3 Changesets created by gseethar have been discussed with 6 replies of this OpenStreetMap Contributor
Changeset # ⏱️ Last updated Contributor Comment
89911558
by gseethar
@ 2020-08-25 11:23
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoskyper
♦871
Hi

How can you add access restrictions with only an imagery as source?

Who is your reviewer? Why did she/he not react?

Cheers skyper
2 ~ 5 years agogseethar Hello Skyper,
Apologies for late response. I was on long leave.
We did not add the access restriction only based on the imagery source. We have a driver who provided us with local ground reality, suggesting that it is a private road and hence edited it. let me know your view/suggestion.

Regards...
3 ~ 5 years agoskyper
♦871
Hi Ganesh

Please, tell me, why did you not add this source to the changeset with the date of "survey".

How was that information provided? Do you have photos? Is access=private correct or is it only (motor_)vehicle=private and some transportation modes like foot are allowed?

If I l...
4 ~ 5 years agogseethar Hi Skyper,

Since I did not personally survey the area, I was slightly skeptical about adding source as survey. Our driver had personally communicated this to us. It is a privately owned road with "residents only" access.
Coming to the routing island issue, since I was editing in near ...
90326059
by gseethar
@ 2020-09-02 22:46
~ 5 years ago
1 ~ 5 years agoskyper
♦871
How can you fix a oneway situation with only imagery as source?
2 ~ 5 years agogseethar Hello Skyper,

Apologies for the delay in response. I was on long leave.
In the above changeset, I have removed one-way for the small segment (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/751610238#map=19/37.83953/-121.25850&layers=N) as it was causing an island topology error.

Let me know if you h...
3 ~ 5 years agoskyper
♦871
Hey Ganesh

So, you were fixing which should have been noticed by the review ten month ago.

Still, I do not understand, why you did not simply cut off the small segment and add it to the "entrance" way from the west. Creating a new way was not necessary.

Why did not fix the routing...
4 ~ 5 years agogseethar Hi Skyper,

We apologize for our error and delay since this is an old edit it took time to investigate and identify the reasons for it. This instance is a sheer human error from both editor and reviewer. The editor had just newly joined our process while making this edit. We have passed on the wr...
5 ~ 5 years agogseethar Apologies for the typo in Change set. The actual change set is 91421675.
66565415
by gseethar
@ 2019-01-23 11:02
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agoyaswap
♦68
Hi,
What is the source of your edit?
2 ~ 7 years agogseethar Local knowledge. I personally know the area.

Regards,
Ganesh