| Country | Changeset | Contributor | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
 | 179383823 (Comments: 1) | Cypp0847 (Discussed changesets: 28) | 1. Feels like a descriptive name, are you sure? 2. Do you have an osm-compatible source for the geometry? commented 2026-03-05 10:18:55 UTC by kingkingHK ♦106 |
| 179369541 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | `=house` is a single home. Multiple homes should be `=terrace` commented 2026-03-05 08:04:17 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179368028 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | 1. When the estate is simply number on street, it should be `noname=yes` , as there's no difference with the addressing. Only styled ones eg `=328 Clear Water Bay` should be accepted. 2. Blocks in estate use `addr:street` + `addr:housenumber... commented 2026-03-05 08:02:12 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179293455 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | HK BBQ should be eg `=picnic_site` + ` bbq=yes` + `fee=yes` ( `amenity=bbq` has been defined for individual grills) , surely not `=restaurant` commented 2026-03-04 18:28:32 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179251617 (Comments: 1) | Kovoschiz (Discussed changesets: 136) | Revert of 179235318 commented 2026-03-04 08:43:37 UTC by Wildsharky ♦54 |
| 179167704 (Comments: 6) | vectorial8192 (Discussed changesets: 128) | Ok, from newer bus videos I can see the signs. Really didn't expect the signs to be erected a few months after the hospital opens. Apologies for the wrong accusation. commented 2026-03-03 08:44:55 UTC by kingkingHK ♦106 |
| 179251791 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | 1. If they are same factory, a `landuse=industrial` + `=works` polygon should be drawn around them, not duplicated as 2 `=works` 2. If it's small scale only, it should use `craft=` , not `=works` commented 2026-03-02 17:31:49 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179256033 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | Sewage pumping stations should use `=pumping_station` , not `=wastewater_plant` commented 2026-03-02 17:28:22 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179251994 (Comments: 1) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | What is Pik Uk Garden? If it's an estate, it should be `landuse=residential` , not `=hamlet` commented 2026-03-02 17:24:15 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179235318 (Comments: 1) | Saaria (Discussed changesets: 1) | Please don't add such `name=` , which is for proper names only. `temporary=yes` should be used. commented 2026-03-02 11:33:31 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179184501 (Comments: 8) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | For Issue 1, if most of you feel uncomforted, I can delete all my work on house number based on my announced citation. I will not delete the object as I draw them from Satellite Map. I have already indicated "aerial imagery" as one of my so... commented 2026-03-01 13:19:40 UTC by Dundee930 ♦3 |
| 179167947 (Comments: 1) | osm_map_amethyst_lok (Discussed changesets: 11) | Please use `*:yue-Latn=` for romanization without commonly recognized and used status, not `*:en=` commented 2026-03-01 09:42:29 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179196155 (Comments: 1) | osm_map_amethyst_lok (Discussed changesets: 11) | Please don't undisussed bulk change from `old_name=` to other `*name=` , and accuse others of vandalisms. You are only accusing yourself together. Use OpenHistoricalMap. commented 2026-03-01 09:06:39 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179196073 (Comments: 1) | osm_map_amethyst_lok (Discussed changesets: 11) | There's no `=peak` if it has become flattened with the surroundings entirely. Only `place=locality` , and it should be on OpenHistoricalMap instead. commented 2026-03-01 09:05:14 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179199146 (Comments: 4) | Dundee930 (Discussed changesets: 8) | Did you check whether others have politely commented on you already? You will see how well your report do for yourself. commented 2026-03-01 09:00:48 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179197177 (Comments: 2) | Kovoschiz (Discussed changesets: 136) | https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/179199146 Please read your own changesets if you know how to comment https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/179184501 commented 2026-03-01 08:59:34 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179168029 (Comments: 2) | vectorial8192 (Discussed changesets: 128) | Rendering can abuse and add `=earth_bank` + `anthropogenic=yes` commented 2026-02-28 13:35:50 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179168373 (Comments: 2) | vectorial8192 (Discussed changesets: 128) | Good catch. Improved / fixed with https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/179170787 commented 2026-02-28 13:30:30 UTC by vectorial8192 ♦120 |
| 179114899 (Comments: 1) | solenoid jam (Discussed changesets: 172) | Is it not `trail_visibility=no` , `disused=yes` , `abandoned:highway=` , or scrambling? commented 2026-02-27 08:40:33 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179092571 (Comments: 1) | stone666 (Discussed changesets: 1) | Please don't upload personal test edits. This is considered vandalism. commented 2026-02-27 08:30:22 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |
| 179073252 (Comments: 1) | Cypp0847 (Discussed changesets: 28) | Should use `=busway` (despite Carto not rendering) commented 2026-02-27 08:29:38 UTC by Kovoschiz ♦2,769 |