| Changeset |
No. |
Date |
Contributor |
Comment |
|
| 49281909 | abDoug | Your group as done an abysmal job of adding Dollarama stores. This particular one isn't even remotely close to the correct province. Those that are in the right city do not conform to OSM standards for tagging. Most stores in Calgary already existed, carefully placed and identified. |
|
| 47847344 | abDoug | none of the things you have tagged as "meadow" on the U of C campus or elsewhere in Capitol Hill are meadows according to OSM documentation |
| Rafee Hoque | My apologies. Should it be 'Grass' instead? I was confused because the grass in these regions don't seem as short or consistent compared to the more well-maintained portions on campus. Hence, I thought the 'Meadow' designation would suffice. It also states that, 'Many meadows would eventually become... |
|
| 48355111 | abDoug | Why have you placed level crossings connecting RR tracks to roads where either the roads are mapped as tunnels or the tracks are on bridges? (at Mcleod Trail & CP tracks) This is yet another case of incompetence of the telenav crew. |
| arming_telenav | Thanks for the feedback. I've identified what you are referring to (it was an issue regarding validation tool) and I will keep an eye out for any more of these cases. |
|
| 47830981 | abDoug | Throughout the city, pathways designated as "regional" by the City are mapped as cycle paths with foot = yes & cycle = yes. Pathways designated by the City as "local" are mapped as foot paths with foot = yes and cycle = yes. |
|
| 48323376 | florinbadita_telenav | Hi Doug, can you be more specific about the problem/s that you are referring.From what i have seen in this changeset, the only difference is that the names are expanded. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Abbreviation_.28don.27t_do_it.29If this is a local rule you should specify it... |
| Viajero Perdido | The suffixes (NW, SW, etc.) are how the City of Calgary spells the names, same with Edmonton. The OSM wiki pages for Calgary and Edmonton use NW, SW, etc. in their examples; the latter page is more explicit than Calgary's with naming examples.So NW is literally correct, and "Northwest"... |
| iandees | Hi Viajero. Please check your language and be more kind to others participating in OpenStreetMap. We're all trying to make the map better, and responding like that isn't really helping anyone. |
| iandees | (Same to you, abDoug) |
| abDoug | Names that are just plain wrong! |
| abDoug | They are not making the map better, they are making it worse! Yes, I'm pissed off. I've put a great deal of work into the map and I do it very carefully and try very hard to be accurate. The telenav crew has showed up, presumably because they have some financial interest, repeatedly name roads incor... |
| iandees | All of that might be true, but you only make yourself (and our map project) look bad and keep people from listening to your opinion when you use such negative and insulting language. If you had responded with something like "hi there, I think your changes are incorrect. here's a link to the cit... |
| abDoug | THE ISSUE IS NOT THE SUFFIXES! - though that could have been avoided if the editors had bothered to look the map over for a few minutes before editing. The issue is that the telenav crew has applied completely incorrect names to roads all over the city.I really don't care if I make your map proj... |
|
| 47978555 | abDoug | Thanks for doing the spiffy pedestrian streets in Shouldice Park. Do do you know anything about accessibility of new washroom? They appear to be open only when "events" are on. I've been by them lots of times, but I usually go by before 6 AM and even those by the pool are closed that early... |
| JamesBadger | I took a look around last evening, and I added more info in this changeset: http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/48443265. The washrooms are in a fenced off area, and if the gates are closed then they are inaccessible. I assume they are locked when the gates are locked.The Change Rooms next to... |
|
| 47196608 | abDoug | added road name and an error - if you can't do things correctly GO AWAY! |
|
| 47095525 | abDoug | wrong name on Panorama Hills Rise - putting wrong name on road is worse than it having no name! |
|
| 47198067 | abDoug | wrongly named 66 Street SE |
| abDoug | By what authority is the connector between east-bound 76 Avenue SE and south-bound 68 Street SE named "76 Avenue SE"? The City of Calgary does not apply names to these connectors. Even if it is accepted that it should have a name, why is it named 76 Avenue and not 68 Street? |
| lorandr_telenav | Thanks for the feedback, i corected. |
|
| 47007538 | abDoug | added wrong road name; has been fixedIt would be appreciated if the telenav crew would quit doing things WRONG all over Calgary! |
| arming_telenav | Thanks for the feedback. I've started double checking all the road names from Calgary that have been mapped by us. |
|
| 47097843 | abDoug | area tagged as water park - this is not a water park according to OSM documentation |
|
| 47009278 | abDoug | Fix the quadrant suffixes to conform to standard used in Calgary |
| arming_telenav | Thanks for the feedback, I've corrected the suffixes to conform to Calgary standards |
|
| 46430817 | abDoug | I've changed this to foot path with tags bicycle = yes (dubious, probably should be dismount), foot = yes & surface = asphalt. Pedestrian street is normally used only for large areas (see Tuscany LRT stn) or wide "streets" such as Stephen Avenue. See OSM documentation.Most of these... |
| wonderstar | Thank you, abDoug. I am still learning. This is a brand new development area (with Auburn Glen Close) with houses still under construction and others lived in. The path is about 2.5 meters wide, has a board fence on each side and a post in each end to prevent cars from passing. It didn't seem like ... |
|
| 45567162 | abDoug | what is the source for this name? |
|
| 45579750 | abDoug | the area shown as Spruce Meadows Off Leash Dog Park is not shown as such on City of Calgary off-leash area map |
| David Anderson Lam | Looks like it was actually closed in preparation of the SW Calgary Ring Road. |
|
| 47069072 | abDoug | You are adding road names without the numeric prefixes used by the City of Calgary. Clearly you know nothing about Calgary! |
| abDoug | you have applied incorrect names to roads! |
| arming_telenav | Thanks for your feedback. My dataset for road name is from Canvec where there are no numeric prefixes in this area. Could you please highlight which ways are wrong? |
|
| 46274110 | abDoug | Quadrant suffixes used in Calgary are NW, NE, SW & SE. It is WAAAY past time the entire telenav crew learned how to do things properly. I am very close to asking OSM to ban all telenav editors from Calgary permanently. I sick of cleaning up your messes! |
| simonap_telenav | Hi,We used Canvec as data source for road name editing and the quadrant suffixes aren't abbreviated there. Thanks for your feedback, we modified them and from now on we'll use NW, NE, SW & SE form for quadrant suffixes. |
|
| 47044210 | abDoug | The quadrant suffixes used in Calgary are NW, NE, SW & SE, not "Northwest" etc. If you are going to edit in a city you know nothing about, take the time to learn what the standard has long been here |
| arming_telenav | Thanks for the feedback. I used the suffix Northwest because this is how the road name in mapped in Canvec, but I will keep in mind that NW, NE, SW & SE is the standard in Calgary. |
|
| 45514730 | abDoug | do not change the quadrant suffix for roads in Calgary to "Northwest", etc - pay attention to how things are done throughout the city before deciding your way is the right way! |
|
| 46575658 | abDoug | you have mangled schools done according to a standard used across the city!The building gets only street name and number. All other details including school name attach to the grounds.Please look around and get some clues as to how things are done before going in and editing! |
| shellguard | I'm sorry, it wasn't clear as some of objects here aren't marked at all comparing to Europe. Should I delete my change or it will be rejected? |
|
| 46575803 | abDoug | Details attach to school grounds, not school buildings. The only details a school building should have are street name and number. |
|
| 45581040 | abDoug | many of the features identified as footpaths (e.g. on Silvergrove Court, Sg Manor, Sg Gardens) are not paths at all but simply concrete curbs |
|
| 45775774 | abDoug | You have mangled the intersection of Stoney Trail and Sarcee Trail NW. Put it back the way it was.You are also slopping "implied turn restrictions" all over Calgary. Cite the Alberta law to support that these turn restrictions are valid. |
|
| 44278643 | abDoug | If you are going to add missing road names, please do it properly in a manner consistent with the way names are done in the locale. |
|
| 44365268 | abDoug | added WRONG missing name |
| abDoug | and another with wrong name - roads with wrong names are worse than roads with no name! |
| petrar_telenav | I have added the names from local data (Canvec) and Geobase Roads layer. If you have other local knowledge, please be kind add them correctly. |
|
| 39485772 | kartler175 | Please connect highways at https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4200170793 to enable correct routing http://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=osrm_car&route=51.05173%2C-114.05508%3B51.05806%2C-114.07009#map=15/51.0537/-114.0704. |
| abDoug | If I did this in the changes, it certainly wasn't intentional. I may have deleted a node that connected Centre St directly to Memorial Drive (would be very messy if you followed a route that relied on that connection without question!), without realizing that it also connect two segments in tunnel. |
| abDoug | There is something else very strange going on here. If I move the destination to west-bound Memorial just east of Crowchild Tr. & the start to west-bound Memorial just west of of the tunnel under Centre St, osrm_car finds a strange route but mapzen_car finds the appropriate route. Neither will w... |