Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12018-08-28 22:10:24 UTCndm I think this one needs reverting - you've deleted the parking that was surveyed on foot and dragged a building to an odd shape.
22018-09-06 17:07:33 UTCsamguer Hello ndm,

The newly added service roads with gates is a more accurate representation than the parking aisles that were drawn over the parking spots were. However, in doing the edit in unintentionally altered one of the building polygons that were attached to the deleted parking lot as seen in ht...
32018-09-06 23:10:59 UTCndm So, I picked this reply while I was in town and had a quick investigate -- I've made a first change on https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/62357550

It's likely the area will need surveying in the near future due to "New Yard" development by http://www.cityandcountry.co.uk/developme...
42018-09-17 17:19:43 UTCsamguer ndm, thank you for the follow up, when the gates were added, the evidence used for adding them was street level imagery: old gate - (https://www.bing.com/maps?cp=51.447401~-2.592546&lvl=17&dir=104.101&style=x&v=2&sV=1) you can see some type of barrier if you move over a few fram...
12018-09-14 19:01:03 UTCRich1234 Hello, thanks for contributing to open street map.

Please note that the Mapbox satellite images of this new way show that the terminal is within a cul-de-sac. Accordingly, the terminal node should also have been tagged with the highway=turning_circle tag to accurately reflect that there is a c...
22018-09-17 04:43:26 UTCjojoyal Hello, thank you for letting me know about the slightest mistake that i have made. will keep that in mind going forward.
12018-09-04 08:56:00 UTCChris Fleming You added it, you deleted it, what is going on?
22018-09-05 11:25:07 UTCGanesh Seetharaman The segment was incorrectly added and jojoyal@ was asked to remove it after expert validation of his edit.
32018-09-05 12:43:34 UTCChris Fleming Thanks Ganesh, in general I keep an eye on edits in Scotland and especially Edinburgh - I've seen a lot of service roads added that have been added now getting removed around Scotland. Ideally I would like to understand a bit more about how they were identified to be added and what sources were used...
42018-09-05 13:11:48 UTCGanesh Seetharaman Hi Chris, We use driver activity as a source to identify missing roads. Once a potential missing road has been identified we use OSM resources to confirm if a road exists. We make an edit only if there is proof available.
However in some cases the editors misinterpret the evidence. We ensure that ...
52018-09-10 20:21:28 UTCChris Fleming Thanks great to know - so these are cases where their probably are service roads going around the building (from imagery) but if you don't have drivers traces to verify this with then you won't add the roads, thank you for yhe detailed response.
12018-09-04 10:24:39 UTCRich1234 Is there a reason why you removed the tag service=parking_aisle from the ways in this changeset that run along the rows of parking spaces?

According to the wiki (see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:service%3Dparking_aisle) the ways that run along the rows of parking spaces in a parking lo...
4 changeset(s) created by jojoyal have been discussed with a total of 12 comment(s)