| Note | # | ⏱️ Last updated | Event | Contributor | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3304147 | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | opened | ti-lo ♦618 | Which parameters for museum and subject ? "showcasing information about the Solar System, cosmology, and spaceflight" as of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_Space_Museum https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=spaceflight#values https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=astronomy#values https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=aerospace#values Probably multiple ? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Semi-colon_value_separator "space" may be misinterpreted https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=space#values "science" values should correlate with "faculty" https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/faculty#values |
| 2 | ~ 1 year ago | closed | seewhyso ♦189 | Amended to science. However "subject" should be sufficient to describe without the use of "faculty" | |
| 3 | ~ 1 year ago | reopened | ti-lo ♦618 | ||
| 4 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | ti-lo ♦618 | Seems to generic to me. The question was (also) whether several values could apply besides https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/museum=spaceflight | |
| 5 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | ti-lo ♦618 | "faculty" only applies to universities but similar values are used, such as https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/faculty=astronomy | https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/museum=astronomy | |
| 6 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | ti-lo ♦618 | The correct value might be museum=spaceflight;astronomy, also see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key%3Amuseum, should also cover "Solar System, cosmology" ? | |
| 7 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | There are only 3+1 `spaceflight` , and 4 `astronomy` . Neither seems dominant. I would suspect some `=aerospace` may be mainly space-related, and obviously many aviation ones don't have a spaceflight showcase. So it doesn't perfect fit either. `=aerospace` has been mass added before https://taghistory.raifer.tech/?#***/museum/aerospace I don't understand how "space" would be misunderstood? | |
| 8 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | `museum=science` could yet be fine if `museum=` is treated as a generic category. But it doesn't have enough work done on it. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:museum#Untitled_1 https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:tourism=museum#On_subtypes_and_topics_/_museum_subjects | |
| 9 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | Both https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/faculty#values and https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/department#values aren't widely agreed on, and are being polluted by the faculty and department names. `department=` has further issue with `=store_section` for `=department_store` and `=supermarket` . There's no definite reason to match with `museum=` . | |
| 10 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:museum_type#Not_very_clear | |
| 11 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | ti-lo ♦618 | Please try whether this description works for you : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:museum:type%3Dscience | |
| 12 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | No. `*type` never works. It's a meaningless suffix. | |
| 13 | ~ 1 year ago | commented | ti-lo ♦618 | Seems to work in a bunch of cases https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:*:type | |
| 14 | ~ 9 months ago | commented | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | I am thinking perhaps `museum=science` with `subject=astronomy` or `museum:subject=astronomy`. Cosmology is a subset of astronomy. Astronomy should automatically imply "spaceflight"; can't have serious (space) observations without rocket-delivered satellites and telescopes. | |
| 15 | ~ 7 months ago | closed | ar_on_hk | ||
| 16 | ~ 7 months ago | reopened | kingkingHK ♦551 | ||
| 17 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | Some extra thoughts: Museum tag should be "museum=science" because this museum does demonstrate some science theories. The museum tag should "converge" to the fields of study at universities. Subject tag should be "subject=astronomy". Taginfo shows a lot of country names for this tag, which we can infer as "clarification of history museums". In particular, there is no usage of "subject=cosmology". We should still converge into the wider "subject=astrology", because e.g. this museum iirc demonstrates Doppler effects, gravity, and black holes, and these are general astronomical phenomena. Museum "type" should be avoided. It is ambiguous whether we intend to describe the subject of the museum (e.g. astronomy), the way the knowledge is presented (e.g. interactive displays, room-size demos, theatrical performances, ...), or the governance/funding structure (e.g. municipal, private, ...). As such, having "museum=science" with "subject=astronomy" is sufficient. | |
| 18 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | (continuation) In particular, the subject should not be "space science". Wikipedia describes "space science" as astronomy and astronautics. For this museum, looking at the astronautics topic, other than human spaceflight (which likely exists in all astronomy museum in the world anyway as general adjacent topic), iirc this museum does not talk about extraterrestrial colonization, life support systems, or cosmo-agri stuff. There is no (or just not much) astronautics in this museum; it still largely is just astronomy. | |
| 19 | ~ 3 months ago | closed | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | Resolved via https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/186391412 ; closing. | |
| 20 | ~ 3 months ago | reopened | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | ||
| 21 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | Can you not instant close a debated note? Space Exploration is its own Hall. `subject=` is used for the exact topic. At least it can be semicolon. `museum=` as you discussed is for the broadest categorization of museums. `museum:subject=` can be used for categorizing the topic. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposal:Subject#Examples | |
| 22 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | `=astronomy` alone makes it seem it's focused on `planetarium` only. It has other panels and exhibits. | |
| 23 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | It does seem like there is no *extra* debate, given the general inactivity, and no additional responses on my museum/subject interpretation. For me, following the Wiki definition, astronomy should simply "contain everything" which naturally includes "planetarium" and other stuff. Holding open for now to collect more info; but imo we should be pretty close to the true solution / tagging method. | |
| 24 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | Kovoschiz ♦2,287 | You said "I am thinking perhaps", which seems you are undecided. And it needs progress on defining the use of `musuem=` , `subject=` , and `museum:subject=` | |
| 25 | ~ 3 months ago | commented | vectorial8192 ♦1,549 | That was 6 months ago. It was definitely not final back then, but now I have some more (concrete) ideas, which was written down in this note. Still, pretty sure we are almost there. |