5 Changesets created by samguer have been discussed with 8 replies of this OpenStreetMap Contributor
Changeset # ⏱️ Last updated Contributor Comment
63360897
by samguer
@ 2018-10-09 21:30
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agoabrensch
♦674
This edit is bullshit.

You reactivated a razed:highway at a construction site and did not even connect it.
2 ~ 7 years agosamguer abrensch, my apologies, I must not have been zoomed in enough to notice that segment (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/98309825) was in fact connected to (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/250807036). I thought it was connected to (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/250807031#map=19/49.00563/8.41037...
3 ~ 7 years agoMitteloberrheinischerWaldameisenschreck
♦65
even though it's connected now, it's still bullshit, because it does not exist in reality ...
4 ~ 7 years agoMitteloberrheinischerWaldameisenschreck
♦65
It's a construction area ...:
https://www.ka-news.de/verkehr/webcams-karlsruhe/Webcam-Kriegsstrasse-westlich-Mendelssohnplatz;art168,1967357
https://www.ka-news.de/verkehr/webcams-karlsruhe/Webcam-Kriegsstrasse-oestlich-Mendelssohnplatz;art168,1967358
5 ~ 7 years agosamguer Sorry, I saw the Mapillary street level imagery and thought that would be reliable evidence to make this edit on. It said 2017, i thought it would be recent enough, I was wrong. Thank you for the link about the construction, sorry for the trouble.

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=ZgwiAYkD3J59n...
6 ~ 7 years agoNakaner
♦3,208
@samguer

Please look at the tag list of every OSM object before you start modifying it. The iD editor you use is not suitable for your task because it hides the list of tags in the bottom left of the window.

The way in question had razed:highway=* without highway=* which is a sign for any mapp...
7 ~ 7 years agosamguer @Nakaner

I agree entirely, I was not trying to argue against what has been said here. I was only trying to explain I made my edit in good faith that it was supported with evidence I saw. I was wrong, and created trouble for people. I should have been more thorough when making the edit.

We try ...
62807783
by samguer
@ 2018-09-21 19:07
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agoBrian@Brea
♦45
tram line is incorrect as that tag relates to train vehicles, not road vehicles [trailway=tram]. This way has been corrected
2 ~ 7 years agosamguer Sorry, I miss understood the use of that road attribution, thank you for following up with my edit.
62860152
by samguer
@ 2018-09-23 19:52
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agondm
♦889
That's what GPS is for :-)
2 ~ 7 years agosamguer Agreed, I wish I had some, OSM has the GPS traces layer but it is not clear enough to reflect the massive development, ton of buildings added.

http://www2.uwe.ac.uk/services/Marketing/students/pdf/Accommodation%20information/Wallscourt_Park.pdf
61513508
by samguer
@ 2018-08-09 21:13
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agoToniE
♦1,263
Hi samguer,

I see your point here.
4 years ago, I tagged the service road that leads to and from the ligt_gate w/o access=no/private/....
Seems that your Navi tries to route you directly to the lift_gate (behind the gate it is motor_vehicle=private) on way 265849909. But isn't the access t...
2 ~ 7 years agosamguer Hello Toni,

I was following the openstreemap wiki:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:access%3Dno

"a road tagged access=no and psv=yes generally withdraws any legal right of way but permits public service vehicles. A routing program in psv mode may use this way."

The Navi...
3 ~ 7 years agoToniE
♦1,263
Hi Sam,

You're welcome.

Let's separate the discussion about Schindlerplatz and the round about.

- Schindlerplatz is on public grounds and access is not allowed for motor vehicles by traffic signs.

- the round about is on private grounds owned by the real estate owner of the sit...
4 ~ 7 years agosamguer Toni,

-Wow, what an explanation. Thanks, so clear now, I see what happened. I see why it is tagged the way so, I will revert back my changes. I think we need to look at how we treat motor_vehicle=private tag internally.

-For more context, when we make deliveries, if a route is motor_vehicle=p...
5 ~ 7 years agoToniE
♦1,263
Hi Sam,

sorry for the delay ... UTC+2 here and your time zone?

The pleasure was also on my side.
Please go ahead, I don't mind if you do the changes.

Best regards
Toni


BTW: way 265849958 should have full access for all - another aspect of splitting:
bicyclists comming from the ...
61514535
by samguer
@ 2018-08-09 22:14
~ 7 years ago
1 ~ 7 years agoToniE
♦1,263
Hi samguer,

that's correct now. Bavaria DOP80 and BING are outdated. These ramps have been closed and replaced by the ramps in the west. During the rebuild of the bridge here, they have been temporarily reopened but are closed now again.
The two fly-overs and roundabouts of M3 and B471 (SE ...
2 ~ 7 years agosamguer Yeah, sorry for the map noise, they should be back to how they were before I made the changes. I acted too soon before doing all the research. Thanks for the follow up.