andrewsh participated in the following changeset discussions
Changeset # Tmstmp UTC Contributor Comment
160035707
by andrewsh
@ 2024-12-07 18:15
12024-12-07 21:38InsertUser
♦444
Most of these appear to be entrances to tourist things, slightly mis-tagged, but how are they spam?
22024-12-07 22:31andrewsh This belongs in personal notes, tourist guides, elsewhere, but not in OpenStreetMap, no. After all, none of those are real objects existing on the ground.
32024-12-08 01:40InsertUser
♦444
Node 6101995487 looks like it was a tourism=aquarium added by someone without enough OSM experience. to know the correct tag. Are you saying that all 1.4k aquariums in the database should be summarily deleted?

Also all 65k natural=cave_entrance? (6006695609)

Have you been to both of these plac...
42024-12-09 09:01andrewsh There’s no need to put words into my mouth and make absurd statements like this. That object might have been a collateral (although I doubt it), but most of these objects were just personal notes on how to walk around the gates.
(Post office in a middle of a roundabout with name:en=Free entra...
52024-12-09 12:34InsertUser
♦444
The inevitable collateral of this sort of blind find and delete edit is one of the main reasons for the longstanding policy against this sort of slapdash mechanical edits.

Here you took genuine edits by people trying to improve things and instead of manually reviewing them to see what the correct...
62024-12-09 13:04andrewsh Well, this wasn't an automated edit. I did check every object I deleted. I may have misjudged with the aquarium — or maybe not. I every other case I checked the actual object was nearby and tagged properly.
117122467
by andrewsh
@ 2022-02-07 14:33
12024-10-13 16:23aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, prevadzkovatel banky staci v znacke 'operator', do 'brand' sa nedava, lebo to moze byt znacka bankomatu (teda jeho vyrobca).
22024-10-13 16:35andrewsh Ako ja čítam to na wiki, brand sa vzťahuje na značku, ktorú vidí konečný používateľ, čiže v tomto prípade VÚB. Ak napríklad je McD, operator bude firma, ktorá ho prevádzkuje (franšízant), ale brand je McD. Tu...
32024-10-13 16:36andrewsh Ale teda súhlasím, že v tomto prípade je to zbytočné.
42024-10-13 17:13aceman444
♦2,567
No hlavne to, ze je to duplicita a potom tam este ludia pridavaju aj wikipedia aj wikidata na brand aj na operator a hned mame 6 znaciek. Potom este aj 'name' nech je tam ta banka 3x.
Ano uz McD je to tak ako pisete.
Na https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Datm znacku 'b...
52024-10-13 17:29andrewsh a už viem prečo som to pridal:

Cash Machine S6AV022A looks like a common feature with incomplete tags

Suggested updates:
+ brand=Všeobecná úverová banka
+ brand:wikidata=Q12778981
62024-10-17 23:53aceman444
♦2,567
Hej, chapem, zase iniciativa editora iD.
147873786
by Leo Slager
@ 2024-02-24 23:07
12024-02-24 23:16andrewsh dank u :)
48475043
by andrewsh
@ 2017-05-07 13:22
12024-01-29 14:30Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
Hello!

You used
cuisine=cakes
on https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4839886771/history

Have you maybe meant
cuisine=cake
?

I am pretty sure that it is a typo, but not sure enough to just replace it (I edited some objects where situation seemed more clear to me).

Or have you used this...
22024-01-29 15:46andrewsh Most likely! Thanks.
138886468
by andrewsh
@ 2023-07-23 10:05
12023-08-13 11:59aceman444
♦2,567
Opatrne, nad Gemersku uz cyklopruh ani parkopruh nepokracuje. A uvadzajte aj nejake zdroje, dakujem.
22023-08-13 12:13andrewsh Ďakujem, pomýlil som sa. Zdroj je taký, že tu každý deň chodím 🙂
20166370
by andrewsh
@ 2014-01-23 20:02
12023-06-20 08:36Tomas_J
♦284
cus, opravil som tvoje ref na railway:track_ref podla dokumentacie
22023-06-20 08:39andrewsh dik, ešte vedľa zopár zostalo, ak máš chuť 🙂
32023-06-20 09:02Tomas_J
♦284
Jj, opravil som aj to. Pozeram, ze v openrailwaymap nemame na slovensku takmer nikde zobrazene cisla trati (okrem trate 110 a 120). Je to preto, ze nemana na railway:track pridane ref s cislom trate. Myslis, ze by bolo ok na par usekov trate ref pridat? Teraz je ref uvedene v relacii k tratiam, ale ...
42023-06-20 17:09Filip009
♦939
Ja vidím ref na väčšine tratí, ale nechápem, že prečo ho openrailwaymap na väčšom zoome nezobrazuje.
52023-06-20 17:12Tomas_J
♦284
Nezobrazuje ref na relácii. Ref priamo na trati (na way) IMHO zobrazuje.
62023-06-20 17:20Filip009
♦939
Aha, vidím že pokrytý nie je hlavne západ Slovenska, východ je na tom celkom okej
136830410
by andrewsh
@ 2023-06-01 13:02
12023-06-06 06:15user_5359
♦19,360
Hello! Please take a look on https://www.osm.org/way/22963885. I assume a copy & paste error for the key motor_vehicle:conditional.
22023-06-06 06:53andrewsh Thanks, fixed.
130723648
by Klerik7
@ 2022-12-31 14:43
12022-12-31 15:42andrewsh Dík, ale je to man_made=spring_box
125477714
by Mauls
@ 2022-08-28 13:24
12022-10-10 22:26andrewsh According to the information I could find, Crieff Junction was the station on the mainline which is now called Gleneagles, but I can’t find any mention of what you added in Crieff itself.
22022-10-11 10:40Mauls
♦28
Crief Junction was also the name of the junction in Crief.
114102210
by andrewsh
@ 2021-11-22 15:01
12022-04-10 09:55aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, aky je problem s tymi dvojitymi ciarkami? Slovak Lines dopravca mal takto oznacene zastavky, cize to bolo spravne, nie preklep. Zda sa, ze ARRIVA to uz tak nema, ale to ako zdroj neuvadzate.
22022-04-10 10:31andrewsh Nemusíme dodržiavať všetky blbosti, ktoré majú v dátach dopravcovia. Dvojité čiarky bez medzier boli len dôsledkom technických obmedzení (skrátka — CSV).
32022-04-10 10:45aceman444
♦2,567
Ako viete? A ako viete, ze to tak nebolo aj v cestovnom poriadku a na zastavke?
42022-04-10 10:48andrewsh Tak to viem. O tom sa vyjadrovali aj dopravné podniky, že žiadne dvojité čiarky tam nemali byť, ale kvôli starému systému to nevedeli odstrániť.

Nevidím zmysel to ďalej rozoberať.
52022-04-10 10:55aceman444
♦2,567
Ma to zmysel, dolozte ze to tak je (neuviedli ste ziadny zdroj, takze je to vhodny kandidat na revert). A nie vsetky zastavky mali dve ciarky, asi v tom bol nejaky system. A keby to aj bola pravda, preco nad tym mame filozofovat? Je jedno aky je dovod, ked to dopravca povazuje za nazov, tak preco ho...
62022-04-13 06:58Dodko
♦1,205
Eurobus sa k čiarkam vyjadril takto.
Čo sa týka čiarok v názvoch zastávok, v našom informačnom systéme používame jednu čiarku. Vyhľadávač spoločnosti INPROP (cp.sk) používa dve čiarky, nakoľko názov zastávky sa sklad&...
72022-04-13 19:37aceman444
♦2,567
No nejaky cudzi vyhladavac asi nebude smerodajny, ale dve ciarky ma v nazvoch samotny Slovak lines, v cestovnych poriadkoch, napr. https://www.jakubov.sk/data/page/jakubov.sk/705/slovak-lines.pdf
76269536
by andrewsh
@ 2019-10-27 15:54
12022-03-15 11:02aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, preco vymaz stareho nazvu?
22022-03-15 11:05andrewsh Lebo je starý a neaktuálny?
32022-03-15 20:38aceman444
♦2,567
Kedze je stary preto je v old_name. Co je na tom zle? Nie je to na co ta znacka sluzi?
42022-03-15 23:18andrewsh Aký má zmysel to ponechávať? Nemá to podľa mňa žiadnu historickú hodnotu.
52022-03-15 23:43aceman444
♦2,567
Zvyknem to nechavat, ked ide nadalej o restauraciu ci kaviaren, len sa zmeni nazov. Moze byt, ze ludia este poznaju povodny nazov, tak to moze byt pomocka.

Ak je ta znacka v poriadku, nemazte to. Ak to podla Vas nema hodnotu, neznamena, ze nema ani pre ostatnych.
116140786
by andrewsh
@ 2022-01-14 09:49
12022-01-14 19:28SekeRob
♦1,433
Driving at the hand of 'latest keys'? Please realise all your level0 edits are getting a semi global view even if it's done 1 by one.
22022-01-15 02:03andrewsh I’m sorry but I fail to understand what you’re trying to say. Could you please reformulate?
32022-01-15 05:41SekeRob
♦1,433
Level0 edits usually stem/launch from the Latest Keys' listing. Even when you save an edit, the sessione somehow stays open until i think 60 minutes after the last edit, here the bonding box spread covers an area from somewhere in the former ussr to NW of Florda. Every mapper inside this box ge...
42022-01-15 09:36andrewsh No, I didn’t ome from the Latest Keys, and I did close the changeset. I deleted a 0 from a node number by accident, which I reverted in the next change.
52022-01-15 09:37andrewsh I has never happened to me before, and I’m not aware of any bug similar to what you describe. Level0 has been very reliable since I started using it.
15449069
by andrewsh
@ 2013-03-21 22:34
12021-10-21 20:01Filip009
♦939
Dobrý deň, kde by som si vedel nájsť info o tých cyklotrasách, čo ste pridali? Konkrétne https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2832949 a https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/2832965 V teréne ani po ôsmich rokoch nie je vidieť žiadne značenie.
22021-10-21 20:21andrewsh Myslím si že info je v plánoch mesta; OZ Mulica by vedelo o tom povedať viac.
92966031
by andrewsh
@ 2020-10-23 18:42
12021-10-19 17:42Dodko
♦1,205
Neviem aký význam malo odstrániť addr:city a addr:place z tejto budovy.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/118281938/history
Tam stačilo zmeniť addr:place na mestskú časť Staré Mesto
22021-10-19 17:47andrewsh Tá budova má ulicu, takže addr:place nesmie mať.
32021-10-19 17:56Dodko
♦1,205
Daná adresa nemá pridelenú ulicu ani orientačné číslo, iba súpisné číslo bez ulice.
To robia na garáže, alebo technické budovy.
https://zbgis.skgeodesy.sk/mkzbgis/sk/zakladna-mapa/detail/adresne-body/0/19609680?pos=49.085059...
42021-10-19 18:10Dodko
♦1,205
Tu je záznam z registra adries https://pasteboard.co/LTdPaZFdBkMl.png
52021-10-19 18:16andrewsh Ok, beriem, ale ešte by som skontroloval ako sa tá adresa reálne používa (v listoch vlastníctva, reklame atď) a až vtedy ak nikto to nepriraďuje na ulici Kpt Nálepku, dať tam Staré Mesto.
101544951
by iWowik
@ 2021-03-23 05:43
12021-03-23 08:49Jay May
♦147
iWowik, пожалуйста, перестаньте откатить мои смены на Польском языке.
Я специально откатываю название "ulica" и "jezioro", поэтому что так делают Поляки. Я уже об эт...
22021-03-26 08:24iWowik
♦1,071
День добрый!
Вы пытаетесь внести польско-язычные названия так, как если бы улицы были в Польше.
Но они не в Польше, поэтому неизбежно возникают отличия.

Следует р...
32021-03-26 09:02Jay May
♦147
Слушайте. Там, где name:pl, это дла польскоязычных пользователей OSM, maps.me, OSMAnd, итп. Таксамо, если name:ru былбы с названием "улица" где-то в Польше (хотя Поляки не пользо...
42021-03-26 09:18iWowik
♦1,071
В Белоруссии и Украине есть официальные правила для передачи названий на другие языки. И они нам велят просто передавать звучание исходного языка, средствами друг...
52021-03-26 10:11iWowik
♦1,071
Провел небольшой эксперимент на ленинизм.

Поискал близлежащие Ленинские улицы и улицы Ленина.
Вот несколько примеров.

Бегомль https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/30969956 и располо...
62021-04-01 14:37andrewsh iWowik, вы неправы.
name:pl конечно же Grodno, не Hrodna.
72021-04-01 15:05Jay May
♦147
Вообще нет смысла, что-бы был name:pl, если вы напишете только транслитерацию из name:be. На это, уже есть int_name. Лучше, что-бы если name:pl вообще пользовать, name:pl=Grodno (как написа...
82021-04-01 16:494004
♦1,882
Я не занимаю чью либо позицию, но в случаях/местности, где есть носители как бы польского языка (eg kresy wschodnie), не стоит ли брать практику местных за name:pl? Или этот pl не я...
92021-04-25 12:41iWowik
♦1,071
andrewsh, что значит не прав я?
Это правила такие, я как раз и пишу, что стараюсь таких перегибов избегать.

Jay May, в int_name привильно вообще ничего не писать. Ибо туда сейча...
9246726
by *Martin*
@ 2011-09-08 15:42
12021-03-01 14:00andrewsh Vyzerá, že tu bol nejaký mini-import-fail: "Z hradn". Neviem či by sa neoplatilo prekontrolovať celý changeset.
22021-03-01 14:06andrewsh Myslím toto (asi má byť Záhradná): https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1427089338#map=17/48.43408/17.03763

Neviem tu nič také nájsť na ZBGIS.
32021-03-01 14:25*Martin*
♦641
import je ok. faily su v kapor2 datach.
42021-03-01 14:26*Martin*
♦641
kokretne tento bod treba zmazat. a raz mozno zmazem vsetky kapor2 names ;-)
52021-03-01 14:28andrewsh Aha, takže asi to nie je prekódovaním, ale je chybný zdroj? Oki, tak to zmažem.
62021-03-01 14:29andrewsh "Sdílejte než to zesmažou!"
98124452
by Mateusz Konieczny
@ 2021-01-25 13:07
12021-01-26 08:17chnav
♦1,073
Please stop adding non-official names to the place. Moreover, it is forbidden in OSM to add private information such as peoples' names, phone numbers etc.
22021-01-26 12:36Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
1) It is perfectly fine to add non-oficial names.

2) Privacy rules are a bit different for publicly known people, especially where known so widely that they result in name changes
32021-01-26 12:42chnav
♦1,073
1) No it is not fine. Use loc_name instead. Anyway, most people in Russia never new such name "Putin Palace", so please do not add it.
42021-01-26 12:49Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
I added back name:en and name:pl only, as currently these are common names to refer to that building, I admit that I am unsure about name and name:ru so I have not added them back

We have name, official_name and loc_name

name has the most common name (with some bias toward official/non-slang o...
52021-01-26 13:36_gig_
♦2
name:lang are the official names, localized for language, and not "folk".
Use the "alt_name" tag if you really want to add something.

However, even in this case, you are using unverifiable data from, sorry, questionable source. Which in no way meets the principle of "gro...
62021-01-26 13:55andrewsh Let me chime in: Mateusz is correct here.
72021-01-26 14:03Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
name:lang are the official names - nope, it is for a common name - that may or may match an official name

official_name:lang is for official names

> However, even in this case, you are using unverifiable data from, sorry, questionable source.

Even if https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putin&#...
82021-01-26 14:45chnav
♦1,073
<..as far as I know..>
All you know is based on internet rumors. Putin is not the owner of building and he has denied this accusation. If the building used for residence then should be called "President Residence" or "President Palace". Nobody cares what slang name is used...
92021-01-26 14:50chnav
♦1,073
According to you wikipedia link the name is "Residence at Cape Idokopas".
102021-01-26 14:54chnav
♦1,073
Please translate it to Polish.
112021-01-26 15:30Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
> Putin is not the owner of building and he has denied this accusation.

It is not relevant at all. If such name is used then it is taggable.

> Nobody cares what slang name is used for this place

Slang names are also taggable in OSM.
122021-01-26 15:32Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
> According to you wikipedia link the name is "Residence at Cape Idokopas".

Please read first sentence and the article title "The Residence at Cape Idokopas (Russian: Резиденция на мысе Идокопас), also known as "Putin's Palace" (Дворе...
132021-01-26 15:38chnav
♦1,073
Since when you care ? )))
BTW if you care then put it in alt_name:pl and/or alt_name:en
142021-01-27 20:35luiswoo
♦599
@chnav
1) No it is not fine. Use loc_name instead. Anyway, most people in Russia never new such name "Putin Palace", so please do not add it.
Вы правы, большинство населения России знает о "Дворце Путина", а не Putin Palace&...
152021-01-27 21:47Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
> Use loc_name instead.

Why? name is for the most common name

> Anyway, most people in Russia never new such name "Putin Palace", so please do not add it.

It does not matter for English name at all. It matters whatever it is the most common English name for this object.
\...
162021-01-27 22:32luiswoo
♦599
@Mateusz Konieczny
Сhnav works for Putin's propaganda. It has only one goal - the absence of the words "Putin's Palace" in the tag "name".
172021-01-27 23:16luiswoo
♦599
@Mateusz Konieczny
It would be wise to write a letter to the DWG about censorship name:pl.
182021-01-28 08:42langoor
♦8
@Mateusz Konieczny
I'm not pretending I know your local prevalence of this name, but it's doubtful poles think about this place days and nights or even know about it unless they have a particular interest. Polish tourists rather would prefer english wikipedia, since polish page doesn'...
192021-01-28 10:45luiswoo
♦599
@langoor
>Almost all his posts about certain issues at local Russian forum are politically biased.<
You forgot to add that these posts were dedicated to the deletion of all data somehow connecting this residence with Putin.
202021-01-28 11:11Mateusz Konieczny
♦7,597
> it's doubtful poles think about this place days and nights or even know about it unless they have a particular interest

It is true for many other names that are clearly existing. If you take random village near border (say https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/337575593 ) it will certainl...
212021-01-28 11:21Something B
♦142
@chnav
The only criterion for a name is its existence, period.
222021-01-28 11:52langoor
♦8
@luiswoo
There was no deletion, but inappropriate tags usage. This is the subject of discussion, not the reason labeling opponents.

@Mateusz Konieczny
I must say that these Polish names are pretty similar to the local ones.
232021-01-28 12:27luiswoo
♦599
@langoor
Not deleting: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/12219596/history
Don't lie: "most people in Russia never new such name "Putin Palace""
No censorship: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/98214801
This is different...
96458169
by andrewsh
@ 2020-12-26 16:25
12021-01-24 01:38aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim a podla akeho zdroja sa nazov tej casti aj pouziva v adresach tej obce? Na priklad v katastri si ludia pisu len Donovaly <supisne>, ziadne Bully.
22021-01-24 09:23andrewsh Bully je oficiálne miestna časť, má vlastné číslovanie súpisných čísiel (iné, ako v Poliankach alebo Donovaloch ako takých), a tak sa reálne zapisujú aj miestne adresy.
32021-01-24 23:13aceman444
♦2,567
OK, ak ste to pouzivanie Bully na mieste zistili. Ale prave preto treba pridat ten zdroj (aspon na uroven sady zmien), kedze v katastri sa skor daju najst dokazy o opaku (ze sa nepouziva). A zda sa, ze nove supisne cisla v katastri su jednoznacne v Donovaloch, nevidim ziadne "vlastne cislovani ...
42021-01-25 15:43andrewsh Teraz pozerám druhýkrát, a vyzerá že naozaj čísla, ktoré sa opakovali, boli len pôvodné súpisné pred prečíslovaním, momentálne už v katastri také nie sú.

K adresovaniu: stretol som celkom d...
96457913
by andrewsh
@ 2020-12-26 16:16
12021-01-24 01:37aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, aky je zdroj tych supisnych cisel? Lebo ziadny neuvadzate a na niektorych budovach ste dali 2 supisne, napr. https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8262024948 na je 130 aj 221 a to 130 je aj na inom dome v Donovaloch (aj ked v inej casti).
22021-01-24 09:29andrewsh 1) V Donovaloch je číslovanie podľa miestnych častí, preto čísla sa môžu opakovať.
2) Niektoré budovy majú aj staršie súpisné číslo s pred prečíslovania — tabuľka je na budove fyzicky, tak predpokladám...
32021-01-24 23:09aceman444
♦2,567
Dakujem. No v sucasnosti vyzeraju byt cisla jedinecne v ramci celych Donovalov. Kde sa cislo v katastri (zrejme nove) lisi od toho co mame v OSM som vyznacil (fixme). Tiez neviem ci staru adresu davat do addr:housenumber na uroven novej platnej adrese. Ale ak ich ludia pouzivaju tak OK (len potom mo...
97007959
by d4s
@ 2021-01-05 22:20
12021-01-08 19:32andrewsh Усё замічацельна, ашчушчэнія харошыя, пішыце ішчо!
92667108
by andrewsh
@ 2020-10-18 19:25
12020-10-18 19:33muchichka_s
♦284
Do you have anything to do with Ukraine and our OSM society?
22020-10-18 19:35andrewsh Yes. Any more questions?
32020-10-18 19:39muchichka_s
♦284
I do not see that you have been actively mapping something in Ukraine for a long time. And local arrangements allow us to leave a transliteration or common name for the street name as name:en
42020-10-18 19:40andrewsh Transliterations go to int_name. However, these "names" are not transliterations but translations.

Also see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Names#Avoid_transliteration
52020-10-18 19:49muchichka_s
♦284
Ukraine even has a law on how to translate to English names correctly. It's a bit like transliteration. I want to emphasize the agreements once again.
Can you tell which language is your native language?
62020-10-18 19:57andrewsh What Ukraine has or hasn’t is completely irrelevant. We try to avoid transliteration in OSM, and we *never* translate street names unless there’s a sizable local community using that language (and hence probably using these names) or if it possible to prove these streets officially have ...
72020-10-18 19:59andrewsh Unless you can show there’s a community of primarily English-speaking people in this town *or* there’s an official document proving these streets are named like that (not a website — anyone can put anything up onto a website), there’s really nothing to talk about and those tr...
82020-10-18 20:17muchichka_s
♦284
BTW In the 2 streets where you erased the name were the official names of people from the English Wikipedia
92020-10-18 20:22andrewsh We’re not mapping people, we’re mapping streets. The fact the people streets are named after are also called something in English (their Hungaian names, surprise!) doesn’t mean the streets also have English names.
Please also keep in mind that the contents of Wikipedia is largely ...
102020-10-18 20:25muchichka_s
♦284
OK Tell us your vision of how it should be please. What names should give navigation to foreign drivers who drove into this city. Where should it take them?
112020-10-18 20:26andrewsh The navigation system will automatically transliterate the names.
122020-10-18 20:30andrewsh https://i.imgur.com/xPi1wu3.png
https://i.imgur.com/pZWo1eC.png
132020-10-18 20:34muchichka_s
♦284
And then everyone is uncomfortable because everyone knows Mihály not Mihaya
You yourself spoke out against transliteration, and here to contradict yourself
142020-10-18 20:39andrewsh Transliteration should be done in the end-user devices except cases when it’s tricky. It should not be in OSM.

Let’s be clear: the person who filled those in has never been to this town, they simply transliterated or translated the names. Take for example Vasút út. Vas&u...
152020-10-18 21:00muchichka_s
♦284
I have already written to you about Vasút in the another changeset. And this case definitely needs to be corrected back

Do you know in which city Munkácsy was born? it is about 35 km from here. I think we can assume he was here
162020-10-18 21:03andrewsh I wasn’t talking about Munkácsy but the OSM user who added English names to the streets.
172020-10-18 21:15muchichka_s
♦284
I do not see auto translation there: https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=48.36068989825205&lng=22.403846189504065&z=14.797914358667631
182020-10-18 21:19andrewsh Because Mapillary doesn’t do it. Which doesn’t matter anyway.
192020-10-18 21:33chlenix
♦74
слухай, тобі не все-одно, є там тег для назв англійською чи ні? таке враження шо ти платиш за оренду сервера для осм, і за кожен зайвий біт тебе жаба душить. ІМХО
202020-10-18 21:44muchichka_s
♦284
OK. Why can't I leave the English name?
According to Wikipedia, the city has an English name:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batiovo
although there are no native english speakers here from your words.
92669190
by andrewsh
@ 2020-10-18 20:46
12020-10-18 20:49muchichka_s
♦284
it is not loc_name. it is official_name, table_name, and just name
our communities have the right to name their streets as they wish. Please let us name our streets ourselves!
22020-10-18 20:50andrewsh Is it on the street sign?
32020-10-18 20:52muchichka_s
♦284
Yep, sometimes "Вашут" sometimes "Вошут"
42020-10-18 21:02andrewsh Ack, updated accordingly.
92666335
by muchichka_s
@ 2020-10-18 18:52
12020-10-18 19:39andrewsh Please make yourself familiar with: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_practice#Map_what.27s_on_the_ground and https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Multilingual_names.

Unless these names are used in reality (on street signs, in documents, in speech etc), don’t put them in. Even if they...
68289152
by andrewsh
@ 2019-03-19 10:43
12020-10-18 19:10muchichka_s
♦284
Why did you decide that they were pretend?
I visited the official site and see that these names are real. Please don't remove street names anymore!
22020-10-18 19:17andrewsh Those are not real English names, that’s not how names work.
32020-10-18 19:18andrewsh No matter what’s on the official site, these names aren’t real. I’m reverting your change now.
42020-10-18 19:20andrewsh English is not an official language in Ukraine or in this town, the English themselves have never given these streets any names. By putting invented English names here you’re lying to the people trying to use the map.
78634581
by andrewsh
@ 2019-12-19 11:26
12020-09-24 07:06aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, preco ste zlucili galeriu Bibiana s kniznicou Bibiana? Ved to boli odlisne objekty, vidite aj ze mali odlisne nazvy (aj description Vam teraz nesedi na kniznicu). Preto "dom umenia" bol na celej budove a kniznica je len cast preto na bode.
22020-09-24 07:12andrewsh Neviem či sú to dva samostatné objekty, asi skôr jedno alebo druhé, potom asi dom umenia; len tourism=gallery nie som si istý či je správny tag.
32020-09-25 08:12aceman444
♦2,567
No urcite to nie je len kniznica, ako to je teraz. Navrhujem revert, lebo predtym to bolo urcite lepsie. Ci moze byt kniznica znacena samostane na bode, preco aj nie, ked aj v skolach kde je cely kampus ako amenity=school, tak znacime jednotlive objekty samostatne, napr. jedalen ci sportovisko.
No ...
42020-09-25 08:15andrewsh Skôr som za community centre. Pretagujem to neskôr.
52020-10-19 13:18aceman444
♦2,567
Mozu tam byt aj obe, gallery aj community centre.
48629484
by andrewsh
@ 2017-05-12 17:08
12020-08-15 22:22aceman444
♦2,567
V tomto dvore medzi domami je dodnes znacka obytnej zony (315), takze preco zmena living_street na service?
22020-08-16 06:47andrewsh Ale je to dvorová cesta, tak to nemôže byť living street aj s tou značkou podľa mňa.
32020-08-16 09:23aceman444
♦2,567
Nie je to uzavrety dvor a keby aj bol, tak prave vdaka tej znacke by to znamenalo, ze to nie je uplne zakazany sukromny pozemok.
88572091
by andrewsh
@ 2020-07-27 14:51
12020-07-27 14:51andrewsh u was meant to be "update cafes"
87847475
by sipka
@ 2020-07-11 09:00
12020-07-11 09:04andrewsh Ozaj sa to volá Medzi domami?
22020-07-11 09:10sipka
♦18
To neviem ja som pridal pokračovanie k tým trom domom a zmenil surface celej cesty.
32020-07-11 09:14andrewsh Jaj, sorry, zle som pochopil. Diky :)
87149548
by andrewsh
@ 2020-06-25 16:03
12020-06-27 10:59skquinn
♦803
Smaller areas per changeset, please. This one covers (apparently) almost the whole planet.
22020-06-27 12:29andrewsh This was intended since it's a planet-wide change.
32020-06-27 12:55skquinn
♦803
This shows up as a changeset in Houston, Texas, US (and for that matter, a huge chunk of the US including everything east of the Mississippi), even though I doubt there were any changes made there. There is no reason to have all of this in one changeset; it is much easier to see what is changed and ...
77786706
by Christian Wirth
@ 2019-12-01 17:04
12020-06-25 15:46andrewsh You mapped those as yes=public, a tag which doesn’t exist. access=yes is more appropriate, but I’m not sure it’s even needed
22020-06-26 08:34Christian Wirth
♦1
Hi, from my comment on the changeset I take I mostly fixed things that different checkers suggested. I might have changed something towards public=yes but I don't think I would have added that if it was not there already, that's not a tag I would use normally (agreed, access=yes is appropr...
32020-06-26 09:31andrewsh The thing is, it was somehow yes=public, not public=yes. I wonder what makes it easy to make that mistake.
86238476
by erenozdemir
@ 2020-06-05 10:28
12020-06-25 15:40andrewsh How did you manage to create the yes=no tag?
22020-06-26 06:58erenozdemir
♦15
I used mapillary images.
32020-06-26 07:34andrewsh It doesn’t matter what you used, the tag yes=no doesn’t exist. You should verify what date you’re uploading.
42020-06-26 09:18erenozdemir
♦15
First of all, when making a comment, you should look at the history of change. I just looked at the road alignment. And I always validate. This is normal if I made a mistake because I am making about 5000 changes per day. Have a nice day :)
76893304
by erenozdemir
@ 2019-11-11 08:12
12020-06-25 15:41andrewsh And here you have yes=-1…
22506972
by MichalP
@ 2014-05-23 15:07
12020-04-20 09:55andrewsh Iste?
82012600
by andrewsh
@ 2020-03-10 14:42
12020-04-06 22:01aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, preco odstranovat addr:city? Ja ho zase vsade zvyknem pridavat :)
A 'levels' asi chcelo byt 'building:levels', prosim poopravujte.
22020-04-07 07:15andrewsh Lebo addr:city a addr:country sa dajú vydedukovať z geometrie, a tak je to zbytočná duplikácia.
32020-04-11 20:29aceman444
♦2,567
No to je sice teoreticky mozne, ale sa ta aplikacia pri dedukovani riadne zapoti, je to rozhodne netrivialne a nebude to kazda robit.
Tie 'levels' som Vam teda opravil.
42020-04-12 06:58andrewsh Nie, to nie je "teoreticky možné", to sa robí bežne a to robiť musí každá aplikácia, ktorá spracúva adresy, lebo je to štandard vo viacerých krajinách, a tak pokiaľ nejaký softvér to nerobí, nev...
67356652
by andrewsh
@ 2019-02-19 15:13
12020-02-13 00:02aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, Vy predsa viete, ze pre 'residents' existuje ina hodnota access.
22020-02-15 11:06aceman444
♦2,567
Alebo chcete vyjadrit rezidencne parkovanie, novu parkovaciu politiku na staromestne parkovacie karty?
32020-02-15 11:27andrewsh https://www.facebook.com/Bratislava.sk/photos/a.218369391559439/2316696751726682/?type=1&theater

Ale neviem či to ešte platí, lebo boli prednedávnom zmeny pravidiel.
42020-02-15 11:37aceman444
♦2,567
Na Facebook nastastie nevidim. Ale ak teda myslite parkovaciu politiku, tak to by ma tiez zaujimalo ako to znacit. Lebo aj v Petrzalke zaviedli svoju vlastnu. Mali by ste to najprv otvorit na fore aby sme sa vsetci dohodli na nejakom znaceni.
52020-02-15 15:33andrewsh Stránka je dostupná aj bez prihlásenia aj bez FB konta.
62020-02-15 15:34andrewsh Nie je to o parkovacej politike.
72020-02-15 18:51aceman444
♦2,567
Takze ako sa to lisi od access=private?
20716171
by *Martin*
@ 2014-02-22 15:55
12019-12-27 16:51andrewsh Ahoj @*Martin*, skadiaľ máš tie Lőgre? Neviem to nájsť v žiadnom inom zdroji.
22019-12-27 20:57*Martin*
♦641
Z katastra - viď zdroj. Len tam to priebežne menia.
74997795
by Linie29
@ 2019-09-27 09:12
12019-09-27 09:26andrewsh danke :)
73386828
by Anna Kočibalová
@ 2019-08-15 17:27
12019-09-11 17:38andrewsh Dobrý deň, pár otázok:

1) Máte zdroj k zmenám Zubre → Zubra a Zúbria → Zúbra?
2) Prečo ste zmazali name:hu=Háromszlécs?
3) Prečo ste dali population=Slováci? Má to byť číslo, nie (slovenské...
22021-02-23 21:59aceman444
♦2,567
No myslim, ze tych povymyslanych nazvov je tu viac, vsetky tie "chodnik, cesta, sesta ..." ci to co je "v Strednom Sliaci". A odpoved asi nedostaneme, autorka nie je velmi aktivna. Mnohe uz su opravene.
72707271
by vakulya
@ 2019-07-27 02:08
12019-09-11 16:56aceman444
♦2,567
Hi, why did you remove the trolleywire on road https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/240696203 ?

Also, the streets in Bratislava do not have Hungarian names. Where did you get those from? You have to provide the source in the changeset. If those are historical names, please move those from name:hu to...
22019-09-11 17:08andrewsh Actually, some streets in Bratislava *do* have Hungarian names, but those a historic names. I’m not sure what’s the best way to map them.
32019-09-11 21:23vakulya
♦6
Hi everybody,

sorry for removing the trolley wire at Sancova, it was a mistake. The matter with the Hungarian names of the streets in Bratislava is chaotic because they were renamed often. I have tried to use the most persistent names.

Best wishes,
vakulya
42019-09-11 21:30vakulya
♦6
Hi everybody,

there is a difference between an unofficial name and a historic name. 'Unofficial' means that it can not be used for official matters, 'historic' means that the community of the users uses a new one. The most of the Hungarian names of the streets and squares in ...
52019-09-11 21:49aceman444
♦2,567
Thanks for the answer. But you still did say what is the source of the names. And if the names aren't official, they shouldn't be put into the main 'name' tag (name:hu). Maybe use loc_name:hu if only some local Hungarian speaking citizens know those names?
71543536
by Maria Blonde Andersson
@ 2019-06-24 00:13
12019-06-27 22:57andrewsh Maria, you should really check what objects you’re editing. You’ve just renamed the entire city of Guanajuato to "union garden".
Please pay more attention in future.
22019-06-27 23:01andrewsh Besides, the Unión garden already existed:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/27356583
32019-06-28 05:04Maria Blonde Andersson
♦1
Hi. I don't think that was intentional if that alteration suggestion was done by me?! When did this happen, because I don't remember trying to change any of this though. What I do remember is that the place on the map where it says Guanajuato, it also says that the English name for it is u...
42019-06-28 05:05Maria Blonde Andersson
♦1
Also it would be nice of you to drop the condescending tone. Thanks.
52019-06-28 14:56andrewsh I’m sorry if the tone came across as condescending, that’s wasn’t my intention. When you edit an object in MAPS.ME, it tells you what the type of the object is, which is a good way to double-check you’re editing the right one, since the user interface in MAPS.ME unfortunately...
70649125
by Marian Mika
@ 2019-05-27 06:15
12019-05-27 07:58andrewsh Ozaj? :(
22019-05-27 10:06Marian Mika
♦21
google píše že tvalo zatvorené
https://www.google.com/search?q=sultan+kebab+zvolen&oq=sul&aqs=chrome.0.69i59j69i57.684j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

videl som u nich na dverách aj niečo popísané, ešte to pôjdem pozrieť
32019-05-28 06:41Marian Mika
♦21
tak nakoniec sa presťahovali k Prima banke
68392316
by dusoft
@ 2019-03-21 23:55
12019-05-25 23:49aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, zase ohybate existujucu znacku? "network" sa zvykne pouzivat na relaciach. Co znamena priamo na ceste? Do akej siete patria tieto cyklocesty, ked na nich ziadna cyklotrasa (relacia) nie je? A z akej "ba map" mapy Bratislavy ste to obkreslili?
22019-05-26 18:52andrewsh @aceman444, nestačilo už? toto som prediskutoval na #osm a všetci tam s tým súhlasili.
32019-05-26 19:40dusoft
♦5
Omylom namiesto lcn=yes. Dam si na to pozor.
42019-06-29 20:27aceman444
♦2,567
Andreswh: Neviem kde je #osm, ale urcite som to necital. V kazdom pripade lepsi by bol asi nazor Slovenskej komunity, aby sme o tom aj lokalne viaceri vedeli.

dusoft: dodnes ste tie "network=lcn" nezmenili.
Ale lcn=yes nie je riesenim, to je tiez uplny nezmysel.

Preberte to prosim o...
68811524
by dusoft
@ 2019-04-02 20:07
12019-04-05 15:52aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, co prosim ma symbolizovat https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/681243390 ? Tam medzi chodnikom a budovou ziadna cesta nie je.
22019-04-05 17:24dusoft
♦5
neviem, cetsu som nepridaval, pridaval som priznak.
32019-04-05 22:07aceman444
♦2,567
Super, tak ju mozem vymazat.
Ten priznak bicycle=yes je tiez zaujimavy. Ak je tam vyslovne dopravna znacka C8, tak sa to znaci inak, cize neviem co ste chceli povedat (len ze podla Vas tam mozu ist bicykle?). A bicycle:practical znamena co? Jedina wiki stranka o tom je po rusky a nie je to velmi po...
42019-04-05 22:25aceman444
♦2,567
Lebo na normalne chodniky bicykel nesmie (bez povolujucej znacky) a na cestach automaticky ano, takze pridavat bicycle=yes tam je nadbytocne. Preto ma zaujima aka je tam dopravna znacka, ktoru ste chceli vyjadrit. Dakujem.
52019-04-06 14:49dusoft
♦5
To je dobra otazka. Zacal som s bicycle=yes, ale ako pises, to v podstate len replikuje nieco, co je vyjadrene inymi tagmi. Takze som presiel na bicyle:practical, ktory je sice pouzivany iba v Litve a spol., ale kvoli tomu ho nemusime diskriminovat.

Tag pouzivam na vyznacenie tras, ktore su bicyc...
62019-04-06 18:35aceman444
♦2,567
Co potom znamena "bicycle-friendly", ked su na tych chodnikoch bicykle zakazane? bicycle:practical teda pouzivajte ako chcete, kedze je to zatial neoficialna znacka bez dohodnuteho vyznamu. Ale tie bicycle=yes teda vsetky odstrante, kedze su klamlive. Dakujem
72019-04-08 09:41dusoft
♦5
Jasne, uz som to aj poodstranoval. Bicycle-friendly = trasy, ktore su pouzitelne a odporucane pre bicykle, ale nie su oficialne znacene zvislym ci vodorovnym znacenim.
Pouzivam teda nadalej bicycle:practical, to by nemalo nikomu prekazat :-)
82019-04-08 09:42dusoft
♦5
BTW, mame takyto pasport znaciek (vid vrstva vpravo)
https://mapa.cyklokoalicia.sk/pasport/public/

Ma niekto z SK OSM komunity zaujem o import?
92019-04-23 05:59aceman444
♦2,567
"odporucane" pre bicykle na chodniku, kde je zakonom zakazane jazdit s byciklom, mi pride ako nezmysel. To, ze si to niekde interne vediete, ako potencialnu trasu, kde by povolenie znackou v buducnosti mohlo byt udelene by bolo OK, ale nejak to zverejnovat (a "odporucat" tam jazd...
102019-04-25 18:40aceman444
♦2,567
Pozeral som dobre tu pasportizaciu a co prosim presne by malo byt predmetom importu? Podkladova vrstva je vyrazne zastarala, a tie farebne ciary vyzeraju byt aktualnym stavom v OSM (nie stavom aky by sa v OSM mal dosiahnut). Co je teda tam navyse, co by bolo prinosom pre OSM a zatial to tam nie je?
112019-04-29 18:00andrewsh > Pouzivat na to bicycle:practical=yes mne vadit nebude, ale mozno tym Rusom, co tu znacku vymysleli, kedze vase pouzitie je v rozpore s jej popisom na wiki (prelozil som si to).

Zrejme ten preklad nebol správny, lebo v rozpore to nie je. Je to trochu inak používane ale st&aacut...
122019-04-29 18:01dusoft
♦5
Tiez som tomu tak rozumel, aj ked oni to myslia skor pre nespevnene trasy.
132019-04-29 18:21aceman444
♦2,567
No neviem, me to prelozilo, ze je to na cesty, ked by sa mohlo zdat, ze sa tam bicyklovat neda (lebo moze byt nespevnena cesta alebo inak fyzicky problematicka) ale v skutocnosti sa da. V Bratislave sa pouziva na cesty, kde sa zrejme (asi nikto nebude mat iny dojem) fyzicky bicyklovat da (vsetko su ...
142019-04-29 18:42andrewsh V Bratislave sa to používa skorej ako subjektivná bicyklabilnosť ≈ cesta je vhodná pre relatívne bezpečnú jazdu, a cyklisti túto cestu skutočne preferujú iným cestám. Čo ani neodporuje „ruskému“ význa...
152019-04-29 20:19aceman444
♦2,567
Ako viete, ze prislusnu cestu cyklisti preferuju? Ok, mozno dusoft ma tie informacie, ale o takomto vyzname nehovoril. A ak by to tak bolo, potom by bola asi vhodnejsia nejaka znacka ako bicycle:preferred=yes. Lebo v takomto vyzname by bola v rozpore s ruskym popisom.

A ked je pouzita na chodniku...
162019-04-29 20:30andrewsh Zopakujem: v rozpore to nie je, ale už nejdem diskutovať o tom, prestáva ma to baviť.

Čo sa týka toho, kto čo preferuje, to sa mi ani nechce komentovať, je to strašne ignorantský prístup.
63100948
by MartinNagyMN
@ 2018-10-01 17:07
12018-10-02 07:25MichalP
♦13
vandalizmus, na revert.
22018-10-02 07:26andrewsh Hi @MartinNagyMN, this import has not been co-ordinated with the community, and is not done properly.

Could you please revert and join the discussion in osm_sk@googlegroups.com?

Thanks!
32018-10-02 07:31MartinNagyMN
♦1
Nerozumiem, co je na tomto vandalizmus?
42018-10-02 07:45andrewsh Myslím si že Michal s touto charakteristikou prehnal, ale upload duplicitných neoverených a nekorektných dát a vymazanie správnych nie je dobrý postup.
52018-10-02 07:51Tomas Kovacik
♦8
idete to revertovat? ci fixnem poziciu BS co mam pred vchodom tam kde bol a ma byt, kedze dotycny panko ani len nepozera source tag, aby vedel co ma a co nema importovat ...
62018-10-02 07:51MartinNagyMN
♦1
Ako som uz reagoval na Michalovu sukromnu spravu: Osobne som tie stanice presiel a chcel som ich sem nahodit. Trvalo by vsak velmi dlho pridat stanice po pamati a tak som si pomohol datami z oficialnej stranky. Za vymazanie stanic sa ospravedlnujem, nevsimol som si ze tam uz su. V kazdom pripade som...
72018-10-02 07:58Tomas Kovacik
♦8
pridana hodnota tam je, otazka je licencne je to ok?
82018-10-02 08:02MartinNagyMN
♦1
Aky by bol rozdiel keby som to pridaval bez datasetu ktory som vyextrahoval zo https://slovnaftbajk.sk/mapa-stanic? Hladal som, nenasiel som ziadnu informaciu ze by tieto data boli licencne zabezpecene.
92018-10-02 09:13Jose Riha
♦189
na moznost pouzit data som sa pytal niekolko mesiacov pred spustenim projektu. kedze bol prislub, ze import urobia sami prevadzkovatelia (na co sa neskor vykaslali), je to licencne ok. takto sa ale importy naozaj nerobia. bez komunikacie, bez co len jedineho zaznamu v osm wiki, poriadneho planu atd....
102018-10-02 14:13MichalP
♦13
kto to teda revertne?
112018-10-02 14:28Tomas Kovacik
♦8
ja by som dal sancu autorovi, nech ide na osm_sk a vydiskutuje sa tam co ako ..
122018-10-02 15:18MichalP
♦13
však samozrejme, po reverte tohto importu kľudne môže diskutovať (resp si aspoň prečítať o čom sa hovorilo doteraz)
132018-10-02 16:36aceman444
♦2,567
MartinNagyMN, rozdiel by bol v tom, ze by ste nezakreslili nespravne polohy stanovist, napriklad https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5943729925 na tomto mieste neexistuje.
Ano, naozaj oficialna stranka ma polohy chybne a nepresne.

Po druhe, ak nenajdete stopu, ze by data "boli licencne zabez...
142018-10-02 16:53aceman444
♦2,567
Revertnute (zmeny odstranene).
63101137
by MartinNagyMN
@ 2018-10-01 17:14
12018-10-02 07:24MichalP
♦13
vandalizmus, na revert
22018-10-02 07:26andrewsh Hi @MartinNagyMN, this import has not been co-ordinated with the community, and is not done properly.

Could you please revert and join the discussion in osm_sk@googlegroups.com?

Thanks!
32018-10-02 16:53aceman444
♦2,567
Revertnute (zmeny odstranene).
50729981
by Essin
@ 2017-07-31 18:23
12018-03-06 16:53andrewsh Hi,

This changeset of yours seems to add a lot of nonsense data, such as ways with invalid tags or without tags at all.

Could you please verify and fix it?

Thanks!
22018-03-11 18:07Essin
♦93
Hi,
I would of course clean up after myself if I accidentally have added nonsense data, but after going through the ways in this changeset, I could only find https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/395003928/history with obviously wrong tagging, which I have now corrected (snowmobile=* without highway=* ...
32018-03-11 18:49andrewsh As far as I can see there are multiple ways which aren't part of any relations and don't have any tags.
42018-03-11 18:51andrewsh Strange, I cannot see them anymore.
52018-03-11 18:52andrewsh I could have made a mistake or looked at a different changeset, but I cannot find the ways I've seen.
53768009
by Arne Paulsen
@ 2017-11-14 11:08
12018-03-06 16:33andrewsh Hi,

You seem to have added a lot of meaningless tags to https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/507084935/history…

Please check the data you upload to make sure this doesn't happen in future :)

Thanks!
54307989
by Borbus
@ 2017-12-03 20:04
12018-03-06 16:31andrewsh Could you please make sure you don't add meaningless tags such as yes=yes next time? :)

Thanks!
22018-03-06 20:45Borbus
♦31
I did? Where? If it was me then I'm surprised that JOSM didn't through up a warning before I made the change.
53633061
by Hagar66
@ 2017-11-09 09:12
12018-03-06 16:29andrewsh Please make sure you don't add meaningless tags like yes=no next time.

Thanks!
55278337
by Jose Riha
@ 2018-01-08 23:24
12018-01-21 12:40andrewsh We don't map official names though, do we? The street sign on this street says Ulica.
46701719
by MatoKesan
@ 2017-03-09 07:49
12017-03-09 10:36laznik
♦79
dobry den, to jazierko sa naozaj vola "Súkromné jazierko"? Na oznacenie faktu ze objekt je sukromny mame v OSM tagy. Do nazvu tato informacia nepatri.
22017-12-29 18:14andrewsh Nepatrí. Mažem.
46707058
by MatoKesan
@ 2017-03-09 11:35
12017-12-29 18:11andrewsh Erm, why?
46701141
by MatoKesan
@ 2017-03-09 07:18
12017-12-28 14:49andrewsh Hi Maťo,

What is the source for the park name? I was unable to find any evidence it is in fact named like that during the survey on the location.

Thanks!
22017-12-29 13:29*Martin*
♦641
It is a Pokemon Go virtual park ;-).

Please revert.
32017-12-29 13:48MatoKesan
♦3
It is not a virtual park, all the changes I described where made, I live here. My motivation to map these changes where Pokémon Go but that doesn't mean I put in something that doesn't exist.
Only the name of the park area has no source it isn't named yet it was my own naming...
42017-12-29 17:17*Martin*
♦641
OK, thanks for the explanation :-).
52017-12-29 18:07andrewsh If there's no source for the park name, I will have to remove it, at least until it is officially confirmed (or not).
54327122
by andrewsh
@ 2017-12-04 12:05
12017-12-05 16:07Harald Hartmann
♦827
Ok, you just fixed the wrong "bunglow", but why not fixed "builing:level", too?
http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/544522258
Please have a look at
http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/54274260
I think the DWG should block him and revert all his changesets.
22017-12-05 16:08andrewsh I haven't noticed that. I only noticed bunglow because I was watching http://osmlab.github.io/show-me-the-way/.
54326713
by Arshan Arshan
@ 2017-12-04 11:47
12017-12-04 11:57andrewsh Hi,

Thanks for your edits.

According to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:building%3Dbungalow, it should be building=bungalow, not building=bunglow (sic: missing "a").

It would be great if you used the correct spelling for your future edits.
22017-12-05 11:21mueschel
♦6,564
The same holds for 2700 buildings with the tag "builing:levels" which should be "building:levels".
And there are buildings mapped twice, e,g, around 7th Commercial Street.
32017-12-05 11:26andrewsh Indeed, I haven't noticed that.
48397418
by emergency99
@ 2017-05-04 14:49
12017-11-04 12:46andrewsh @emergency99, when you do this next time please go and actually check it on ground. The name wasn't wrong, it was (unfortunately) put into a wrong tag.

Thanks very much.
22017-11-04 14:20emergency99
♦288
But also the tag “shop=vacant” was wrong in that case.
32017-11-04 14:28andrewsh Well, it was, but unfortunately I couldn't see it in the app, it looked just like a shop.
42017-11-04 14:50emergency99
♦288
Well, Maps.me is not necessarily a good OSM-editor.
52017-11-06 08:28andrewsh Obviously it isn't. Yet it's necessary to pay more attention when reverting changes contributed using it.
36878147
by Panorama-mingas
@ 2016-01-29 12:21
12017-05-25 11:19andrewsh Добрый день,

Можно поинтересоваться, зачем Вы удалили бо́льшую часть Прилукской Слободы?

47594514
by andrewsh
@ 2017-04-09 14:32
12017-05-10 22:38aceman444
♦2,567
Zdravim, vsetky objekty odoslane cez maps.me sa nahrali s name:en, takze tie nazvy nie je normalne vidiet. Presiel som ich a niektore zmenil na 'name', kedze su po slovensky. Da sa s tym nieco robit, aby to nerobilo?
22017-05-10 22:49andrewsh Sorry, ze som neskontroloval po sebe. Treba asi nahlasit bug, inu moznost nevidim. Ked som to daval tam, vyzeralo to kvazifajn.
32017-05-10 22:51andrewsh A dakujem za opravu.

Je to take dost blbe, ze neponuka nazov "by default", ponuka samostatne slovencinu, anglictinu, madarcinu. Mozno som to a ja niekde nespravne dal, predpokladajuc, ze to pochopi spravne, uz teraz neviem.
48285566
by andrewsh
@ 2017-04-30 16:26
12017-05-03 06:10MiroJanosik
♦139
Ahoj, toto bude duplikat (mozno starsie mapy v maps.me?) pretoze pred dvoma tyzdnami som tu pridal Centrum Caffe aj s detailami. Dovolim si zmazat ho, noda pre cafe je https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4333007691
22017-05-03 09:33andrewsh O, jasne :)
47475017
by andrewsh
@ 2017-04-05 12:42
12017-04-05 12:48trigpoint
♦2,372
Hi, is this a real business that customers can visit?
I was about to ask, the website looks like it is contact by web or phone only so should not be in OSM.
Cheers Phil
22017-04-05 12:53andrewsh No idea, I just added the correct tag.
32017-04-05 12:53andrewsh Hmm, the website says they're in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire:
4 – 12 Kempson Close
Gatehouse Way Industrial Estate
42017-04-05 12:54andrewsh I will probably remove them. Thanks for paying attention. It looked like a legitimate business to me… which it probably isn't. Well, not in Oxford, at least.
52017-04-05 12:59trigpoint
♦2,372
Thank you.
It looked like spam, both the username and long description.
62017-04-05 13:00andrewsh Well, these two looked like spam, but the website looked okay-ish to me. I should have checked the address :)
43660721
by Ivor Švihran
@ 2016-11-15 04:35
12016-12-10 13:48andrewsh "Vnútorné Mesto"? To vážne?
22016-12-10 15:10Ivor Švihran
♦9
Vychádzal som z tohto: https://sk.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vn%C3%BAtorn%C3%A9_mesto_(Bratislava)
32024-08-10 12:15aceman444
♦2,567
No otazka je nakolko ten nazov este dnes plati, alebo je cisto historicky. Taktiez z wikipedie sa nazvy nemozu odpisovat do OSM.

Taktiez by ma zaujimal povod nazvu https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2518786859 alebo je to len opis toho kriza. Zase neuvadzate ziadne zdroje.
36502116
by andrewsh
@ 2016-01-11 12:21
12016-01-11 13:32TomH
♦14
I assume you followed http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct for this mechanical edit?
22016-01-11 13:54andrewsh Well, not quite…
32016-01-11 17:50trigpoint
♦2,372
Please revert it then
42016-01-14 14:27chillly
♦819
Undiscussed mechanical edits must be reverted.
52016-01-15 17:41andrewsh Sorry, I haven't yet had time to revert it. I will try during the weekend.
62016-01-15 17:43trigpoint
♦2,372
I have already reverted it, the UK community will work out how they should be tagged.

Thanks
72016-01-15 17:46andrewsh Right, having googled that I see this is a topic already discussed and quite a controversial one.
82016-01-15 17:57andrewsh Actually, one of your comments isn't quite right:

> ALDI, LIDL, ASDA and SPAR are all abbreviations of their full names, in
the same way as NATO, AIDS, BBC, OSM or GNU are.

Except Lidl isn't :)
36501921
by andrewsh
@ 2016-01-11 12:11
12016-01-11 12:12andrewsh Okay, not German, probably, but Dutch.
22016-01-11 12:13andrewsh Okay, and originally an abbreviation:

The name was originally DE SPAR, an acronym of the Dutch phrase Door Eendrachtig Samenwerken Profiteren Allen Regelmati
32016-01-11 13:32TomH
♦14
I assume you followed http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct for this mechanical edit?
42016-01-11 16:59trigpoint
♦2,372
SPAR is an abbreviation as you have mentioned, the shops are signed SPAR, not Spar. This change should be reverted.
52016-01-11 17:00andrewsh The company is now called Spar, not SPAR.
62016-01-11 17:02TomH
♦14
So that would be name=SPAR; operator=Spar then.

This is why we ask you to discuss mechanical edits before doing them.
72016-01-11 17:04andrewsh Well, if a police department says POLICE on the label, we don't tag it as name=POLICE, do we?
82016-01-11 17:29chillly
♦819
Undiscussed mechanical edits should be reverted.
92016-01-11 17:39trigpoint
♦2,372
Police is a word, rather than an abbreviation.
The day the signs on SPAR shops in the UK changes, then local mappers will change the tags.
In the meantime this change needs to be reverted.
102016-01-15 17:45trigpoint
♦2,372
I have reverted this, the UK community will decide how to correctly tag these shops
12749534
by Alexey_ND
@ 2012-08-16 11:37
12015-11-27 18:43andrewsh Уже не 8? Сколько сейчас-то?
21014566
by evgenykatyshev
@ 2014-03-09 21:15
12015-11-16 08:35andrewsh Вообще говоря, делить границу на 107 маленьких частей — не очень хорошая идея. Не стоит так делать впредь.
22015-11-16 09:33evgenykatyshev
♦108
А в чём проблема? Все части объединены отношением, поэтому вообще не важно на сколько частей она поделена.
32015-11-16 09:33andrewsh Ну теперь уже, когда katpatuka пофиксил. А не были. Katpatuka был жутко недоволен.
42015-11-16 09:48evgenykatyshev
♦108
Ну да, если не были, то плохо.

Я обычно аккуратно отношусь к отношениям границ, но если в этот раз что-то случайно сломал или не доделал, то приношу свои извинения.
52015-11-16 09:50andrewsh Окей, передал :) Он по-русски с гугль-транслейтом только, потому попросил кого-то по-русски на всяки
62015-11-16 09:51andrewsh …на всякий случай написать.
72015-11-16 10:53katpatuka
♦194
thanks - well nothing was "broken" though but the boundary was just difficult to maintain ;)
33440551
by wonchs91
@ 2015-08-19 14:05
12015-11-11 13:28andrewsh Hello wonchs91,

I'm not able to find anything in this area on any satellite images or on any other maps. Could you please explain where do the data come from?

Cheers,
Andrew
35151699
by ante44ante
@ 2015-11-07 15:34
12015-11-11 13:03andrewsh This doesn't look real; where do the data come from?
22015-11-14 10:32Jose Riha
♦189
Razumiješ li engleski?
34924078
by andrewsh
@ 2015-10-28 11:15
12015-10-28 18:23Jose Riha
♦189
preco obchodom a podnikom vymazavas adresu?
22015-10-28 18:28andrewsh Pretože adresu už majú.
32015-10-28 18:31Jose Riha
♦189
kombinacia shop/pub + adresa nie je nic neobvykleho. pred mazanim akehokolvek tagu prosim konzultuj wiki alebo taginfo https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/amenity#combinations
42015-10-28 18:33andrewsh Nie je nič neobvyklého, ale neznamená to, že to je potrebné a to má byť. Ako mať nekonzistentné adresy na POI a budovách, tak lepšie ich mať len na budovách, za podmienkou že sa jednoznačne to otagovať.
52015-10-28 18:34andrewsh …že sa jednoznačne to dá otagovať.
34841569
by RobJN
@ 2015-10-24 14:17
12015-10-28 11:10andrewsh Hello,

Thanks for your contribution, but there's no need to add extra duplicate data: the addresses of these places are already on the buildings there in, so adding them to the places themselves increases duplication and adds some confusion if the address information is not exactly the same ...
22015-10-28 18:05RobJN
♦77
Actually as a tourist it is more important to have the address data in the POI so that when you search for the POI you get all the detail you need. My preference would be to move all the POI data on to the building in cases where the POI occupies the building.

Something for you to think about: D...
32015-10-28 18:07andrewsh No, it usualy does not apply to the building, as normally there are multiple POIs in the building except when it's a building specifically built for some purpose (in that case it's okay to have POI tags on the whole building).
42015-10-28 18:11RobJN
♦77
It's cute that things are so clear cut in Bratislava. Shame you're not thinking about the benefit to the end data user but that's one for you to figure out with the local community.
52015-10-28 18:12andrewsh How does the end user benefit from excessive or wrong data?
62015-10-28 18:17RobJN
♦77
Because when they search for Moods bakery they get results that include an address - something that most people would expect. Ultimately it comes down to what you think an "address" is. One could argue that the address is a delivery point and therefore the address should be tagged to the d...
72015-10-28 18:19andrewsh If some software can't figure the address from the building the POI is in, it's defective software and it needs to be fixed.
82015-10-28 18:22RobJN
♦77
So please offer to fix all the software that doesn't currently work in your desired way.

Also what to do with a large building that includes multiple addresses (say 1 to 20) and one of these is a cafe at address 18 in that building?
92015-10-28 18:27andrewsh Multiple addresses is one of the use cases for having addresses on POIs, I never argued that.
102015-10-28 18:30RobJN
♦77
Well no worries. I'll leave it to your community to work out. I just wanted to highlight that it is not as clear cut as you think it is and the "so fix your software" argument is not particularly helpful when the matter isn't so clear cut and the software developers are usually w...
30451655
by Komяpa
@ 2015-04-24 11:23
12015-04-24 13:40andrewsh Teh Wow.
22015-04-24 13:55trolleway
♦21
Солсбері
32015-04-24 14:35woodpeck
♦2,425
What is the source of these names? For example, Russian names of "Swadlincote" or "Great Dunmow"? Is there any evidence of these places actually having a name in Russian, or are these just transliterations?
42015-04-24 14:38dudka
♦284
This should be interesting discussion :D
See the previous one.
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2014-August/thread.html#16294
52015-04-24 14:46Komяpa
♦22
Hello,

to find russian names for places, I googled for English place names plus "достопримечательности", "погода" or some other russian word. It shows a lot of pages where the name is used, and some of them have russian version.

see for example
...
62015-04-24 14:59woodpeck
♦2,425
Frankly, no - is *any* of these web sites more than a database of transliterated place names? I saw hotel listings, tour operators, and weather pages, all obviously using a generic catalogue of transliterated place names. These sites would generate a place page for any remote village that has a hote...
28724296
by Veronika VeLe
@ 2015-02-09 11:05
12015-02-10 17:55andrewsh Takto sa to prosím nerobí. Ak chcete doplniť dáta — v pohode, ale nerozhádzať popri tom existujúce. Kolega-Žilinčan tuším teraz to opraví, ak nie — skúsim ja, ale Vaše dáta žiaľ budú zmazané....
22015-02-11 10:45andrewsh Revertol som to.
28471641
by Mergen
@ 2015-01-28 18:45
12015-01-29 12:47SomeoneElse
♦13,362
Hello and welcome to OpenStreetMap. What exactly is http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/325048641 ? Is it something that you can actually see on the ground?
22015-01-29 12:49andrewsh Seems like a new branch of Eurotunnel…
32015-01-29 12:54andrewsh Mergen, I think it's not a good idea to add low-cost flights to OSM, at least not in the specific way you did.

Добавлять лоукостеры в ОСМ — не самая лучшая идея вообще, ну и точно уж не таким способом, как это...
42015-02-05 20:11zool
♦50
OpenStreetMap is an attempt to make an accurate map of the observable world.
52015-02-11 16:30aceman444
♦2,567
On the other hand, there already are ferry (ship) routes (on water) in OSM.
62015-02-11 16:44Mergen
♦1
Блин, я вообще не хотел выгружать это в OSM. В общем, я нуб и накосячил по полной. Пытался освоиться в JOSM, но видимо что-то пошло не так, только сейчас заметил. Как вообще...
72015-02-11 16:47SomeoneElse
♦13,362
@Mergen - don't worry, it's not there any more :)

We've all made mistakes like this - the only people who haven't have never tried to do anything in the first place!
28236423
by Komяpa
@ 2015-01-18 17:52
12015-01-26 13:22andrewsh Далеко уплыл, однако!
28304543
by Clira14
@ 2015-01-21 11:53
12015-01-21 19:30aceman444
♦2,567
Dobry den. Tu bola povodne budova a teraz je z nej bazen? Ak je to kryta plavaren, potom budovu nechajte a dajte samostatny bod do budovy, ktory bude mat leisure=swimming_pool a indoor=yes a covered=yes.
22015-01-22 11:17Clira14
♦4
Upravene. Takze na tej budove ten tag swimmingpool nema byt? Teda, ze v OSM je budova proste budova a swimming poolom sa mysli to, co je v budove, preto tam mam dat pin?
32015-01-22 12:40andrewsh @Clira14, nie úplne. Ak je to budova, je postup ako napísal @aceman444: vytvori bod, dať tag. Mazať building vo väčšine prípadov nie je dobrý nápad ;)
42015-01-22 12:41Clira14
♦4
budovu mazat nechcem... len ja by som ten swimmingpool a indoor a covered dala aj na nu, tym padom by tam nemusel byt aj ten pin naviac. pride mi to zbytocne duplikovanie akoby... ci? @andrewsh
52015-01-22 12:45Clira14
♦4
este jedna vec mi nejde do hlavy... ze preco tato mapa nesedi so satelitnymi snimkami - myslim napriklad tvar budovy? http://puu.sh/eRO5V/a1552c9d7a.png odkial sa vzalo, ze ma ta budova takyto tvar? ... a prave som zistila, ze som to tu asi uplne zle oznacila... jedine, ze by nie, este musim popatra...
62015-01-22 12:58andrewsh source=kapor2 → asi je to z katastru importované.

Ďalšia vec je že sa obkresľuje podľa ako keby podľa ‘tieňa’ budovy: predstav si že na budovu svieti zhora (90°) paralelný prúd svetla. Ten obraz, ktorý zostáva na zemi, sa obkre...
72015-01-22 12:59andrewsh Inak ale asi tu je táto budova označená nesprávne, asi ju prestavali od toho času kedy to bolo importované.
82015-01-22 13:01Clira14
♦4
ahaa... uz chapem. vdaka. inak vobec to nie je ta budovova, ktoru som myslela. uz je to dobre, zmenila som to cele... lebo tu ta budova s plavarnou uplne chyba. Mozno este updatnem ten obrys, ktory neviem ci je uplne spravny, ale v zasade je to uz lepsie. Navyse tam uz nie je ten tenisovy kurt ktory...
92015-01-22 13:07andrewsh Hej, už vidím, asi bazén je tuná, [kde budova chýba](http://i.imgur.com/VUozVoQ.png), ale ten kurt je asi vpravo vedľa.
102015-01-22 13:07andrewsh Aha, Markdown tu nefunguje.
112015-01-22 20:41aceman444
♦2,567
Ono islo o to, ze ste building=yes vymazali a namiesto toho dali len leisure=swimming_pool. Takze uz to nie je budova (nech je vnutri cokolvek) ale otvoreny bazen pod holym nebom (ako napr. na kupalisku Tehelne pole). Aj keby ste building nechali, je to hybrid, lebo budova nemoze byt zaroven bazenom...
122015-01-22 20:56aceman444
♦2,567
A k tej nepresnosti fotiek: satelitne fotky byvaju aj niekolko rokov stare, takze budovy mozu byt davno zmenene. A aj na najnovsej mape potom plati to co pisal andrew: budova moze byt tazko obkreslitelna kvoli tienom, stromom a streche zakryvajucej skutocny podorys.
28305148
by Clira14
@ 2015-01-21 12:25
12015-01-21 12:28andrewsh Len toto, ak dávaš to na way, tak nezabudni tak dať aj building=yes
22015-01-21 12:29Clira14
♦4
ahaa... ok, idem to upravit.
28192949
by Walter Schlögl
@ 2015-01-16 17:58
12015-01-19 10:20andrewsh This change has to be reverted as conscription number unfortunately overrides housenumber, which is why streetnumber is important.
20486433
by michaelis1888
@ 2014-02-10 14:37
12015-01-14 17:22andrewsh Ahoj, prečo si vymazal name?

Hi, why have you removed the name tag?
22015-01-14 17:25andrewsh Inak by bolo dobre ak by ste sa zapojili do diskusie: osm_sk@googlegroups.com

By the way, it'd be great if you joined the discussion here: osm_sk@googlegroups.com
27364856
by AvnerR
@ 2014-12-09 20:26
12014-12-10 09:00andrewsh *Part* Tomášov? What's that?
27080145
by AvnerR
@ 2014-11-28 00:07
12014-12-02 09:43andrewsh You shouldn't add the name in Hungarian to name, there's name:hu for that.
26070192
by TomasRegina
@ 2014-10-14 11:49
12014-11-13 13:29andrewsh Dávajte si prosím pozor na to kam posúvate body a aký to má vplyv na všetko.
Ďakujem.
26511878
by *Martin*
@ 2014-11-02 20:00
12014-11-04 10:37*Martin*
♦641
test
22014-11-04 12:22Durko_freemap
♦282
vyzera to dobre
32014-11-04 12:40andrewsh ahoj
42014-11-04 12:54*Martin*
♦641
vsetko funguje
26493883
by Kilkenni
@ 2014-11-02 00:09
12014-11-02 12:37lks1[konto usunięte]
♦17
Test
22014-11-02 12:53andrewsh Failed.
25578550
by Komяpa
@ 2014-09-21 12:32
12014-11-02 11:40andrewsh кот тут?