Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-05-13 17:33:36 UTChoppyhop This edit has deleted the correct location of Grotta Pitagora added in 4161852398.
Did you visit this location to confirm this?
12017-03-28 11:57:00 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 11:53:53 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 11:53:40 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 11:53:04 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 11:52:44 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 11:50:00 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
22017-03-28 11:51:14 UTCDavide_sd Please, DO NOT USE Google Map or other map services to bring data into OpenStreetMap, you are violating their term of service and there is absolutely no proof that what you are mapping is correct. SP11, SP1 indicates the the road network, not the name. Clearly you added this after looking at other m...
12017-03-28 11:45:59 UTCDavide_sd I'm sure you have read the documentation about service=driveway (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Ddriveway) where it's stated that such a way is to be used with access=* tag appropriately.

It is my understanding that it is impossible to say if a road have access private, permissiv...
12017-03-28 09:33:57 UTCagnostico Hello,
as stated in the other changeset, the correct name here is "Via Trecenta" and not "Via Trecenta - SP11".
There's no evidence that the road is a part of the SP11 network.
Please correct accordingly.
22017-03-28 10:29:03 UTCDavide_sd Please, DO NOT USE Google Map or other map services to bring data into OpenStreetMap, you are violating their term of service and there is absolutely no proof that what you are mapping is correct.

SP11 indicates the the road network, not the name. Clearly you added this after looking at other map...
12017-03-28 09:35:40 UTCagnostico Hello,
The correct name here is "Via Magherino" without the "- SP11"
There's no evidence that the road is a part of the SP11 network.
Please correct accordingly.
22017-03-28 10:28:36 UTCDavide_sd Please, DO NOT USE Google Map or other map services to bring data into OpenStreetMap, you are violating their term of service and there is absolutely no proof that what you are mapping is correct.

SP11 indicates the the road network, not the name. Clearly you added this after looking at other map...
12017-03-28 10:07:25 UTCDavide_sd You are moving the geometry accordingly to the new Bing imagery: this imagery is affected by an offset of several meters in respect to real world. This introduce a consistent error in the map, making it unreliable. You are not allowed to move correctly-placed-geometry based on this imagery!!!!!

Y...
12017-03-28 09:56:47 UTCDavide_sd I wonder why you changed the name. "Parco regionale dei Colli Euganei" was the correct name, why did you changed that???? What are your intention with this edit????
12017-03-28 09:32:44 UTCagnostico Hello,
The correct name here is "Via Trecenta" and not "Via Trecenta - SP11".
There's no evidence that the road is a part of the SP11 network.
Please correct accordingly.
22017-03-28 09:54:03 UTCDavide_sd Please, DO NOT USE Google Map or other map services to bring data into OpenStreetMap, you are violating their term of service and there is absolutely no proof that what you are mapping is correct.

SP11 indicates the the road network, not the name. Clearly you added this after looking at other map...
12017-03-28 08:51:12 UTCAle_Zena_IT Please, do write a more descriptive comment in your changesets.
In the last 15 days you did 554 changeset, all with the 'trace' comment.
Comment are very useful to the people who monitor activities.

Moreover, many people in Italy is worried about your massive edit; consider to be more collabora...
12017-03-28 06:06:58 UTCfrancoLI il Parco dell'Etna non è un parco nazionale, ma è un Parco Naturale Regionale in Italia vi sta differenza.
difatti è codice tag 4.
per favore se non sapete quello che fatenon toccate
12017-03-28 05:57:24 UTCfrancoLI l'area SIC non è una riserva difatti il tag code è 97,
scrivere riserva porta in confusione, le aree SIC fanno parte di Natura2000 che è una legislazione europea

le riserve sono codificate tag da 1 a 6
12017-03-26 06:21:44 UTCdgitto all deletions and no comment.
12017-03-26 06:00:40 UTCdgitto OK but please consider to add meaningful comments to changeset now
12017-03-21 17:11:50 UTCfrancoLI L'area dei crateri sommitali geograficamente si chiama 'Mongibello Recente' mentre l'area sommitale in OSM è un'area burocratica ovvero quella di rischio di pericolo vulcanico ordinario, e pertanto l'accesso in tale area viene regolamentato
22017-03-25 05:33:33 UTCselect the name in OSM is the "common name". common name means the name tupically used by the general public in everyday life. I have not written "Area Sommitale", so the "common name" of that area is "crateri sommitali"? for sure it is NOT "mongibello recente&q...
32017-03-25 05:45:21 UTCselect the field "Common name" means the name normally known by the general public in everyday life. it cannot be used to publish announcements or recent event. for official bureaucratic names use the tag "official_name"
42017-03-25 11:48:14 UTCfrancoLI 'Mongibello' è il vero nome proprio dell'Etna caduto in disuso per motivi storici-politico
Ad oggi con il termine 'Mongibello' si intente solo la vetta, ma l'Etna è un vulcano quindi la vetta è plastica, cambia forma secondo l'attività vulcanica. quindi abbiamo Mongibell...
52017-03-25 22:51:49 UTCselect mongibello is not the "common name" used by the general public in everyday life to call the volcano etna, so it cannot be used in OSM under the tag "name" , meaning common name, because it is a falsity and decieving
12017-03-21 16:31:02 UTCConstable what's your source? where did you find that name "Demanio Forestale della Giarrita" ?
22017-03-25 05:38:41 UTCselect i did not write demanio forestale
32017-03-25 11:23:49 UTCConstable I know what you did, you replaced "Demanio Forestale della Cerrita" with "Demanio Forestale della Giarrita" and I want to know what's your source for this name change!
What made you think "Ceritta" had to be replaced with "Giarrita"?
Do you live in the area?...
42017-03-25 12:07:55 UTCfrancoLI Giarrita o Cerrita è lo stesso toponimo ma con due grafie. Deriva dal nome del Quercus Cerris. ed è lo stesso bosco assieme alla Cubania. Solamente che chiamiamo Cubania quello che ricade nel Comune di Milo, e Giarrita o Cerrita quella parte del bosco che ricade nel Comune di S.Alfio...
52017-03-25 12:12:57 UTCfrancoLI la Sic o la ZPS/SIC non è una Riserva Naturale difatti il codice tag è il 97
12017-03-25 11:52:35 UTCConstable We kindly asked you quite few times to use proper changeset comments, why do you keep ignoring us?
12017-03-22 11:09:13 UTCConstable sir, please start using proper changeset comments http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
22017-03-22 12:18:40 UTCdieterdreist I can second this. It is really difficult to navigate through your changesets, because you make a lot of them and do not comment any with something meaningful.
32017-03-25 05:25:46 UTCselect these are minor corrections
42017-03-25 11:20:38 UTCConstable Cool, why didn't you write "minor corrections" in the changeset comments box then?
52017-03-25 11:25:51 UTCdieterdreist actually, minor corrections is not much more helpful than "traces" (although a little more true). If you delete stuff it would be good to state why it was deleted (e.g. superfluous nodes, feature ceased to exist, etc.)
12017-03-22 12:42:30 UTCConstable Please start using proper changeset comments http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Trace means nothing!
22017-03-25 05:25:02 UTCselect if you know the place, make the changes yourself
32017-03-25 11:17:25 UTCConstable As a community member you should realize by yourself that sooner or later you'll have to interact with other mappers and right now your attitude (and lack of uselfull changeset comments) are making this interaction quite impossible.
Why do you attack me as you did? I said "start using proper c...
12017-03-25 08:20:37 UTCSomeoneElse Hello select,
Thanks for replying to some of the comments at http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=3042095 . However, all of your changeset comments seem to be just "trace". This isn't helpful to other mappers. Please read https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_cha...
12017-03-21 10:59:53 UTCConstable sir, would you be so kind to start using proper changeset comments?
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
12017-03-20 16:35:47 UTCfrancoLI dopo quello che è successo sull'Etna in questi giorni, non ti sembra che se non conosci i luoghi, di lasciar stare?
12017-03-18 06:43:00 UTCdgitto I wonder how one is able to shift the position of a cave entrance, in chairmapping.
12017-03-14 13:58:06 UTCdgitto Bitte ändern Sie nicht die Namen der Polizeibeamten. Sie stehen im Einklang in der Provinz von Messina
12017-03-11 16:23:51 UTCdgitto again you deleted all info of the townhall: email, website, telephone number
12017-03-11 09:00:15 UTCdgitto please, why do you delete the name? is it a wrong name?
12017-03-11 05:04:14 UTCdgitto you have deleted all info for townhall, names (cinema and a residential building)
12017-03-09 05:05:19 UTCdgitto is not in use as place of worship
12017-03-04 06:28:34 UTCdgitto Ciao, chiamare la scuola media soltanto "scuola secondaria" purtroppo non va bene, perché abbiamo la secondaria di primo grado e la secondaria di secondo grado (le scuole superiori)
22017-03-04 06:29:28 UTCdgitto Poi tutte le scuole medie della provincia di Messina hanno tutte denominazione standard, coerente con tutte le altre
32017-03-04 06:30:40 UTCdgitto Ah già qua siamo in provincia di Catania!
42017-03-04 06:31:12 UTCdgitto ops mi sto confondendo, no
12017-02-22 21:42:19 UTCdgitto As I told you a couple of days ago... pay attention: the Bing aerial imagery in Santa teresa di Riva is totally distorted (near the beach). do not use it
12017-02-21 05:45:16 UTCdgitto Ciao, secondo me non serve a molto tracciare edifici così grossolanamente. Devono solo essere cancellati e rifatti.
12017-02-14 17:53:53 UTCdgitto Ciao, l'ortofoto di bing a santa teresa ha un difetto. Il lungomare è praticamente dritto, non c'è quel rigonfiamento della linea di costa. L'avevo allineato col CTR 1:2000
12017-02-13 18:16:18 UTCdgitto Ciao, il municipio l'avevo già piazzato (via provinciale). è davvero là invece?
12017-01-24 06:43:37 UTCdgitto you removed the name tag from the hotel. If you mean that the hotel is only located into the building then we have to move on the building also all the other tags (tourism=hotel and contacts)
12017-01-13 15:33:44 UTCdgitto Anche il Fermento Pub è amenity=bar?
12017-01-13 15:29:29 UTCdgitto hai ragione
12017-01-01 08:46:12 UTCConstable Hi Sir, could you be so kind to use more detailed changeset comments than just "trace"? It'd make other mappers job a little bit easier.
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Thanks, have a nice 2017!
Cheers
12016-12-31 04:52:49 UTCdgitto Ciao, buone feste. L'atahotel Naxos beach resort hotel si estende per tutta l'area su cui hai messo il tag tourism=hotel?
Se è così, dovremmo mettere il nome (e tutti i dati di contatto ecc) su quest'area.
Altrimenti così vedo un hotel senza nome e un palazzo che si chiama &qu...
12016-12-13 12:38:43 UTCdgitto Is it ok? why building=university?
and why now there is a museum without name and a name="museum..." without museum tag?
12016-12-13 06:00:03 UTCdgitto Ciao. La SP 21 esiste già e va da Romissa a San Biagio. Dove hai visto che il tratto da Rina a Savoca è una provinciale?
12016-12-13 05:47:41 UTCdgitto L'ufficio postale è duplicato. E non mi sembra che occupi l'intero edificio. Per questo è reso come nodo.
(stessa cosa varrebbe per il bar)
12015-12-27 16:46:20 UTCArlas Solo nodi cancellati senza motivo
22016-01-03 11:17:32 UTCwoodpeck Dear user "select", could you please explain why you deleted these nodes? Are you the same person as "gnuckx"?
32016-01-05 12:40:09 UTCgnuckx which nodes exactly?
42016-01-05 16:45:45 UTCwoodpeck There were 93 nodes deleted in this changeset and the comment given - "trace" - is insufficient to explain. Data Working Group has received a complaint about this and other deletions performed by you and user "select", and we're considering to revert all your edits made with mean...
52016-01-05 16:52:29 UTCgnuckx the garbage dumpers in the city are illegal as of eu law and they are being removed by the catania city hall by implementing a door to door garbage collect system. moreover it is totally disproportionate to put 5 6 or 7 dumpers in the collecting same point for every single dumper in OSM. it is total...
62016-01-05 18:27:51 UTCArlas 1) "overbloating" is not this case where object are mapped by people that follows osm wiki rules
2) openstreetmap is not a simple "map" of things that you wish in and wish not. It's a more complex geodatabase. If someone puts data inside, that's useful data. Moreover if someone ...
72016-01-06 00:43:46 UTCwoodpeck gnuckx, you have used the changeset comment "trace" instead of, what now seems more appropriate, "deleting garbage dumpers because they will be removed". Why? Also, in this changeset you deleted other things for example http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2431432250 - why? -- As a ...
12015-12-27 16:59:03 UTCArlas Hai solo cancellato fermate e cassonetti, perché?
22016-01-02 22:26:31 UTCgnuckx i do not delete bus stops. i delete the OSM shelter symbol that are generally refered to outdoor refuges. city bus stops are not shelters just because it might have a tiny ceiling.
32016-01-03 10:02:12 UTCArlas Sì, c'erano fermate cancellate. E ogni shelter a catania ha un numero di referenza che è stato mappato con "fatica". Quanto meno potevi inserirlo nella fermata su di una nota.
42016-01-03 10:26:33 UTCArlas Example Bus stop deleted:
changeset: 35416066 http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/35416066
node: 297990913
http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/297990913

No reason to delete it. User cannot be trusted on deletions.
52016-01-03 10:30:51 UTCArlas in this edit:
node: 295436053
bus stop via etnea (!!)

Please stop deleting things.
62016-01-05 12:38:42 UTCgnuckx tecnically and architectonically they are not shelter. they are city bus stops. whether bus stops are numbered or not is irrelevant. they are not shelters in any way whatsoever.
72016-01-05 13:04:47 UTCArlas in this and other changesets you've deleted bus stops entirely, not shelters.
12015-12-27 17:10:24 UTCArlas Hanno tolto tutti i cassonetti di Catania? Non mi sembra
22016-01-02 22:38:46 UTCgnuckx it is legally required by law to remove the garbage cages, and remove deferenciated garbage door to door. city hall has started in 2015 and in 2016 must cover the whole city. to fill OSM with garbage cages all over the map creates a bloating effect that degrades the clarity and quality of OSM maps.
32016-01-03 10:12:46 UTCArlas You need to map what actually IS there. I checked and many of your deletions aren't true, so cannot be trusted.
42016-01-03 14:16:10 UTCArlas I've made photos of this area. Garbage cans are STILL here, thelephones are STILL here. You are deleting things for months! see http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/30578497
12015-12-27 17:09:30 UTCArlas tra tutte le cose cancellate che ancora esistono come faccio a fidarmi che questo telefono non ci sia più?
22016-01-02 22:30:53 UTCgnuckx most if not all street phones are non functioning since all the people already have cell phones. non emergency city street phones are outdated, unreliable since they are no longer properly maintained, and only bloats the map. phone symbol con be maintained for emergency highway phones, no longer for...
32016-01-03 10:08:21 UTCArlas I cannot (and don't) trust (because of all your deletions) that you actually did go there and checked the existence of that phone.
12015-12-27 16:40:25 UTCArlas perché hai semplicemente cancellato dati inseriti con tanta fatica?
22016-01-02 22:20:29 UTCgnuckx perche con la raccolta porta a porta e differenziata spariscono i cassonetti .. e l'immensa quantitta' di cassonetti redundanti crea l'efetto bloating della mappa che degrada la qualita' e l'utilita'
32016-01-03 10:04:26 UTCArlas Fermo restando la regola principale:
1) non si mappa per il rendering della mappa di osm
2) osm è un geodatabase e non una "mappa" di quello che vuoi vedere o non vedere

la qualità della mappa viene degradata dalle tue cancellature. Per mappare tutti quei cassonetti qual...
12015-12-10 21:56:35 UTCMatthewFazio Si chiamano salinelle dello stadio. è un sic
22016-01-02 22:17:53 UTCgnuckx ok
32016-01-02 22:43:46 UTCMatthewFazio Nel frattempo sono diventate Geosito di interesse mondiale!
42016-01-02 22:44:57 UTCgnuckx e discarica di inmondizia :-D :-D :-D
52016-01-02 22:46:56 UTCgnuckx http://www.etnanatura.it/sentieri/cittagarbage.php?citta=Paterno
12015-12-27 17:07:43 UTCArlas Ci sono solo cancellazioni. Perché?
12015-12-27 17:04:00 UTCArlas Hai cancellato cassonetti e fermate bus, perché?
12015-12-27 17:02:50 UTCArlas Hai cancellato tutti i cassonetti. Perché?
12015-12-27 16:51:13 UTCArlas Hai cancellato tutti i cassonetti inseriti. Perché?
12015-12-27 16:49:31 UTCArlas Perché cancelli solo dati?
12015-12-27 16:44:28 UTCArlas Solo nodi cancellati. Senza motivo
12015-12-27 16:43:45 UTCArlas solo nodi cancellati. Perché?
12015-12-27 16:41:27 UTCArlas solo nodi cancellati senza motivo?
12015-08-20 13:58:31 UTCMatthewFazio alpine hut significa rifugio, per rifugio si intende un luogo dove si può pernottare e mangiare (pagando), perché non pubblico, ma privato (essenzialmente un hotel di montagna). Sei mai andato al Timpa Rossa?
12015-08-20 13:39:28 UTCMatthewFazio Cose che un bivacco, ti fa pensare sia un rifugio??? Sei gentilmente pregato di rispondere.
12015-08-20 13:38:10 UTCMatthewFazio Mancano i changeset
12015-08-20 12:40:50 UTCemacsen This changeset is a bit strange. What is the source of this data?

It's not Bing, as indicated, because there's no way to know some of the information that's on the object, just from Bing.

In addition, the changeset comment does not explain the change at all.
12015-08-20 00:07:51 UTCMatthewFazio http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism%3Dwilderness_hut
22015-08-20 12:37:28 UTCemacsen It is not possible that Bing imagery has the name of this cave entrance, so where are you getting it from?
32015-08-20 12:38:13 UTCemacsen sorry I was looking at the wrong changeset here
12015-08-20 00:54:54 UTCMatthewFazio Ciao gnuckx, se continuassi a fare così, rischi il ban anche qui. Considera che si può arrivare anche ad il ban geografico. Esistono delle regole, rispettale!
12015-08-20 00:47:16 UTCMatthewFazio Mi dispiace correggerti pure grammaticalmente, ma si chiama bosco cubanìa e non cubania....
22015-08-20 00:47:49 UTCMatthewFazio Quando si va a tracciare, bisogna almeno sapere di cosa si stia parlando, almeno leggendo un po...
12015-08-20 00:24:36 UTCMatthewFazio Non si mette l'elevazione nel nome. Esiste il tag apposito. Facendo parte di una comunità si è OBBLIGATI a leggerne il regolamento, accettarlo e rispettarlo.
12015-08-20 00:02:47 UTCMatthewFazio Perché hai cancellato questi nodi???
12015-08-20 00:00:06 UTCMatthewFazio Ciao, mi spieghi come mai un bivacco lo hai fatto diventare un rifugio??? Ci sono delle regole ben precise. Prima di cominciare a modificare è buona norma chiedere a chi ha modificato prima di te, ma soprattutto leggere le regole. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism%3Dwilderness_hu...
69 changeset(s) created by select have been discussed with a total of 116 comment(s)