| Changeset | # | ⏱️ Last updated | Contributor | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 135546990 by azakh-world @ 2023-04-30 17:39 ~ 2 years ago | 1 | ~ 2 years ago | Bobropiton ♦147 | Приветствую. Перевешивать линию с мультика на platform_edge-не совсем корректно, геофабрика начинает ругаться да и птв2 не предполагает таких участников. Согласно вики... |
| 2 | ~ 2 years ago | azakh-world | Здравствуйте.Апелляция к вики не всегда годится. Кто изначально писал те или иные схемы, сам не вполне представлял проблемы, которые выявятся при их практическом ... | |
| 118047328 by azakh-world @ 2022-03-03 08:58 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | ToniE ♦1,259 | Thanks, I noticed and fixed that for the Train-Relations (using PTNA ptna.openstreetmap.de) but forgot to fix the stop_areas as well.RegardsToni |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Yeah, Zverik's validator is also alive and well :)Best regards,Alexey | |
| 3 | ~ 3 years ago | wurzelast ♦1,560 | https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/127307284 | |
| 116424215 by azakh-world @ 2022-01-21 10:36 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | az09 ♦101 | а надо-то было наоборот! ну и POI бы тогда тоже (но лучше таки наоборот) |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Добрый день.А что наоборот? Слово "Газеты" с маленькой буквы писать? При выборе я опирался на нормы русского языка, какие нашёл для этого случая.С уважением,\... | |
| 3 | ~ 3 years ago | az09 ♦101 | кремлевского штурмана уже дважды банили, а именно он взялся кавычки расставлять (https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/109330472). так что предлагаю еще раз хорошо подумать над этими ка... | |
| 4 | ~ 3 years ago | azakh-world | Упоминание бана кому-то там за что-то там не является аргументом. Была бы полезней ссылка именно на договорённость, заключать ли в кавычки несклоняемое имя собстве... | |
| 124338792 by azakh-world @ 2022-08-01 10:48 ~ 3 years ago | 1 | ~ 3 years ago | osmee333 ♦9 | Thank you, and apologies again. Take care! |
| 124354105 by azakh-world @ 2022-08-01 16:11 ~ 3 years ago | 1 | ~ 3 years ago | osmee333 ♦9 | Thank you, and apologies again. Take care! |
| 116655107 by azakh-world @ 2022-01-27 08:48 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 3 years ago | DaveF ♦1,625 | Please don't delete valid railway stations. (different codes)Please don't remove valid tags (station=subway) |
| 122058263 by azakh-world @ 2022-06-07 08:09 ~ 3 years ago | 1 | ~ 3 years ago | Kovoschiz ♦2,858 | Hi, that one is created as a placeholder for the PTI. |
| 2 | ~ 3 years ago | azakh-world | Hello.What is PTI?In any case, I think it's incorrect to have a stop_area in two stop_area_groups one of which is fictitious. These leads to weird effects when software try to build a transport scheme on this data.Best regards,Alexey | |
| 3 | ~ 3 years ago | Kovoschiz ♦2,858 | Yes, I'm going to fix it now. | |
| 119621824 by azakh-world @ 2022-04-12 13:12 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Обсуждение:https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/119321704 |
| 119289334 by azakh-world @ 2022-04-04 07:13 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | danctc ♦17 | Hello.The Boa Esperança station of the VLT was inaugurated on February 1 of that year (2022).On the railroad operator's own website, CBTU, is described: https://www.cbtu.gov.br/index.php/pt/?option=com_content&view=article&Itemid=1102&id=9328. Therefore, the changes... |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Hi.The tags on the station were misleading, so I changed them into some value. Thank you for the correction. I also removed 'disused' tags from some rails. Could you check if it's all right now? https://osmcha.org/changesets/119568362/ | |
| 117940677 by azakh-world @ 2022-02-28 11:34 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | ChaireMobiliteKaligrafy ♦472 | Can you explain a bit more what was wrong by setting the building as a subway station. This is a legit subway station... |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Hello.Please read at least the first paragraph of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:railway%3DstationAccording to it, a subway station drawn as an area should include at least passenger platforms. When the extent of a station is unclear which is often true for underground stations, its bet... | |
| 3 | ~ 4 years ago | ChaireMobiliteKaligrafy ♦472 | OK, sorry, I did not see that there was already a node with the same info. :-) | |
| 115813905 by azakh-world @ 2022-01-05 21:44 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Toronto metro: restore Warden station in Line 2 routes #vk_maps |
| 115473478 by azakh-world @ 2021-12-28 14:20 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | а можно было бы просто name исправить... Восстановлю |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Не надо восстанавливать. Кроме неверного название, удалённая stop_area дублировала существующее верное отношение. | |
| 3 | ~ 4 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | поздно. Теперь у нас есть вот это: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/13592294 | |
| 115151247 by azakh-world @ 2021-12-20 07:13 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | BJMTR ♦15 | Shaoxing Railway Transit Line 1 is belong to Shaoxing Railway Transit, not Hangzhou Metro. And Hanghai Intercity Railway is belong to Hangzhou inter city Railway Transit. |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Ok. Please fix it. | |
| 114925743 by azakh-world @ 2021-12-14 13:53 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | теперь на линии 4 как будто по два дублирующих маршрута получилось. Видимо, тот, что был рекаверен, ранее следовал на варшавскую-каховскую, и его просто следовало уд... |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Привет.Я восстановил остановки в маршрутах Филёвской линии, видимо ненамеренно попорченной в редакторе iD. БКЛ тронул по минимуму, не меняя структуру. Если ты разо... | |
| 3 | ~ 4 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | я имел в виду Замоскворецкую ветку (да, № 2, а не 4). Поправлю. | |
| 112182309 by azakh-world @ 2021-10-06 18:24 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | 快乐的老鼠宝宝 ♦585 | Hello! Mapper from Maps.me/organicmap, OSMChina are greet for someone using metro data to create usable application, thank you for your hard work.But, we noticed that there are still a lot of error in China（https://alexey-zakharenkov.github.io/subways/rapid/china.html）Will you give some ... |
| 107504868 by azakh-world @ 2021-07-06 14:56 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Добрый день! А расскажите пожалуйста что вы сделали? Не очень понятно как рассмотреть изменения в таком большом списке отношений в ченджсете. |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Добрый день.Пожалуйста. Я разделил места посадки/высадки (отношения stop_area) в наземный транспорт от этих мест для метро, объединив их в пересадки (отношения stop_area_group... | |
| 3 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Понял, то есть наземные stop_position & platform в одной группе, подземные в другой (трамваи видимо в третьей?) и всё объединить в stop_area_group?Я пытался разобраться во всех эти... | |
| 4 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Отредактировал станцию метро Парк Культуры, надеюсь, правильно? https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/107706019 | |
| 105109620 by azakh-world @ 2021-05-21 20:13 ~ 4 years ago | 1 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Хорошая правка! Вот только domostroynn.ru не сайт застройщика, это агрегатор новостроек НН, не уверен что правильно давать на него ссылку.Сам же застройщик испарился и те... |
| 2 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Привет!Нигде вроде не сказано, что в теге website должна быть ссылка именно на сайт застройщика. Зато там можно посмотреть границы ЖК и состояние дел. Там же есть помет... | |
| 3 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | В английской версии статьи https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:website говорится всё же об official website.В таком случае лучше давать ссылку на сайт застройщика (https://kvartstroy.ru/nn/novinki), или п... | |
| 4 | ~ 4 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Вот их группа вконтакте, если понадобитсяhttps://vk.com/novinkismartcitynn | |
| 5 | ~ 4 years ago | azakh-world | Более-менее ясно, что такое оф. сайт организации, но что такое оф. сайт места, с которым связано несколько ответственных организаций? В случае ЖК это не только застро... | |
| 100803333 by azakh-world @ 2021-03-10 21:59 ~ 5 years ago | 1 | ~ 5 years ago | alexashh ♦44 | Приветствую! Подскажите какой схемой вы руководствуетесь когда удаляете дублирование платформ?Это не похоже на то как размечено метро в Нижнем Новгороде, и, во... |
| 2 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | Добрый день!Там было две платформы - одна как линия по оси, другая - прямоугольник. Я перенёс теги с линии на прямоугольник, чтобы остался только один объект railway=platfo... | |
| 97195552 by azakh-world @ 2021-01-09 00:18 ~ 5 years ago | 1 | ~ 5 years ago | kajalk27 ♦1 | The needy person can buy spy cheating playing card devices in India online and offline at spy shops. These devices will help you to make your move secretly and quietly that no one get any hint of your cheating devices to win every type of the playing card in gambling. Place and time doesn’t m... |
| 93216017 by azakh-world @ 2020-10-29 06:24 ~ 5 years ago | 1 | ~ 5 years ago | variable90 ♦13 | Why have you changed the subway station & route status to Inactive/Construction? |
| 2 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | I haven't changed anything fundamentally, only followed common practice for tagging things under construction: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:construction, https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Lifecycle_prefix | |
| 3 | ~ 5 years ago | variable90 ♦13 | But things you have tagged under construction are operational. So there is no point of tagging them under construction.You can take reference from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaipur_Metro#Phase_1BPlease revert the changes done. Thanks. | |
| 4 | ~ 5 years ago | variable90 ♦13 | And i am working in Jaipur/Rajasthan based on my local knowledge. | |
| 5 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | Reverting of my changes won't make things operational. The features I touched already had 'construction' or 'construction:railway' keys. All 'construction' tagging should be removed consistently. Could you do it base on your local knowledge? | |
| 6 | ~ 5 years ago | variable90 ♦13 | Sorry, My bad. I didn't see that it had construction tag/key prior. Though I have removed the tags. | |
| 92808852 by azakh-world @ 2020-10-21 06:50 ~ 5 years ago | 1 | ~ 5 years ago | Percherie ♦35 | Bonjour,Je peut accepter, dans le cadre du RER, que stop_positions ne sont pas des railway=station mais ces même arrêts sont également utilisés par les lignes de train suivant le modèle PTv2 (TGV, OuiGo, Eurostar)Dans ce modèle PTv2 les stop-positions ... |
| 86251646 by azakh-world @ 2020-06-05 15:24 ~ 5 years ago | 1 | ~ 5 years ago | clay_c ♦521 | Hi there. I noticed you added stop_area_group relations to encapsulate the subway stations I've split into separate directions due to lack of in-station transfer between the two platforms. These are stations where one must exit, cross the street, and pass through a different entrance (paying ad... |
| 2 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | Hi.None of the rapid transit network in the list on http://osm-subway.maps.me treated opposite platforms within one station as belonging to different stop_areas. You were the first and we accept it to be a proper way. It took a lot of effort to keep routing in our application by means of the (poss... | |
| 3 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | I think relation 9813444 should not be a stop_area_group due to stop_areas spatial separation along with "need-for-pay" consideration.BTW, it seems subway_entrances are distributes not correctly between the stop_areas. | |
| 4 | ~ 5 years ago | clay_c ♦521 | Thanks for pointing out the subway_entrance discrepancy—it should be fixed now.Stations lacking free transfer between directions are typically not found at transfer hubs. Bleecker Street (6) used to be an exception, where the southbound platform connected to Broadway–Lafayette Street... | |
| 5 | ~ 5 years ago | azakh-world | "... that a routing algorithm would actually direct someone to make this sort of opposite-direction transfer."Nevertheless it's a nonfictional case. At some subway station the eastbound platform and entrances were closed for 2 years for reconstruction, allowing (un)boarding only fro... | |
| 79939891 by azakh-world @ 2020-01-22 22:07 ~ 6 years ago | 1 | ~ 6 years ago | xhzyh1 ♦3 | Hi.I'm so sorry about changeset 79895704.I didn't check the wiki at that time because there aren't any similar tags on Line 1.I'm sorry for the problem.Thank you for fixing them. |
| 70251936 by azakh-world @ 2019-05-14 20:29 ~ 6 years ago | 1 | ~ 6 years ago | ma-rt-in ♦1,764 | Hallo,warum hast light_rail=yes ergänzt? Das ist eigentlich garnicht nötig.vg |
| 2 | ~ 6 years ago | azakh-world | Hello.Tagging stations with light_rail flag (station=light_rail or light_rail=yes) is common practice, more than 2000 stations have this tag. About 60 stations of Hamburg S-Bahn already have it, I have added it to 5 rest stations. This tagging is an element of validation, allowing to check that ro... | |
| 3 | ~ 6 years ago | ma-rt-in ♦1,764 | Hello,the argument that "only" 2000 times the key is used, it rather weak. Well it may be that it helps to find bugs, but it is not necessary after PTv2. In addition, it can be determined via the entry at pt = stop_position whether there is an error in the route. | |
| 4 | ~ 6 years ago | azakh-world | Neither tagging scheme in OSM is final truth. Often they reinforce existing good practices afterwards. By the way, Hamburg S-bahn doesn't conform PTv2. Also, additional tags (like light_rail=yes) may not contradict other tagging.As alternative to light_rail=yes I can offer to tag all Hamburg ... | |
| 70252498 by azakh-world @ 2019-05-14 20:52 ~ 6 years ago | 1 | ~ 6 years ago | Retired Account ♦104 | Hi,I don't think there is a need to remove the stop node even if the station is still under construction, because the node stop itself is already marked as under construction. |
| 2 | ~ 6 years ago | azakh-world | Hi.Your point is not devoid of logic, but as soon as it comes to real application, better to keep things as simple as possible.I know at least 3 really used tagging methods for stations under construction:1) railway=construction + construction=station2) railway=station + construction=yes3)... | |
| 3 | ~ 6 years ago | Retired Account ♦104 | In terms of relation, it will be preferable to just use another role (i.e. construction_stop) instead of role (stop) for the member node instead of deleting the node from the relation. By deleting off the node, it makes maintenance of such relations difficult.The node itself is already tagged wi... | |
| 67210888 by azakh-world @ 2019-02-14 23:34 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | Supaplex ♦11,282 | Why do you revert? --- Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/67210888 |
| 2 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | I left a comment to the reverted changeset. | |
| 66256521 by azakh-world @ 2019-01-12 17:57 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | Dakon ♦121 | Please revert this changeset, it's entirely wrong. S-Bahn Hannover uses normal trains, and on basically all tracks are also used by normal (freight) trains. Hint: even the Hamburg and Berlin S-Bahn systems are "real" trains, they just mostly operate on dedicated infrastructure. Hannov... |
| 2 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | Changeset https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/65955443has converted Hannover s-bahn routes from route=train to route=light_rail, so I've just brought things into consistent state. If anything needs to be reverted then we need to start with that change, right? | |
| 3 | ~ 7 years ago | Dakon ♦121 | Yes, thanks for bringing the other one to my attention. Please either revert both or tell me to do so. | |
| 4 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | I've reverted this changeset. 5955443 has been reverted by Nakaner-repair. | |
| 65381201 by azakh-world @ 2018-12-11 16:17 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | не знаю, что там Википедия, это не авторитетный источник, а на официальной схеме метро http://mosmetro.ru/metro-map/ это две отдельные станции. Аналогично все кроссплатформенные... |
| 2 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | Хорошо. Но всё же, где на указанном Вами сайте сказано, что там две отдельные станции? | |
| 3 | ~ 7 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | на официальной схеме метро, которая по ссылке, отмечены две станции. Ткнитесь в станцию на схеме - а потом сравните с другими, не кроссплатформенными | |
| 4 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | Посмотрел. В отличие от полноценных раздельных станций, кроссплатформенные имеют по две карточки с полностью или почти полностью совпадающим содержимым начиная о... | |
| 5 | ~ 7 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | я не занимаюсь тегами wikidata, это люди из Википедии продвигают и расставляют, мне они не сдались, и мне сложно понять, зачем они нужны. Обратитесь к ним. Кстати, в той же... | |
| 6 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | Отмечу, что я не хочу оставить одну станцию из двух, я хочу разобраться, почему сделано именно так как сделано и насколько это соответствует действительности. За сс... | |
| 7 | ~ 7 years ago | literan ♦7,062 | Вы же сами в источнике правки указали, что брали информацию из "Moscow metro scheme". А теперь когда я вам привожу сведения из схемы, вы вдруг считаете, что "ниоткуда н... | |
| 64832640 by azakh-world @ 2018-11-23 21:26 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | MatheusFormal ♦1 | Hello. I'm still a beginner at OSM, but in some parts of the beach line of my city, Itaipava, I noticed some mistakes. The line has surpassed some places where there is no beach like a rock that exists here. Sorry for misunderstanding, but is this necessary? |
| 2 | ~ 7 years ago | azakh-world | Hello.I saw your effort to separate sand from rocks. I fixed so that the coastline is a continuous not doubled line between the sea and the land. Is something wrong with the beach now?Look here https://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=64797336You moved a line towards the continent thinking ... | |
| 64832282 by azakh-world @ 2018-11-23 21:07 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | LeifRasmussen ♦88 | Thanks! |
| 64732834 by azakh-world @ 2018-11-21 09:50 ~ 7 years ago | 1 | ~ 7 years ago | viloan ♦9,905 | Bem-vindo(a) ao OpenStreetMap e parabéns pela sua primeira edição! :-)Temos um portal brasileiro sobre o OpenStreetMap, com várias informações úteis em https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/BrasilEnquanto você está se acostumando co... |