45 Changesets created by Mashin have been discussed with 32 replies of this OpenStreetMap Contributor
Changeset # ⏱️ Last updated Contributor Comment
191253136
by Mashin
@ 2026-10-30 19:44
~ 15 days ago
1 ~ 12 days agoChannel91
♦6
Hi. I noticed you removed the railway=abandoned tags that I had added a few weeks ago. While these lines have been successfully converted into bike paths, the standard OSM practice for rail-to-trail conversions is to retain the abandoned railway tag alongside the new highway tag. This preserves the ...
136844025
by Mashin
@ 2023-06-01 19:20
~ 3 years ago
1 ~ 2 months agolanahomeowner
♦1
Hello, please do not mark this as a driveway, it is not. Ref: 136844025. It's a private property with kids and animals. There should be no trucks driving by, no matter what you're trying to do here.
2 ~ 2 months agoMashin Hi, our policy is that if something exists in real world, we include it in our data. This looks like a property access road, which we call driveway.
There is now a tag access=no, which should give any driver information that entry is not permitted.
185385653
by Mashin
@ 2026-07-09 05:19
~ 4 months ago
1 ~ 4 months agoevgenykatyshev
♦357
Strange value of the check_date tag. Did you add it manually?
2 ~ 3 months agoMashin Thanks, not sure how that happened.
183483128
by Mashin
@ 2026-06-01 07:55
~ 5 months ago
1 ~ 5 months agodmjab13
♦154
please try to submit changesets like this in smaller regions, such as by state or city
160187400
by Mashin
@ 2024-12-11 22:26
~ 1 year ago
1 ~ 1 year agoJoseph R P
♦480
Do innocuous changes like those which you have reverted actually need to be discussed beforehand? I don't see how changing frivolous bits of road (I'm talking less than a quarter mile long each) to fix highway connectivity or indicate that a very short highway segment does not meet OSM...
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin Hi Joseph,
sorry, I know that this feels frustrating, but it is certainly not about all edits to OSM. Road network is a bit of a special case. Not so long ago the road classification in US was a mess until quite long discussion and difficult agreement happened. Jnighan was part of that discussion f...
3 ~ 1 year agoJoseph R P
♦480
I considered reaching out to jnighan at first before hesitating and ultimately deciding against it because I figured it would not be productive to converse with another person over some few hundred feet of roadway on the map. That's not reaching out to any community (just one person who has doc...
4 ~ 1 year agojnighan
♦125
Hi, Joseph! Thanks for the replies and direct message. In 2022, I created a classification system based on community input and other models for CT (link at bottom of comment). Mashin has been a great partner in alerting users that we do in fact have a system in place, and edits should be in keeping ...
5 ~ 1 year agojnighan
♦125
Here's the link to the classification page: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Connecticut/Highway_classification
6 ~ 1 year agoJoseph R P
♦480
In response to the classification of side streets which connect primary roads to motorways—I classified it as primary not with the expectation that it wouldn't be properly navigated by routing systems if tagged lower than primary, but rather from the standpoint that if the section of road...
7 ~ 1 year agojnighan
♦125
Hi,

Re: classification gaps, I think this makes sense. I will add a note about this type of mapping on the wiki page, and I'll start working on it. Feel free to do the same. I'll add text on the wiki page saying very short gaps (use reasonable judgement) on side streets between motorway...
8 ~ 1 year agojnighan
♦125
I added a paragraph to this section:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Connecticut/Highway_classification#Motorway
9 ~ 1 year agoJoseph R P
♦480
Thank you for adding the paragraph regarding these classification gaps and clarifying the reasons for the other roadways' classifications.
10 ~ 11 months agoZLima12
♦294
Generally, in cases like the I-91/CT-159 interchange, I feel that it is better to not change the classification of the connecting road (Meadow Road in this case). The ground truth is that CT-159 is the primary road, and you have to get off onto a side street to access it. If we tag the side street a...
174776665
by Mashin
@ 2025-11-17 15:08
~ 11 months ago
1 ~ 11 months agoRobMcC85
♦1
These changes should not be reverted. Portions of Oak Street and Hickory Street do not exist. Avenue C, D and E do not exist; one might be a driveway.
I tried to run this area and can confirm the south end of Oak Street is a lawn and woods; the northern/middle section of Hickory Street is woods, ...
2 ~ 11 months agoMashin Sorry, I haven't inspected the changeset properly.
172635521
by Mashin
@ 2025-09-29 23:11
~ 1 year ago
1 ~ 1 year agostevea
♦329
Thanks, Mashin, for fixing up my tagging. I was a bit hasty entering this, looks nice now.
170608022
by Mashin
@ 2025-08-18 10:18
~ 1 year ago
1 ~ 1 year agoDean Batchelder
♦1
I totally understand this, and it is okay to keep these trails as paths, but the trails labeled as cycleways are mountain biking trails with mountain biking features and primarily mountain bikers riding them. It is totally fine to keep these labeled as simply paths, but it is dangerous for walkers w...
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin Hi, from what I know cycleways are considered more for "urban" cycling infrastructure and having cycleways in the middle of a forest would be misleading. Also I've seen that some of them have hiking difficulty scale tags which tell that those are used by hikers as well.

When it com...
3 ~ 1 year agoDean Batchelder
♦1
Alright, thank you for letting me know. These trails are not endorsed, but do exist on various mountain biking websites and such. You are totally correct - I do feel like a cycleway might more refer to urban greenways. Even though I agree these trails should be marked as paths, I wish there was a wa...
113974011
by Mashin
@ 2021-11-19 05:23
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 1 year agoHb-
♦391
Where is the benefit for tagging simple areas of water as multipolygon instead of a closed way? The amount of nodes is the same and the amount of ways is similar. Big disadvantage is the costly computation, especially on handheld devices.
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin Hi,
Any particular examples? As far as I know I wasn't creating any new objects and majority of edits were changing tags.
3 ~ 1 year agoHb-
♦391
no. It was only a general remark on multipolygons.
4 ~ 1 year agoMashin I believe that if the multipolygon relation has only a single member (which is the outer way) then is should be deled and the tags moved to the closed way.
98474823
by Mashin
@ 2021-02-01 03:24
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 1 year agoTomas_J
♦447
Ahoj, priechod footway=crossig kresli na mape iba tam kde vidis na ortofoto zebru. Napr. priechod way 902508489 si nakreslil cca 10 x dlhsi nez v skutocnosti je. Opravim. Dik.
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin Diki za upozornenie ale to bol niekto iny.

https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/902508489
153692501
by Mashin
@ 2024-07-08 08:43
~ 2 years ago
1 ~ 1 year agodiamondarmorsteve
♦78
Eh... they could still be permissive. Permissive is when something is privately owned, access is granted by default, but the owner has every right to deny access at will.
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin That's true, could also be permissive.
165061904
by Mashin
@ 2025-04-17 09:22
~ 1 year ago
1 ~ 1 year agoZack Bowden
♦8
Thanks for fixing that, it looks a lot nicer than what I did, lol
2 ~ 1 year agoMashin Hey! You are doing a great job Zack! I really appreciate the patience you put into drawing these land covers.

Just in this case I saw that the lakes were supposed to be part of the Wildlife area, but not a part of the forest. And the only way was to re-draw the wood polygon.

Also at this point...
3 ~ 1 year agoZack Bowden
♦8
Thank you :D

And that makes sense, tbh

And I haven't done much with JOSM before, but it looks interesting, and I do want to try it out and play around with it sometime :)
125494366
by Mashin
@ 2022-08-28 20:33
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 2 years agoCurlingMan13
♦2,102
FYI - you can connect paths over water, just make sure you use bridge/tunnel, as appropriate...
2 ~ 2 years agoCurlingMan13
♦2,102
actually, it appears it was the edit before this one. :)
148145181
by Mashin
@ 2024-03-02 20:12
~ 2 years ago
1 ~ 2 years agoquincylvania
♦93
Hi Mashin 👋
I see you're removing trail names from ways that are already present on trail relations. I fear this is a nonstandard pattern with spotty support. Most maps and routing engines will not show labels for these trails, including the default osm-carto style. As such, I recommend rev...
2 ~ 2 years agoMashin Hi Quincy,
It's a mix of both. There are name tags that are truly descriptive and not an actual name e.g. red trail. The other names are just a duplicate of what is already in the hiking relation and creates just a duplicate when name searching. This is actually quite common way of mapping hik...
3 ~ 2 years agoTomPar
♦125
Mashin, can you point to any other mappers in CT or elsewhere in New England/NY that are actively removing accurate names from paths/footways to support your assertion: "quite common way of mapping hiking routes". I have been involved in multiple threads over multiple years of people comp...
4 ~ 2 years agoMateusz Konieczny
♦11,413
I would rather focus on whether paths are themself having names.

If they have then removing names is wrong (and I heard from multiple USA mappers that in USA path commonly are named after hiking route using them).

If they do not have names then adding names to them is deliberate mistagging for...
5 ~ 2 years agoElliottPlack
♦953
Mashin,

It is fine to leave the trail names even if you've added a relation. I find it destructive and counter productive to remove them. Here are some precedential examples:

1. [Queen's Loop @ Bryce Canyon NP](https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/650406545). The most popular hiking tra...
134827477
by Mashin
@ 2023-04-12 16:59
~ 3 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoa_runner
♦4
Maybe, Im missing something, but why cant these trails have the name in the relation AND in the trail name? The Hop River State Park trail to the north has a Name Tag and Relation, so why cant these trails have it too? This is the official map from DEEP: https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/DEEP/stateparks...
2 ~ 3 years agoa_runner
♦4
After doing some reading, I see where my mistake was. I found documentation saying that the name tag "should not describe or label the feature" and should instead be the common name of the feature. So although it seemed counterproductive to me, it now makes sense that the blaze color shoul...
3 ~ 3 years agoMashin Hi, I can see the good motivation behind this, but those maps made a choice not to show the hiking trails and using name= tag for this purpose is kind of like hacking the information in. This will then also cause problems for other maps that do not expect this. Generally there is a rule 'one fe...
4 ~ 2 years agoezekielf
♦92
Forum discussion about this here: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/trails-use-name-and-or-hiking-route/110106
146137585
by Mashin
@ 2024-01-11 10:47
~ 2 years ago
1 ~ 2 years agoMateusz Konieczny
♦11,413
have you edited based on local knowledge or other indicator that path itself has no name?

Also, in future remember to add source of edit (note that it is missing also on say https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/102658003 )
102658003
by Mashin
@ 2021-04-09 16:33
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 2 years agoMateusz Konieczny
♦11,413
You removed name from https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/423006651/history in this edit

have you edited based on local knowledge or other indicator that path itself has no name?

Also, in future remember to add source of edit (note that it is missing also on say https://www.openstreetmap.org/cha...
126325452
by Mashin
@ 2022-09-18 10:25
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoandrewsuzuki
♦103
I think way 29373850 (Naugatuck River outline) should stop where it meets the Housatonic in Derby? Currently it extends a few miles south. My computer is broken at the moment so I can't fix it very easily :)
2 ~ 3 years agoMashin That's a good point. River areas are not supposed not even have names, those should be only on waterway=river/stream lines.
I removed the name from the relation that had the way as outer member.
130241670
by Mashin
@ 2022-12-19 10:12
~ 3 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agojnighan
♦125
Hi, some ways with waterway=dam were added that aren't good fits for the criteria associated with that tag. I've changed some to man_made=embankment or waterway=weir
2 ~ 3 years agoMashin Thanks, I just guess what it is from the imagery.
135464201
by Mashin
@ 2023-04-28 11:11
~ 3 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoZeLonewolf
♦584
Should Pawcatuck be a proper admin boundary or is it only a CDP?
2 ~ 3 years agoZeLonewolf
♦584
Oh, I guess it's just part of Stonington.
3 ~ 3 years agoMashin It should just be a CDP
125496285
by Mashin
@ 2022-08-28 21:33
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoCurlingMan13
♦2,102
Why did you change the cartpaths that were correctly mapped into service roads without the cartpath tags?

Such as:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/587935762/history

These should be changed back to cartpaths with path tags.
2 ~ 3 years agoMashin They had golf_cart=designated access tag, which indicates who can use them. I feel like the not approved golf=cartpath was just created by TGC mappers for their own purpose.
112597588
by Mashin
@ 2021-10-17 04:10
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoJackNUMBER
♦10
Salut, j'ai l'impression que les nœuds 9177441989 et 9177441988 de ce changeset sont mal placés.
2 ~ 3 years agoMashin Thanks for catching those. I have no idea how could that have happened.
131399692
by Mashin
@ 2023-01-17 23:39
~ 3 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agoE1892
♦2
Hi there, I am new here. I removed several roads/trails from OSM today because they are on private land. It looks like you have restored them to the map. This makes them appear on AllTrails, and encourages hikers. How do we get them removed?
Many thanks.
113503616
by Mashin
@ 2021-11-08 04:40
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 3 years agomaraf24
♦5,379
You didn't check if river is actually a river. See
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/794273139/history
2 ~ 3 years agoMashin Oh boy, you're right!
Fixed that here: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/129277340

Though it seems that waterpark needs some love. Some of the slides are even tagged as water drains. I think more appropriate would be something like:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:attraction%...
84582047
by Mashin
@ 2020-05-03 21:39
~ 6 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoandrewsuzuki
♦103
Check out note 3244011 when you have a chance. It renders fine in openstreetmap-carto but not OsmAnd. I don't know much about tagging boundaries but it seems like there are two boundaries for New Haven? 270191 and 11065393.
2 ~ 4 years agoMashin I can also see the same issue in OsmAnd. After poking around it seems to me that the most likely cause will be that the boundary in this place is using a part of coastline (www.openstreetmap.org/way/41744416). This seems more like a bug on the OsmAnd side. We can always duplicate the way and use it...
3 ~ 4 years agoandrewsuzuki
♦103
I see, thanks. There are a lot of coastline-related issues on the OsmAnd github but nothing really matches this case. I'll open a new issue
4 ~ 4 years agoMashin That's great, thanks!
124926160
by Mashin
@ 2022-08-15 12:28
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoSomeoneElse
♦13,938
Thanks
110398400
by Mashin
@ 2021-08-29 03:07
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoandrewsuzuki
♦103
FYI Most (~80%) "congregational" churches in CT, such as way 206954336, can be tagged as united_church_of_christ (UCC) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Church_of_Christ#History
2 ~ 4 years agoMashin Nice. Thanks for the info!
110882705
by Mashin
@ 2021-09-07 23:41
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
hi. I was reviewing the osmose reports for Panama, and I noticed a whole series of "Same wikipedia topic on other language". OSMCha also warns about "Deleted a wikidata/wikipedia tag" and "Invalid tag modification".
hopefully you have time to review your work even if i...
2 ~ 4 years agoMashin Removed a wikipedia tag. Maybe that was it.
3 ~ 4 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
possibly, I don't check osmose every week, and its refresh cycle is also rather slow. thank you for the fix!
120358695
by Mashin
@ 2022-04-29 17:42
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
:+1: :-)
118177208
by Mashin
@ 2022-03-06 23:03
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoS-zation
♦123
Why did you revert this? Following your own source and ConnDOT maps, CT 82 is a "minor arterial" from CT 9 to Saybrook Road. It does not meet expressway classification.

https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/DOT/documents/dpolicy/policymaps/fcl/pdf/060fcl.pdf
2 ~ 4 years agoMashin Sorry, there was a recent road reclassification in CT and I am just trying to prevent it from getting mixed up again.
Maybe you are right. Try asking Jack (https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/jnighan) what he thinks about that.
3 ~ 4 years agoS-zation
♦123
Ok, I'll send him a message
4 ~ 4 years agojnighan
♦125
I think this should be tagged highway=motorway_link and oneway=no, rather than motorway (as it is tagged), trunk (as it was changed to), or secondary (as the CTDOT scheme would have it tagged). The documentation for motorway links allows for this, and this road serves no purpose besides entering/exi...
5 ~ 4 years agoS-zation
♦123
Motorway_link makes the most sense to me because the road is essentially serves as a long on/off ramp for route 9. The only reason I would be hesitant is because I've never seen an example of a such a long motorway_link for a 2+1 road
107595352
by Mashin
@ 2021-07-08 02:30
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGRailMapper
♦8
please do not remove abandoned railway tagging. The information is used by OpenRailwayMap to locate former lines even when the tracks are gone
117373881
by Mashin
@ 2022-02-14 01:40
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
Hi Mashin - As you may remember, after extended discussion on the OSMUS Slack #trails channel late last year, there was overwhelming consensus (9 to 2) that removing the Name tag from a way simply because it's a member of a named relation is not desirable. Yet you are once again deleting trail ...
2 ~ 4 years agoMashin Sorry I was restoring some of the relations that you deleted before and in the process I converted some blazed trails to relations. But moved all the information to relation so there is on data loss.
117366407
by Mashin
@ 2022-02-13 19:18
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
Please see comments for changeset 117373881.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/117366407
117367085
by Mashin
@ 2022-02-13 19:44
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
Please see comments for changeset 117373881.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/117367085
117371210
by Mashin
@ 2022-02-13 22:19
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
Please see comments for changeset 117373881
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/117371210
115615338
by Mashin
@ 2021-12-31 16:05
~ 4 years ago
1 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
So you're just going to delete the trail names with no discussion, not even 24 hours after I edited? Not cool - at all.
I'm taking the names from DEEP - these are the names of the trails according to THE authoritative source. What is YOUR source for the changes you made?
2 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
I take it back - the names are coming from the CFPA (www.ctwoodlands.org). Do you not consider them authoritative?
3 ~ 4 years agoMashin "The Green Trail" etc. are definitely not official names.

Also would you mind including source of you data to your changesets? You are adding peaks with elevation and names, deleting existing hiking relations, adding stream names... which clearly couldn't come from Strava layer.
4 ~ 4 years agoGreg_Rose
♦180
So much to deal with here....

a) You seem to know that those "are definitely not official names", yet fail to name your source for that knowledge. In this same change you deleted the name of the Pond Mountain NA "Entry Trail", despite it clearly being the official name (ww...
5 ~ 4 years agoMashin I hiked those trails many times. There are no such names posted anywhere, no one knows or uses those names. You are just adding stuff from various online sources without knowing anything about the local situation.

Look, I spent weeks cleaning trails in CT and building hiking relations which is a ...
113674960
by Mashin
@ 2021-11-12 01:53
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoDaveF
♦1,703
Hi
Did you mean to tag this as rough?
https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/13431264
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin I think I just assumed, because this little area was tagged as fairway.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/13431265
113392918
by Mashin
@ 2021-11-05 04:18
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoMateusz Konieczny
♦11,413
Ideally, names wuld be also removed from water areas
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin Oh I was not sure if there was some sort of local agreement on keeping those names on areas since so many rivers have it like that.
Ok, I'll be removing those. Thanks
27990137
by Mashin
@ 2015-01-08 04:48
~ 11 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoaceman444
♦3,112
Zdravim, tie cesticky ako https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/221441062 maju naozaj take dlhe nazvy? Je k tomu nejaky oficialny zdroj? Alebo su to len ich opisy. Do nazvu 'name' totiz patria len skutocne mena objektov, vlastne mena, nie opisy ani vyjadrenie typu objektu (napr. name=cesta).
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin Urcite nie su oficialne
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/16135182
112860512
by Mashin
@ 2021-10-23 01:07
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoTomas Straupis
♦2,150
Hello, please do not reduce the quality of existing tagging. iD editor is giving incorrect advices. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WikiProject_Cartography/Waterways
111174115
by Mashin
@ 2021-09-14 05:05
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
Hola Mashin! would you mind having a closer look at "river" Guigalá near node 2516873790? I just added a road, crossing the river there, and while in Bing it looks like a ford, Maxar gives me the impression that the intersection is now implemented as a culvert. still a "rive...
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin This one is hard without an actual survey. Trees along Guigalá are too thick to see how wide the river is.

Since the nearby river Escarrea is wide enough to see that it is a wide river I would lean more towards classifying Guigalá as a stream, but that is hard with this type of imag...
3 ~ 5 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
I see that in this changeset you have also "fixed" Río Chevo, in the sense that you did indeed fix the spelling of "Rio" into "Río", but would you review the course? it makes very little sense to me. I don't know how to behave here.
4 ~ 5 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
Mashin, do you think your team can have a look at this area? https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/111703174
111203955
by Mashin
@ 2021-09-14 16:13
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agomariotomo
♦1,914
looks quite nice, thanks. do you think you can follow the Río San Juan near Calobre? and the pressurised stream?
Nœud : 7435260825
96582009
by Mashin
@ 2020-12-29 07:51
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoAlan Bragg
♦155
osmc:symbol not matching symbol= on relation 12107000
Not trying to be picky, just curious based on slack discussions.
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin it has `symbol=White rectangle`, which should be described as `white::white_stripe`. At least some sites render it correctly..

I am in contact with Sarah and Nop and looking for solution for two color blazes.
100521527
by Mashin
@ 2021-03-06 04:38
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoBrilej
♦1
Hi Mashin,

this cleanup was long overdue, thanks a lot for it. But IMHO you should not mix geometry improvements with retagging operations.

Kind regards,
Bogumil
2 ~ 5 years agoMashin You're right. I got carried away by the editing too much and then it was too late to split it into several changesets.
Will remember for the future.
33088437
by Mashin
@ 2015-08-04 06:29
~ 11 years ago
1 ~ 11 years agoSei Han
♦3
Hey Mashin, thanks for alerting me to my improper edit. How could we reattach this building to Silliman College? I've been trying to figure this out...