Changeset No. Date Contributor Comment
12017-06-19 18:59:24 UTCSanniu Not connected footpaths are useless for pedestrian routing, can you connect them to surrounding streets where appropriate, as you seems to have local knowledge?
22017-06-20 11:59:14 UTCYaron Giat Hi,
This is a footpath that have a dead end with a pond in the end of it. It doesn't connected to any surrounding streets.
32017-06-20 12:01:59 UTCSanniu Can you map a pond too, for map completeness? :)
And other paths in this park? As I see no path here is connected to the outside world...
12017-06-18 19:08:14 UTCSwiftFast KKL should be short_name:he
22017-06-18 19:08:43 UTCSwiftFast More specifically:
short_name:en = kkl
shor_name:he = קק"ל
32017-06-19 08:04:33 UTCSanniu ok, thx, fixed
12017-06-19 08:02:42 UTCSanniu looks very strange...
12017-06-19 07:55:35 UTCSanniu - unconnected foot-way does not help to pedestrian routing. Can you connect it to nearby streets where appropriate?
12017-06-18 11:39:19 UTCSanniu - מעלה כנען or גבעת שושנה?
22017-06-18 11:52:07 UTCzstadler Fixed.
גבעת שושנה is a different node.
12017-06-18 11:28:44 UTCSanniu - is it כפר ערבי or כפר עברי?
12017-06-18 09:59:06 UTCSanniu - Is it Gal'ed or Even Yitshaq as primary name? There is mix in Hebrew names here.
12017-06-18 09:30:01 UTCSanniu The OpenStreetMap is not a private note storage, lease do not add such data here.
12017-06-18 08:56:55 UTCSanniu Kfar Ganim or Kfar Ganim A?
22017-06-23 19:36:30 UTCYnhockey I think the neighborhoods are labeled separately in Hebrew: כפר גנים א, ב, ג. Should be reflected in English, I suppose.
12017-06-18 08:47:46 UTCSanniu - is it חתוכה סעדיה or העצמאות?
12017-06-18 08:32:26 UTCSanniu - is it קרן היסוד or מבצע יהונתן?
12017-06-15 09:55:43 UTCSanniu - should it be marked as peak or similar?
22017-06-15 11:05:50 UTCzstadler Frankly, I do not remember.
12017-06-15 09:52:32 UTCSanniu - foot-way not connected to surroundings is useless for pedestrian routing. Can you connect it where appropriate?
12017-06-14 05:19:02 UTCSanniu Can you add also name:he tags for new roads?
22017-06-14 08:16:44 UTCFlayer Done
32017-06-14 10:28:23 UTCSanniu Thanks!
42017-06-14 10:56:16 UTCSwiftFast Note that SwiftFast_bot adds name:he automatically. So it's not necessary anymore.
52017-06-14 10:57:04 UTCSwiftFast ...and I guess it's faster to work with one name tag.
12017-06-14 05:33:10 UTCSanniu Foot-ways not connected to surroundings are useless for pedestrian routing. Can you connect them to nearest roads where appropriate as you seems to have a local knowledge?
22017-06-14 10:16:28 UTCnivstein Connected them to street + service road:
32017-06-14 10:27:06 UTCSanniu Thanks!
12017-06-14 06:13:39 UTCSanniu Please name streets according to
Usually name + name:he with Hebrew name, name:en with English one. Thanks!
12017-06-14 06:08:06 UTCSanniu Footpaths not connected to surroundings are useless to the pedestrian routing. Can you connect them to nearby roads where appropriate, as you seems to have a local knowledge?
12017-06-14 05:51:42 UTCSanniu is it דליה רביקוביץ' or אוריאל אופק?
12017-06-14 05:26:44 UTCSanniu is it יצחק למדן or הרב ירמה?
22017-06-14 10:10:05 UTCYnhockey Good question. I haven't visited the area in a while, but according to all the other mapping services, Lamdan is the pedestrian footway between Rothschild and Krol. However, if that small street is Yerma, then it sort of doesn't make sense. Consider this (from Rothschild):
12017-06-12 07:38:40 UTCSanniu What do U trying to achieve with this change?
12017-06-12 07:28:03 UTCSanniu Judeia e Samaria = Judeia e Samaria look like bad tagging
22017-06-16 19:45:18 UTCSwiftFast Agreed
12017-06-11 09:40:22 UTCSanniu Can you connect where it connects to surrounding streets to make it useful for pedestrian routing?
12017-06-07 07:31:28 UTCSanniu end abruptly with that change. Is some road part missed there?
22017-06-11 09:14:40 UTCSanniu No answer, will fix as good as I can
12017-06-08 08:20:58 UTCSanniu - is it really a roundabout? It has very strange geometry for this...
12017-06-08 08:15:44 UTCSanniu Hi
Paths that are not connected to surrounded roads are useless for pedestrian routing. Can you add such connections where exists, as you seems to have the local knowledge?
12017-06-07 07:27:06 UTCSanniu Now bus terminal has no exit at all, can you fix?
12017-06-07 07:15:41 UTCSanniu look like roundabout? Is it?
22017-06-07 08:51:20 UTCYnhockey Thanks, I have added the tag.
12017-06-06 07:57:00 UTCSanniu - you added two names there, it's quite unusual. If you can survey, can you check what the real name of this street part?
12017-05-31 09:39:52 UTCSanniu You've vandalized point in Holon, Israel in this changeset. Can you revert this change?
22017-05-31 12:58:51 UTCSwiftFast Reverted in
12017-05-29 08:27:26 UTCSanniu Footpaths not connected to anything are useless for pedestrian routing, can you connect them?
12017-05-28 09:01:26 UTCSanniu have no type. What is missed there?
22017-05-28 09:59:41 UTCFlayer Just a forest.
12017-05-24 10:33:46 UTCSanniu Foot ways not connected to surrounding streets are useless for pedestrian routing. Can you connect paths in that area, as you seems to have a local knowledge?
22017-05-24 10:52:31 UTCFlayer OK, I will.
12017-05-24 10:00:45 UTCSanniu Park paths are not connected to the rest of the map, that make them useless to pedestrian routing, as the person that seems to live in the area, can you add connections to surrounding streets? Thanks!
12017-05-24 09:56:31 UTCSanniu - it's look like right turn to bypass a traffic light but does not have a one-way property, is it missed there?
Also the same on another turn at the same junction.
12017-05-24 08:09:38 UTCSanniu You replaced Hebrew name with generic Russian one, please don't do it. You may add proper Russian name at name:ru tag.
12017-05-22 11:01:43 UTCSanniu You reverted part of road 1 to trunk, this may be ok, but you change-set message doe not mention that. Is this intentional?
22017-05-22 11:13:53 UTCWillRock41 yes
12017-05-22 10:58:28 UTCSanniu Please don't revert 55 road ref to 40. All signs there are for 55, I've drive there from time to time
12017-05-17 14:46:06 UTCSanniu It should be halt, not station in my opinion - no switches and other attributes of the station
22017-05-17 15:14:42 UTCYnhockey I think all passenger stations in Israel should be labeled as station, because they all have significant infrastructure associated with them. The last "pirate" station with no entrance and no security was Yavne (east) afaik, until its renovation. We also don't have stations lacking a fixed...
32017-05-18 07:45:55 UTCSanniu Yeah, rendering is the strong point here. About service stations like Nahal Sorek I prefer to follow rules.
12017-05-15 14:17:51 UTCSanniu have no tags, what is it?
12017-04-28 15:37:41 UTCSanniu have no tag, is it street?
12017-04-28 10:30:10 UTCSanniu have no type tag, what is it?
12017-04-27 09:17:31 UTCSanniu have strange geometry, can you check?
22017-05-02 11:19:03 UTCSwiftFast Definitely an error in an attempt to mark scrubs/forests via Bing. Fixed in
12017-04-24 11:24:38 UTCSanniu Hi. You marked way as oneway, but it first node not connected to anything, can you look there?
12017-04-20 20:28:13 UTCSanniu Some corrections: it's not a living streets, ordinary residential. Please name street in two languages according to convention, I'll fix these.
12017-04-19 09:08:57 UTCSanniu Are you sure that way has so strange geometry? It self-crossing and overlaps nearby road.
12017-04-04 13:44:57 UTCSanniu שביל הבשור looks really strange - self-intersections, staright line through the fields, etc. Can you check it?
12017-04-03 15:04:12 UTCzstadler Hi,

It looks like way
does not have any tags. What is it?
22017-04-04 06:47:01 UTCSanniu Thanks, fixed
12017-04-01 19:48:45 UTCSanniu The gaps in mineral transporter are strange, why some parts are not tagged as railway?
22017-04-02 05:44:39 UTCzstadler Fixed. The mineral transporter is not a railway. It's a man_made=goods_conveyor. Some parts were not corrected in this edit.
12017-03-29 13:46:20 UTCSanniu The circle near train station is roundabout?
22017-03-29 14:18:08 UTCgalh The circle on the left size is a roundabout. The one on the right is a half a circle that connects the two parallel roads.
32017-03-29 14:19:49 UTCSanniu Want me to fix left circle and mark it as roundabout?
42017-03-29 14:21:30 UTCgalh Sure.
12017-03-29 13:41:43 UTCSanniu Node: טבע עירוני שביל סובב חריש (4226356752) you killed leisure=park. Is it intentional?
22017-03-29 20:42:48 UTCeric22 I was probably thinking that a park should be an area, not a point. Looking at it right now, there is an area there. It's a "meadow" not a "park", but as far as I can tell that is accurate since the land is not developed in any way. Feel free to change if you know otherwise.
12017-03-29 13:12:22 UTCSanniu Way: 201666822 have no tags, is it path?
12017-03-29 09:30:04 UTCSanniu Way: HaZamir (406278492) is it the street or building?
12017-03-26 08:47:18 UTCSanniu Way: 398455276 have no tags, is it path?
22017-03-26 12:04:56 UTCzstadler Fixed. Thanks!
32017-03-29 14:37:22 UTCzstadler Based on your initiative, I've created a query that finds all the ways in Israel that have no tags and are not a member of a relation. I've fixed what I knew and sent messages to most others.
If you want, the query is available at
You can change the initial...
12017-03-25 19:11:04 UTCSanniu Way: 120917121 has no tags
12017-02-27 14:54:20 UTCSanniu Way 388398875 was residential, why it untagged now?
22017-02-27 16:33:14 UTCzstadler That change was a JOSM usage mistake, and it's fixed now.
32017-02-27 21:33:23 UTCSanniu Thanks
12017-02-26 08:57:29 UTCSanniu Duplicate with 474109592, should it be track or bike single?
22017-02-26 09:27:52 UTCMenashe Korot Track
12017-02-22 21:20:54 UTCSanniu If there is round about, please draw it on a map, don't tag node, routing programs can't understand that.
22017-02-23 12:13:49 UTCRose7 Thanks, I've updated it.
12017-02-22 12:14:04 UTCSanniu Look like this changeset adds many duplicate tracks, osmose is jumping at many tracks added here. E.g. Way: 474173611
12017-02-08 10:38:54 UTCSanniu Way: 421491738 is it footway?
22017-03-26 13:15:55 UTCzstadler Ways 380785433, 421491738 have no tags. What are they?
32017-03-26 13:33:26 UTCzstadler Correction: Way
has no tags. what is it?
42017-03-27 13:32:15 UTCzstadler Correction (again...): Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-02-08 09:10:06 UTCSanniu Way: 449855015 - should it be part of emergency road or it's a footway only?
22017-03-26 13:16:28 UTCzstadler Ways 380785433, 449855015 have no tags. What are they?
12017-02-08 09:00:01 UTCSanniu Way: 389765969 have no tag. What it should be?
22017-03-27 12:56:37 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
Is it duplicate way that should be deleted?
12017-02-05 13:24:07 UTCSanniu Track you've added miss highway=? type, please fix
12017-02-05 10:57:06 UTCSanniu אסאדו is not a correct width :) Do you remember real width for this track?
12017-02-05 09:16:57 UTCSanniu Leumit clinic is not here it's behind Beit Kanner, please validate you changes!!!
12017-02-02 15:58:03 UTCSanniu There is no park there. Have you surveyed the place?
12017-01-31 08:48:05 UTCSanniu It can't be secondary road - it's motorway link.
Is it completed? If not, please mark as construction.
Also adjust geometry to fit under 444 bridge :)
12017-01-30 15:31:11 UTCSanniu Look like you returned tags building=* that describe building name. That is not right way to tag buildings. Please set building=[commercial|industrial] and put proper name= tag on buildings
12017-01-30 12:15:15 UTCSanniu Path you've added look erratic and does not corresponds to satellite imaginary. Are you sure that paths are right?
12017-01-30 11:51:52 UTCSanniu The way with no tags, should it be road? Also it not connected to road network, so not-navigatable.
22017-03-27 13:19:58 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-01-30 10:58:03 UTCSanniu Way: 316353843 - should it be path?
22017-03-27 11:03:10 UTCzstadler Ways,,,,,
have no tags. What are th...
12017-01-30 10:33:03 UTCSanniu Way: 226193984 - should it be the wall too?
22017-03-27 11:58:15 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-01-28 14:44:56 UTCSanniu Please connect park path to existing paths/roads, otherwise it will be un-naivgatable. You don't have to add name to paths. If you add them, add official name, not the generic one, it does not help in navigation
12017-01-28 14:40:52 UTCSanniu There is no such path and park there, only wild land, have you surveyed it?
12017-01-28 13:50:15 UTCSanniu Hi, can you connect that footway to road network, otherwise it is not-navigatable.
12017-01-27 10:57:34 UTCSanniu It've added fully duplicate track
12017-01-26 14:29:58 UTCSanniu Way: 398602061 have no type, is it park?
12017-01-26 13:36:20 UTCSanniu Way: 423146015 - not type here, is it sport pitch or some other amenity?
12017-01-24 10:39:39 UTCSanniu Relation: 1646887 - Missing tag or role on relation
22017-01-24 11:18:37 UTCsivan00 Not sure what the problem is.
32017-01-24 12:13:33 UTCSanniu that relation doesn't have tags - e.g. name
42017-01-24 12:25:56 UTCsivan00 Since I have'nt created the relation (just cleaned up some of the borders), I'm not sure what needs ot be done.
52017-01-24 12:33:26 UTCSanniu Ok, dug in history, there was KKL import with forest name that somehow wiped. I've updated type and name.
12017-01-20 11:59:14 UTCSanniu Are all these main streets pedestrian now? It look strange...
22017-01-21 18:20:25 UTCIlanride22 As Part of the construction for BRT bus line in ashdod all of this "pedestrian streets" are closed. They are closed for vehicles but open for pedestrian. In several moths they will reopen again. For more details:
32017-01-24 12:22:12 UTCSanniu Thanks, may it be better mark them with right classification, but restrict access for motor vehicles for now? After end of the works all of the streets will be reopened to traffic? Or some remain pedestrian?
12017-01-24 11:00:11 UTCSanniu Way: 364503554 - should it be road or footpath?
22017-01-24 11:48:31 UTCeric22 Fixed
32017-01-24 12:15:06 UTCSanniu Thanks
12017-01-24 11:06:22 UTCSanniu Way: 229036528 - no tags - what is it?
22017-01-24 15:24:54 UTCYnhockey Fixed.
32017-03-27 10:02:38 UTCzstadler Apparently, it was not fixed.
still has no tags.
12017-01-24 11:04:14 UTCSanniu No tags on lines - is it footpaths?
12017-01-24 10:53:38 UTCSanniu Way: 453049615 have no tags
22017-03-27 10:09:14 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-01-24 10:10:21 UTCSanniu Way: 399525181 Missing tag or role on way
22017-03-27 12:54:57 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-01-22 09:07:27 UTCSanniu Way: 317407960 should be footpath?
22017-03-27 10:21:36 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12017-01-19 11:26:57 UTCSanniu Way: 100132812 - Missing tag or role on way - should be path?
12017-01-16 11:45:54 UTCSanniu It it's motorway it should have ref.
12017-01-16 10:41:29 UTCSanniu Is there roundabout on road 384 on entrance to Ramat Beit-Shemeh? It's now glued from pieces and not marked as one-way nor roundabout, but look such from it geometry.
12017-01-12 08:40:31 UTCSanniu Look like you added some areas without other tags (e.g. Way: 250927015), should them be removed or you can add tags to them?
12017-01-05 11:50:32 UTCSanniu Please tag railway stations according to
12017-01-03 08:49:49 UTCSanniu משצק:יק=נחל יתיר
22017-01-03 09:02:55 UTCzstadler Corrected. Thanks!
12016-12-18 10:48:15 UTCSanniu Please add footpath tag to new way.
Also, if you adding Cyrillic street-name in address, add Cyrillic name to street itself
22017-03-27 09:09:12 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12016-11-28 11:34:17 UTCSanniu Missing object kind - from OSMOSE. Can add more descriptive attributes to this point?
12016-11-15 12:07:10 UTCSanniu Reverse roundabout on way 112976546, don't think we have such in Israel
22016-11-16 07:52:05 UTCzstadler I've only added a roundabout tag.
The way direction and the oneway tag were set in changeset 8131512.
However, from the patterns of car movement as seen in the Rehovot GIS orthophoto - - it looks like these are not necessarily one way roa...
32016-11-16 10:18:37 UTCSanniu It still normal roundabout, somewhat abused for parking, also locals short-cutting it, will fix direction.
42016-11-16 19:58:09 UTCzstadler Can you please check if there is any roundabout or one way traffic sign there.
Otherwise, it would be legal to drive around in both clockwise and counterclockwise directions
12016-11-14 08:56:01 UTCSanniu You have ways_without_tags on 398412603, should it be building?
22017-03-27 12:55:21 UTCzstadler Way
has no tags. What is it?
12016-11-08 10:31:33 UTCSanniu Rails are there but many different support systems are in progress and that part of line AFAIK still not delivered to IR by contractor, so it should be marked as construction.
12016-09-04 10:54:41 UTCSanniu HaBanim road looks broken with this edit - spur to north not aligned to aeral and intersects everything
12016-04-04 12:19:59 UTCSanniu Missing object kind
It better be:

Also it should be on road, not unconnected point and this crossing exists on both lanes, so should be marked twice
12016-02-14 09:43:07 UTCSanniu Some of service roads in this edit marked 'leisure=park'. Why?
Sanniu has contributed to 99 changeset discussions(s) with a total of 162 comment(s)