Hi. Why have you deleted these trees?
22017-11-18 21:59:51 UTCtonyf1 No reply to comment, reverted deletion of trees with changeset #53912129
12017-11-17 22:53:19 UTCtonyf1 Hi. This appears to be a duplicate of https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5110753221
12017-11-17 10:25:53 UTCnevw Hi
I shifted the node for your business off the centre of Newcastle Street to the nearest building. Can your relocate it to the correct building that your occupy and not on to the street. I also added craft=locksmith to your tags. Actually tagged the type of office, shop or craft seems to be the mo...
22017-11-17 22:45:40 UTCtonyf1 This appears to be a duplicate of https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4918726351 on the south side of the road and probably the correct location
32017-11-18 01:53:57 UTCnevw Thanks tonyf1
I shifted the tags to the correct location node.
12017-11-16 04:03:47 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have created a caravan park named 'Qusay's house'. You may not be aware that your edits appear on the public map. I am reverting your edit. مرحبا. لقد قمت بإنشاء حديقة قافلة يدعى 'منزل قصي'. قد لا تكون على دراية بأن تعديلاتك ت...
12017-11-11 00:10:21 UTCtonyf1 Hi. This looks like a duplicate of Node: Cabañas Rivendel (662450105) https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/662450105
22017-11-16 01:50:18 UTCtonyf1 No reply. Transferred wifi information to the older node. Deleted as duplicate in Changeset #53826178
12017-11-08 21:43:05 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Your edits to Open Street Map are visible to all users. Please do not add imaginary features.
22017-11-08 22:13:01 UTCtonyf1 Reverted Changeset #53623195
12017-11-08 21:46:50 UTCtonyf1 Sorry wrong changeset description. Should be revert imaginary town in the Australian desert.
12017-11-06 06:26:53 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You are editing a public map that lots of people depend on. Please stop adding imaginary features.
22017-11-06 09:57:05 UTCCloCkWeRX At this point, I'm inclined to suggest reverting - this area had a whole lot of other fictional edits around ~2 years ago, its odd that it attracts them or its the same user with a new account vandalising.
32017-11-06 23:03:40 UTCtonyf1 Hi atschulz7, I'm sorry but I had to revert all your edits. OSM is for mapping real things only.
12017-11-05 06:57:00 UTCtonyf1 Hi. This still looks like SEO spam to me. Your first attempt was at the post office. This version has a street name but no street number. The website only gives a PO box. The node is placed in the road reserve. I will happily accept a map location that matches a physical address on your website.
22017-11-06 07:22:33 UTCtonyf1 No reply to comment. Deleting because the feature does not exist at this location
32017-11-06 09:35:48 UTCDynamic HVAC Hey Tony..I don't know who made you "god all mighty" in relation to open street map but if you took the time to check the ASIC register you would see that the address where the pin is located is the actual registered business address. What is listed on my website is a mailing address !! I ...
42017-11-06 11:11:37 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for the reply. I have restored the node. I have moved it from the road reserve to the adjacent property. Can you please confirm it is on the right property. A street number would be good.
52017-11-07 21:59:44 UTCaharvey There has been an influx of poor quality SEO entries where we don't hear back on changeset comments when things don't add up. Sorry you got caught up in this @Dynamic HVAC, but glad to see things have been worked out in the end. Thanks @tonyf1 for always being on the ball!
12017-11-04 22:29:47 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map contribution. This is an unlikely place for a nursing home, what were you wanting to map here?
22017-11-04 22:44:18 UTCmurrayslavin Yes. Highly unlikely - and it isn’t. It was put there until I can unravel how Categories can be added or edited. Most are related to urban situations - not rural. I’ve been trying to find a way to do this
32017-11-04 22:59:41 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for the prompt reply. Editing with a PC using the ID editor at http://www.openstreetmap.org is fairly easy but its hard if you are using a phone in the field. The Vespucci editor is available for Android. Good luck.
42017-11-06 07:13:08 UTCtonyf1 I changed nursing home to locality as an interim fix, feel free to improve on this.
12017-11-04 22:18:03 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions. Rest area seems unlikely here, 'A rest area is place along a road, usually a motorway or dual-carriageway, where a driver can stop to have a rest.' What were you wanting to map?
22017-11-06 07:09:19 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I didn't get a reply so I deleted the rest area.
12017-11-05 04:03:32 UTCtonyf1 Deleted SEO spam. Business is not at this location.
12017-11-03 23:03:30 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your map contributions. Can you please tell me your information source. These new subdivisions don't seem to be on the satellite images and you don't seem to have used GPS traces. Also can you please use more descriptive changeset comments than 'M'.
12017-11-03 22:15:40 UTCtonyf1 All edits appear on the public map, deleted hostel named home.
12017-10-31 05:19:47 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I don't know if it is a town or a suburb but I suspect that this is a controversial change that may require consultation with the mapping community.
22017-10-31 07:02:58 UTCWarin61 Take a look at the Sydney relation:(5729534) .. that is a suburb.

If you want Parramatta as a city/town etc then maybe look at what has been done for Sydney as a city?

But I'd recommend contact on the Australian mailing list first.. talk-au@openstreetmap.org

In the mean time I have chan...
32017-11-02 06:05:17 UTCaharvey +1 with discussing this change.

I tried to document the current situation at
https://gist.github.com/andrewharvey/6c55bff57b96481528cc4da974e69e35

In summary, I'm okay with how it is currently, but still think we should distinguish certain suburbs as higher ranking (eg. Parramatta vs Harris ...
42017-11-02 07:05:42 UTCtonyf1 Interestingly, closer to home for me, Dandenong is a town - Node: Dandenong (67340420) and Node: Berwick (2166885522) is a suburb despite being further out. Both were towns before greater Melbourne absorbed them.
12017-11-02 05:18:39 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for the edits. Did you know that you can square up the corners of buildings in the ID editor using the right mouse button menu.
12017-11-01 23:15:36 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for mapping a highway rest area at Katherine Gorge Airport. Can you please describe this feature. Judging from the satellite image 'A rest area is place along a road, usually a motorway or dual-carriageway, where a driver can stop to have a rest. ' may not be the most accurate match.
12017-10-29 22:02:46 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have mapped an outdoor shop named Mount Bruce. This is an unlikely location for a shop. Mount Bruce is mapped 1km east. What are you wanting to map, a lookout perhaps?
22017-11-01 06:33:01 UTCtonyf1 Deleted shop, see Changeset #53414944
12017-10-28 03:36:49 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I think leisure=fitness_station is a better fit? See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure=fitness_centre. Also the name may be better deleted, its for proper names not descriptions see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only Thanks for your contributions
22017-10-28 08:06:25 UTCaharvey Just adding the link for fitness station https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure%3Dfitness_station
32017-10-31 05:06:15 UTCtonyf1 No reply. I made the changes, see Changeset #53384389
12017-10-28 23:27:46 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have tagged your business as a caravan park, "a place where people with caravans / motorhomes / recreational vehicles can stay overnight, or longer" https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism=caravan_site . Is this correct? Thanks.
22017-10-31 04:58:06 UTCtonyf1 No reply. Changed to a factory, product=campers. Changeset #53384268 From the satellite image and their website it doesn't look like a caravan park
12017-10-25 23:56:19 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your edit. This camp site appears to be a duplicate of one 40 metres away called Lake Benaroon. Is this correct?
22017-10-26 02:55:00 UTCSo Ber Yes it should be the same!
32017-10-27 07:34:43 UTCtonyf1 OK thanks. Sorry, I am deleting this campsite because it is a duplicate. Keep on mapping please.
12017-10-22 03:50:13 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. The Great Stupa of Universal Compassion is already mapped as a place of worship. What is your intention in mapping a tourist artwork in the same location?
22017-10-27 07:29:22 UTCtonyf1 No reply, deleting as duplicate
12017-10-20 05:32:10 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. You have added a post office, maybe you mean a barrier=toll_booth? Also I can't see it in the satellite photo, how do you know its there?

Salut. Bienvenue à OSM. Vous avez ajouté un bureau de poste, vous voulez peut-être dire une barrier = toll_booth? Aussi...
22017-10-21 06:35:12 UTCSpokester Hi, indeed it's a toll not a post office but I didn't find the proper category when I added it. I know it's there because I was there last week. It's one of the 2 entrances of the Kalbarri National Park.
32017-10-21 23:25:11 UTCtonyf1 OK thanks, see Changeset #53140323, I have changed it to a toll booth, I also deleted the name=Toll because the name tag is for proper names and Toll is a description, see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only. Thanks again for your valuable contributions!
42017-10-22 04:35:24 UTCSpokester Thanks a lot. I would have changed it myself but I didn't know how to do it. I used MAPS.ME to add it, maybe it's not possible from there. Do I have to remove the French name as well?
52017-10-22 04:36:20 UTCSpokester Oups just saw you already did it!
12017-10-21 04:18:44 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You might find http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dtrack and http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:access helpful here.
12017-10-14 02:39:36 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to Open Street Map. I am curious, you named the carpark Baba deda, despite it being associated with the golf club. Where does the name come from?
22017-10-16 01:29:30 UTCtonyf1 Ћао. Добродошли на мапу Опен Стреет. Радознао сам, назвао си аустралијски царпарк Баба деда, упркос томе што је повезан са голф клубом. Одакле долази име?
32017-10-21 00:13:17 UTCtonyf1 Hi. No reply received so I reverted with Changeset: 53116951
12017-10-09 05:29:45 UTCtonyf1 Hi, welcome to OSM.You may not be aware but your edits are live and visible to map users round the world. Your edits seem unlikely, please provide justification or reverse them. Thanks
22017-10-16 00:58:09 UTCtonyf1 I have deleted the historic castle named home and the florist in the empty field, I am less sure about the two fast food and leave them for those with local knowledge to decide.
12017-10-03 07:06:02 UTCtonyf1 Hi, welcome to OSM and thanks for your edit. You have tagged Beacon Hill lookout as a hunting stand, see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=hunting_stand for a definition, maybe its more of a tourism viewpoint? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism%3Dviewpoint
22017-10-09 05:16:10 UTCtonyf1 No reply, edited, see Changeset #52747197
12017-09-30 23:02:39 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I think bicycles=no means that it is not possible to take a bicycle on the ferry. https://www.rottnestexpress.com.au/luggage says that subject to dimensions they can for $15. The issue that you want to address is with the routing software and not the map.
22017-10-01 01:44:40 UTCAushiker Thanks for the explanation. I and others have taken the issue with the routing software developer so hopefully we can resolve it from their end.
32017-10-02 20:20:04 UTCaharvey Mind if I ask which routing software you're having the issue with?
42017-10-03 00:27:20 UTCAushiker Sure. It is Wahoo Fitness "Take me anywhere" feature which is part of their Android app for the Wahoo Elemnt [and Bolt] bicycle computer/GPS.
52017-10-09 05:06:42 UTCtonyf1 I removed bicycle=no in Changeset #52747057. I hope you are OK with that.
62017-10-10 05:03:11 UTCAushiker No worries. Thanks for fixing.
12017-10-01 00:42:07 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You accidentally dragged a node of the coast 4735608552. I restored it with Changeset #52524642
22017-10-01 01:46:08 UTCAushiker Thanks for the fix. Learning this editing process so any suggestions for a good beginner's guide most welcome. I plan to ride this area in a couple of months so hopefully will have a few tracks and the like to add to the map.
12017-10-01 00:12:14 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your OSM edit. You have left the changeset comment blank. It is important that your changeset comments give others sufficient information to understand your edits. Its good to include what you changed, why you changed it and your source of information. You have added 2 nodes, 51368228...
12017-09-30 23:56:42 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your OSM edits. You have described several changesets as 'fix the maps'. It is important that your changeset comments give others sufficient information to understand your edits. Its good to include what you changed, why you changed it and your source of information. Specifically abou...
12017-09-30 23:45:36 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your OSM edits. You have described several changesets as 'fix the maps'. It is important that your changeset comments give others sufficient information to understand your edits. Its good to include what you changed, why you changed it and your source of information. Specifically abou...
12017-09-30 23:37:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your OSM edits. You have described several changesets as 'fix the maps'. It is important that your changeset comments give others sufficient information to understand your edits. Its good to include what you changed, why you changed it and your source of information. Specifically abo...
12017-08-09 22:54:25 UTCtonyf1 change port of thevenard from landuse industrial to locality, its not land so not landuse, the map was showing water as land
22017-08-10 05:30:23 UTCtonyf1 (change = I changed)
12017-08-09 22:50:12 UTCtonyf1 changed port of portland from landuse industrial to locality, its not land so not landuse, it was making the map display water as land
12017-08-02 08:35:26 UTCtonyf1 Hola. Our driver was very sure that this was Isla Campana because it looks like a bell (campana). He pointed out an island a few km to the east or northeast and said it was pia pia. I am not sure exactly which one.
22017-08-05 16:31:31 UTC51114u9 \\o. yes, peak phia phia (not island) is more east of this point. this islands dont have official name, but people called by name of peak.

official name of this point (peak) is "cerro asalchi" but people can called with other name...

if you want, add this name of island, something b...
32017-08-06 00:22:39 UTCtonyf1 Thanks, I added the name Isla Campana.
12017-08-04 22:25:42 UTCtonyf1 Shane, please only add real features.
Deleting, not evident on aerial pic.
12017-08-04 03:44:49 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Renaming. The Dakar Monument is 200m east, this building (68775453, v6) is the hotel de sal, much older.
12017-08-04 03:22:30 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I am deleting this. This is not the tourism attraction, the pueblo fantasma of San Antonio is 10 km south.
12017-06-06 05:25:11 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Your edits to the map are encouraged. A lot of people depend on the map so please only add real things.
22017-06-06 09:22:29 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 49299541 where the changeset comment is: Revert buggy vandalism
32017-09-20 11:41:42 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 52208464 where the changeset comment is: Revert all Itzscallywagyt changesets that had not be reverted already. See https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1482
12017-06-05 05:25:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi. What is your source of information for these ferry routes? A web search of Sealink doesn't find them.
22017-06-05 06:05:39 UTCtonyf1 I have reverted these changes
32017-06-06 09:22:28 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 49299541 where the changeset comment is: Revert buggy vandalism
42017-09-20 11:41:43 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 52208464 where the changeset comment is: Revert all Itzscallywagyt changesets that had not be reverted already. See https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1482
12017-06-05 05:41:37 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You appear to have created a fictitious town Austina in the Sudan desert. OSM is not the place for imaginary places.
22017-06-06 09:22:29 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 49299541 where the changeset comment is: Revert buggy vandalism
32017-09-20 11:41:40 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 52208464 where the changeset comment is: Revert all Itzscallywagyt changesets that had not be reverted already. See https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1482
12017-06-03 07:43:41 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have made slight changes to the marine boundary west of Coffin Bay. Is this correct? What is your data source?
22017-06-04 02:54:18 UTCtonyf1 No reply to comment. Reverting.
32017-06-06 09:22:30 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 49299541 where the changeset comment is: Revert buggy vandalism
42017-09-20 11:41:43 UTCwoodpeck_repair This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 52208464 where the changeset comment is: Revert all Itzscallywagyt changesets that had not be reverted already. See https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1482
12017-06-03 07:17:09 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I don't think you will get the changes to the map that you want. My suggestion: if there is a gate then add a node barrier=gate with the access tag set to private, if it is a private road then tag the appropriate length of road with access=private
12017-06-02 22:42:08 UTCtonyf1 Hi. When you converted the shop Interiorwise from a node to an area you lost the tags giving the street address
12017-05-30 06:39:13 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have deleted some features. It looks suspicious but I am not familiar with Sydney so its hard to know. Can you please give information on why these features were deleted. Thanks.
22017-06-16 12:18:48 UTCaharvey Removing http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/9922132/history was probably good since it's also mapped https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/499234807.

But without justification for removing all those POIs and no response here in 17 days, I'm going to revert this. If there features really aren't there an...
32017-06-18 23:38:34 UTCchris_o Hi guys, very sorry for the lack of response. I was not aware that removing nodes would affect map for everyone - as I thought it would just change my "instance" of the map.

I initially removed the nodes as I was trying to make a "clean" looking map for a project I was working...
42017-06-19 00:20:53 UTCaharvey That's okay, at least now you know. I've already fixed up the deletions.
12017-05-30 05:11:13 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I see you have been converting buildings from node to area. This is very useful. Thanks. Unfortunately you don't seem to be carrying across all the information, address, wifi, website, for example Gosford RSL.
12017-05-28 22:59:00 UTCtonyf1 Hi. It appears you accidentally dragged a node of Mark Place. I have fixed it.
22017-05-29 22:40:56 UTCWarin61 Way 496461665 - wood crosses itself ... this is not good. Ways forming areas should have a clear inner and outer .. when they cross it becomes difficult to determine which bits are inner and outer.
Suggest you 'fix it' so you learn what to do?

Use http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&...
32017-06-07 23:11:25 UTCWarin61 I see you have not fixed this.

So i did it myself.

Several things that .. the wood used

nodes on a street -- the wood does not extent this far - they should be separate nodes off the street/footpath!.
The wood includes several swimming pools, backyards...

Deleted. If you want that l...
12017-05-27 12:34:47 UTCtonyf1 Hi
You have tagged https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/496262536 as heath. It looks like lawn and car park to me.
22017-05-28 07:05:08 UTCtonyf1 No reply to my comment. Changing natural=heath to landuse=commercial
12017-05-28 03:39:24 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for your contributions. You have mapped a park where, according to the satellite images, none exists. Is there a park here or is it a lookout or is it a named locality or what?
22017-05-28 04:08:15 UTCAJThompson Many things I've marked on the map today don't appear in satellite images. As for whether this area is a park, it depends on your definition. It is a flat dirt area that acts as a trail hub for mountain bikers. It has seats and trees, and I guess that makes it a park. It is funded by the local and s...
32017-05-28 05:32:21 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Thanks for the prompt reply and your contributions. It is important to get things right and have the most accurate tagging. OSM is a database used by many maps so this goes beyond getting a good result on the map at openstreetmap.org. Its not good practice to use the wrong tag as a "marker&...
12017-05-21 06:27:38 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. Thankyou for your contributions. Unfortunately you have dragged nodes by mistake in a couple of places damaging the Gosford station footbridge and the boundary of the commercial area immediately to the east. You need to be especially careful when editing high density urban areas ...
22017-05-22 07:27:27 UTCtonyf1 Fixed
12017-05-11 22:14:05 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I am surprised that there is really a Reserved forest and a standing stone here. Can you provide more information? Map features which are unverifiable are at risk of deletion.
22017-05-11 22:57:43 UTCAnnabelle Daniel Hi Tony,

The standing stone is there because I put it there with a crane. It's at the very end of my backyard. The triangular forest is fenced off, quarantined as Sydney Rail corridor property and filled with native vegetation. There is significant local wildlife living there, including bird and ...
32017-05-13 00:22:04 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for the reply. I think that there are problems with the Reserved forest. You have mapped it as a complex re-entrant polygon. The map rendering software has difficulty rendering this and shows a sliver of green little bigger than a car. Also, I think "Reserved forest" is a descriptio...
42017-05-13 05:51:48 UTCAnnabelle Daniel Thanks! I'll try and fix it as it is larger than a car - but oddly shaped. Like a wedge with a blunt end.
52017-05-13 07:14:51 UTCWarin61 The landuse tag is for the human use of the land, so a forest would be used to produce wood for example ... I think you want to tag it natural=wood ... (as close as OSM gets to landcover=trees).
If you want to add 'information' to the feature .. then possibly use comment=reserved forest ... and I'...
12017-04-24 08:37:45 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You appear to be mapping the underground stormwater drainage system. Maybe they would be best tagged as man_made=pipeline rather than waterway=drain considering that they are underground. See http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:waterway%3Ddrain
22017-05-11 07:05:40 UTCtonyf1 Hi, you quote Source: Hurstville City Council Drain Map. Is this your source for all these drains? Is its licence compatible with OSM?
32017-05-11 11:16:37 UTCaharvey @Spookylad, it doesn't seem the license of your source is compatible. Unless you can point us to further details about the license, could you please revert these changes and instead add data from ground survey or other sources which can be used in OSM.
42017-05-12 06:48:25 UTCSpookylad Sorry I didn't have much time to review and finish the details. I removed the non park drainways, and I will continue to map Empress Park correctly. The drainways from the park are a mixture of Tunneled and underground/hidden. How do I go about tagging each of those aspects appropriately? I can take...
52017-05-13 00:08:30 UTCtonyf1 Thanks for your reply.

You should delete anything that is not compatible with OSM's licence conditions.

Reading the wiki, I don't think that drain or culvert are the right tag. man_made=pipeline location=underground substance=water seems the best fit but I haven't seen what's on the ground.\...
12017-05-05 05:58:30 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have created a tourism attraction named Snorkeling. What is special about this particular location? Is this a known and named dive site or just one location of many in the Whitsundays where you can dive?
22017-05-10 06:55:52 UTCtonyf1 No reply to my comment. Deleting.
12017-05-10 06:13:08 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Definitely not highway=services that's for a fuel stop on a highway. It looks like a terrace house. Your website has a PO box but no address. Is there anything physically at this address which deserves to be on the map?
12017-05-10 05:56:29 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Its definitely not a historic castle. Deleting.
12017-05-07 23:36:45 UTCtonyf1 Etiqueta equivocada? ver http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway=emergency%20access%20point?uselang=en-US

Wrong tag? see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway=emergency%20access%20point?uselang=en-US
22017-05-08 16:17:36 UTC51114u9 @tonyf1 no, Norman wants to map the entrance door to the emergency room, because many people can confuse where it is attended ... at the front door (6 august avenue) or on the service street

@norman dibujé el edificio posterior a la torre del hospital, seguro está mal o falta, si fu...
12017-05-06 07:29:08 UTCtonyf1 ¿Hay realmente un cajero automático aquí?
Is there really a ATM here?
12017-04-29 01:24:17 UTCtonyf1 Bienvenido a OSM
¿Que desea eliminar la calle Padre Ricardo Ermesino del mapa?
Si no highway=residential quizás highway=unclassified o highway=track
Ver http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Key:highway

Welcome to OSM
Did you mean to delete the street Padre Ricardo Ermesino from...
22017-05-05 06:01:26 UTCtonyf1 Restoring highway=residential
12017-05-05 05:54:51 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You have placed a tourism attraction here. What is special about this particular location within the Villa Borghese?
12017-04-30 01:49:44 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I doubt there is a historic monument in the middle of the bridge named "Beautiful bridge. Possibly delete the monument and tag the bridge historic = yes and/or tourism=attraction, and/or tourism=viewpoint
22017-05-04 01:57:42 UTCtonyf1 No reply to changeset comment. Deleting monument and tagging bridge with tourism=attraction
12017-04-29 23:44:05 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. The new bar and a tree were mapped as the same node. I created a new node for the bar on the south side of Argyle St.
12017-04-29 23:14:41 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to Open Street Map. You appear to have created a camp ground in a suburban front yard. You may not know but your edits appear on public maps. I'll delete it, I am assuming its a mistake.
12017-04-28 23:58:48 UTCtonyf1 Reverted by SomeoneElse_Revert . See https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1331
12017-04-28 05:47:54 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I note you are using tunnel=culvert. See http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:tunnel where it says "For a structure that carries water or another liquid some considerable distance then it may be more appropriate to tag it as a pipeline using man_made=pipeline"
12017-04-26 07:37:03 UTCtonyf1 Are you sure there is a shop here? There's nothing in the sat photo.
22017-04-27 00:32:51 UTCCloCkWeRX I think its http://winetasmania.com.au/east_coast_wine_route/listing/devils_corner_cellar_door_lookout
32017-04-27 07:13:33 UTCtonyf1 Thanks. Then I suspect the correct placement is 1km south, near viewpoint #2283984229 and "Corner Tasman Highway and Sherbourne Road"
12017-04-26 06:27:52 UTCtonyf1 I see you have added tunnel=yes to one of the underground stormwater drains. The wiki http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:waterway%3Ddrain says: "Use man_made=pipeline where water, or other materials are carried underground or on the surface in pipes."
12017-04-25 11:05:15 UTCtonyf1 Deleted. Please reply to changeset comments. I don't think that your shop which has no physical presence is suitable for tagging on OSM. If you still disagree please discuss with a changeset comment or on the talk_au list.
12017-04-25 10:46:08 UTCtonyf1 Nothing visible, deleting.
12017-04-25 01:38:53 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. It looks like you are adding things that don't exist to get Pokemon spawns. Please only add real features.
12017-04-25 01:36:39 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. It looks like you are adding things that don't exist to get Pokemon spawns. Please only add real features.
12017-04-23 22:51:45 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM
Dam is the wall, the water behind is reservoir or pond. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:waterway=dam
12017-04-23 05:50:42 UTCtonyf1 maybe internet_access=wlan
22017-04-23 06:32:03 UTCtonyf1 and internet_access:operator=Brisbane City Council
32017-04-23 06:35:29 UTCIan TF Thanks Tonyf1, this is my first interaction with Open Street Maps so am feeling my way. I will have a go at changing the naming to what you suggest.
42017-04-23 06:45:05 UTCtonyf1 Hi Ian. Welcome to OSM. Good to see you mapping. Its always worth searching wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki when unsure how to tag and you can always get help on https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au Keep up your good work.
52017-04-23 06:55:01 UTCIan TF Thanks, I have also tried to relocate the off leash dog area in Kalinga to the new location. I think I have messed it up a bit as the insertion does not look like other entries. I am guessing you may be part of the local community in Brisbane. Therefore you may know David Dean. David is going t...
62017-04-23 07:35:41 UTCtonyf1 No I'm Melbourne. I presume the off leash area you created is Way: 488792552 . It doesnt have any tags and wont show on any map. I dont know how best to tag it, I would have to look at the wiki. The one you deleted a day ago was tagged barrier=fence and leisure=dog_park
12017-04-23 06:21:29 UTCtonyf1 I am deleting this node because it does not represent anything on the ground. There are plenty of Whitsunday features which can be tagged tourism attractions if they are not already.
12017-04-22 02:47:45 UTCtonyf1 This is a duplicate of Way: Sydney Opera House (4960757)
Deleting.
12017-04-21 07:47:12 UTCtonyf1 Hi, you may well be right but Google Maps is not an allowable source because of copyright. Can you provide alternate evidence like a photo of a street sign?
12017-04-21 07:39:40 UTCtonyf1 Hi, you may well be right but Google Maps is not an allowable source because of copyright. Can you provide alternate evidence like a photo of a street sign?
22017-04-21 08:03:15 UTCmapovis Hi Tonyf1,

Here is a link to a master plan for a development which is being built on this road. It shows the correct names for the surrounding roads and confirms that the data in OpenStreetMaps was incorrect.

LINK: https://we.tl/hjjtk3HTAd
12017-04-21 05:02:29 UTCtonyf1 "building = yes" no "building=Si" o mejor "building=school"
ver: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ES:Key:building
12017-04-20 23:52:58 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. You appear to have deleted a quarry that shows in the satellite image and added a quadrilateral that will not show on any map. Please document your changes with a comment to explain what you have done and why.
22017-04-21 03:09:00 UTCtonyf1 Changeset reverted
12017-04-20 23:46:30 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. Your changeset comment was "Jeebropily". It would be better if your comment explained what you changed and why.
12017-04-19 04:37:29 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image, please only map real features
12017-04-19 04:26:26 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image, please only map real features
12017-04-18 07:49:40 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You appear to be creating paths that are not in the satellite images. Please only add things that are really there. If you have some source for your edit its good to mention it in your changeset comment.
22017-04-19 03:47:22 UTCtonyf1 I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image.
12017-04-19 03:38:08 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image, please only map real features
12017-04-19 03:36:03 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image, please only map real features
12017-04-19 03:12:40 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to OSM. I have deleted a path which is not on the satellite image, please only map real features.
12017-04-15 22:38:10 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I deleted footpaths that did not appear in the satellite image. They looked like they had been added for Pokemon Go spawns. My apologies if they were real.
12017-04-14 08:21:32 UTCtonyf1 Hi. I deleted multiple grassland wedges and non existent tree lines. If you want help editing you can ask on the mailing list https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
12017-04-13 22:23:48 UTCtonyf1 Hi. Welcome to Open Street Map. Please add features that actually exist, your contributions are welcome. But please do not add Pokemon Go features which do not exist.
12017-04-12 06:49:47 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You are editing a public map. It is important that additions are accurate. Your continued contributions are welcome if they accurately reflect what is on the ground but I will delete the historic castle named My House.
12017-04-11 06:30:57 UTCtonyf1 Added shop=car_repair so that now the business appears on the map. Reduced description text to objectively verifiable facts.
12017-04-08 08:05:17 UTCtonyf1 Hi Addison, you say "somehow they disappeared". They were deleted by a very experienced user, presumably because he thought the names weren't verifiable see https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/47528007
12017-04-08 06:44:36 UTCtonyf1 Hi Addison. Welcome to Open Street Map and thanks for your contributions. I am however a bit doubtful as to whether some of the names belong on a public map. The names should be verifiable, that is other people would know these features by the same name, see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Verifi...
12017-04-03 02:37:48 UTCtonyf1 Hi
You continue to add features which do not seem to exist. Maybe you are not aware you are editing a public map? Please reply to this comment as well as one two weeks ago.
Thanks
22017-04-03 05:02:21 UTCCloCkWeRX I removed this.
12017-03-28 06:10:54 UTCtonyf1 Hi
You are welcome to add your shop to OSM if you have one, but OSM is for real objects on the ground and not suited for virtual data like PO box and websites. Also changeset comments are important, not for product promotion. Please give reasons why your map edit should remain.
12017-03-27 07:26:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi
Welcome to Open Street map. You have made map edits near Gosford. Its unclear to me what you were intending. If you need help just ask.
Tony
12017-03-26 22:45:23 UTCtonyf1 Hi. You seem to have created a duplicate to Way: 91850128 but of lesser detail. Any reason for the edit?
12017-03-26 06:49:51 UTCtonyf1 Hi cebby. Welcome to Open Street Map. Lots of people depend on the map. It looks like you have added stuff that's not there, maybe for Pokemon Go. Am I right? Please keep contributing, but only real things
12017-03-26 06:48:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi cebby. Welcome to Open Street Map. Lots of people depend on the map. It looks like you have added stuff that's not there, maybe for Pokemon Go. Am I right? Please keep contributing, but only real things
12017-03-01 22:58:48 UTCtonyf1 Hi, thanks for your recent edits and detailed changeset descriptions. I note that you changed the access tag for Ant Track and added some new bike tracks. You may not be aware that these tracks are illegal and Parks can prosecute users. I think it is better if they are tagged access=no. As a guide, ...
22017-03-01 23:28:24 UTCpaul1928 Hey Tony. Thanks for the feedback and link to the in-depth discussion. I'll go through and change access=no for all the illegal tracks I've recently added. Your right, Parks have clearly sign-posted (although they tend not to last for long) a number of these tracks as illegal and have general inform...
12017-01-18 07:41:01 UTCtonyf1 Hi Rory, mapping of airspace is contrary to OSM policy, http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Aviation#Things_Not_to_Map
tonyf1 has contributed to 132 changeset discussions(s) with a total of 238 comment(s)