4 changesets created by Chezfisto have been discussed with 3 replies of this contributor
Changeset # Tmstmp UTC Contributor Comment
54910082
by Chezfisto
@ 2017-12-25 15:37
12018-01-05 16:15neuhausr
♦331
Hi, I'm wondering why you've disconnected the sidewalks from the streets?
22018-01-05 16:24Chezfisto I felt that it looked strange, like the sidewalk was extending into the middle of the street. I can add them back if that's how it should be mapped.
32018-01-05 16:39neuhausr
♦331
I think that's the convention for areas like this, it's especially useful for routing. More info here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Sidewalks#Sidewalk_as_separate_way
42018-01-05 17:07Chezfisto Okay thanks, going through now adding them back as street crossings
48234841
by Chezfisto
@ 2017-04-28 17:33
12017-05-08 14:29neuhausr
♦331
Hi, looking at the Amery Golf Club (https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/7145495) I think you've misunderstood golf course tagging. Most importantly, you do not need to create that include all features in a golf course--the outline of leisure=golf_course should surround all these features. An...
47162651
by Chezfisto
@ 2017-03-25 21:05
12017-04-11 15:15neuhausr
♦331
Welcome to OSM! I notice that in these edits you've tried to create "islands" in landuse areas in the wrong way. You should be using multipolygon relations. See http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:multipolygon on the wiki for a description, and the Relations section of the iD ...
22017-04-12 04:25Chezfisto Okay thanks. I think I fixed some of them. I understood making "islands" by merging two things together. Should I be doing that for two bordering areas (like forest and wetland) or only if one totally encompasses the other. (Sorry, all the code stuff on the wiki confused me)
32017-04-12 14:26neuhausr
♦331
I think that's better. I'd just use the "merge" for areas contained by other areas. If there are adjacent areas with the same tag, I think you need to merge them more manually. In case it helps, I did a couple others (the ponds N of 100th and W of 143rd, the island in the N end o...
46914693
by Chezfisto
@ 2017-03-17 01:20
12017-03-28 08:31Spanholz
♦398
Nice accurate mapping!