| Changeset |
No. |
Date |
Contributor |
Comment |
|
| 48865452 | trigpoint | Again are you sure this isn't Lloyds Pharmacy? |
| Steve Cazwell | Yes changed to Lloyds Pharmacy. Not Pharmacist as I mistakenly typed originally. 😊 |
|
| 48859364 | trigpoint | Hi, the name suggests that this should be tagged as leisure=fitness_centre, a shop=sport is a place selling sports equipment. |
| Jethro10 | It's a shop. Sells primarily running gear. It's not a gym or similar |
| trigpoint | Thank you, the name implies a gym type place. Was just checking . |
|
| 48851365 | trigpoint | Hi, are you sure this isn't Lloyds Pharmacy? |
|
| 48862646 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, however you have made a few classic beginners mistakes.The school is already mapped, you have therefore created a duplicate. The name tag should only be used for things that have an actual name, hence bus stop, church, postbox are descriptions that sh... |
|
| 48834097 | kreuzschnabel | These were the last landuse=farm on the British Isles, so please don’t add new ones :-) And just in time we were, the new carto revision (which will not render landuse=farm any more) seems to have been switched active a few hours later. |
| trigpoint | It was never a pressing issue, farm/farmland is of dubious values consiting of vast areas armchaired by crayonists. It.adds very little value to those of us using OSM in rural areas.Many areas close to me were poorly drawn with connections to roads/rivers (not riverbank) and I had left them until ... |
| kreuzschnabel | I agree that landuse=farmland is of pretty little use (moreover, it’s not clearly defined from landuse=meadow, so there are areas already where these two collide). landuse=farmyard, on the other hand, is of higher value for the walker or bicyclist, and I wouldn’t really like to miss them... |
| trigpoint | I would agree farmyard is far more important than farmland itself. It is afterall the default state of non urban areas. It is a big shame that meadow has been so badly misused, it should be a rare but useful tag. Most.is simply pasture.If we are going to map farmland we should be doing it at a muc... |
| SomeoneElse | Hi kreuzschnabel,This looks very much like a mechanical edit. Have you ever actually visited e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2876566751/history to see if it deserves any sort of "place" tag?Best Regards,Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group. |
|
| 48836980 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we map what exists in the real world, we do not map things as something it is not.I have reverted this edit. |
| Tim Hill | Hi trigpoint,I don't understand your comment.I can assure you it's a park area. I walk through it frequently. If it's the description/designation you disagree with e.g. open space then fair enough, but I don't understand why you have reverted the change. Could you explain further.Thank you,\... |
| Tim Hill | Ah ok, I have seen a comment left on the note about this. I honestly don't know what the difference is between field / park in OSM. I'll check what the correct designation should be in the wiki and perhaps come back to you. It has benches, paths and the grass is maintained short, but i'll check.\... |
|
| 48828100 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for this addition. You should add religion and denomination tags here.Maps.me is a bit basic, so probably wont allow you to do this, you should use a proper OSM editor such as iD from the OSM site. |
|
| 48731129 | trigpoint | Hi, I think something has gone wrong with this series of edits. This is a pub beer garden, not a German style biergarten. According to the wiki https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=biergartenTo be clear, a biergarten is not the same as (what is known in the UK as) a "beer garde... |
| Aleks-Berlin | Hi Phil, it seems that this is a private tag by single users. on this planet are only 25 beer_garden, see https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/amenity=beer_gardenAlso the OSM wiki tells both should be tagged as "biergarten" or pub (not beer_garden", see https://wiki.openstreetmap.... |
| Aleks-Berlin | After found a solution that is alligned with OSM wiki, I will change this. Please make a proposal. Thx, Alex |
| trigpoint | Hi AlexThere is no such thing as a private tag, OSM allows a user to add any tag they wish. Those with a small number are unlikely to be rendered but a mapper is free to use any tags, this one is pretty well accepted in the area where it is used and describes a beer garden. Maybe the tagging can b... |
| Aleks-Berlin | Hi trigpoint,I changed it back. I searched forway(user:"Aleks-Berlin")["amenity"="biergarten"]({{bbox}});bbox=over Bristisch Isles, no node or rela found.You can verify here.https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/48848464Many regards, Alex |
| geow | Hi trigpoint, as a frequent visitor of "biergarten sensu stricto" aka Bavarian Biergarten I'm just curious - what are the characteristic features of a pub beer garden?Cheersgeow |
| Aleks-Berlin | He said: read https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=biergartenBut it is a philosophical question if the garden beside a pub (in UK beer_garden) is something else a german biergarten (which has typically a pub beside). The one is the garden of a pub, the other the garden with an attached ... |
| geow | The wiki in this case is fairly clear. But some people, even in Bavaria ;) are not aware of the strict definition:Necessary characteristic of a "biergarten" is that you are allowed to bring your own food.That is why many so-tagged amenity=biergarten" even in Germany qualify only... |
|
| 48810555 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please remember that OSM is a public database and the name:xx tag should only be used for things that actually exist. It should not be used for personal markers or to record how much you paid for lunch.I am reverting this changeset. |
|
| 48765219 | trigpoint | Hi, this is a big change and covers a large area. Please could you use meaningful changeset comments that tell other mappers what you were doing. Did you actually look at every one of the 11 pages of ways you have changed.I am sure that if as you say you were fixing josm, you would not have touch... |
| ninjamask | I meant, that I used the validator in JOSM to fix issues like double nodes and other auto-fixable issues. After that i fixed some issues of ways with double segments. |
| SomeoneElse | Please don't use rely on the validator in JOSM without manually checking every change. The JOSM validator will get some things right, but it will get some edge cases wrong as well. |
|
| 48724108 | BCNorwich | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.Your POI guest house is placed in the roadway. As such and without an address, name or other contact info it is of little or no use to anyone. Could you please rectify this if not the POI will be removed in due course. Regards Bernard |
| trigpoint | It translates as Oli's House, suggesting that this is yet another maps.me personal marker.I am reverting this rubbish |
|
| 48658364 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. We do not map geocaches, it kind of defeats the object.I have reverted this. |
|
| 48574727 | trigpoint | This is a garden, it is not a park |
|
| 48560266 | trigpoint | Hi, the railway stations should be tagged as Borth, not Borth Station. You have also changed it to a station. Borth is a request stop, hence it was already correctly tagged as a halt. |
|
| 48557606 | trigpoint | Hi, you seem to have removed the railway=rail tags from the Cambrian Line. I am fixing this. |
|
| 48555866 | trigpoint | Hi, does this church really have a postcode?Any postcode is likely to be the vicarage, I doubt post is delivered to the church. |
|
| 48570568 | trigpoint | This is not a park, reverted |
|
| 48570725 | trigpoint | This is not a park, reverted |
|
| 48570872 | trigpoint | This edit is unacceptable. Reverted |
|
| 48570922 | trigpoint | This edit is unacceptable. Reverted |
|
| 48570850 | trigpoint | This edit is unacceptable. Reverted |
|
| 48555310 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The correct way to tag a school is on the area covering the grounds and just tag the building as building=school. The grounds here were already correctly tagged.As for language you should not put Welsh and English into the name tag. here I would use Welsh as the primary and use... |
|
| 48487340 | trigpoint | Hi, please could you explain why you have removed the name from this school?Thanks Phil |
| adventure1 | Duplicated data cluttering map. There is a school pinpoint within the school grounds. This entry is the school grounds one.Many thanks for querying :) |
| trigpoint | Hi, the correct place to tag a school is on the grounds. Nodes are seen as a poor way to tag large areas. There was a successful project There was no additional node however, there was a bus stop, which you have added school tags to. I believe that both these changes should be reverted. Cheers P... |
|
| 48564919 | trigpoint | Hi, please could you explain your reasons for deleting this churchyard? |
| RichRico | Hi trigpoint, I made a mistake deleting the churchyard, but I reversed the change.https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/406558653/history#map=19/52.48800/-4.04586thanks for your observation |
|
| 48474127 | trigpoint | Hi, please can you make your changeset comments meaningful. Describe what you are actually trying to achieve. This and many of your other changes are huge and covers a very large area.Thanks Phil |
|
| 48477017 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. There is no supermarket here. I have therefore removed it. |
| Chris Fleming | Thanks trigpoint - think this was probably a "duplicate" of the store next to the Last Drop. |
|
| 48448046 | trigpoint | Hi, this should probably office=company, it certainly isn't a clinic |
|
| 48457176 | trigpoint | Hi, please remember that that name tag should only be used for actual names, not descriptions. I an object doesn't have a name then the tag should be left blank. |
|
| 48455640 | trigpoint | Hi, please remember that that name tag should only be used for actual names, not descriptions. I an object doesn't have a name then the tag should be left blank. |
|
| 48445782 | trigpoint | Hi, this edit looks a little odd. Firstly is it a hotel or is it a holiday cottage? Also a name is meant to be a name and the tag should not be used for a description.What is the source of this edit? I am assuming you have not been there as it is not near a building. Is it verifiable? Does it have... |
|
| 48337343 | trigpoint | Hi, what is your reason and source for this change? Have you been there?The section you have tagged as a bridge is very definitely a causeway, and it is called simply Swarkestone Causeway.I will see what other local mappers view is, but mine is that this should be reverted.Cheers Phil |
| Mike Baggaley | I agree, although not local, I have been over it. My understanding is that there are sections that are bridges and sections that are causeway and that it is in total known as Swarkestone Bridge and Swarkstone Causeway - see https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1088337. It certa... |
| trigpoint | I received a reply to this as a private message, for changeset discussions it is better to keep these discussion public where they can be seen by all mappers.The whole is known as Swarkestone Bridge by most people, but most don't consider the detail in the way that a mapper does. The actual brid... |
| trigpoint | No response so am reverting it based on my local knowledge gathered over many years |
|
| 47778714 | trigpoint | Hi BernardNot sure if you looked through the history of this object but it was changed to a park, from a village green, by Doily17. I suspect this is pokemon related and should probably to put back?Cheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Hello Phil, I actually only adjusted the outline to better reflect what I saw on the Bing image regarding the street car parking. A well known web site shows the area looking much like a park. I've searched the web and find that Corner Pin is the old name for a much larger area to the south now buil... |
|
| 48394534 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM, these are very odd places to buy fuel. What were you trying to achieve? |
| trigpoint | Fiction reverted |
|
| 48031445 | ndm | Dave, thde wiki says "Set a node Node or draw as an area Area along the building outline." -- I know that isn't how you map them in Bath, but that's how I've mapped the a lot of the ones in Bristol -- it would be good to keep this one consistent. |
| DaveF | I think the wiki page needs expanding. Similar to schools, Universities & hospitals, a boundary around all elements owned by the pub seems the more detailed/accurate way to map.I've posted to the tagging forum: "Mapping pubs as full areas"Mapping pubs as full areas |
| trigpoint | The biergarten tag is a little out of place. I suspect it is a pub beer garden.http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=biergarten?uselang=en |
|
| 48248316 | trigpoint | I am reverting these edits, they are very definitely recreation grounds |
|
| 48234563 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The Guards Museum is already mapped. I am removing this duplication |
|
| 48228126 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.I am always a bit concerned when a new mappers first edit is to just delete things.You have not explained what was wrong with the Health Centre but the building seems to match what is on bing imagery so maybe the tags should be changed but deleting the building is not the way ... |
| deathterrapin | The real health center is further down the road, and is marked correctly there. That building used to be the Rose Inn but is now just a house.The former Crossfield Tavern is also now just a house. |
| trigpoint | Thank you for your relply, I will revert this change to put the buildings back and then correct the tagging. |
| deathterrapin | Ah, I see, didn't realise I was deleting the whole buidling, sorry! |
| trigpoint | I have put the buildings back, less pub and health centre tags |
|
| 48228233 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Is this a verifable office with signs I would see if I walked down Adelphi Road? |
| Stephen Dench | This Business is registered to this address on pretty much every aggregator and directory online, including GMaps, Apple Maps, Bing maps etc.. And yes if you look outside of the front of the house you will see my sign "Web App Designer" |
|
| 48057569 | trigpoint | Hi, SOFA should be mapped as shop=charity, charity=furniture. You will need to use a proper editor such as iD to change it though. Give me a shout if you need a hand. |
| gerv | Yep. Thanks for the tip. The software I was using is very convenient, but only has a limited number of presets. My plan was to come back and fix them in a few days. I'm fine with using iD. Thank you for the reminder :-) |
|
| 48079366 | trigpoint | Stirling Castle is already mapped in great detail, a node doesn't add anything so I am reverting this edit. |
|
| 48084079 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I am not sure a community centre is really the way to describe a yacht club. Plus it is already mapped as.a marina. |
| Dusty52 | Thanks for this -If I could have found a "Marina" descriptor I would have used that! |
| Dusty52 | Can't find how to correct this misleading information. Can someone advise? |
|
| 48018758 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for adding the car park however you have made a common beginners mistake by putting a description in the name field. If the car park doesn't have a name, then leave the name field blank.Cheers Phil |
| Genoma | Thanks will change it :) |
|
| 47981886 | SomeoneElse | Can you explain what you mean by "invalid layer tag"?Layer tags are relative, so "layer=-1" or "layer=-100" isn't any more valid or invalid than "layer=0" or an implied layer=0, if all crossing features have positive layer tags.What problem are you trying ... |
| wongataa | I should have put some more detail in. These layer tags were not used in conjunction with any other tags such as bridge or tunnel. The features in question could also be clearly seen at surface level on the satellite imagery and were tagged as layer -1. The layer tags were applied in error as the... |
| SomeoneElse | Again, to be clear, _layer tags are relative_. Layer 0 does _not_ imply ground level.Again, what _actual problem_ are you trying to solve? |
| trigpoint | There are more changes here than your stated incorrect layer.You have also changed oneway=-1 to oneway=yes on way 204098940 thus reversing the direction of travel for that section |
|
| 47947482 | trigpoint | Hi, please can you point me to where this mechanical edit was discussed?You seem to have mechanically armchaired layer=1 onto bridges with no survey, if you had you would have seen that the bridge should be at layer=0 and maybe whatever is below them needs a later=-1 where it is below ground level... |
| wongataa | All bridges need a layer tag of 1 or higher. This is detailed in the OSM wiki on the bridge page. It doesn't matter if the bridge is a simple plank or not. It is above ground level.In that mapillary link the bridge needs a layer tag as it crosses a river/canal. The layer is to show where a f... |
| SomeoneElse | Firstly - please take the wiki with a bucketload of salt :)Secondly - layer=0 doesn't imply ground level - layer tags are relative, so "All bridges need a layer tag of 1 or higher" is simply wrong. Also, although it is possible to infer relative level from imagery and other sources, i... |
| SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 48258464 where the changeset comment is: Reverting some mechanical changes to layers. See http://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1325 and http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=133272 |
|
| 47844875 | trigpoint | Its a recreation ground, reverted |
|
| 47844669 | trigpoint | Reverted, not a park |
|
| 47844839 | trigpoint | It is in a park, but this is a football pitch. Reverted |
|
| 47950853 | trigpoint | Hi, please could you add some more detail to the artworks. A pub car park is an odd place for an artwork.Thanks Phil |
| ENB45 | Phil, I think this person is just messing about. There are a few changes by this person in the area. I have just cleaned up a set of paths that have been dragged all over the place in this users changeset, also with Artwork randomly placed that doesn't exist. |
| SomeoneElse | I've never been to that pub but I've commneted on another one that I don't think exists: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/47950670 . |
| SomeoneElse_Revert | This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 48420321 where the changeset comment is: Reverting Pokemon-inspired edits and other fiction. Attempts to contact the mapper have failed. |
|
| 47965805 | trigpoint | Hi, https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/188281048 does not need to be mapped as a tunnel. The road is already mapped as a bridge. |
| Genoma | good point thanks I'll change it |
|
| 47976840 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for your contribution however there are a few issues with this edit.1. You have not tagged it as junction=roundabout.2. A roundabout normally takes the highest classification, so this one should be primary. Exceptions are when there are motorways involved but that doesn't apply h... |
| samely | Thanks Phil! I've already added these details. |
|
| 47911091 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. We do not map Airbnbs as they are not verifiable.I have reverted this edit. |
|
| 47871125 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank yo for your contribution however it is looking a bit odd.I assume that the Blockbuster shop has become a solicitors but is still tagged as shop=video.Maps.me is a bit basic and doesn't allow even simple things like changing the category, in order to do this you will nee... |
|
| 47865027 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Redwell Leisure Centre is already mapped, it is not a park so I am reverting this pointless addition |
|
| 47840984 | chillly | Welcome to OSM Fairfield Recreation Ground is not a park it is a recreation ground - the clue is in the name. I have removed the extra park you added and altered the existing rec's name |
| trigpoint | Reverted duplicattion |
|
| 47820062 | trigpoint | Hi, you seem to have made a lot of these edits. What is the source of the opening hours you are adding? They are very spread out so I doubt you have visited them all. |
| ehm1806 | Hi, The source is the official supermarket websites as well as local knowledge. I do travel around! I see there is a place to put source in. I will do that. Thanks for the reminder |
| trigpoint | Thank you, however have you obtained explicit permission to copy from these websites? |
|
| 47822661 | trigpoint | Hi, this edit looks very odd. Bare rock is kind of unusual in Leicester. I think the original paved is a better description. |
| trigpoint | Fiction reverted |
|
| 47822765 | trigpoint | Again wetland along the new cut, I don't think so |
| trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 47822785 | trigpoint | You are wrong here, the node is the Bede Island area of Leicester. The park is already mapped as an area.Reverted |
|
| 47822927 | trigpoint | This is fiction, reverted |
|
| 47762476 | Mike Baggaley | Hi Martin, please do not add names that are descriptive, e.g. Playground - we already know it is a playground from its tag.Thanks,Mike |
| Martin Wynne | Hi Mike,But map users don't know it's a Playground unless I give it a name. I know there are some tiny little squiggly icons, but they are too small for someone of my age to see properly or understand what they mean. Also they vanish at some zoom levels. Most things have a name used by local resid... |
| Mike Baggaley | You should not add incorrect data just so because something is not visible at a different zoom level. If the icons are too small for you to see, then please set the zoom level on your browser to display larger (I don't mean zoom in on the map). In addition to an icon, playgrounds are clearly display... |
| trigpoint | Hi Martin, also remember that OSM is a geographical database. The map you see on the OSM site is just one, of many renders that are available and anyone is free to create their own if what they require something different. |
| Martin Wynne | Hi Mike,But how do map users know what the colours mean? I clicked on the Map Key and a Playground isn't listed.When I zoom the browser some icons vanish. Also the map gets very fuzzy. I can't seem to attach a screenshot here, so here's a link:http://85a.co.uk/forum/gallery/2/2_151117_37000000... |
| trigpoint | Icons are displayed at different zoom levels, I cannot tell what zoom level that image was, but the playground icon (in mapnik) displays starting at z17. |
| Martin Wynne | Hi, I was zooming the browser (Firefox) as suggested by Mike, not zooming levels in OSM. At some browser zoom settings the icons vanish, and reappear at both higher and lower settings (which doesn't make sense to me).cheers,Martin. |
| trigpoint | Use the + - zoom buttons, or simply the scroll wheel if you have a mouse.But do remember that OSM is a database and mapping should not be dictated by a single renderer. |
| Martin Wynne | Hi, Yes that's what I'm doing, using the mouse wheel. I have added a lot more detail to the Cemetery. Cheers, Martin. |
| Mike Baggaley | Regarding items and/or icons seeming to vanish at different zoom levels, you may not be aware that each zoom level is generated separately over a period of time, so after you add something, a few hours later you may see it at one zoom level, but it may not have yet made it into the others. I usually... |
|
| 47765086 | trigpoint | Does this cemetery have a name? It is unlikely to be just Cemetery. |
| Martin Wynne | Hi, Thanks for your message. Part of the cemetery is St Michael's Churchyard. The old sign on the other part is "Stourport Urban District Council Cemetery". That council ceased to exist in 1974, it is now run by Stourport Town Council. Local people just call it "The Cemetery". I ... |
|
| 47793584 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for you contribution however there are a few issues.Is there any evidence the names Berwick Grange and Sundorne Grove actually exist beyond marketing and estate agent speak. I have never seen, or heard, those names. Also please try to work with existing objects rather... |
| sleepingwolf | Hi PhilThanks for your comments, my apologies I hadn't realised I had deleted grassed areas, I'll replace them and bare in mind for the future about editing existing objects instead of replacing. I'll amend the school names too.In terms of the estate names they are very much used locally in thos... |
|
| 47788394 | trigpoint | The correct way to describe this is amenity=playground. |
|
| 47639516 | trigpoint | Hi, this looks a very odd edit. Please can you explain? |
| trigpoint | No response and very unlikely to be verifiable so reverted |
|
| 47738616 | trigpoint | Hi, you seem to have deleted the Kidderminster Pay Scale area, why? |
| Martin Wynne | Hi,Sorry, I'm new to all this. I'm not aware of deleting the Kidderminster Pay Scale area? I have no knowledge of what that is, and Google doesn't seem to know either.If I deleted it, it was not intentional. As far as I know I have only ever deleted things which I have added myself, and thin... |
| trigpoint | Hi MartinIt is the area for which a plus bus ticket is valid. I will put it back if it was accidental.Cheers Phil |
| Martin Wynne | Hi Phil, Thanks. I understand now.p.s. PlusBus is one word with camel case or all-caps, see http://www.plusbus.infocheers,Martin. |
|
| 47783006 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.I have disconnected the park boundary from the centreline of the road and also converted the parts to a multipolygon. |
| chillly | Welcome to OSMThanks for the detailWhen you are adding an area please don't join it up to a road. The line that marks the road is the centreline so there will always be a gap. |
|
| 47780920 | chillly | Welcome to OSMYou have added a park over the top of all the existing stuff. This is clearly a doodle and I will revert (undo) it. |
| trigpoint | Duplicate reverted |
|
| 47776942 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Sidewalks should only be drawn as separate ways if there is a physical separation. Then you need to make sure you make all connections, otherwise you will cause some very silly routing, The normal way to add sidewalks is to tag the road, sidewalk=both|left|right. |
|
| 47755922 | trigpoint | Hi, these are definitley areas of grass, certainly not parks so I have reverted this change. |
| rgt | my mistake, thought it was park of the park upriver, thanks for the change |
|
| 47710321 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Deleting paths because they are private is the wrong way to go about things, they are a feature on the ground and should stay in OSM. If they are private they should be tagged access/foot/bicycle=private.OS maps are copyright and should not be used even to check something. Use... |
| dothelalalalala | HiThankyou for the feedback, I havent edited before.The paths I removed have been ploughed over since access was retracted, so they dont exist now. Ill be sure not to mention OS maps in future and rest assured anything I add or change is based on first hand observation.Re access rights, I fo... |
| trigpoint | Thank you for the explanation, it is fine,Keep up the good work. |
|
| 47618640 | trigpoint | Hi, I think this has gone a little wrong. What you have tagged as a private park is actually a garden. I have removed this error |
|
| 47596000 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I think this edit has gone a little wrong, you seem to have added a caravan site which should be tagged as tourism=caravan_site but you have probably pressed a wrong key and tagged it as a park. Please can you correct it? |
| Newton Grove | Hi TrigpointThanks for comment would love to correct it. Using ID browser editor I can not see how to tag it as tourism=caravan_site |
| Newton Grove | TrigpointI think I have got it typed into "search". Now updated |
| trigpoint | That looks good, thank you |
|
| 47594619 | trigpoint | Hi, we do not map airbnbs in osm. I am reverting this edit. It is also unlikely to be in the middle of the road. |
|
| 47595674 | trigpoint | Hi, the correct way to map aavement which is attached to a road is by the tag sidewalk=left|right|both. They should not be mapped as separate ways unless there is a physical separation. Mapping as you are doing breaks rendering and spoils OSM for its users. Highway=pedestrian is intended to be used ... |
|
| 47594447 | trigpoint | Hi, the YHA in Earls Court is already mapped. I am therefor removing your duplication.I also doubt that Casa de Ania is in the middle of the road. |
|
| 47586108 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution however there are a couple of issues.It is still a building, area=yes on its own does nothing and is not needed on a building.In order to render it needs a tag, rather than remove the shop tag it should be changed to shop=charity, if you want t... |
|
| 47570276 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your addition however it looks like it should be a recreation ground rather than a park. |
|
| 47557198 | trigpoint | Hi, mae hyn yn ddefnydd rhyfedd iawn o'r briffordd = preswyl. Fel arfer, ffyrdd sy'n arwain at ffermydd yn cael eu mapio fel naill ai annosbarthedig neu wasanaeth yn dibynnu ar amodau'r mynediad.Hefyd dylai'r sylwadau changeset fod mewn iaith glir fel y gall mappers eraill yn deall, yna yn hytrach... |
| MalingaGIS | Hi, trigpoint. Thank you very much for the correction. I update these as highway=service, it seems those are farms. I thought it was residential. Will included the meaning full comments. Thanks again. |
| trigpoint | Thank you for making the corrections, however your changeset comment is still hashtaged, hashtags belong on twitter, not in OSM, thanks. |
|
| 47567572 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution however the tagging appears to have gone a little wrong, it is easy for newcomers to make these mistakes.You have said you have mapped a wood, and I can see a wood exists however you have mistakenly tagged it as a park. Would you correct that? Al... |
|
| 47520174 | ndm | Is this copied from the website -- they have a "warning" notice:"This entire site © BM Services and UKMotorhomes.net. If you wish to reproduce any information published here, including copying to online discussion groups or forums, please make a request via our contact form. ... |
| p3et | Thanks for the hint. I'll ask them for permission. |
| trigpoint | The mapping of these also feels wrong. They seem to be existing car parks, so the tag should (if allowed, although there is a pretty big notice saying it must not be copied) be added a tags to the existing objects. However the site uses google maps which makes the data incompatible with OSM even if ... |
|
| 47555258 | trigpoint | Hi, I know the tagging here was inconsistent. But this section was probably right.Kingsland Bridge and the associated roads are privately owned and not PROW hence access=permissive was correct. |
|
| 47554569 | trigpoint | Hi, should footway https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/485430915 not connect to Bynner Street, rather than the Prince of Wales car park, it should also connect to the service road (probably needs parking_aisle too). I did spot some sort of path there yesterday after a couple of Threads to get a chines... |
|
| 47544783 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Does this guest house have a name. It is very unusual for a business not to, also does it have a phone number/website? |
| trigpoint | No response so reverting |
|
| 47542450 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. What is the actual source of these edits? The document you quote does not have specific permission for use. |
| Itay Greenspon | Hi, I'm a resident of this community and am using my local knowledge of the area. The document is an accurate reflection of the actual layout. |
|
| 47533284 | trigpoint | Does this shop still exist?The domain is for sale. |
| ti-lo | I can't check it personally. Left a "fixme" entry. In case you can check it directly, you may certainly edit it. |
|
| 47465824 | Robert Whittaker | In this changeset, you've created a node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4776270621 with an address, but tagged it as a bank/building society. Abbey Street appears to be a residential street, so are you sure this is correct? |
| trigpoint | Hi RobertI have already removed a similar node by this user from this location. The name 'Home' gives it away as a personal marker by a maps.me user.This one should also be removed.Cheers Phil |
|
| 47514239 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The correct way to tag a field where sheep graze is landuse=farmland, although farmland is normally left blank.For some reason you have made a mistake and tagged it as water, wont the sheep drown? |
| wir3d123 | Appreciate the advice. New to this as you can probably tell... I think i have corrected this now. Please tell me if i need to change it again. |
|
| 47489044 | Pillock | Wrong description.Changed carpark to two seperate areas as you cannot drive from the Public carpark (south west) to the Red Lion Carpark (north east) and they have separate entrances. |
| trigpoint | Can you walk between the two, or is there some sort of barrier? |
| Pillock | You can walk through a gap in the fence but not drive. The red lion carpark is customers only so should be separate. |
|
| 47478037 | Mike Baggaley | Hi, is foot allowed as well? Perhaps access=no could be removed?Cheers, Mike |
| trigpoint | As it is designated as a public_bridleway foot is very defiintely allowed, as are horses and bikes. The bicycle=yes tag is therefore pointless and adds tag clutter. |
| jogger333 | Dear Mike, Looking at the wiki, one should indeed make the usage clear with appropriate access tagging:"Also taginfo shows a significant number of uses of:designation=permissive_footpathdesignation=permissive_bridlewayThese tags should be used in combination with an appropriate highwa... |
| Mike Baggaley | Hi Jogger333 , No I think the tagging was was incorrect (the original done by Russ McD). The update by bttyA was what brought it to light. The designation=public_bridleway would set the default access of foot, bicycle and horse=yes, however, access=no would override this and set them all to no. This... |
| jogger333 | Hey mike, thanks for the explanation! I was looking for a reference of your statement "The designation=public_bridleway would set the default access of foot, bicycle and horse=yes" but I couldn't find it in the wiki, I really would like to implement it correctly in our routing, Can you giv... |
| Mike Baggaley | Unfortunately, I can't find a reference any more - the pages on access and UK mapping guidelines appear to have been changed towards the end of last year with the meaning of designated being changed. Bizarrely, the access=designated page now says the value is deprecated without saying what replaces ... |
| jogger333 | Oh yes, the information is really vague. This will make it a bit difficult to conclude routing rules from it that are correct worldwide, not only in UK.Let's see if that is possible and if there are any conflicts popping up.Thanks for your summary, this helped me a lot to understand the issue he... |
|
| 47512158 | trigpoint | Hi, what is the source of this edit?You have removed footpath L57 and the airport trail for example. L57 is a PROW and cannot simply be closed, it will at most have been diverted. Do you have any reference to this? |
| Arrow A2B | Hi,Sorry, I should have referenced such a significant change like this. All the site plans and access arrangements are available here:http://www.eastmidlandsgateway.co.uk/community/phasing.phpThe public right of way info is here:https://infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/wp-con... |
| will_p | Hi Luke,I haven't looked what's happening on the ground here for a couple of months, but I'm a bit surprised that all these features have already been cleared. Have you actually confirmed that they have all gone? For example, you have removed a service road all the way from Church Street, Lockingt... |
| Arrow A2B | Morning Will,The features I've removed have all gone this week. The construction area I've added is the full area where ground work has started. (Obviously it's impossible to get GPS tracks at the moment as there is no access). The roads which are closed, such as the junction with Ashby Road and... |
| will_p | Today I have had a look at the current situation. It turns out that many of the deleted features do still exist:The Airport Trail is still there and is still open to the public with minor diversions.The service road from Church Lane (Lockington) is still there. It's being used as one of the main... |
|
| 47510243 | chillly | Welcome to OSMYou have placed a point right over the top of a cafe (Cafe Nero) . Has this business replaced Cafe Nero? Is it sharing the building? The point you have added doesn't describe what it is. You have given lots of details, but no shop tag or office tag to describe what category the b... |
| And Albert Fair Trading Ltd | How do we make the point SHOP? This isn't clear at all. We are actually a shop on the upper tier of Chester's Rows ABOVE cafe Nero. |
| chillly | I have added shop=yes tag. If there is a better shop description you can change it later. Now it has a shop tag it is easier to change it. Adding a shop above another is a problem. I suggest staggering the two points a little, maybe to reflect the relative entrances to the two premises. If your ... |
| And Albert Fair Trading Ltd | OK, Thank you.I find this site awfully confusing to navigate and add the correct information. Well as long as people can find us that's all we want really. Thank s again |
| And Albert Fair Trading Ltd | I can't see the tag point to change it? |
| trigpoint | Hi, also spotted that you have used=ele=1, that means 1m above sealevel. The correct tag is layer=1, as already used on Eastgate Street North. |
|
| 47483943 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSMThank you for your addition but please remember that changeset comments are intended to inform other mappers of your intent and should be in plain language.Meaningless hashtag comments fail to do that, please do not use them in OSM. |
|
| 47475017 | trigpoint | Hi, is this a real business that customers can visit?I was about to ask, the website looks like it is contact by web or phone only so should not be in OSM.Cheers Phil |
| andrewsh | No idea, I just added the correct tag. |
| andrewsh | Hmm, the website says they're in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire:4 – 12 Kempson CloseGatehouse Way Industrial Estate |
| andrewsh | I will probably remove them. Thanks for paying attention. It looked like a legitimate business to me… which it probably isn't. Well, not in Oxford, at least. |
| trigpoint | Thank you.It looked like spam, both the username and long description. |
| andrewsh | Well, these two looked like spam, but the website looked okay-ish to me. I should have checked the address :) |
|
| 47451235 | chillly | Welcome to OSMYou have tagged something as a village (place=village) but you have called it Llanddew church. Is it a church or the place? I think the place is called Llanddew. If it is a church, is this different from the Church of St David which is already in place? If so, you need to add a... |
| trigpoint | The village was already mapped as Llanddew, which was correct according to OS OpenData, my view is that this maps.me edit is probably a personal marker should be reverted, it altered an existing object. |
|
| 47419181 | trigpoint | Hi, postboxes do not normally have names, they have a reference number which is already mapped. The name you have added is just a description so I removed the name. |
|
| 17361001 | trigpoint | Hello, is there any reason you have changed these halts to stations?When I last caught a train to Llandecwyn I had to ask the guard to stop, which makes it a halt. |
|
| 47318879 | trigpoint | S’il vous plaît pourriez-vous expliquer la raison de ce changement ? Vous avez enlevé l’étiquette d’agrément, supprimé le nom : es et changé le nom de tag du Centre vers les Centres.Please could you explain the reason for this change? Yo... |
| upendrakarukonda | Hi trigpoint,Thank you for noticing this. I reverted back my changeset. This must be accidental. I am not aware of this deletions at all. Regads,Upendra. |
|
| 47357657 | trigpoint | Hi, are you really sure this postbox exists?It was created by a maps.me user and the odd tags make it look like some sort of personal marker or misuse of a tag.The rubbish tags are likely to indicate to a local mapper that a survey is needed and by cleaning the apparant rubbish you have left a c... |
| upendrakarukonda | Hello Trigpoint,I deleted the tags which are not correct. I added a note in that place for confirmation of existence of post box in that place. Regards,Upendra |
| trigpoint | A quick search reveals that Abras is some sort of Brasilian organisation at the address given. It looks like typical mistagging by a maps.me user. |
|
| 47320307 | trigpoint | Is there a reason you have changed these tags, what survey did you carry out? |
|
| 47220858 | trigpoint | Hi, is this name correct?Creek is an American word, and not used in terms of UK geography. |
| sharync | Yep it's the correct name. http://www.scottishpower.com/pages/damhead_creek_power_station.aspx |
| trigpoint | Thank you, was just checking as it looked an odd name in the UK.Cheers Phil |
|
| 47220241 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.According to the address you have given you business is on Queens Road, yet for some strange reason you have added it in the middle of Morrisons.I have reverted this as it is clearly the wrong place, assuming you have an actual office that customers can visit you can add that ... |
| trigpoint | Just realised that you have not simply created a spam node in the wrong place, but had deleted information from the Weybridge place node, that is considered vandalism. |
|
| 47204884 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.It always make me nervous when I see a new mappers first edit is just deleting the work of other mappers. I have reverted this edit, but please can you explain what you were trying to achieve? |
|
| 47075722 | trigpoint | Big question, why? What is the problem you are fix? Does it need fixing?In the case of these roundabouts, they are a single way so I would question why they are relations in the first place. But once the roundabout is split for route relations then having the name on the relation makes.perfect sen... |
| Polarbear | I was analysing the usage of jct=roundabout on relations for a wiki discussion, please find the results here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:junction%3Droundabout#On_a_relationtype=junction (here) is only a proposal and ignored by prominent data consumers. Also, I find type=route i... |
| SK53 | I very much doubt that the road name on these roundabouts is actually XXX roundabout, it is more likely to be the name of one of the roads (as for instance the junction of Donnington Wood Way with Celandine Road). It is the junction which carries the name not the road segments which form the junctio... |
| Polarbear | Is there any evidence that supports the assumption that the road forming a roundabout does not carry the name of the roundabout? Is there a streetsign posted along the loop carrying the road name and not the roundabout name? I only know cases where the roundabout name is posted. |
|
| 47066126 | trigpoint | Hi, you seem to be using a strange imagery URL. What were you copying and do wehave explicit permission to use that imformation? |
| jesus_army | Information came from a GPX trace rather than the map tile but I will remove that way and re-edit for clarity |
|
| 47052270 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.In OSM we map what exists on the ground, you have for some bizarre reason changed the Chertsey town node to a hospital. This sort of edit breaks the map for other users and will be reverted. |
| trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 47052513 | trigpoint | The hosital is already mapped, for some reason you have created a duplicate node. |
|
| 47034486 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. You seem to have changed a place node to a park, the park is already mapped and the name you added looks very unlikely. I have put this back to the place node |
|
| 47007752 | trigpoint | HI, I am not convinced there is a legal no-U turn restriction here. I have never seen any signage and if there was one, how would I get into Knighton Junction Lane or the New Road Inn?However I have spotted that Welford Road is incorrectly mapped as a single carriageway so I will fix that.Cheers... |
| Cebderby | Hi, If turning right from the southbound Welford Rd into Knighton Jnct Ln or the pub is ok then this new turn restriction can't remain. The specific routing problem was in (expecting to) turn right from Victoria Park Rd to northbound Welford Rd - OsmAnd app's router gives left turn then U-turn whic... |
| trigpoint | Hi, I have looked at this on OSMand and it has got a very serious routing issue. Both OSRM and mapzen work perfectly here.Maybe it should be reported to OSMand? |
| Cebderby | I suspect it is over-penalising a route from a secondary to a primary road via a minor way, even though it seems short and obvious. Trying with 'fuel efficient' route option (ie. short route) OsmAnd gets the right turn, it's only the 'fastest' route with the problem. For now, I've removed the no-U... |
| trigpoint | I agree the cross ways should be secondary, and I would consider Putney Road/Commercial Square to be tertiary. But a router should cope with the mapping as is, classifications are an indication of importance rather than speed, especially when they are tagged as 30 mph.I am working through Mapill... |
|
| 46999015 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.It looks like you were adding a hedge. They are tagged as barrier=hedge.Give me a shout if you need any help. |
|
| 46982421 | will_p | Hi, what does 'RA surveys' mean? The abbreviation isn't clear to me.Thanks. |
| trigpoint | My guess, and knowing Stan as I do. it would be Ramblers Association |
|
| 46986811 | trigpoint | Has the building been demolished? |
| sam kenney | Yes and has been replaced by fuel station |
|
| 46985260 | chillly | Welcome to OSMI see you have added Humbleton Farm, which is great. We outline the farmyard, as best we can, and ass landuse=farmyard, not place=farm. That will make it consistent with most farms in the UK on OSM |
| trigpoint | You have also joined it to a powerline, which is obviously incorrect and to the centreline of Mill Lane. |
| delfimo | Apologies. Have sorted now. Deleted old area as unable to figure out how to change area. |
|
| 46920511 | trigpoint | Hi, the name tag should only be used for an actual name, not just to add additional information. The correct way to indicate that a car park is private is to use an access tag, in this case access=private. Not sure if maps.me can fix this, you may need to login to osm.org and use a proper editor suc... |
|
| 46863433 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for edit, however according to the osm wiki smoking=no should not be used if it is the law, as it is in this case.You seem to be using an app called SpotOn, please could you provide a URL for it?Cheers Phil |
|
| 46842212 | trigpoint | Hi Mike, just checking that you have surveyed this path recently. The area is being developed so just checking.Cheers Phil |
|
| 46761728 | trigpoint | Hi, what is the source of this information?I have never seen any evidence for the existence of a Roman Road and find it highly unlikely that it followed the modern alignment of the A49 between Weston and Prees.Also this type of information is more appropriate in OpenHistoricalMap rather then OSM... |
| trigpoint | The North Shropshire section appears to be pure fiction, the Roman Road is only shown on your claimed source in very short sections. Where did the rest come from?It is very unlikely that the Roman road followed the present roads through Shawbury.I do not have a usable source but I do know it did... |
| Dyserth | Hi. Please see area around SJ55471 24483. Marked as Roman Road (Course of) on OS Map, northern section curves to the west near Moston Grange and follows the alignment of the unclassified road heading towards the A49 where it passes through the modern cutting. This has been constructed at a natural... |
| trigpoint | Thank you for these updates, it does seem much more believable and there are references to the Roman Road on OS Opendata. I would suggest that the route was not through Prees village but followed a straight line from the present junction with the B5065 via Prees Church which forms a straight line ... |
| trigpoint | I should probably add that is is likely that the course of the road drifted over time and that up until WW2 this section of the A49 was a minor road which was upgraded as a bypass. |
|
| 46781382 | trigpoint | Hi, I'm not sure what this shop is. But it is certainly not a department store. Please do not mistag. |
|
| 46774911 | trigpoint | Fiction reverted |
|
| 46774915 | trigpoint | The middle of a residential road is a very unlikely place for a viewpoint, I am reverting this edit. |
|
| 46783851 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Cherry Hinton Campsite is already mapped, so I am removing your duplication. |
|
| 46740571 | trigpoint | Wow, the A14 is being extended to North Wales? |
| Glucosamine | Ooops - one of those change set titles which gets copied from one set of updates to quite another - mea culpa for not checking. Any ideas on how to change a change set title? On the other hand, with a £1.3B budget, the A14 really ought to reach the border ... |
| trigpoint | Don't worry about changing the existing ones, not sure if that is even possible. I was just jokingly making you aware so you would fix it next time you edit. |
| Glucosamine | Taken in the spirit intended. Not the first time this has caught me out when using a specific title when I normally use a generic - will try to remember to check for at least the immediate future - though I'm sure I'll slip up again at some point. |
|
| 40145804 | trigpoint | Airbnbs are private homes and do not belong in OSM, I have reverted this |
| Hpriem | Good...thank you |
|
| 46737943 | BCNorwich | Are you sure that is a hotel, or is it just a room rental?? |
| trigpoint | Airbnb are private homes and have no place in OSM, I am reverting this |
|
| 46719392 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM Rapid Welding is an unlikely name for a hardware shop. What are you trying to map.Maps.me is a very basic editor, to do more than basics you need to use a proper editor such as iD on osm.org. |
|
| 46717406 | chillly | Welcome to OSMYou seem to have added a park over the top of an existing park. This is not a good idea.I will revert (undo) this edit. |
| trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, the park was already mapped so I have removed your duplication and put the name onto the existing area. |
| DaveF | Removed |
|
| 46614832 | trigpoint | Hi, way http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/387927974 appears to be total fantasy. There is no separate way visible on bing or mapbox imagery. Also many entry exit nodes are shared which causes exit counts to be wrong, i.e. you have to enter a roundabout to leave it. Oneway on a roundabout is not neede... |
| Dyserth | Fantastic appearances can be deceptive. The left carriageway separates into three lanes here, the left hand one of which you can only use to bypass the roundabout, turning left along Abergele Road. You cannot enter it. I have therefore tagged it as a one-way Primary Link as this lane has no intersec... |
|
| 46593568 | trigpoint | Hi, this looks very small and an odd place for a hospital. What were you trying to achieve |
|
| 30451635 | trigpoint | Hi, I got some odd instructions from maps.me for this roundabout today. Now I am home and able to check I see that for some strange reason you removed the roundabout tags and replaced it with oneway. Why? |
| Dyserth | If I remember correctly at some point iD was not showing roundabouts as oneway unless they were tagged as such. I did change a few tags to reflect this as clearly roundabouts are not two-way flows but clearly this flaw in the editor has now been rectified. However because that edit was done 2 years ... |
|
| 46591270 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please remember that osm is a live database, please do not usr it for tests. I am removing this doodle. |
|
| 46570563 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for adding these footpaths, however they should not end where the gate/stile is, they need to connect to the road otherwise routers will see them as dead ends and not use them.I have connected the footpaths to the roads.Cheers Phil |
|
| 46505236 | trigpoint | Hi, not sure how closely you were looking here, but the smaller roundabout is clearly a mini-roundabout. |
| chris_debian | Hi, trigpoint.Thanks for bringing this to my attention. I've done some reading, and it seems that a mini-roundabout is frequently described as being a white painted circle, on the road, or a slightlyraised white bump, in the road. Having reexamined this roundabout, for it's construction and size... |
| trigpoint | The definition of a mini-roundabout is not necessarily painted white, but it needs to be traversable. At least one in Oakengates is cobblestones.This one is very definitely a mini-roundabout, and painted white, so I have corrected it. |
|
| 46546103 | trigpoint | Hi johnnieThere was no need to remove these paths, I am in no doubt that they exist. They just needed to be connected to Thornton Lane and the sidewalk tag removing as they are not sidewalks. But please do no check OS, we do not have permission to use such data, what you see is the best data we ... |
|
| 46532033 | trigpoint | Vandalism reverted |
|
| 46461127 | trigpoint | Hi, please can you explain this change, as far as I know wikipedia tags are not case sensitive. Who decided they must start with a capital letter? |
| nyuriks | Hi @trigpoint, the Wikipedia title has a "normalized" form (actually the rules for it are very complex, such as each portion of the title has to be capital first, such as namespace, after namespace, and after each "/" if subpages are enabled). Plus some url decoding, spaces inste... |
| nyuriks | I just updated my auto-generated page with lists: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/User:Yurik/OSM_wiki_tag_problems#List_pages -- these are only wikipedia articles with their wikidata's "instance of" = Q13406463 and Q15623926, but I could obviously add more. Let me know |
| nyuriks | oops, wrong changeset, sorry. |
|
| 46523808 | trigpoint | Hi, I'm not sure the address and postcode belong on the ATM. They belong to the post office to which it is attached :) |
|
| 46362645 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Priory Country Park is already mapped as a nature reserve. Adding a park over the top seems contradictory and doubles the name. Bing imagery seems to confirm it is not what we normally tag as a park. |
| trigpoint | No response, so reverted |
|
| 46529263 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your additions, however you do need to connect them to the road for them to be useful. Also I do not think footway=sidewalk is really an accurate description of these cross-field rights of way.The correct way to tag rights of way is highway=footway, designation=pu... |
|
| 46519756 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit however you have created a number of duplications. McDonalds and TNT were already mapped using ways, mapping with nodes are a bit of a step backwards.Also the name tag is for an actual name, and should not be used for descriptions such as 'playground' an... |
|
| 46466438 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I have been trying to work out what you were doing here and all I could find were two new ways which had no tags. I am going to revert this change.Please carry on editing, but it is better to map things locally that you know well to start with. |
|
| 46488863 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.In OSM we map what exists on the ground, the tags you have added suggest that this is on the wrong continent. Please remove and, if it.really exists, add.in an appropriate place. But please remember that OSM is not a business directory. |
|
| 46427801 | trigpoint | Hi, just wondering if ref:gss has any purpose in osm. There appear to be several within the town, why this one? and what purpose do they serve? The areas have no geographic meaning and appear to have been drawn by a 2 year old.Cheers Phil |
| The Maarssen Mapper | Hi PhilThe areas are civil parishes, so they are definitely geographically relevant, just like districts and counties. The ref:gss indicates the ID of the polygon in official records. When the boundary changes, it gets a new ID, so knowing which version of the boundary is represented by the relati... |
| trigpoint | A google search took me in a little deeper and that gave a strange area, http://statistics.data.gov.uk/doc/statistical-geography/E00147121 which I could not work out the logic behind although it was suggested that it is postcodes, that example cuts at least one postcode in half.It does feel wrong ... |
| The Maarssen Mapper | Hi Phil,An output area is only for statistical and not for local government jurisdictions... E00 polygons are not present in OSM as far as I know. The immediate source of the data may be OSBL, but the actual source of the boundary is GSS, who provide the boundaries to the OS, also for "public... |
|
| 46359243 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution however Rose Park appears to be someones back garden, please remember that we only map things that exist on the ground. |
|
| 46373473 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution, based on your description and aerial imagery this area is a recreation ground, rather than a park. I have changed it and added the playground. |
|
| 46288551 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to osm. Something has gone a little wrong here, the building you have created is rather large and covers several streets. Would you like some help fixing it? |
| BCNorwich | Hello yes welcome.Your next changeset made incorrect alterations so I've reverted both changeset as both have problems.I researched your company and have added a POI at the building mapped as 46 Loman Street. Please check this out and adjust as necessary.RegardsBernard |
|
| 46275705 | trigpoint | Hi BrianHi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution, I agree that the hypens are not required, although you have made a small typo in the name.Yout have used map.me to make the change, which is a bit Mickey Mouse when it comes to names. Your name has gone into name:en, which is a bit iro... |
|
| 46193747 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM tagging is sometimes subtle, there is a difference between a park and a recreattion ground and all evidence suggests this is a recreation ground.1. OS Opendata calls it a recreation ground.2. Imagery shows a grassy area with pitches laid out, that definitely fits the w... |
| trigpoint | Reverted and name added |
|
| 46187245 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your input however your comments make me a little wary. You state 'as per OS map', current OS maps are copyright and cannot be used in OSM and your lines do not match older out of copyright data.When mapping rights of way we map the line as it exists on the ground... |
| Tom Webster | Phil, Many thanks for your input. I came across this site whilst looking for local walks and footpaths and then thought to check paths crossing our own land. Your current map appears to be incorrect and shows a path that does not exist in practice or on any other map I have seen. It is this that... |
| trigpoint | Hi TomThank you for your comments, that sounds like you have actually made these changes using your own knowledge, rather than just copied from another map. This is the kind of input we prefer, there is no need to justify what you know/have seen by quoting another source.Thank you for your input... |
|
| 46172921 | trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 46139215 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Something little wrong.You seem to have created a number of duplicate/overlapping ways on the southbound Blackwall Tunnel. What were you trying to achieve? Maybe we can help?Cheers Phil |
| mArtagnan | Hi PhilVery sorry about that, im new to OSM so must have done it wrong. Basically, the southbound blackwall tunnel route doesn't work i.e. it routes me around to the rotherhithe tunnel instead even when i put the start point really close to the blackwall tunnell. I concluded there must be someth... |
| trigpoint | Thank you MartinI will sort it out.Which router are you using?Phil |
| mArtagnan | i was testing the route on the OSM website http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=13/51.4909/0.0043But i use the Scout map Sat Nav app in my car. Thats based on open street mapMany thanks |
| trigpoint | I have reverted your changes and am trying to understand the problem. I can see that there is an issue with OSRM, but Mapzen works fine.Will keep you posted.Phil |
|
| 46143672 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please could you keep your edits to sensible areas. Edits like this are hard for other mappers to follow.Thanks |
|
| 45925506 | trigpoint | ?? |
| chillly | reverted |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 45955690 | trigpoint | Personal marker? |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 46009402 | trigpoint | More personal markers? |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 46018453 | trigpoint | These look like personal markers, what are you trying to achieve? |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 46146051 | trigpoint | Hi, this looks a bit odd. What are you trying to achieve? Maybe we can help. |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 46090418 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This looks a bit odd. Do you really return hire cars to the middle of the road? |
| eric_ | I just moved it to the correct location. |
|
| 46030832 | trigpoint | A Chalet in Osbaston? Seems unlikely |
| chillly | reverted |
|
| 46019572 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. What is this artwork, it seems a very odd location.Thanks Phil |
| Catherine Lewis | it's my workshop/studio. abd the whole lane has many artists studios. |
| trigpoint | Thank you, it should be tagged as something like craft=artist, that is assuming it is verifiable. will I see a sign if I walk along that street.As it stands it is definitely incorrectly tagged.It would be good if you can correct it, you will need to use a proper OSM editor such as iD from osm.or... |
|
| 45946299 | BCNorwich | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap. IMHO one ought not to assume speed limits, it's really just guessing. Would it be possible to go there and properly survey the roads. |
| BCNorwich | Oh and the foot-way, are cycles allowed there? Also the foot-way is not joined to the roads at each end so software will not be able to route along it.Regards |
| markf0wle | I live on this road. The speed limit isn't sign posted on the estate, my assumption was my interpretation of the highway code. I will double check & correct if nessecary.I will amend the footpath. Yes, bicycles are permitted on all the footpaths in the area to my knowledge. |
| trigpoint | You have tagged Welling Road as lanes=1, is that true? It doesn't look like a single track road on bing imagery.Also 20mph areas cannot exist without signs. |
| markf0wle | OK, good shout. I have corrected the lanes on Welling Rd, is 2 lanes - 1 in each direction.I have too found this reviewing the highway code, therefore the official speed limit would be 30mph as that is the last posted speed as you enter Welling Road from Brentwood Road. |
| BCNorwich | Would you then correct the speed limits on the estate please? It would be wrong for OSM, (the best map in the world), to knowingly contain wrong data.Regards |
| markf0wle | Done Sir. |
|
| 45978096 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I think maybe something has gone a bit wrong here, I suspect you mean the London Astoria however that closed in 2009.Is there something here you have surveyed recently? |
| trigpoint | I am reverting this edit as this area is a construction site for crossrail.Please comment if I am wrong? |
|
| 45921032 | trigpoint | Hi, are you sure this path has gone. I do remember it was to be retained and quarried around. It and the bridge are clearly on bing imagery. Has it since gone? If so what is the new route of The Rutland Round as the relation now has a hole in it. |
| B'o'B | The diversion route was temporary and the Rutland Round and E229 footpath are now back on the original line which is the straighter path to the NE of the path I deleted. Kind regards |
| B'o'B | My apologies for making a hole in the Rutland Round route I had assumed it was still marked on the original route which it has now been returned to |
| B'o'B | I have re-edited the removal of the temporary diversion of the Rutland Round by moving the nodes to the line of the footpath that it now follows instead of deleting it. I hope this is satisfactory to you. |
| trigpoint | Thank you, I have tidied up a bit and all looks good now. |
|
| 45965014 | BCNorwich | Hello Dreamer. This POI "Buckingham Palace" is actually along way from the Palace.The Palace is already tagged as tourism so no extra tag is needed there, would you please then remove inadvertent POI?Your POI "Greenwich" is not needed either as the place is already mapped, ... |
| trigpoint | Hi Brian, I have reverted both of these changsets,Maps.me users are very unlikely to respond and maps.me is not capable of changing or removing anything. |
|
| 45881722 | trigpoint | Hi, I have spotted that you have been making a lot of edits in different areas and wondered what you are changing as you have not put any changeset comments in.In this particular changset you have deleted on side of the triangle at the junction of Plex Road and Plex Lane, http://www.openstreetma... |
|
| 45920770 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The correct way to tag a private road is to add the tag access=private rather than simply deleting it from the map.The presence is useful as a navigational aid and some people will need to route to the farm. By adding private routers will not route along that way.It is al... |
| B'o'B | Hi, thanks for the welcome. Please allow me to explain my edits. I would normally take your point about unnecessary tags although in my dealings with people on the footpaths on bikes, horses and on one occasion a motorcycle people don't always fully understand the rights of access and I have just... |
|
| 45826715 | trigpoint | Hi, I have reverted your London changes. You have deleted a building that was already correctly mapped as residential, with full address data, it is a Hall of Residence and you replaced it with a hostel node. |
| Jesus Tudela | I'm sorry, but I have a reservation in a hostel (LSE Bankside House, http://www.lsevacations.co.uk/Accommodation/Bankside-House/Bankside-House.aspx) located in the same direction, and in that same Building, and I thought ALL building was a Hostel. I am going to put a new point that reflects the Host... |
|
| 45810856 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for these additions, they are very useful. One small thing, these types of path are normally tagged as highway=footway, highway=pedestrian is normally used for pedestranised streets such as Gallowtree Gate. Keep up the good work.Phil |
|
| 45797585 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The post office was already mapped so I have removed the duplication. |
|
| 45798619 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. You seem to havbe misplaced this node. It has an address in the US yet you have put it in London.I am reverting this edit.Please drop the verbal diarrhea in the changeset comment. |
|
| 45776874 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Some of your edits seem a little strange. For example if I were to visit this location will I actually see a monument? and if I do is it really in the middle of the road?Also tagging a modern office building and a bike rack as historic is very bizarre. What were you trying to a... |
| Stuart Lennox-Hill | I seem to be having some difficulty with the tagging, it's copying from history. (Same with the edit notes... it's using the old one).The office building is Vantage House, right next to it is the bike rack, they should be two completely separate edits?! I had to un-merge it once already. Zoom in... |
|
| 45738771 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The school is already mapped as an area and with a name.I am removing this duplication.Cheers Phil |
|
| 45712620 | chillly | Welcome to OSMThanks for the new road. You may like to join it to Millhall Road. This allows routing by phone and satnav to get people to the road.HTH |
| trigpoint | Also please could you capitalise the name correctly, thanks |
|
| 45697115 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.We try to map things accurately as they exist in the real world This and many of your other additions appear to be doodles, this one is on top of a road. |
| BCNorwich | Removed duplicated way. |
|
| 45676845 | trigpoint | I am reverting this change, you have turned a correctly mapped skateboard area into a park, that is considered vandalism |
|
| 45677727 | trigpoint | Hi, you seem to have changed a wood that had been added by another mapper to a park. I can see it is a wood so I have fixed it. |
|
| 45677945 | trigpoint | HI, you seem to have added a park to a mountain area. In OSM we map what exists on the ground and this is not most peoples idea of a park.I am reverting this edit. |
|
| 45632077 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The paths you added were already mapped as service roads, you therefore created duplications. I have removed these. |
|
| 45630128 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Something has gone a little wrong here, you have added impossible paths which pass through houses. I have reverted this change.Please remember that we add only what really exists. |
|
| 45531854 | chillly | Welcome to OSMThanks for the edit. You need to add amenity=fuel to mark the object as a fuel station. It probably isn't called 'Petrol Station', so changing the name to the name that is displayed on the business would be good too.HTH |
| trigpoint | I have tagged this from memory, will check sometime or NWillowsrough can confirm.Cheers Phil |
|
| 45624625 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I have reverted this changeset as you have incorrectly changed recreation grounds and a common to parks.The clue is in the name i.e. Fryern Rec is not likely to be a park. |
|
| 45586934 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we map things that really exist on the ground, we do not map thing that do not exist such as your reservoir, a garden as a park or footpaths through gardens. I am reverting your edits |
|
| 45568757 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I assume this footpath is meant to connect to Wellbeck Drive? For it to be usable it does need to connect. Shout up if you need a hand. |
| BCNorwich | I don't think there is a footpath goes through the houses just there. |
|
| 45533170 | trigpoint | You seem to have deleted all the buildings in the botanic gardens, that is vandalism. Reverting |
|
| 45533332 | trigpoint | These areas were correctly mapped as grass, they are not parks. Reverting |
|
| 45533484 | trigpoint | You have for some reason changed two schools to colleges, that is clearly incorrect they are very definitely schools. I am reverting this edit |
|
| 45533954 | trigpoint | Reverting fiction |
|
| 45534052 | trigpoint | This footpath is a duplication of the existing cycleway. I am reverting this edit. |
|
| 45534104 | trigpoint | This footpath is fiction, I am reverting this edit |
|
| 45534158 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. OSM is a live database, used by many people and as such we only add what exists in the real world. There is no park here, it is houses so I am reverting this edit |
|
| 45534886 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for your edit. You do seem to be making things complicated, a relation for your first edit. In this case it is not really needed, just join the two way and put the tags there. And of course delete the relation.Give me a shout if you need a hand. |
|
| 45511393 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Something appears to have gone a bit wrong here. You seem to have deleted a large number of POIs. I am sure that was an accident so I am going to revert this changeset.If you would like to comment and explain what you were intending then we can help |
|
| 45506386 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM, I am reverting this as we only map what already exists and this is housing. |
|
| 45534287 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please remember that OSM is a live database and that we only map what exists in the real world,This area is clearly not a park, I have reverted this change. BTW It is unlikely you will find a missing park in Wigston. |
|
| 45436606 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your addition, however Greenfields Rec was already correctly mapped as a recreation_ground. Your park was a duplication which I have removed.Please ask if you need advice on adding information to OSM.Cheers Phil |
|
| 45448674 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The area around a church should be tagged as a churchyard. It is not likely to be a park. That seems to be mistagging. |
|
| 45428074 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for correcting the position of the Admiral Duncan, although we only map the building where it is, I have tidyed this up and mapped the car park. The beer garden isn't exactly a park so I have retagged it.The village green can be tagged as a village green, no need to ... |
|
| 45360043 | trigpoint | Hi, please can you point me to where these changes, and the others in the series, were discussed?Thanks Phil |
| RitterR | hi, sorry form my english. I use google translator.I based on http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Demergency_phone.Many of these nodes has been added long ago, and no one since then has not changed under the new rules adopted.I watched thes points, and if they were on the highw... |
|
| 45354867 | trigpoint | I am reverting this as it is spam. |
|
| 45352945 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM and thank you for your addition of a footpath. It looks good.As you are local I wonder if you could check the legal access status of Vincents Roadm it has previously been tagged as access=permissive which looks a little odd.Thanks Phil |
|
| 44772736 | imagico | I would consider this essentially mapping for the renderer - beaches do extent below the high water line obviously and natural=tidal_beach is not documented while equivalent established tagging exists (natural=beach + tidal=yes)If the lowest parts here is still a beach (i.e. wave formed) or a ti... |
| dmgroom_ct | The wiki is very clear that the tag "natural = beach" is only for the part of the beach above the MHW line.So what you refer to as established tagging is still in contravention of what is expected. |
| imagico | Well - the 'how to map' section on the wiki does not represent common mapping practice here and contradicts the basic definition of natural=beach as a landform.The wiki by the way currently also says you should tag the part of a beach below the high water line as natural=shoal - which of course ... |
| dmgroom_ct | I will emnail you via the OSM msg system |
| trigpoint | Please don't do that, it is better to keep these discussion in the open.Thanks Phl |
|
| 45278608 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This edit looks very odd, what is the source you are using. It seems very odd to map mud around jettys.Also please could you use meaningful changeset comments describing what you have done so that other mappers know what you are intending. #thamesmapathon tells us nothing.T... |
|
| 41094685 | trigpoint | Please see comments on note https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/650624The spelling does not match OS Opendata Locator or local tradition.Thanks Phil |
| ACS1986 | By bizarre coincidence I stopped at the premier inn next door earlier in the year and noticed the Dutch spelling at the time. Unless it has been changed Kopje is the spelling on the road sign |
|
| 45219274 | maldav | I do not seem to be able to label the route 6. What am I doing wrong? |
| trigpoint | What do you mean by label? What are you expecting |
| SK53 | If you want it to appear on the transport map I think you need to put the bus route number in the ref tag, so add ref=6 and then it should appear along the relevant roads. Here's an example from my own area: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/71283 |
| maldav | Many thanks for this information. It took me a while to realise that I was missing the Relation:route. I have now found the details on the wiki. This information didn't appear with the existing bus routes 4 and 4a put on by someone else. I now have to decide how far along the route I need to go. ... |
|
| 45141513 | trigpoint | Hi Bernard, you have missed sport=soccorCheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Hello Phil,No I didn't miss it, I left it for you, please see my comment here :- https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/45139235#map=18/51.75318/0.45146, just joking. It will always be football to me! What do you think, conform or not?Regards Bernard |
|
| 45129340 | trigpoint | Another undisguised mass edit, with no explanation. And you are still ignoring mappers comments. |
| dmgroom_ct | I was nit ignoring mappers commenst, I have no idea what changeset comments were not being emailed to me, but to be fair there were enough other ways of contacting me. |
|
| 45074747 | DaveF | HiOut of curiosity, what software are you using to validate these errors? |
| trigpoint | And what are you actually fixing, and please map in smaller areas so that you don't waste mappers time trying to work out which of the 6 pages are in their area. |
| dmgroom_ct | It's not a mass edit. Each edit was individually made my me after viewing Bing imagery, looking at the error I was trying to fix, and then fixing it in JOSMThe sort of problems fixed are:mainly highways which do not connect to other highways, for a number of reasons , including:a) the 1st... |
|
| 45052485 | trigpoint | Hi, FP20 is a public right of way reference and should be put in the prow_ref tag, rather than the name. The name tag is for names.It is certainly not FP20 for the majority of its length, it obviously isn't a Leicestershire right of way reference.It also needs a bit more, I doubt it is Derbyshir... |
| ENB45 | Hi Phil, I continued on an existing path, I guess the name was already in there.I've seen a few of those names in the area, I'm aware some older OS maps show these references.I've cut the path where I continued the line. Name removed from my edit, but I've left the original as it is for now.... |
|
| 44950151 | stev | This, and many other changesets from the user appears to be erroneuous advertising information. I have also sent the user a message |
| trigpoint | You should revert them. they are spam. Shout up if you need any help. |
| SomeoneElse | For info, I added https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/843348 about a week ago. |
|
| 45005561 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. What does ref:sponsored mean? |
|
| 44900490 | trigpoint | Hi Geoff, welcome to OSM but please remember that OSM is a live database. It should not be used for testing. To get started it is far better to find something that is missing and add that, or a shop that has changed name. Simply adding a node with a name will not render without other tags describing... |
| trigpoint | No response received so I am reverting this change |
|
| 44878848 | Robert Whittaker | Is the node at https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4587558092 in the correct location? (I've just added some buildings and roads for Apperley Court from arial imagery. Should be node be within the building?)You also appear to have changed the address of https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/36789780... |
| debelasers | Hi Robert, Yes the node should be in one of the buildings but I couldn't place it correctly on the first go and then couldn't work out how to move it. We are in the north east corner of Appley Court, directly facing the access road.And yes we moved from St Francis Way in November so I was trying t... |
| debelasers | Also, Electronics shop is a poor description of what we do (we design industrial lasers) but it was the closest I could find |
| trigpoint | Shop is probably the wrong description, made_made=works, product=industrial_lasers would fit better I think.You will need to use a proper computer based editor, such as iD, rather than maps.me as it only allows a very limited subset of pre-defined tags to be used. |
|
| 44952798 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.The correct way to tag a a postcode is addr:postcode rather than the name tag. I am not sure what Wy Wyri is, but the middle of the road is an odd place, postcodes normally apply to places where mail is delivered to, and maybe use addr:housename.Trees are mapped as natural=tre... |
| MikeValentineUK | Cheers Phil.I'm completely new here and clearly blundering around whilst trying to make myself accessible to the World!The trees are a local landmark and regular navigation aid.Mike |
| trigpoint | Thank you Mike, they sound a useful thing to add. If you change them to natural=tree, you probably need a new node so you have one for each tree, then tag them as natural=tree then they will show on the map. You can add species:en=oak, maybe species:cy if you can.http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wi... |
|
| 44953138 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.THis edit looks a little odd, a stream that passes through a house.I am reverting this edit. |
|
| 44917073 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Heathrow is already mapped, please do not add personal markers to the map.I have removed this node. |
|
| 44903867 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This should probably be amenity=social club, bar implies it is open to the public, whereas a social club has membership rules.Cheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Yes welcome to OSM. Actually the facility is already mapped and all information is on the building outline. It is tagged as amenity=social_club, so I have removed your POI so as not to duplicate the information, hope that's OK. |
| trigpoint | Well spotted, the building and club outline are separate and overlapping ways. That could do with a tidy up while you are removing the node. |
| BCNorwich | Sorry forgot to mention the duplicate I removed as well. |
|
| 44846077 | trigpoint | Hello, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit however something has gone a little wrong here, you seem to have created 2 untagged ways on top of existing ways.What were you trying to achieve, maybe we can help.Cheers Phil |
| chillly | Hi, Welcome to OSM.You seem to be struggling. You have added two things over te top of existing roads, but they are not tagged in any way to say what you intend them to be. Did you mean to save this? Would you like some help to tidy this up? We would like you to add or improve stuff in the a... |
|
| 44797386 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.This addition looks a little odd, looking at bing imagery it does not look like a car park, or accessible. What were you intending, the name trailhead also looks odd. That is an American concept. |
| Sparky59 | .This is a new hill walk that a local farmer has created to allow the public to use 4 purpose made trails (each between 1.5 and 5.5 km long, from the car park, along the side of the river and then up into the hills before returning to the car park.The car park is a small stone area with room... |
| trigpoint | Thank you for that information, it just looked a bit odd with no road link.Its not possible with maps.me, but would it be possible to login to osm on a pc and add the access road, bridge and car park and maybe the paths too?Ask if you need any help.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44567581 | SomeoneElse | Is the pub really separate to the "Inn at Ardgour"? Does it have a different name? |
| trigpoint | They were one and the same place when I was there a few years ago |
|
| 44807538 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for your addition however you should connect the steps/paths to the road in some way otherwise you are just creating an unusable island.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44802975 | trigpoint | Hi, what does fgmn mean? |
|
| 44678843 | RobJN | Not bogus trigpoint! Please check before reverting. This is a grassed "park" area with paths through it. |
| RobJN | Needs a proper survey but I've done a basic revert of your revert as the user was right to add a park here: changeset 44807049 |
| trigpoint | Sorry Rob, it does need a survey but not sure I would consider a small grassy area in the middle of a housing estate to be a park. |
|
| 44793212 | trigpoint | Hello, thank you for your additions. In the UK we use footway, rather than path, for mapping PROW. I have changed these to footway and added designation=public_footpath. Not sure why we need path at all to be honest, it just confuses new mappers.The southern path you added is actually a track, aga... |
|
| 44789353 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I have spotted your edits and they appear a little strange to me.What are you trying to achieve? Maybe we can help?Cheers Phil |
|
| 44750154 | Wynndale | Did you mean to enter the postcode as NW10 7F? |
| ORaha | Well there are two postcodes assigned to this building, 7FR and 7FS |
| trigpoint | I assume they are for different businesses?If so then it would be better to add a node for each and remove the postcode from the building. |
| ORaha | No it's a residential building. One block and different flats have different postcodes |
|
| 44765993 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM, thank you for your edit however are you sure it is a park, imagery suggests a school to me. |
| xWolfeBlitz | Hiya yea its a park, there is a nursery there aswell but mainly its a public park |
| trigpoint | Thank you, keep on adding to OSM.Coalisland looks rather empty, there must be load of stuff to add. Schools, pubs, shops and stuff |
|
| 44765344 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database, it should not be used for personal markers |
|
| 44009435 | trigpoint | Hi, I am not sure why you changed the relation type from the British Museum, but the type multipolygon was correct, there is no such relation as building.I am fixing this mistake, but please read http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Types_of_relationCheers Phil |
|
| 44760754 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Shiprow 15 is a very odd name for a hotel, however 15 Shiprow is the address of the Ibis which is already mapped. I have removed your duplication as it is in the wrong place |
|
| 44728432 | trigpoint | Hi, something has gone a little wrong here.Chessington South station is now tagged both as an active station and a disused one. Which is correct? |
| shitworth | Ah, that probably explains my confusion at not being able to spot it earlier. It's definitely an active station: http://ojp.nationalrail.co.uk/service/ldbboard/dep/CSS |
| trigpoint | It was changed a few weeks ago, will comment on that and tidy up here. He has also changed the platforms to disused. |
| trigpoint | Hopefully all fixed now |
|
| 44202781 | trigpoint | Hi, something has gone rather wrong with this change. You changed Chessington South to disused, which has obviously confused local mappers as it is very much still in use. I have fixed this but in future please can you add meaningful comments to your changes so that other mappers can work out what y... |
|
| 44687982 | trigpoint | Hi, the name tag is for actual names. Gated road is a description, if there are gates then map them but please to not use name for stuff like this. |
|
| 44711732 | chillly | Welcome to OSMWhen I see your first edit deleting stuff with comment of deleting excessive detail, this is worrying. OSM wants MORE detail not less. Why have you deleted stuff like this? |
| chillly | Looking at this more closely I have reverted this edit. There is no way all this should be deleted. |
| BCNorwich | Just wanted to add support to the decision to revert this changeset. It's very easy to make mistakes when you first jump into OSM mapping, I'm sure freefromsociety can make positive contributions. Just takes little research as to best practices first. |
| SomeoneElse | Whilst it might make sense to restore some of this detail, I'm a bit sceptical about others - I doubt that https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/385445828 is any sort of "pedestrian area", for example. |
| trigpoint | Also, whilst not part of this changeset. The A16 is incorrectly mapped as a dual carriageway. This could use a tidy up. |
|
| 44715622 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The paths you added in Central Park were a duplication of the existing cycleways. I have removed the duplication. |
|
| 44693630 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This edit has gone a little wrong, the Drayton Court Hotel is already mapped, I have removed your duplication. |
|
| 44682080 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The paths you have added seem to be pure fiction. There are no marks on the ground and they cross pitches.Please remember that in OSM we only add what exists in the real world. |
|
| 44635297 | trigpoint | Does http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/461460787 really exist, it looks like it goes through someones garden? |
| Afrocomb | Yes. the three tracks can be seen on this source http://www.rowmaps.com/showmap.php?place=Almondbury&map=OS&lat=53.6354&lon=1.74837&lonew=WThey can also normally be found on the local council website rights of way map (http://maps.kirklees.gov.uk/publicrightsofway/map.aspx?postco... |
| trigpoint | Thank you, just couln't see it on aerial imagery |
|
| 44672361 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. The footpath you have added is a duplication of the existing cycleway, I have removed the duplication. |
|
| 44664084 | trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 44663978 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database, please do not add personal markers.I am reverting this addition |
|
| 44660785 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please remember that OSM is a map in which we map what exists in the real world. Please do not retag objects for your own purposes, this is considered vandalism.I have reverted your changes as neither are parks. |
|
| 44648395 | trigpoint | Is there really a pear tree in the middle of the road? |
| Harrymapping | So sorry, it's left a bit, there's a residents pear tree at the end of the road. |
| trigpoint | You may want to create new node and tag it as natural=tree, tree=pear.Just creating a point with a name does nothing.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44648365 | trigpoint | Please can you explain this? |
| Harrymapping | There's a small plaque on the wall for Bobby. |
| trigpoint | This is normally mapped as historic=memorial then memorial=plaque. You may want to add some more detail, they usually say a bit more than Bobby.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44635602 | trigpoint | Reverted fiction |
|
| 44632640 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please remember that OSM is a live database, and we only map what exists in the real world.Aerial imagery suggests that this path does not exist, can you convince me otherwise? |
| BCNorwich | Yes Welcome to OpenStreetMap. The park doesn't look right either. I can find no reference to a park or public space here. It is likely to be part of Woolmer's park, a large farm. |
| trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 44603490 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.I think this change has gone a little wrong, you have changed New Walk from a pedestrian street to a footway which seems a little odd to me as it has been mapped that way since it was first mapped 9 years ago. Just wondering why you consider it to be wrong?You have also create... |
| trigpoint | I have restored New Walk and Highcross to highway=pedestrian |
|
| 44635873 | trigpoint | HI, welcome to OSM. We only map what exists on thbe ground, and we do not mis-tag what does exist. Changing a road to a footpath means map users will not be able to route over it. I consider your change vandalism and have reverted it. |
|
| 44605626 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.What is the source of this addition? I am not aware of any such path. The name also looks a bit odd.Cheers Phil |
| Zanigan | Hey PhilYeah, made corrections to the playground in town. For some reason the name 'Minsterley Play Ground (with in-built GYM)' kept to other corrections made for some reason. Would I have to delete and re-create again to change the title?There is also a public footpath that goes directly thro... |
| trigpoint | There is no need to recreate the playgound, the odd title is only on the changset, although you may want to disconnect it from the road.The name on this path is is probably not verifiable and the path obviously exists so is fine.It would be good to map the legal lines, if a farmer illegally obst... |
|
| 42993393 | trigpoint | Hi, what is the source of these edits, this entire estate looks very unlikely to really exist. |
| trigpoint | I drove passed here today, your edits are entirely fiction. I intend to revert them. |
|
| 44499316 | trigpoint | Is tourism really the correct tag for https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/460389218 ?Aerial imagery suggest it is residental, rather than somewhere to go on holiday? |
|
| 44480312 | GinaroZ | Hi, noticed you added a number of duplicate POIs in this changeset. I've removed some of them, please make sure you check buildings/nodes already present before adding duplicates next time :) |
| trigpoint | A miners welfare is normally tagged as amenity=social_club, it is unlikely to be a traditional pub. |
|
| 44556009 | trigpoint | Hi, whilst I can see that Dalefiemapld Drive has been extended on mapbox imagery, I don't see a turning circle. It looks like a cul-de-sac, you certainly cannot turn around without using reverse. |
| nikhilprabhakar | Hi Trigpoint,Excuse me for the late reply, I have removed the turn circle as per your feedback. Please have a look and lemme know if everything else is correct in this area. And thanks a lot for pointing this out.Regards,Nikhil |
|
| 42930401 | Mike Baggaley | HI, can you please take a look at the changes you have made to highways you have named Melton Road B666. Certainly the name should be Melton Road, rather than Melton Road B666. Are you sure the B666 still exists? If so, please put B666 in the ref field and also update the bridges and links to rounda... |
| trigpoint | I also don't believe that this is secondary road, you have changed it from a tertiary. It would be unlikely that a B road alternative to a bypass would be provided, it just isn't the way LCC do things.Have you any evidence that this is not a tertiary road?I also have serious doubts about the B... |
| trigpoint | Fixed in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44553986 |
|
| 44535446 | trigpoint | Hi, something went a little wrong with this changset. Whilst you created a building in Japan, you also dragged a crossing node in London. I have fixed the node drag and hopefully did not affect the building. |
|
| 44548786 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I think that something has gone a bit wrong here. We normally change the tagging on a closed pub to disused:amenity=pub. For some reason you have changed the name of the bus stop. |
|
| 44548821 | trigpoint | Hi, I don't think the postbox is actually named Post Box. The name tag should not normally be filled in for object such a postboxes. |
|
| 44494285 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. What is actually here, is it a building or simply a signpost.I imagine that you have made a typo and it is spelt Centre rather than the American way?Cheers Phil |
| SomeoneElse | I'm guessing that it's a duplicate of https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/410268974 , actually. |
| vbth | Hi, the place might be right but the name was only Cymraeg for village Hall. Also it was not visioble on the (offline) map. therefore i set an named it. Just give it a "i"-button an name it "Myddfai Community Hall & Visitor Centre". thanks.http://www.myddfai.org/ |
| SomeoneElse | @vbth I wouldn't worry too much about what any particular map does or doesn't show, since they all show different things. I've tried to merge everything together and added a building in https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/462068160 . |
| vbth | thank you. |
|
| 32409987 | DaveF | Hi Snake SkinThere's an expression in OSM: 'Don't tag incorrectly to suit the renderer'.For accuracyIf a KG is a KG then it should be tagged as such. If you wish an item to be visible in a specific render you should contact the person creating the tiles.CheersDave F. |
| Snake Sting | Why don't kissing gates or stiles show up on OSM? What I mean is when you zoom right it will tell you if you hover the mouse over the node but not as a symbol on the map like gates. It would be very usefull for anybody on a bike knowing if there is a ton of stiles or kissing gates to leave bike an... |
| DaveF | Sorry for the delayed reply.OSM is a database. Lot's of different rendering are mad from this one source. It allows map creators to add relevent data & ignore what the don't want.What's now described as the 'standard' map ie the mapnik rendering unfortunately doesn't render all barriers. I... |
| DaveF | Err... try https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/issues |
| SomeoneElse | Looks like geocaching.com (if that's what you're talking about) offer lots of different background styles, but don't host any themselves, so you'd just have to lobby for one of those to support it; not necessarily openstreetmap-carto. |
| SomeoneElse | Just for info, I've just added a separate "kissing_gate" icon to https://github.com/SomeoneElseOSM/openstreetmap-carto-AJT (that's a style that other people can use if they want to). See https://github.com/SomeoneElseOSM/SomeoneElse-style/blob/master/style.lua#L877 for which gate types ar... |
| trigpoint | Not really a comment on the mapping, or the rendering, but if a PROW has stiles or kissing gates then it is a public footpath. You should not be taking a bike on such paths. |
| DaveF | There's nothing to prevent someone pushing a bike; although a few walkers have disagreed with me. |
|
| 43603478 | trigpoint | Hi, this looks a very odd place for a shop to be located. Is it a bakery factory? |
| SomeoneElse | See https://www.openstreetmap.org/note/819653 |
| trigpoint | Reverted after user did not respond to changeset comments |
|
| 44371093 | trigpoint | Bourns Office is a very odd name for a mobile phone shop, are you really sure about this? |
| trigpoint | Reverted after maps.me user didn't respond |
|
| 24391013 | trigpoint | Hi, I think something went a little wrong here.You added cycleway=lane to https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/124354558 In my recollection, and looking at bing imagery, this is a two lane road with no cycling infrastructure. Did you visit the location? |
| trigpoint | Also http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/24271318 is a 3-4m wide road. It does not have lanes, its not wide enough. It also has no sidewalk, yet you have tagged it as having a sidewalk on both sides. This can lead to misleading routing information being provided to map users.It is important that we m... |
|
| 44534996 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSN.Please remember that OSM is a live database and should not be used for test data that does not exist in the real world. |
|
| 43442287 | trigpoint | Hi, I have reverted this change.The admin_level=10 boundary already exists and you removed the place node which is important for navigation. |
| shirokazan | The difficulty of the existing boundary is that it means that roads such as Curlew Croft are not recorded as Leighton Buzzard but Billington, which doesn't make any sense. |
|
| 44454540 | trigpoint | Please do not add spam to name tags or change the name of bus stops away from their official name. I am removing these tags. |
| SomeoneElse | Actually, I'd suggest adding a "real_ale" tag, like here https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/354421040 .You won't be able to do this from MAPS.ME, but you will from the web-based editors at openstreetmap.org. |
|
| 44465076 | trigpoint | Hi, is there really a church here. The area is mapped as a school and imagery suggests that the mapping was correct. |
| Trebor51 | If you look at Google Streetview you will see the church is to the right of the school. Look art this link: https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@51.5399819,-0.4513927,3a,75y,100.04h,86.19t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sksT2GeGoJbq0ZCS22eFjEA!2e0!7i13312!8i6656BTW I used to worship at that church and my children w... |
|
| 44435058 | SomeoneElse | Are you sure that these are "gift" shops? If they're really record shops please don't map them as something else.You can see what shop tags are in use looking at http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/shop#values . "shop=music" seems to be the most popular tag for record shops... |
| trigpoint | Also please check that what you are adding is in the correct place. For example Piccadilly Records is already mapped some distance from your addition.Your additions of one type of object is spead over a very large area, what is your source of information/location. |
|
| 44445426 | trigpoint | Please can you make meaningful comments, this is OSM not twitter and London rather than Tanzania. |
| mrlourobinson | Apologies, I didnt realise it had added that comment. Seems to have kept the comment from a previous change for Missing Maps. I'll be careful it doesn't happen again. |
|
| 44396157 | trigpoint | Hi, oneway is unnecessary when junction=roundabout is used. I have removed these tags. |
|
| 44447204 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Little Venice is already mapped a short distance from there. I have removed this node as it could mislead other map users. |
|
| 44420926 | BCNorwich | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.It is impossible to work out what you wanted to achieve with this addition to the live OSM database as there are no descriptive tags. What I can deduce is that as far as I am aware this line is not verifiable as existing in reality, (unless you can enlighten me).... |
| BrianWharf | Feel free, what I was trying to achieve doesn't seem possible here. Also, you may wish to get somebody to read back your text as some of it seems rather condescending. |
| trigpoint | What were you trying to achieve? Maybe someone can help. OSN is based around tags, so any untagged object will do nothing in OSM. |
|
| 44403171 | trigpoint | Hi, did you discuss the removal of the building tags from HMS Belfast anywhere, such as with the GB community?It is long accepted practice that permanently moored ships are tagged as buildings. HMS Belfast is a significant national tourist attraction. I have replaced the tag you have removed. |
| 4b696d | I did not discuss anything. All I did was following the rules I found in the wiki which clearly state otherwise, but it is not my object to cause any trouble. In case you have complaints about my other edits please let me know. Don't worry about the ship, I will not touch it again. |
|
| 44339326 | trigpoint | Hyde Park is already mapped, reverted |
|
| 44337318 | trigpoint | I doubt there is a clothes shop in the car park, reverted |
|
| 44327215 | GinaroZ | from their website/social media it seems like the name should be lowercase? |
| trigpoint | Oh, sorry. Just saw it and had to correct it. Maps.me users not bothering with case because they are using a phone has made me much more parricular about grammar in OSM names. |
|
| 44215396 | trigpoint | Please do not use OSM for personal markers, I am deleting this |
|
| 44210705 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Green Motion car hire is already mapped at Birmingham International, I am removing your duplication. |
|
| 44218396 | trigpoint | Hi, when I visited Albert Dock, there were no signs in Russian |
|
| 44325532 | trigpoint | Hi, I am removing the unofficial viewing point. It is not something that belongs in a public database |
|
| 44294298 | trigpoint | Hi, is Quorn Village Hall really a Town Hall (as in seat of local government). I have been there a few times and would consider it a community centre.Cheers Phil |
| JoeNerini1 | Hi Phil,The OpenStreetMap Wiki states that Town Halls "may just serve as a community meeting place" so I feel this classification is appropriate.Thanks,Joe |
| SK53 | No this is not an appropriate classification. Use either amenity=village_hall or amenity=community_centre which are the accepted values for such places in the UK, and have been so for at least 6-7 years. |
|
| 44308428 | trigpoint | Hi, Attack Snooker Club seems a very odd name for a pub. Are you sure it isn't a social club? |
| SomeoneElse | It's also a duplicate (same mapper) of https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4548245699 . |
|
| 44263803 | trigpoint | Hi, have you some more details about this ATM? Such as operator, associated object? An ATM without an associated bank, shop is very unusual.Cheers Phil |
| JohnnyCab | It's just in the wall of the Cheeky Coffee shop. See https://goo.gl/maps/6bD7TYq9jLM2 |
|
| 44253078 | trigpoint | Please could you use meaningful comments that state what you have done, Wales is a big place.Thanks Phil |
|
| 44262070 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please could you capitalise names properly.Thanks |
|
| 44224738 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.The access tags you have added here seem a little odd. I would expect motor vehicle to be private, only the farmer can use it to access their field. Permissive means there is general permission to access it, but not a right and can be withdrawn.It is a public footpath, so bike... |
|
| 43767598 | trigpoint | Should be fixed |
|
| 44160417 | trigpoint | Is this really a public car park? Have you surveyed it. Looking at imagery it looks like it is private parking space for the surounding houses. |
|
| 20951303 | trigpoint | Is http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/42740901 really 2 lanes, I remember it being quite a narrow single track road and thats certainly how it looks on bing imagery. Did you survey it? |
|
| 44177724 | trigpoint | Please stop adding personal marker to OpenStreetMap, there are no Alpine Huts in London. |
| trigpoint | Reverting no response again |
|
| 44181230 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, however we tag disused things as disused:shop, disused:amenity etc. That tells the render not to render them. Changing the name implies there is an object called Empty, which is no the case.Happy mapping, Phil |
|
| 44181330 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, however you do need to tag the objects you add. As a minimum they will need building=yes, area=yes isn't needed very often.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44168483 | trigpoint | Hi, do you have any more detail for this hotel, such as a phone number. Also please could you capitalise names properly, all lowercase means others will have to clean up. |
|
| 44166646 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, however Tesco Express is already mapped, https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/223063426. Tesco Express is normally mapped as shop=convienience, supermarket is used for larger shops.I have removed the duplicate. |
|
| 44158610 | trigpoint | Hi, these artworks look a bit odd. Please can you explain? |
| mapping man | There are 7 (i could only find 6) artworks located along the cycle path as you enter Winslow. Some more info herehttp://www.rogerperkins.com/sel_work1/winslow.htm |
| trigpoint | Thank you, looks interesting.Hope you find number 7.Cheers Phil |
|
| 44151822 | trigpoint | Hi, thank you for your edit however when reversing ways it is good to also look at the other tags on the way you are reversing. This is particulary important when the way forms a boundary. We now have Wales on the left of this stream and England on the right. That is not right.Cheers Phil |
| trigpoint | In this case the tags are obsolete as they are defined as relations but when reversing way please to look at the tags to ensure they still make sense.Cheers Phil |
| Bman | @trigpoint - oops. Sorry. Thank you for cleaning that up after me. |
|
| 43930398 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we map objects which exist in the real world, we do not make things up and we do not add fantasy names to objects.Your edits make me suspicious that you are not mapping what really exists. |
|
| 43930384 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we map objects which exist in the real world, we do not make things up and we do not add fantasy names to objects.Your edits make me suspicious that you are not mapping what really exists. |
|
| 44134357 | trigpoint | Are you sure about the spelling? |
| afrihagen | eh, yes: http://www.whitemustache.co.uk/ |
|
| 44135985 | trigpoint | Hi, please could you make your changeset comments a bit more meaningful, Added Additional Information say absolutely nothing.Also please don't join landuse polygons to the centreline of the road. It makes the map harder to maintain. and landuse stops at the edge of the road.Thanks Phil |
|
| 44072247 | trigpoint | Again, can I get my car repaired at an ambulance station? It seems unlikely. |
|
| 44072334 | trigpoint | Hi, does the surgery have a actual name? Doctors Surgery is a description rather than a name.And can I really take my car to an Ambulance Station to be repaired? |
|
| 39545272 | trigpoint | HI, this change seem to have been copied from http://www.flintshire.gov.uk/en/pdffiles/tourism/flintshire-leisure-tour.pdf, did you obtain written permission to use this data as stated in the copyright notice within the document?Also the maps within it are 'Crown Copyright' meaning we absolutely c... |
| SiHollett | I drove it, saw the signs (hence 'marked'), and then provided the document to explain what the route is. |
| trigpoint | If you have driven it, and seen the signs, then that is the ultimate in good data.Routes are mapped as relations that combine the ways, there are many examples in OSM, such as the National Cycle Network. Tagging signs will not mean anything, especially a node with just a reference, chances are the... |
|
| 44042265 | RobJN | Hi. Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Just to make you aware, we have guidelines for the road status in the UK. Basically if the road sign is green then it is a "trunk" road (not a primary).As such please don't be surprised if someone reverts these edits.For more info:https://wiki.openst... |
| trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
| A12B | The road signs in the north south direction are in fact white. Only East West direction are green and hence I have left as "Trunk". I have checked against other sources e.g Bing Maps and the classification I have used is also reflected there. |
| trigpoint | Please do not copy other maps, they are copyright and we do not have permission to use them. Besides bing and google have their own way of classifying roads, the OSM method for the UK is defined in the wiki.I am 100% sure that the Leicester ring road, and A50 are still trunk as I was there less th... |
| RobJN | Hi both,Thanks for responding. @trigpoint: I don't think this was a case of copying, just bringing in comparisons to prove that it isn't quite so simple cut.Also in my rush to send a message, I actually wrote it on the wrong changeset. On this changeset Narborough Road is fine. By convention... |
|
| 44060982 | trigpoint | Hi, what is the source of these reference numbers, and do you have permisson to use them?Also I assume they are not verifiable on the ground so should be in admin_ref rather than ref. A satnav telling a driver to turn left into UX2 will be both confusing and annoying.Cheers Phil |
| SiHollett | 1) source - https://www.hillingdon.gov.uk/media/28177/List-of-classified-roads/pdf/JW-LIST_OF_CLASSIFIED_ROADS.pdf2) there's zero copyright on the document (and it's illegal for it's data to not be accessible to the public), though I should have sourced it3) there's masses of unsigned roads ... |
| SomeoneElse | Ahem. I'd suggest that your paragraph (2) could probably benefit from a bit of wider discussion - I'd suggest that talk-gb list https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb for that - it's where youll probably find the widest audience of GB mappers.Re (3) it's definitely worth following custo... |
| Richard | Just because a document doesn't have a copyright notice on it doesn't mean it's uncopyrighted, I'm afraid. Quite the opposite- copyright subsists unless expressly disclaimed. Second, a document being "accessible" has no bearing on its copyright status. Third, as SomeoneElse explain... |
| SiHollett | "ref= means the same thing the world over: let's not add a needless exception for one country."Which is to include references that aren't signed with ref= tags. Unless Hungary, Estonia, Ukraine, Russia, Bulgaria, Switzerland, Albania and all the other countries that include every road nu... |
| SomeoneElse | @SiHollett Your comments above seem to suggest that you believe that you and you alone have the correct answer - everyone else who disagrees with you must be wrong or somehow unenlightened. If only life was so simple - n the real world there are different views that need to be taken on board and di... |
| SiHollett | "Your comments above seem to suggest that you believe that you and you alone have the correct answer"Not at all - that's you guys demanding that only you have the right version of true and that I conform to it. If you actually held to the idea that there's different versions of "tru... |
| SomeoneElse | > you refuse to handle it personally,No - go back and read it again. |
| SiHollett | "Finally, speaking as someone who creates maps for my own satnav based on OSM data, how am I supposed to make it know which refs are signed and which not?"This reads like 'I, personally, don't deal with it as I'm clueless and must get other people to do that for me, relying on them to ... |
| SomeoneElse | Seriously - when you've got three people suggesting that you might want to reconsider what you're doing, just how unable-to-consider-alternate-points-of-view do you have to be to think "I'm right; evereyone else is wrong".If you'd actually read the links I provided above you'd understand... |
| SiHollett | "Seriously - when you've got three people suggesting that you might want to reconsider what you're doing, just how unable-to-consider-alternate-points-of-view do you have to be to think "I'm right; evereyone else is wrong"."So, hang on, so beyond having not one, not two, but ... |
| Mike Baggaley | Looking at Lees Road (way 23111785 and adjoining), the U prefix reference suggests this is a tertiary road, but the highway tag has secondary in it, so either the ref tag or the highway tag is incorrect. Can you please either put a B road ref or change highway to tertiary?Thanks,Mike |
| SomeoneElse | @Mike Baggaley - I think you mean https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/4275498 (I keep doing that too!) |
| SiHollett | Mike, any reason why you couldn't do it? surely it would have taken less time for you to do it than to ask me to?also, why am I responsible, when someone else erroneously made it secondary, rather than tertiary?Anyway, I've changed it, though I have no idea why I'm being so nice. I even chan... |
| Mike Baggaley | Thanks for that, Si. I am not local to the area so don't know anything about the road, other than that it failed my check of secondary roads with a ref beginning with something other than a B, so I had no way of knowing which tag was incorrect. As the last change to the road was to set its ref, it s... |
| SiHollett | OK, thanks Mike, that makes sense |
| EdLoach | I just stumbled across UX6 and wondered why ref has been used in place of official_ref - https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:official_ref but see there has been discussion already. It looks like we're being left to correct them as we find them? |
|
| 30760143 | trigpoint | Hi, I think the words Roman Road mean it was a Roman Road, its not the name. |
|
| 44042207 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042454 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042510 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042676 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042771 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042796 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44042815 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44043027 | SomeoneElse | Hello and welcome to OpenStreetMap!It's great to see people adding stuff around where they live, but please do be careful and only make updates that actually exist on the ground - I'm not convinced about the large swathe of grass at https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/456649469#map=17/52.60762/-1.... |
| trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
| A12B | I can confirm this area of land is grass and can even be seen from the satellite imaginary. |
| SomeoneElse | Er - not really. If you look at http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/koF you can see a dog-leg of grass which covers part of the university's sports ground (which presumably is grass, but there's already a football pitch tagged there) amd also Manor Road itself (which presumably is asphalt rather than grass? |
|
| 44043085 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44043154 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44043354 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 44043431 | trigpoint | Reverted in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/44047606 |
|
| 43719180 | trigpoint | This seems an unlikely name for a garage in Greenford, does it have an actual name? |
| trigpoint | No response, bing imagery doesn't match so reverted |
|
| 43719161 | trigpoint | Reverted, does not match imagery |
|
| 43700495 | trigpoint | I cannot see a chimney on bing, and you have placed it in the road?What are you trying to achieve? |
| trigpoint | No response so I have reverted, there is already a garage mapped where the tyre shop was added |
|
| 43949818 | trigpoint | Do we have permission to copy from the parks department information board? |
| LE6Ram | Hi. These paths are being put in as part of a project funded by the City Council. I probably didn't make clear on my reasons that I walked all paths using a GPS unit and paper and pencil survey maps provided by the council and then checked against notice board. I did tell the on site ranger what ... |
| trigpoint | Thank you, walking them with a GPS is the best survey you can have. There is no need to justify what you have seen, unlike wikipedia we prefer original work. |
|
| 42301880 | trigpoint | I have fixed https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1179247495 which you had dragged.Cheers Phil |
| LE6Ram | Thanks Phil. No idea what happened there.Are you Phil from the Get Walking project? |
| trigpoint | Not me I'm afraid. |
|
| 44014576 | trigpoint | The user did not respond, but I was able to see the path on bing imagery and have added it |
|
| 43882393 | trigpoint | Please do not add personal markers to OSM. I have reverted this |
|
| 43866430 | trigpoint | Again this is already mapped, please do not add duplicates |
|
| 43866462 | trigpoint | The US Embasy is already mapped, there is no point adding duplications. |
|
| 43899793 | trigpoint | Is there really a bar called Fullers in the middle of the road? Unlikely as Fullers is a brewery and they do proper pubs, not bars. |
|
| 43955622 | trigpoint | Are there really shops in the middle of the pitches at Stamford Bridge and White Hart Lane? |
| trigpoint | Rubbish has been deleted |
|
| 43982471 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.This is a very odd place for a Jewellers, what were you trying to achieve? |
| trigpoint | Rubbish deleted |
|
| 43918078 | trigpoint | Is there really a toliet here, there is nothing visible on mapilary and it just seems unlikely. |
| vwJim | Hi, yes its one of those small "pay toilets" that self clean etc. Ony slightly larger than a phone box. |
| trigpoint | Thank you |
|
| 43968129 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.It is helpful to other mappers if you keep changes to managable areas. Changes over an area this large are very difficult to follow.Thanks Phil |
|
| 43538179 | trigpoint | Hi, is there really a toilet here?It looks like a house on aerial imagery. |
|
| 43938634 | trigpoint | Hi, this should probably be tagged as a gallery rather than an artwork.Cheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Agree, changed. |
|
| 43943207 | trigpoint | Hi, this would be better tagged as shop=farm, but maps.me probably doesn't offer that :)Cheers Phil |
| mapping man | No maps.me doesnt give that option. I always try to find the closest equilavent with an aim to correcting later when im back on a desktop. Thanks |
|
| 43945145 | trigpoint | Please do not change the names of football stadiums to include the club name, that is not the name of the ground.I am reverting this vandalism. |
|
| 43942322 | trigpoint | Is your office really in the middle of a car park? |
| mapping man | They have also deleted the road in the carpark. http://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=43942322This users edits need to be reverted. |
| trigpoint | I have reverted this |
| mapping man | @trigpoint thanks. I suspect that its a spam account. Out of interest how do you revert a changeset? |
| SomeoneElse | The address given in their edit checks out with their website - might be worth someone phoning the number on the website to ask if they added it themselves (and then explaining how to do it not in a car park) or if they paid someone else to do it, and if so who.There have been a large number of &q... |
|
| 43937796 | trigpoint | Hi, changing Tesco Express from amenity=fuel to a shelter looks very odd to me. Is there a good reason for that?Cheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Sorry, I wanted to add the feature/area as a shelter but failed to realise I was removing the fuel tag from amenity. Looking at it again shelter doesn't seem right anyway. Now found building=canopy, perfect.Regards |
|
| 41213734 | trigpoint | Hi, something has gone very wrong here. The A442, and Kidderminster are nowhere Llangollen. I am reverting this change. |
| John Grubb | Well spotted! Heaven only knows what happened there - probably had that section selected and then, after a distraction of some sort, went and held down CTRL to pick other edits having panned the map to another area of interest. Oops... |
|
| 43919748 | trigpoint | Is this verifiable, i.e. if I walk down the street will I see a sign on the building and can customers visit to book an appointment? |
| ptmaintenance | We don't have a sign for our office. We book our customers via phone and email. |
| trigpoint | In that case there is nothing to map, OSM is not a business directory. |
|
| 43888796 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. There is no need to fill the name tag with what is a description.We can see it is a postbox from its amenity tag. Cheers Phil |
| BCNorwich | Corrected operator name spelling and collection time syntax. |
|
| 43822126 | trigpoint | Do you have any information on this artwork? |
| Cale_xox | Yes, it is called 'Cornucopia' |
| trigpoint | Thank you, you should probably add that name to the object. |
|
| 43853638 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for your additions, but they don't really look like they should be mapped as highway=pedestrian. That is for pedestrianised streets in town centres.I would suggest that these should be mapped as highway=footway.There is also no need to add oneway=no, that is assu... |
|
| 43834983 | trigpoint | Hi, is this really a hotel? The name suggests self catering holiday cottages. |
|
| 43733444 | trigpoint | To be more accurate, it is a University not a school. It is also already mapped as an area.I am reverting this addition. |
|
| 43720937 | trigpoint | Hi, we normally tag Tesco Express as shop=convenience, supermarket is reserved for the larger ones that are subject to Sunday opening restrictions. |
|
| 43730921 | trigpoint | Hi, Berkley Mansions is already mapped as way, you have created a duplicate node in the middle of the road. I am removing this duplicate.I also doubt it is an attraction. |
| Dr-Mx | I've removed the node and added the postcode to the apartment building |
|
| 43633102 | trigpoint | Does the post office have an actual name? |
| Peterwhs | I don't think so. It's just a Post Office. Maybe it's called a Royal Mail Post Office? Does it matter? |
| trigpoint | Post Offices always have a name, it will either be Raphael Street Post Office or maybe Knightsbridge Post Office. There is no point just putting Post Office in the name, we can see that from the symbol. It does matter, when a card is left saying there is something to collect it will need to say whic... |
|
| 43672160 | trigpoint | Hi, I assume the numbers you are adding are housenumbers.These should not be put in the name, they should be put in the addr:housnumber tag.Cheers Phil |
| JC49 | These are not quite house numbers as the buildings are massive concrete bunkers. They don't have addresses as such. |
| trigpoint | Sorry, having zoomed out a bit further I can see where they are. No not housenumbers. |
|
| 43666282 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.You should probably remove the name old toilet block is more a description than a name. Its your bike workshop that should show up first. It is not recommended to combine Welsh/English in the name tag. In an area such as Machynlleth I tend to put Welsh in the name tag and put ... |
|
| 43634759 | trigpoint | P A Pike Joinery is a very odd name for a post office, what were you trying to achieve? |
|
| 43617847 | trigpoint | I have reverted this vandalism |
|
| 43616840 | trigpoint | We do not map airbnb's in OSM, they are not verifiable. |
|
| 43603170 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for your addition but please remember that maps.me is very limited in what it allows. It only allows nodes to be added to the map, and has a very small subset of tags and encourages misuse of tags (I assume that his is not a Post Office).To add paths you will need to... |
|
| 43509055 | mueschel | Hi,way 389961326 has the tag 'adpoted =no' that doesn't make sense to me. Could you check that?Cheers, Jan |
| trigpoint | That looks like a typo, it should be adopted=no. |
| Paul Berry | My mistake; thanks for correcting it, @mueschel. |
|
| 43554738 | trigpoint | Does this ATM have an operator, it is also unusual not to be associated with either a bank or a shop. |
|
| 43566539 | trigpoint | I doubt the name is really McDonald's Restaurant with Drive Thru. We simply use the name McDonald's. If it has a drive through, then we map that as a way. You need to use a proper PC based editor to do that. McDonalds is normally considered fast_food rather than a restaurant.Cheers Phil |
|
| 43570854 | trigpoint | Again, this is not how you spell Barclays and I seriously doubt any of these ATMs are genuine. Please could you explain what you are trying to achieve. |
|
| 43555606 | trigpoint | Hi, your edits in London look a bit odd. I somehow doubt that there is an ATM in The Palace of Westminster and that the London community could have missed 10 ATMs.I suspect that these are personal markers.Please learn to spell Barclays. |
|
| 43551976 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Does this clothes shop have a name and I imagine it is one of the buildings and not in the middle of the road? |
|
| 43526922 | trigpoint | This looks very odd, are you sure there is a post office here. It is mapped as a farm and that what it looks like on bing imagery? |
|
| 43446050 | BCNorwich | Hello and welcome to OpenStreetMap.Features added to the OSM database must be factual and verifiable on the ground by any one. So this POI looks like it is a fiction. It is in fact a Post Box address and as such should be removed. |
| trigpoint | Should we not just remove the spam, and tag it as a postbox. The shop could probably use a post office node too? |
| BCNorwich | Agreed that makes sense. My information came from a web search so I'm not free to transfer that positional data. If you're happy please make the change. |
|
| 43306232 | trigpoint | Tagging a driving test centre as a police staion seems very odd, it should be tagged as office=government.You will need to use a proper editor to make this change, please ask if you need help. |
| trigpoint | Maps.me user did not respond, fixed tagging |
|
| 43469161 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Does this department store have a name? |
|
| 43446277 | trigpoint | If http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4485696947 is a postbox, then it should be tagged amenity=postbox, there will be a ref on the plate. It will not have a postcode as it is not somewhere post is delivered to. |
| Jim Thurston | This is the postal address for The Maylands Mayl - The PostBox is where the mail is placed so that it doesn't get mixed up with the mail for the supermarket. |
| trigpoint | So is thete an office inside the supermarket building? |
| BCNorwich | Hi, this is a Post Office Box presumably inside the post office not outside the building. From their website (http://www.themaylandsmayl.com/) there is no office at the building. |
|
| 43446078 | trigpoint | H welcome to OSMWhat actually is http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4485696947/history ? Please remember OSM is a map not a business directory, please cut out the SPAM comments. By all means map the shops, but leave your self promotion to yourself. |
|
| 43424301 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database and is not your private map.Despite my attempts to contact you, you continue to add personal markers to the map. The imagery indicates there are no hostels in the areas you are adding them, and the names you give them do not ring true.We do n... |
| Miya Zhang | Dear Sir,Sorry for making trouble to OSM, and please forgive my pool English.I am totally new one on OSM, and I can not find any instruction in APP, so I think OSM is same as google map......Yes I received you reminding, and I revised the signature, I thought it will take me to the right way, ... |
|
| 43418307 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your addition however the Travelodge is already mapped as a building.I am going to remove the duplicate. |
|
| 28688591 | trigpoint | Hi, I pass https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/326960247 every day and cannot recall any signs legally prohibiting HGVs. What is the source of this, remember access tags are meant to indicate the legallity, if you wish to tag suitability then lanes=1 or width = 2m are the way to go. |
| Mike Baggaley | Hi, I split this way from way 39207901 and did not define any of the tags whilst adding the Shropshire Way relation to parts of it. You may wish to look at the adjoining parts of Isombridge Lane and remove the hgv tag from those as well. I am not local so don't know the restrictions on it.Cheers... |
| trigpoint | Sorry, should have dug a bit deeper. I can see the tag has been on the original way since forever. I will investigate.Cheers Phil |
|
| 39032411 | trigpoint | This is a duplicate, the hotel was already mapped |
|
| 43231745 | BCNorwich | Hello, I think you have positioned this property on the wrong side of the road (as far as the existing mapping of roads is concerned). It is not therefore verifiable on the ground as mapped. Further it is very unlikely that the feature is officially name "Home". Also if it is your home i... |
| trigpoint | Reverting #DROB |
|
| 43372412 | trigpoint | Please stop adding personal marker to OSM, I doubt that there is really a hostel here called Shaun |
|
| 43331841 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This seems a very odd place for a Police Station, have you more detail |
| trigpoint | I have reverted this rubbish, although I would have loved to hear the mappers reason for placing a police station in an animal enclosure |
|
| 43260712 | trigpoint | Is there really a motel here, with its name only in Korean? |
| trigpoint | The area is clearly residential, and the mapper has not responded after a week.I have removed this motel. |
|
| 43376035 | trigpoint | Again, is this really here? |
| trigpoint | It is too close to http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4120739487 to be likely |
| BCNorwich | This node is not listed on the website :- https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/cycling/santander-cyclesThere is a bike rental place listed and mapped just over the water on Goods Way. |
| trigpoint | I had already pointed out that node, and we really should not be using gm based tfl.gov.uk |
|
| 43375930 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.This edit looks a little odd, the name indicates that these should be bicycle_hire but I am not sure about these. There are others mapped nearby and it is unlikely that such things would be missing from the map. Do you have any more information? |
| BCNorwich | I don't think 4478909590 exists, but there is a dock round the corner on Greenland Road.The other two I've tagged similar to other cycle hire stations. If Lui_E98 would like to look at these and use this type of tagging it would concur with how other stations are mapped. |
| trigpoint | I am not convinced any exist, discussion on irc suggested that they are personal markers of some sort. Cycle hire is not something our London mappers generally miss.I was planning to revert, just seeing if I can get a response from the maps.me user. |
| BCNorwich | Nodes 4478899792 and 4478899791 are listed at the mapped position on the website :- https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/cycling/santander-cyclesNode 4478899790 is not listed, there is a bike rental just around the corner. |
| SomeoneElse | For info, see "message to you as one that has to be read before you can continue mapping" at https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/1076 . |
|
| 43290649 | trigpoint | Hi, is costa.coffee really.cuisine=italian? Normally they are coffee shops, i.e. cuisine=coffee. |
|
| 43261441 | trigpoint | Reverting spam that is in the wrong place, its not in the middle of the road |
|
| 43250220 | trigpoint | This is a very odd name for a bus stop, please can you explain? |
|
| 43247070 | trigpoint | Welcome to OSM.Thank you for your addition but I doubt this entire building is number 14.In order to add such detail you need to split the building into sections. Maps,me isn't up to such a task, you will need to use an OSM editor on you PC. |
|
| 43195479 | trigpoint | This is a very odd set of tags, please can you explain? |
|
| 43195439 | trigpoint | This is a very odd set of tags, please can you explain? |
|
| 43179718 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database and it is considered vandalism to rename existing objects as personal markers.I am reverting this change. |
|
| 43196151 | trigpoint | Does the Vet have an actual name, is B&M a Homestore or Bargains?Please capitaise name correctly |
|
| 43021466 | trigpoint | Already mapped, yopu have changed a gate. I am reverting this change |
|
| 43193363 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database, it is considered vandalism to rename existing objects to personal markers. I am reverting this change |
|
| 43158863 | trigpoint | I doubt that your office is really in the middle of the road, is it signed and verifiable? |
|
| 43063356 | trigpoint | Are these really Guest Houses, notes indicate that they are self-catering. I would expect someone to cook me breakfast in a guest house.If they are self catering, are they verifiable? Have they got a sign that a passer by will see? |
| RBChest | This is a self catering holiday cottage for two people. Maps.me don't have a category for s/c cottage, this was the best I could do. There is no sign outside as bookings are made online or via letting agents. I did put the website (www.valleycottagemilford.co.uk) in the details but they don't appea... |
| trigpoint | I am sorry, if something is not verifiable on the ground, then it has no place in OpenStreetMap.We are not a business directory. |
|
| 43085599 | trigpoint | Welcome to OSM, this edit is a little wrong. Please do not mistag a driving school as a school. If there is an office that the public can visit, then map it as office=company. If this is just a house, then it has no place in OSM |
| RJSKG | Hi there. Thanks for the correction. This is my home, but I also have an office there where I teach & meet some of my pupils. The office is used as a classroom for 1-2-1 tuition. I hope this helps. Thank you. |
| trigpoint | Thanks, I have moved the tags to the building and removed the extra nodes.It is now tagged as amenity=driving_school |
| RJSKG | Thank you! |
|
| 43097490 | trigpoint | Please only add a website if the place has its own. Links to booking sites should not be added, I have removed this link. |
|
| 43094451 | trigpoint | https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4460064889 looks very odd, it is named as a Rugby Club, but tagged as a post office. What is it? |
|
| 43128020 | trigpoint | I really doubt that this bus stop has been re-named as 102 Epsom High Street, I am reverting this change |
|
| 43082743 | trigpoint | Hi, you should add the tag access=customers to this, it is not public.Also this isn't Portmeirion.Cheers Phil |
| alpman | Updated now. Thanks for letting me know I had miised it off. |
|
| 43053866 | trigpoint | This is The Ivy Market Grill, as it was already mapped. Is there any reason that you have changed it? |
|
| 43061813 | trigpoint | Hi, have you any more detail for https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4458000289It looks a very odd location for a place that sells cars. |
|
| 43024843 | trigpoint | Welcome to OSM, I do not recall a hotel inside the cathedral last time I was in Edinburgh.Please remember that OSM is a public database and should not be used for personal markers |
|
| 42752459 | trigpoint | This is an odd place for a viewpoint |
|
| 42764209 | SomeoneElse | Hello,Are you sure that https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4439805289 is really a tourist attraction?Best regards,Andy |
| trigpoint | I would imagine that the mosques you have mapped have actual names and are not simply called Mosque, you should add a religion tag to indicate that they are Mosques. I doubt that https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4439805189 is in the middle of the road. |
|
| 42845629 | Jarek Piórkowski | Are these hostels open to the public, or are they places where your friends live that you've added for your own reference? The marks you've added are visible on the public page on openstreetmap.org, if it's just a friends' that might not be accurate. |
| trigpoint | I am reverting this, sixt car hire and Long Walk are already mapped. |
|
| 42907042 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to osm.A cricket pitch is not generally considered a tourist attraction, we tag these as leisure=pitch, sport=cricket. Would you be able to change this? You will need to use iD from osm.org on your computer. It would also be useful if you could map it as an area rather than a node. In ... |
|
| 42929338 | trigpoint | Please remember OSM is a public database, please do not add personal markers |
|
| 43023844 | trigpoint | Please remember OSM is a public database, please do not add personal markers |
|
| 43066661 | trigpoint | Clare's nan is not a likely name for a place of worship, I am reverting this and your other personal marker |
|
| 43066288 | trigpoint | Is your house really an off licence? |
|
| 42916419 | trigpoint | Are you absolutely certain about this?Have you been there and checked? Did this Strava user send you a photo?Firstly a missing unclassified road in the Midlands has alarm bells ringing, there is as much chance of finding Elvis selling fruit and veg on Leicester Market.So did you check the av... |
| Richard | Geograph photos:http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/408432http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/1036267http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/408921http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/408923http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/4019525http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/408927http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/4... |
| trigpoint | I have changed this to a track |
| CloCkWeRX | Thanks, that seems a more appropriate modelling |
|
| 42716153 | SomeoneElse | Hallo,The website isn't correct here, surely?You've added a link for the website for the chain, not this example of it.Best Regards,Andy |
| gtjack9 | Each resteraunt does not have a unique website so I used the general McDonald's website/menu.Is that ok? |
| SK53 | Generally no OSM is not a directory of business services, so when websites are provided it should be directly related to the object itself. One of the more useful purposes of website/url tags is to enable other mappers to quickly verify information. A generic McDonald's url adds no information that ... |
| trigpoint | A similar issue to this has also caused problems in the past, somebody in Japan helpfully added starbucks wikipedia page to every outlet in Japan, which caused a nominatim search made anywhere in the world to return those ahead of local ones that the user actually wanted. Not sure if a website has ... |
|
| 42907056 | trigpoint | Is there there really a sign in Telford with Centre spelt in the American way?Actually from memory they are usually just signed as Arc Car Wash? |
| dogmatic69 | No its not spelt the American way, its a typo... |
|
| 42835549 | trigpoint | Welcome to OSM, thank you for your edit. I have tidied the node you had dragged on Lavender Hill and tidied the additional nodes to leave a single node for the CAB within the library. |
|
| 42290024 | trigpoint | Hi, does this guest house have a name/phone number? Also I doubt it is in the middle of the road, please can you put it in the right place?Thanks |
| SomeoneElse | @trigpoint What's the next step here - remove https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4409160291 or add a note? |
| trigpoint | I have removed it, the housing on bing imagery makes it look very unlikely that there would be a guest house in that area |
|
| 42780806 | trigpoint | The location of this cafe looks a bit odd, I would expect it to be in one of the buildings rather than on the pavement.Cheers Phil |
|
| 42753039 | trigpoint | Please could you explain what you have done in this mass edit and where it was discussed.It is a really nasty big edit that is too big to even analyse, |
| maggot27 | this add a space to maxspeed=40mph to make it maxspeed=40 mph to comply with the standard formathttps://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:maxspeedThis is the only change made to all nodes. |
| trigpoint | Whilst the space is something josm moans about, but what doesn't it moan about. In practice it really doesn't matter. OSM base tools, such as OSMand, has never cared if the space is there or not. Other tools certainly don't mind. Which tool has caused problems for you? |
| Nakaner | @trigpoint You might have a look at another discussion of maggot27's changesets. https://openstreetmap.org/changeset/42742859 |
|
| 42779850 | trigpoint | What is in the place of Costcutter? |
|
| 42780773 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This is a very odd name and location for a viewpoint, please could you explain? |
|
| 42639754 | trigpoint | Tesco is not spelt with a k, I am reverting this. |
|
| 42741127 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM, thank you for spotting this ommision. The correct way to tag a roundabout is junction=roundabout, rather than oneway=yes. Keep on mapping, its great fun.Thanks Phil |
|
| 42736978 | trigpoint | A court seems a very odd place for an ATM, please could you explain it? |
|
| 42732043 | trigpoint | Please can you explain this addition? |
|
| 42714017 | trigpoint | This looks to be a very odd place for an ATM, are you sure its not some sort of personal marker?Please remember that OSM is a public database and somebody getting off the train and needing some cash for the races will not be please with you. |
|
| 42727892 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. These hotels look very odd, they all appear to be personal markers. Please could you explain this edit? |
|
| 42712435 | trigpoint | HiThis appears to be a large mechanical edit, was it discussed anywhere.What is your justification for this change, the wiki says waterway=riverbank is the correct way to tag riverbanks on large rivers. |
| DaveF | What evidence makes you think it was "mechanical"? |
| trigpoint | It covers a large area, which makes me suspicious, howevet what is the justification for this change that goes against the wiki and changes the work of local mappers? |
| DaveF | Why haven't you read the wiki fully? |
| DaveF | It's a "large area" because it's the "longest river in the United Kingdom". Why do I have to explain that to you? You should be intelligent enough to work it out for yourself. |
| DaveF | Do you look at the time a changeset is active before making unfounded accusations? |
| DaveF | Do automated mechanical edits involve deletions mixed in with tag edits? |
| DaveF | It appears you are unaware of P2's 'task' facility. Why is that? |
| DaveF | You need to perform a such of the Tagging archive for 'Canal Banks' before replying further. |
| DaveF | perform a *search |
| DaveF | Do mechanical edits involve splitting polygons & rejoin them so they correctly abut their neighbour? |
| DaveF | Do mechanical edits involve splitting polygons to remove sections to create separate objects which are part of a different entity? |
|
| 42713432 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM and thank you for the information.I have added a bollard, please could you check it is correct.Thanks Phil |
|
| 34008870 | trigpoint | Hi, is this work complete?I keep seeing notes from Navmii users which indicate that what we have on the map is no longer what is on the ground. That said there are no gps or strava traces indicating it is yet open.Thanks Phil |
| RichardB | Hi. I've not been down the A21 for about a year or so, so haven't seen for myself recent progress. I do believe, however, that the official opening date for this section is Spring 2017 - but equally it's likely that some sections may have recently been realigned before the full opening. |
|
| 42584949 | trigpoint | HiSomething has gone very wrong here, you seem to have put the box back to how it was before redevelopment. You have removed 3 new roundabouts and put Coach Central back to oneway. Please could you explain the reasons for this edit?Thanks Phil |
| trigpoint | BTW The box, as it is now, is on mapillary. |
| trigpoint | I have reverted this change, mapbox imagery also shows the box as it now is. |
|
| 42569861 | trigpoint | Hi, just wondering what the source of your edits is?Some of them seem a little odd, for example I don't recall Oakengates Road being a single lane road. From memory it is cerainly wide enough for two cars to pass.Also http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/445236877 seems unlikely to be highway=pedest... |
| dogmatic69 | source: residentchanged the highway to footway, Changed the other one to a pvt alley. its for "residents" only, no reason for anyone to walk/ride a bike there. |
|
| 42424524 | trigpoint | I don't think the name of this museum is Belfast, reverting |
|
| 42572526 | BCNorwich | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.The positioning of this hotel POI, in the alley behind buildings, some way away fro the address of Romford Road, will not be much help in helping folk to find it. Better to actually draw the building and state the floor if the building has multiple businesses.\... |
| trigpoint | The name translates as house, which is an unlikely name for a hotel so I suspect this yet another personal marker edit from a maps.me user. Reverting this. |
|
| 42573179 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please can you capitalize names correctly and not use lowercase.Thanks |
|
| 42400502 | trigpoint | Ikea isn't here, its already mapped in its correct location. It certainly isn't open 24/7.Reverting/. |
|
| 42498986 | trigpoint | Welcome to OSM, thank you for your addition but does this restaurant have a name? It is also more likely to be inside a building?Please could you login to OSM and use iD to correct it.Thanks |
|
| 42355577 | trigpoint | This seems a very odd name for a bar, are you sure its not part of the hotel? Is it open to non-residents? |
| trigpoint | Mapper not responded so reverting |
|
| 42439206 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This seems a very odd place to find a bus station. Are you sure it is here? |
|
| 42437465 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Has this pub, actually I assume its the hotel bar, really changed its name to Bedford. It looks a little odd. |
|
| 42359488 | trigpoint | Holland & Barrett is not normally considered to be a convienience shop, is this one somehow different? They are usually health food shops. |
| sampierce_ | That's what I wanted, but there was no option to put it in that category when I created it for some reason! |
| trigpoint | No problem, I can update it.Thanks |
| trigpoint | Updated, thank you |
| sampierce_ | Great, thanks |
|
| 42297156 | trigpoint | I am removing this toilet as it is a duplicate |
| mikemiee | Apologies for duplicating this. Obviously did not see the original on the map I had on my phone. |
|
| 42323324 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to osm. Do you have a shop customers can visit here? |
| BCNorwich | There's no shop, that address is the registered company office for an online wine seller. |
|
| 42283572 | trigpoint | HI, something has gone wrong here. The pub now has two names, not your fault as maps.me is very broken when it comes to name tags. Which name is correct? |
| Jethro10 | Ah I see what it's done. It's recently changed to The Spotted Pig, I've fixed it along with another one I did at the same time that's also wrong, The Tithe Barn a few miles away.A shame that because Maps.me is an excellent map product I use loads and do add quite a few things with it as well. Howe... |
| Jethro10 | Are you aware if it's actually been reported as a bug to Maps.me? |
| trigpoint | There is a bug reported https://github.com/mapsme/omim/issues/4149 |
| Jethro10 | Ah, well debated!Anyhow, my two are fixed and I'll try and remember to avoid it in future.thanks |
|
| 42285046 | trigpoint | HI, something has gone wrong here. The shop now has two names, not your fault as maps.me is very broken when it comes to name tags. Which name is correct? |
| trisosaurus | Hi, yeah i think i'll stick to making changes on OSM; it is now called 'Best One Local' |
|
| 42232829 | trigpoint | Is this shop really call Last Shop Before Ferries? |
|
| 42073037 | trigpoint | Please do not map personal markers |
|
| 42264807 | trigpoint | Does this hotel have a name? |
|
| 42272300 | lostmike | This looks like an error to me. Did you mean to add a new tag with the name in your language? |
| trigpoint | Reverting |
|
| 42239399 | trigpoint | Do yo have any more details for this charging station, it looks to be in an unusual place and we do need the type so that electric car users can find one that is suitable for their vehicle |
|
| 42239311 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Does this hostel have a name? It is also very unlikely to be in the middle of the road. |
|
| 42229144 | trigpoint | Are you sure this is a guest house, in a guest house I would expect someone to cook me breakfast. |
| Alan Streluk | I can see your point and indeed I didn't want to put it as a guest house. Sadly to put a listing on OpenStreetMap you have to use one of their categories and they don't have a "Holiday Cottage" or "Holiday Rental" option. This was the nearest they offer... Sorry! |
| trigpoint | Thank you, I can fix the tagging. Maps.me is really intended for mapping on the go and is very limited, You do need to use a proper computer to be able to edit OSM properly. |
| trigpoint | I have changed it to tourism=holiday_cottage |
| Alan Streluk | Thanks for doing that! As for your comment about my "note" being spam, There was an "about" field in the Maps.me interface so I thought it was for a description. I had no intention of adding spam. I just wanted to add a listing! |
| trigpoint | No problem, maps.me isn't the greatest osm editor. |
|
| 42229034 | trigpoint | More maps.me vandalism. Please remember that OSM is a public database used by many people, you have changed the name of a tesco to a personal marker. Please use the bookmarks function for that. |
|
| 42222347 | trigpoint | Starbucks is normally tagged as a cafe, cuisine=coffee. Is this one different? |
|
| 42200018 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Horse=no is a very odd tag to find on a bridleway, after all that is the point of them. Also please do not copy from the definitive map, it is based on OS and is therefore copyright. |
|
| 42200328 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your contribution, however the Premier Inn is already mapped on the surrounding way, I am going to remove your duplicate.When editing please capitalise names properly. Thanks |
| BCNorwich | POI deleted before I saw the above comment. Note also that the tag name:en=??? is not needed. |
| trigpoint | Sorry, I meant to delete the node when I got home.The name:en problem is a feature of maps.me, not something the user has any control of.https://github.com/mapsme/omim/issues/4149 |
|
| 41891854 | trigpoint | Hi AndyYou have added a node for Lloyds Bank inside a building tagged as a Lloyds TSB.It would be better if you can remove your node and update the name on the building as it has full address information.Thanks Phil |
|
| 42189454 | trigpoint | I am reverting this, jot is not thew English name for Selfridges |
|
| 42189317 | trigpoint | Does this ATM have an operator that can be added? Also this is a residential street and hence is a very unusual place for an ATM. |
|
| 42196125 | trigpoint | Hi, this should be tagged as amenity=book_exchange. Tagging it as a bookshop is misleading to map users.Please can you correct it and please capitalise words correctly. Thanks |
| JanetChapman | Hi, I added this via Maps.me as a test and where that wasn't an option so I have now deleted it. |
|
| 36278827 | trigpoint | I have removed the name node you added, as the name was already on the beach area way |
|
| 42199829 | trigpoint | Is really a guest house that is open to the public? https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4404027490 |
|
| 42174442 | trigpoint | Has this shop really become a restaurant? If so please could you fix the tags, it is still tagged as a shop. |
|
| 42179237 | trigpoint | Does this guest house have a name/phone number? |
|
| 42167631 | trigpoint | Polish name is unlikely to be X2, reverting |
|
| 42167502 | trigpoint | Reverting vandalism |
|
| 42152643 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This edit has gone a little wrong, the mddle of an airport is a very odd place to find an ATM. What were you trying to achieve? |
|
| 42045746 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I am just wondering what this is and what the source is?It sounds very dodgy.Descriptions do not belong in the name tag, I am hoping that it is something historic and is no longer operational Maybe historic=crow_trap? |
| andydj | As you noted, I'm new here... I was asked by an "Against Corvid Traps" investigator to provide a bing map link with a flag showing the location of a crow trap I found and reported to them, and not wishing to sign up to bing, I decided to use OSM. Apologies if I've not followed protocol - i... |
| trigpoint | Thank you for your explaination, they would probably be better tagged as man_made=crow_trap but keep on mapping them. |
|
| 42109902 | trigpoint | Reverted |
|
| 42103934 | trigpoint | Grow up |
|
| 42066032 | trigpoint | Did you happen to get a name for this caravan site when you visited it? It does look a very odd edit, it may be some sort of residential caravan site but looking at aerial imagery I really don't think its for tourists. |
| ericthefish | Yeah it was an odd edit sorry. I did mean to come back and add more info but I forgot. I stayed at this site recently. I'll add a name (Oaklands) and some more info. |
|
| 41884592 | BCNorwich | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.I have corrected the spelling of your POI and removed the unneeded tag name:en=???.I've added the website and moved the position. |
| trigpoint | The name:en is an annoying "feature" of maps.me |
|
| 41841056 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.B & M is usually tagged as a variety store, it is not really a supermarket.Cheers Phil |
| SomeoneElse | Actually - what sort of B&M is this? There's "B & M Bargains" (which is a classic "variety store") and the slightly more upmarket "B & M Home Store". That gets various tags, including "homewares": http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/iaP (but probably not ... |
| Ross Deacon | Hi Phil, it's a B&Monday Home Store. Cheers Ross |
| Ross Deacon | Should have said B&M Home Store. |
|
| 41861079 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. I am a little confused by this edit, a terraced street is not the usual place to find a shelter. Please could you explain what you were trying to achieve? |
|
| 41271897 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Something seems to have gone a bit wrong with this edit, this appears to be a residential area and is hence a very odd place for a bus station. Please could you confirm what you were trying to achieve? |
| trigpoint | No response and its clearly a residential area so reverting |
|
| 41820571 | SomeoneElse | If there's a starbucks here I'd map it separately. Also, is this perhaps a duplicate of the other amenity=fuel just to the west? |
| trigpoint | There is also a petrol station, mapped as a way, very close by which I expect is a duplication |
|
| 41814528 | BCNorwich | Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap.For Pandora it would be better if you could place the POI on the building rather than in the street. The address would help as well.Bubba Gump, are you sure this is a jewelry shop, looks like a restaurant, Please correct if it's wrong. Also address and precise pos... |
| trigpoint | Also, please could you capitalize names properly |
|
| 41752443 | trigpoint | Hi, Totters Hostel was already mapped, I have therefore removed your duplication.Also what is http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4370785500 a view of, it seems to be surrounded by trees? |
| singingcarols | The Totters Hostel on the map is wrong which is why I placed the new one in the correct position. I couldn't remove the other one. So if you can then please do. The viewpoint is of the quarry, the lake and the city. That area there is actually a break in the trees or the path winds over the trees pr... |
| trigpoint | Totters Hostel was already in the the correct place in OSM, unfortunately maps.me replaces some hotels/hostels with incorrect locations Looking at maps.me I can see this is what has happened here and i can understand your confusion. |
|
| 41763720 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This edit seems to have gone a little wrong, you seem to have added two hotels but have got their locations in the wrong place. What source of information did you use.The Foundry Masters House is in fact in Coalbrookdale, not Muxton, I have removed this node as a I do not have ... |
|
| 41732827 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to osm.This seems an odd place for a bus station, can you give more details ? |
|
| 41669039 | trigpoint | I have removed http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4365154591 as it is already mapped as a car park.It is certainly not an official caravan site and has no facilities. |
|
| 41681566 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.This changeset looks a little odd, you have created a recycling point in a wood and a recyling centre, with an operator three which is also in a wood. You agree these are not normally where you find these objects.I have reverted this change but please could you explain what yo... |
|
| 41674292 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM, I doubt your business is really in the middle of the road.If you have an office where customers can call, please add it in its correct location. You may want to add further details, such as a phone number. |
|
| 41616176 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. You seem to have added 2 stations with no name. They are very close to Euston and Kings Cross so appear to be duplications.What were you trying to achieve with this edit?. . |
| trigpoint | No answer and they are clearly duplicates/wrong so reverting/ |
|
| 39976136 | trigpoint | Hi, is http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/3077317663 really a post office?It seems a very odd name, and there is a post office over the road. Actually I visited Kings Cross Post Office on the way to SOTM-EU |
| yourealwaysbe | It's a good question. Doddle is a service to which you can have packages delivered and then pick them up (eg on the way home from work). I'm not 100% happy it's a post office, but i'm not sure what else to tag it, and post_office had been used elsewhere to tag Doddles. If there's a more accurate tag... |
| yourealwaysbe | The description of post_office on the wiki seems appropriate, though it doesn't match the intuitive meaning in the uk.http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dpost_officeThere is one in Birmingham tagged parcel_collection_point, but googling for this doesn't turn up anything for me. |
| trigpoint | The description in the wiki is a bit like describing a supermarket as a place that sells baked beans:)THis does look like it is tagging for the renderer and really isn't the understood meaning of a post office which does banking, passports, car tax and loads of other things. Somebody searching for... |
| yourealwaysbe | I expect the wiki takes a more international view: Fedex and UPS seem to be generally tagged as post_office also. I think Doddle sits happily with these two (packages can be sent and received and there is a customer service desk). It is also the typical tagging of Doddle in the UK (admittedly n~=1... |
| SK53 | I think basically in the UK tagging them as post_office is not accurate. The minimum I would expect from a post office is to be able to buy stamps & send letters, packets & parcels through International Postal Union members. I would suggest amenity=parcel_service |
| SK53 | Or possibly amenity=post_depot (but parcel services do not handle post (yet!)) |
| yourealwaysbe | amenity=parcel_service sounds good to me :) |
|
| 41598530 | trigpoint | Is this really a resturaunt, or even a take away that customers can visit? The website makes it look like it is delivery only. |
|
| 41597588 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. This seems a very odd place for a tourist attraction, can you give more detail? |
|
| 41438471 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.DOes this greengrocer have a name? Looking at the map, it seems to be in a very unlikely place for a shop.Cheers Phil |
| trigpoint | No response from maps.me user and its already mapped as residential so I am reverting this very unlikely greengrocers |
|
| 41120640 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.You have added a shelter inside a shopping centre, that seems a very odd place to map a shelter. What were you trying to achieve/ |
| trigpoint | No response from maps.me user so reverting unlikely edit |
|
| 41502409 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for you addition but what is here now? Looking at bing imagery I am guessing it should probably be tagged as leisure=park.Cheers Phil |
|
| 41409751 | trigpoint | Hi, this edit seems to have created a duplicate campsite. Was that really your intention?Cheers Phil |
|
| 41370197 | trigpoint | Is this shop really called Polish Delicatessen, it sounds more like a description than a name.Please also capitalise the names, lower case looks wrong on a map.Thanks Phil |
|
| 41363885 | trigpoint | Has Viva really become a Costa?If it has it should no longer be tagged as a restaurant but as a cafe with cuisine=coffee.Cheers Phil |
| EdLoach | Also, has "The Filling Station" become "Beatles" - the FHRS data extract from yesterday suggests not? |
| Derick Rethans | Phil, Maps.me doesn't allow you to change category ... |
| Kenneth Gafa | Sorry but I do not have an idea about "The Filling Station" |
| trigpoint | Hi Kenneth, was there a fast food place called Beatles when you were in Liverpool?Have you some more details if so?Cheers Phil |
| Kenneth Gafa | Trigpoint, I do not recall such a place but in Liverpool The Beatles are mentioned at every corner. When I was there I ate at Nando's and TGI. |
| SomeoneElse | It's already been changed back, but I'm pretty sure The Filling Station was still called that when I walked past it a couple of months ago. |
|
| 41311613 | trigpoint | Hi MikeSomething seems to have gone a bit wrong.here, you seem to have removed the.ways from this through route relation.What.were you trying to achieve or what did you see wrong here? Cheers Phil |
| Mike Baggaley | Hi Phil, my understanding of the through_route relation is that it should have two ways and one common node to indicate the normal way ahead. This relation had more that two ways connected to it and was causing warnings to be generated in a process I use based on the OSM data. I was going to try to ... |
| trigpoint | Thank you for your reply Mike.The number of ways had increased, caused by adding speed limits.Had not realised the proposal had been rejected, although it is important and should be revived at some point. I am quite surprised by the lack of understanding in some of the comments, these junctions ... |
|
| 41291876 | trigpoint | Reverted rubbish added to name |
|
| 41289904 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. From your edit I assume Brantano has closed? Poundworld is normally tagged as a shop=variety. Cheers Phil |
| maroubal2 | Thanks Phil. Yes, it's closed. Couldn't seem to change the category within MAPS.ME. Will trying using other editors. |
|
| 41246010 | BCNorwich | Hi and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.The website you posted for the restaurant is no valid so I have removed it. |
| trigpoint | The website which this changeset removed, does appear to be valid. |
| trigpoint | http://kirazu.co.uk/en/ |
| BCNorwich | But apparently the restaurant is now under new ownership and a new name. |
|
| 31236628 | CloCkWeRX | Strava users report way 345760205 is just farmland now, imagery tends to concur. Can you resurvey and perhaps add notes to it to reflect whats on the ground? |
| trigpoint | Historic OS 1-25k mapping shows a PROW on this line, unless it has been legally extinguished it should not be removed.There is a legal right to walk a PROW irrespective of condition. |
|
| 41223745 | trigpoint | Hi DaveThank you for your contribution to OSM, however we do not add personal routes to OSM. If you simply want to display your route on a map, http://umap.openstreetmap.fr may be what you are looking for.OSM is a public database, hence we only add what is verifiable on the ground. Overlaying wa... |
|
| 41135775 | trigpoint | Hi, is cafe the right tag here? craft=btewery would seem more appropriate |
| Vincent Vandalon | True, I did this from Maps.Me which is not the greatest tool (it did not give me).Thanks for noticing, there was a chance that I did not get back around to changing this after my trip if you hadn't reviewed it. |
|
| 41164878 | trigpoint | Hi BrianPlease could you split your changesets into smaller areas. Large areas such as this make it difficult for the community to see what has changed in their areas of interest.Thanks Phil |
|
| 41075506 | BCNorwich | Hi, this node is where the footway (Rupert Court) joins with the street (Rupert Street). There in no restaurant in the middle of the street so I will remove it.If you know where the restaurant is sited please add the POI at that position. |
| trigpoint | Looking at the users other edits notes/edits this is a personal marker of where a tourist coach should stop. I think this should be reverted. |
| Mike Cahill | Well spotted trigpoint....I am a 'tour coach driver' and the flag is for me and my fellow drivers to navigate to that point! |
| trigpoint | Is there anything verifiable in these locations, some sort of rule you need to follow?Although it is clearly wrong to map this as a restaurant it could be a bus stop with some appropiate tags that ensure a normal map user wont walk there to try to catch a normal bus. |
| trigpoint | Hi Mike, please could you answer my question?OSM is a collaborative project and we all need to work as a community. As these edits stand, they are misleading to other map users and need to be corrected, or removed.If these are official places or marked in some way then they can be tagged accordi... |
|
| 41147705 | trigpoint | HiJust wondering what your source was for this change? Did you visit Chirk at some point?Cheers Phil |
|
| 41127346 | trigpoint | Again, please could you explain this edit? |
|
| 41127226 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM. Please could you explain this addition, a shelter inside a building is very improbable, wlan doubly so. |
|
| 41064106 | trigpoint | Is there really a bus stop here? It seems unlikely that it would have been missed by the London mappers. |
|
| 41097074 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Thank you for your addition, however Madame Tussauds is already mapped.See http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/29269886You have created a duplicate node which should be removed. |
| Derick Rethans | Reverted. |
|
| 41086593 | trigpoint | Hi, welcome to OSM.Please could you provide some more information, like what its the site of.Thanks |
|
| 40936755 | trigpoint | Hi, something has gone wrong here. You have placed a campsite node in the middle of a road in a built up area. It seems unlikely there is a campsite here. If one does exist, please add it as an area in the correct location.I am reverting this change |
|
| 41072762 | trigpoint | Hi, something has gone wrong here.Hashguard cross caravan park is already mapped, hence you have created a duplicate.I am reverting this change |
|
| 41075779 | trigpoint | Please remember that OSM is a public database, please do not add personal markers.I am reverting this change |
|
| 41034858 | trigpoint | Hi, you created a guest house here last week, is there any reason you have created a 2nd with the same name? |
| Martin Escardo | It was probably a mistake because it was the first time I tried to do this in openstreetmap. Apologies and sorry for the inconvenience. |