Copyright © Pascal Neis (neis-one.org) - Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (Data is updated every 30 min) - See latest OSM discussions - Legend: Discussion without an answer - RSS feed - Show only discussions without an answer
Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
50216829 by
VictorIE		12018-09-20 14:32:30 UTCStereo I'm delighted to see I'm not the only one interested in Inishtrahull :)
22018-09-20 19:34:30 UTCVictorIE :)
56461950 by
SK53		12018-09-11 09:33:29 UTCVictorIE Is all of this way a stream? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/302619386#map=15/55.2148/-7.0136
22018-09-11 15:51:23 UTCSK53 Good spot. No looking at the aerial imagery it probably is not (also comparing with GSGS 4136). I suspect I added the stream tag before I cut the way into pieces. It is certainly a stream where it goes under the R241 and the upper road, as I ground surveyed those locations). I've removed the stream ...
32018-09-11 17:03:37 UTCVictorIE Cool.
61920131 by
Ards Man		12018-09-09 08:24:47 UTCVictorIE Some of the roads in this junction aren't joined up. :)
61129771 by
TheEpicWaffle		12018-08-12 14:52:41 UTCVictorIE Hi, just checking if this is correctly tagged as a power line https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/611665813
61159071 by
Jean-Pierre Rondeau		12018-07-30 00:31:44 UTCVictorIE I'm not sure if calling each of these buildings: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/611966569#map=18/52.42482/-8.19096 a guest house: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:tourism=guest_house is accurate.
60972898 by
BCNorwich		12018-07-23 10:25:17 UTCVictorIE https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/609983359

Is this a highway=corridor ?

22018-07-23 10:26:23 UTCVictorIE Never mind, I see you raised the same query. :)
59468774 by
gmcternan		12018-07-15 12:18:33 UTCVictorIE Are these traffic lights correct? It seems an odd location for them.

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5656951185
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5656951187
22018-07-16 16:28:32 UTCgmcternan Right you are!
Not sure how they got there,
thanks for the heads up.
32018-07-16 17:30:04 UTCVictorIE Cool. :)
60310351 by
VictorIE		12018-07-05 15:19:14 UTCAA_NP Hi there
I am not 100% sure that the new coding for the M50 from the motorway roundabout eastbound is correct. The signs show it as the R139 (June 2017). There is no reason why this section should be coded as motorway - can you verify with current and up to date road signs please? Thanks
22018-07-05 21:24:17 UTCVictorIE Ultimately, unless you want to double back, it only leads to motorways. The "motorway ahead" sign is east of the Bewley's (Clayton Hotel) roundabout.

To be honest, the situation / signage is a bit of a shambles, with a mix of blue, green and white signage in use. The roads schedule, lik...
32018-07-06 08:09:17 UTCAA_NP Thank you for your reply and all the information you have supplied. It does look inconsistent in the signing. This one here looks to be clear showing it as motorway - https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@53.4103644,-6.2160402,3a,75y,265.04h,89.26t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRgzQaQ039Nv3r3U29tJcAg!2e0!7i13312!8i...
46449340 by
Dafo43		12018-06-19 07:55:37 UTCVictorIE landuse=forest needs relation for https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/263471384 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/264634167
58172738 by
Dafo43		12018-05-10 00:28:47 UTCVictorIE This seems to have a corrupt tag: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/407698767

(new tag)=Serough Island
22018-05-10 09:27:27 UTCDafo43 fixed
32018-05-10 11:02:08 UTCVictorIE Cool. I would have fixed it, but thought you want want to know how it came about. :)
42018-05-11 10:14:42 UTCDafo43 It's just the default null value in Potlatch, so usually if you select the first letter it will autofill the value.
52018-05-11 13:00:07 UTCVictorIE Ah, ID doesn't allow blank tags.
58748263 by
CrushedSoul		12018-05-08 06:19:01 UTCVictorIE Is this lake accurate? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/585651249
22018-05-08 11:10:06 UTCCrushedSoul Hi VictorIE

It is not accurate. We used to have the river in the Pokémon game, but eversince OSM, it's been gone. I'm just fiddling around a bit, to see if we can get it back. I'm using the area around the park to test with
33643374 by
Easky30		12018-04-28 01:02:22 UTCVictorIE Is this https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3718519988 a public library? Not listed here: http://www.fingalcoco.ie/community-and-leisure/libraries/find-a-library-and-check-opening-hours/
27756392 by
brianboru		12018-04-23 12:00:01 UTCVictorIE I think this https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/4434330 should be "Castle Farm" the problem arising from the edge of a map being cropped and the "C" being missing from the 1:25k background map.
22018-04-24 08:18:35 UTCbrianboru Thanks for spotting this error. Please go ahead and correct it ( and any others like this you come across - no need to go through changeset comments for my edits - I'm not precious about them)
40158904 by
Bob Harper		12018-04-16 14:17:34 UTCVictorIE In https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/426140344 should

access=p be access=private?
57567979 by
gaoithe		12018-03-28 23:48:40 UTCVictorIE Are you happy with this way? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/573606000 It seems to not match the overhead photos and duplicates other ways
53885651 by
THE_Chris		12018-03-28 09:33:26 UTCVictorIE Is the section of deleted road correct? this image seems to indicate it should be 50-100 metres further north. https://www.rte.ie/news/dublin/2018/0328/950576-road-dublin/

It seems from the photo it is open for pedestrians and cyclist.
56723721 by
Dafo43		12018-03-17 22:35:39 UTCVictorIE Could you take a look at this https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/273446650#map=16/53.3142/-6.2871 ?

thanks
22018-03-18 11:28:20 UTCDafo43 should be fixed now
33903917 by
VictorIE		12018-01-31 15:30:24 UTCKDDA What is this - https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/162476851#map=18/53.45747/-6.24083
22018-01-31 17:47:44 UTCVictorIE Possibly changed by https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/55935823#map=15/53.4569/-6.2417 when a mouse had a spasm.
51306995 by
SJ_IRL		12018-01-22 05:02:58 UTCVictorIE Is this a Civil Defence or Defence Forces training area?

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/517317566
50484297 by
Teester		12018-01-22 04:10:24 UTCVictorIE Hi, what is this relation? https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/7411709

The rest of Luas has operator=Luas - Transdev Dublin Light Rail Limited

Note that operator is the system operator, not the tram driver. With Luas, the system operator is complicated enough to include both names.
22018-01-23 16:55:05 UTCTeester It's a network relation. A super-relation for route masters. It's suggested in JOSM as an option, but I don't think it's an approved relation type on the wiki (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relations/Proposed/Network), but it's used in several cities. I have one for Dublin Bus as well which ...
55360045 by
VictorIE		12018-01-18 18:42:04 UTCuser_5359 Hello, You add to https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3169166666/history a " (MOVED)" to the key name, want does this mean? If the business moved to an other address, please add the prefix disused: to the main keys.

I am also interest on maning of contact:dx (used on https://www.openstre...
22018-01-18 19:59:12 UTCVictorIE I took some photos as I went by on a bus. There have been several changes in the businesses along Arran Quay. I will need to go back and confirm the changes.

I understand KOD Lyons have moved, but I want to be sure. I don't want to delete them and not add the new location / only to have to restor...
52418952 by
westprt		12018-01-12 18:48:42 UTCVictorIE Marked as both bicycle_parking and cycleway?
50415421 by
RinIRL		12017-12-22 01:45:05 UTCVictorIE Hi,

The water here: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/508793701#map=16/53.1224/-6.7339 seesm to be grossly over-stated. If you zoom in on the 'DigitalGlobe Premium Imagery', it shows the streams as quite modest.
41632559 by
VictorIE		12017-12-19 00:10:29 UTCKDDA Why is this multipolygon tagged as a building?
22017-12-19 00:12:54 UTCKDDA Also, the address should not be Aghadrumsee, it is just the name of the club, not the actual location. The townland is actually Cortrasna.
32017-12-19 21:25:54 UTCVictorIE "Why is this multipolygon tagged as a building?" - possibly because the ID Editor defaults leisure=sports_centre to be buildings and I didn't notice. If I remember correctly, I edited dozens of GAA clubs that day,

Address - I used to be zealous on adding addresses, have calmed down sinc...
46918041 by
VictorIE		12017-12-15 12:44:33 UTCrorym 🏳️‍🌈 You left some untagged ways here https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/235543455 https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/235543453#map=19/53.33074/-6.26178

What's going on with them? Maybe best to just delete the ways if the buildings are gone...
22017-12-17 02:37:44 UTCVictorIE Thanks for noting this. Fixed :)

They're demolished buildings. I wanted to note that they were demolished to prevent them being re-mapped.
52652975 by
Dafo43		12017-10-21 01:19:36 UTCVictorIE Could you check these two:

http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/530060414#map=19/53.29516/-6.23789 - zero area landuse.

http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/530063748#map=17/53.29335/-6.23646 Taney -> Taney Estate? Not all 'Taney; highways included.

:)
52497510 by
VictorIE		12017-10-03 14:25:09 UTCHarald Hartmann Hello VictorIE. It's me again ;-)
http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/528907370
`contact:flikr` instead of `contact:flickr`
#typo
22017-10-03 14:44:29 UTCVictorIE :(

:)
46106153 by
weralesniak		12017-10-03 10:33:48 UTCVictorIE Is this line defunct? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/363908732
52130533 by
VictorIE		12017-09-20 17:30:45 UTCHarald Hartmann Hello VictorIE. At http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5112030988 you have tagged `contact:pintrest` instead of `contact:pinterest`, right? And if you have a look at http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:contact you see, that you could (although pinterest isn't mentioned there) use only the username ...
22017-09-23 13:34:37 UTCVictorIE Hi,

Typing error related to not knowing the correct spelling. :) Error fixed.

VictorIE
51780738 by
Stabilo_boss		12017-09-19 18:25:34 UTCVictorIE Wasn't the Camp Field (section south of Old Youghal Road) sold off?
22017-09-20 07:17:34 UTCStabilo_boss It's still in Defence Forces Possession, The Housing was
supposed to be handed over to Cork City Council for Social Housing. but no move yet.
43503259 by
g sumithra		12017-04-19 09:58:21 UTCVictorIE This appears to be on the wrong continent.
22017-09-16 23:06:24 UTCVictorIE Deleted
33061607 by
brianh		12017-09-16 20:07:47 UTCVictorIE This appears to be a duplicate of the river: http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/363692578
40120745 by
g&co		12017-09-16 03:32:53 UTCVictorIE Could you check the paths around the lake?

source=GPS
surface=Bing - this seems incorrect.
51072240 by
Teester		12017-09-05 12:49:57 UTCVictorIE Duplicate ways here:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515121896
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515123278
22017-09-07 11:57:32 UTCVictorIE Duplicate ways:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515121882
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515123264
32017-09-08 23:41:21 UTCTeester I've deleted the duplicate Route 27A relations in changesets #51866689 and #51866735.
42017-09-09 01:12:50 UTCVictorIE Thanks. I didn't want to break things! :)
52017-09-15 17:26:45 UTCVictorIE Could you check these two?

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515121887
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/515123269

Thanks
51922100 by
VictorIE		12017-09-11 15:19:09 UTCHarald Hartmann Hello VictorIE. At http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4454170327 you have introduced some new (undocumented) keys (`googleplus`, `soundcloud`, etc.), which has a smell of SEO. So be careful with that ;-) #newkey
22017-09-11 16:06:02 UTCHarald Hartmann or move it all to the `contact`-namespace (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:contact)
32017-09-11 19:31:20 UTCVictorIE Both methods seem to be in use, e.g. with Facebook:

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:facebook

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:contact:facebook
25428036 by
GoalkeeperJ		12017-09-09 23:41:55 UTCVictorIE What does this line represent? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/303287754
31517703 by
NoelB		12017-09-02 01:06:17 UTCVictorIE This looks like a duplicate of the townland boundary: http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/349333803
22017-09-02 01:06:49 UTCVictorIE Oh, that said, this line appears to be correct - townland boundary slightly off
618318 by
mapryan		12017-08-30 16:54:56 UTCVictorIE Does this road exist? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/29257244
22017-08-30 21:05:54 UTCmapryan Victor, you're right. I'll go ahead and remove it. Thanks,. Mike
50697544 by
CoubazRemy		12017-08-29 11:03:06 UTCVictorIE Is this line a duplicate? https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/260655142
50814708 by
brianh		12017-08-28 10:39:08 UTCVictorIE Can you check the tags on http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/512633011 ? :)
50591504 by
Jord5792		12017-08-27 16:10:58 UTCVictorIE The connection between the N52 and Main Street seems to be missing. Has the layout of Emmet Square changed?

22017-08-29 10:44:50 UTCJord5792 Yes it has changed. They removed the straight connection between N52 and Main street, creating a one way road from Green St./The Green (R439) to MainSt. in front of the Garda Station and a two way from N52 to MainSt. in front of Doolys Hotel. A pedestrian area was made around the statue there.
50391952 by
MacLondon		12017-08-24 22:11:02 UTCVictorIE The edit to this way: http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/419502785 seems to have broken the bus / cycle connection from St. Stephen's Green East to Leeson Street Lower
22017-08-25 00:33:27 UTCMacLondon Thanks. I think I have now resolved this issue.
49288104 by
LateNightTone		12017-06-24 10:21:20 UTCVictorIE Instead of

bridge=low_water_crossing

would

ford=yes

be more appropriate? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:ford
22017-06-24 20:29:01 UTCLateNightTone Hi VictorIE, no a ford wouldn't be appropriate here as it is a tidal body of water, so the crossing can only be made at low tide. The highway is covered at any other time. A ford is only where a waterway i.e. flowing river is to be crossed, so the highway would be passable in all but flood condition...
49407705 by
Joey Seth		12017-06-20 12:35:13 UTCVictorIE When doing pedestrian crossings and other road ways, do make sure that they join up with adjacent roads. :) The geometry and Routing layers here: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/ are good tools.
48336286 by
TimLynch		12017-06-20 04:35:06 UTCVictorIE Is a right turn allowed from Saint Michael's Drive to the R852?
22017-06-23 08:50:50 UTCTimLynch Sorry, don't know
49527802 by
rorym 🏳️‍🌈		12017-06-14 17:25:17 UTCVictorIE Cool
43771281 by
VictorIE		12017-04-16 15:21:42 UTCKDDA Hi Victor, where did you source the voltage for this line?

It is definitely 33kV or more and I would not class it as a minor line in any sense. Please take a look at it on StreetView https://goo.gl/maps/4o5g4R7v1Kp
22017-04-16 18:50:16 UTCVictorIE This one? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/444670138

I don't have a specific recollection. Importantly, it only connects to a 110kV substation at one end.

It seems to be consistent with: http://www.nienetworks.co.uk/documents/Connections/Networkmap_33kv.aspx and http://smartgriddashboard.eirgr...
32017-04-16 23:08:48 UTCKDDA NIE/ESB have done a lot of work on this line, I think it joins two 110kV substations now and is designed as a "bypass" around Enniskillen.
45138255 by
Ards Man		12017-03-26 05:08:41 UTCVictorIE Is Newtownards Exchange NINT a BT telephone exchange?
46659194 by
VictorIE		12017-03-08 22:26:30 UTCPolarbear Victor, when reverting CS 46496897 with the boundary splitting, I had to include your CS here in the revert.
I attempted to restore useful stuff from both CSs, you might doublecheck.
It would be a good idea to do repairs and own additions in separate CSs, though.
22017-03-08 23:47:28 UTCVictorIE Fair point. I've done a quick tidy up.

I was only drawn to the area by the newly disconnected road of a previous changeset.
32017-03-09 13:11:23 UTCPolarbear Thanks, and no criticism from my side. Reverting is a race against time, as lots of people do small fixes quickly.
Thus just the recommendation when fixing something, upload, before doing regular refinements and uploading them.
46496897 by
WernerP		12017-03-07 18:16:35 UTCVictorIE Again main road split from side road: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/299490794
22017-03-08 19:59:40 UTCPolarbear @VictorIE: those will be fixed automatically when I revert the incorrect boundary line separations.
32017-03-08 22:30:34 UTCPolarbear Full revert in CS 46692924 for incorrectly separating roads+waterways serving as border member; restoring useful additions in 46693197, refinements in 46693752.
46483415 by
WernerP		12017-03-07 18:14:26 UTCVictorIE Hi,

Can you just be careful when splitting boundaries and roads that you don't disconnect roads? This road: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/104377544 became split from the R357.

VictorIE
41490163 by
VictorIE		12017-02-09 11:49:37 UTCKDDA Why did you add the street name as Lacky Road?
22017-02-09 12:45:16 UTCVictorIE Is that not the road it is on? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/114282636#map=16/54.2318/-7.2600
41502741 by
VictorIE		12016-08-17 06:32:27 UTCmanoharuss Hi VictorIE,

Your contributions to OpenStreetMap are greatly appreciated. I looked through this changeset along with your other changesets 41465760, 41488327, 41488458 to understand what happened here. The wiki for tagging power stations is here(http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:power%3Dsta...
22016-08-17 08:03:32 UTCVictorIE Hi,

Apologies for the unorthodox method. I've been removing deprecated tags and names. For example:

http://stat.latlon.org/ie/latest/tags-o.html lists operator=ESB (154), operator=ESB Generation and Wholesale Markets (21), operator=ESB Networks (394), operator=ESB Telecoms (3), operator=ESB ec...
32016-08-17 08:27:05 UTCVictorIE http://stat.latlon.org/ has updated. I'll get to work. :)
42016-08-18 13:33:15 UTCVictorIE I'm working on the last set and it should be gone today
38185952 by
VictorIE		12016-03-31 07:45:37 UTCKDDA Is disused the correct tagging for this section? This section has been restored, complete with a train carriage and crossing gates.
22016-03-31 10:11:49 UTCVictorIE From https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:railway%3Ddisused "A section of railway which is no longer used but where the track and infrastructure remain in place."

I can only image "used" should be construed as "used for transport" or a **mobile** museum piece, no...
26646130 by
VictorIE		12015-11-07 16:23:40 UTCPolarbear Hi VictorIE, do you have further details about this club, and who it operates? Would you know if it targets children, juveniles, or both? Is there a website for the club?
22015-11-07 19:38:25 UTCVictorIE I know nothing of it. I only got the details from passing by on the bus. you might try http://www.cdysb.ie/ - they might know something. Google doesn't throw up much, but it seems to have been around for a long time.

Alternatively, I presume the city council housing department is their landlord.
33534460 by
VictorIE		12015-10-25 12:17:44 UTCPolarbear sport=gaelic_football is deprecated. As your changeset comment already suggest, the correct tagging is sport=gaelic_games + gaelic_games:hurling=yes
gaelic_games:football=yes

This also avoids using unsupported keys as "sport_1".
22015-10-25 15:35:23 UTCVictorIE If you look at http://stat.latlon.org/ie/latest/tags-s.html there are 9 "GAA" or "gaelic" tags in use. Last month there had been about 20. I did my best to rationalise them.
32015-10-25 19:30:01 UTCPolarbear Nice. But your goal should be sport=gaelic_games. If you change a freestyle tag into a deprecated one, it would have to be corrected again by somebody else.

Question again, is iD proposing gaelic_football? If so, we would need to file a bug report with iD.
33975213 by
VictorIE		12015-10-25 12:48:41 UTCPolarbear sport=gaelic_football is deprecated. The correct tagging is sport=gaelic_games + gaelic_games:hurling=yes
gaelic_games:football=yes
etc.

See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:sport%3Dgaelic_games
22015-10-25 15:32:04 UTCVictorIE If you look at http://stat.latlon.org/ie/latest/tags-s.html there are 9 "GAA" or "gaelic" tags in use. Last month there had been about 20. I did my best to rationalise them.
33534431 by
VictorIE		12015-10-25 12:53:13 UTCPolarbear I've seen the deprecated sport=gaelic_football coming mostly from iD and Potlatch users. Could there be an outdated preset in iD?
22015-10-25 15:30:57 UTCVictorIE If you look at http://stat.latlon.org/ie/latest/tags-s.html there are 9 "GAA" or "gaelic" tags in use. Last month there had been about 20. I did my best to rationalise them.
34416216 by
VictorIE		12015-10-05 14:30:37 UTCVincent de Phily Sorry, I don't agree with that change (healthcare:speciality -> health:speciality).

The heathcare:speciality tag is the documented one and used 7613 times, vs 6 times for health:speciality.

Please revert that change, unless you have a very convincing argument to transition obkects to the he...
22015-10-05 15:27:37 UTCVictorIE You're correct, my apologies. I was correct a group of mis-spelling sand seem to have put int he wrong spelling. Will sort this evening.
VictorIE has contributed to 59 changeset discussions(s) with a total of 113 comment(s)